Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think these changes to the housing waiting list are not “cruel” but simply realistic?

492 replies

Eastie77Returns · 27/09/2021 13:49

Our council has announced changes to the local housing waiting list from next month. There are tens of thousands on the list who will never be housed as they are not deemed to be in urgent need so they will now be removed.

The council has said they will be offered “personalised support to explore their options” which probably means advising they leave London, advances to help with private rent etc. I understand in many cases that is really not helpful but a close relative of mine who works in housing has been on the phone to me in tears because of the level of abuse she has faced from frustrated residents who have been on the list for years and are being removed.

Now a parent from DD’s school is organising a march on the town hall to protest all of this and has asked parents for support. She has been offered a council house 100+ miles outside London and is refusing to leave as her support network is here and I fully understand that. However, I do think a dose of realism is needed. There are 15,000 people on the waiting list here and a few hundred council properties become available each year. This parent has been told she does not fall into the 3 bands that will be kept on the list so she will never get a council house and she has responded by accusing the council of unimaginable cruelty Confused

I don’t understand where she expects the council to magically just find thousands of homes and change that situation?

OP posts:
EvilPea · 28/09/2021 09:05

It is now essentially a form of benefit, and that is why it is massively oversubscribed

No it’s over subscribed because it’s the only way millions can have secure housing.
Paint their babies nursery, put pictures up in a house, not have to move every year. Keep their children in the same schools with their friends, be part of a community. Maybe give their child a pet, maybe plant flowers in the garden you will be there to see flower.
Not having to pay find £5000 every time your landlord gives you 2 months notice.

Renting as a family is hard, it’s depressing and the insecurity occupies your brain constantly.

Kendodd · 28/09/2021 09:05

I think you're being very short sighted.
If people are in private rented very often their rent is subsidised in the form of HB anyway. I also worry about the financial time bomb when generation rent retire, the tax payer will be picking up the bill to house them.
Seems to me that in the past people would could afford to buy, bought a house, paid for it while working, then had only maintenance and minimal ongoing costs when retired.
People who couldn't afford to buy got a council house, paid rent all their working lives and got HB when they retired, this was effectively money moving from one council account to another, so essentially, minimal ongoing cost for the public purse.
Now the people who couldn't afford to buy live in private rented, what will happen when they retire?

TheYearOfSmallThings · 28/09/2021 08:56

The point of my post was that social housing is not subsidised.

I'm all in favour of social housing, but yes it is massively subsidised. It is now essentially a form of benefit, and that is why it is massively oversubscribed. It also eats money, which is why the government prefers to divest itself of the responsibility.

I think there is a massive need for more good quality social housing, but the initial cost is huge, the maintenance cost is huge, and the rents come nowhere near covering those costs.

EvilPea · 28/09/2021 08:55

@WildBluebell

Some of us have moved to a foreign country for a better life. No sympathy for those whining about moving away from their "support network". So much entitlement.
But that was a choice. A considered, researched, choice based on your circumstances. It’s not a choice for them, and it completely disregards their circumstances.
Kendodd · 28/09/2021 08:44

It's interesting this whole shift that social housing should only be for the most desperate people, and even they're resented for it. This wasn't always the case. Social housing used to be for everyone, the point of it was to provide good quality secure homes. Houses have now been renamed 'property' and are all about money and investment. And before anyone starts with the 'no money' 'we can't afford it ' 'nice idea' nonsense, this change isn't about money, theres been a cultural shift in thinking that's driven this.

Clocktopus · 28/09/2021 08:20

Our council help with deposits, they also have accredited private landlords who are able to advertise via the council homefinder website.

For balance, we also have some new build social housing properties here that are £110-£150 a week (depending on size) whereas comparable private lets are £90-£110 a week.

The point of my post was that social housing is not subsidised.

OverTheRubicon · 28/09/2021 08:11

@WildBluebell

Some of us have moved to a foreign country for a better life. No sympathy for those whining about moving away from their "support network". So much entitlement.
As for renting privately, I can't speak for all areas but around here a private rent and a council rent aren't that much different. A two bed property in the nearest town is £375 a month private rent while a two bed council property in the same street is £360 a month

That's still £15 a month that the council tenants don't need to find, plus they don't have to have hundreds locked in a deposit, nor to factor in the cost of finding a new place and moving, or the risk of moving. And in places like London, where the private sector rents can be £1000 or far more for a basic 1 bed, the difference is larger again both in % terms and absolute £ terms.

Oldsu · 28/09/2021 02:56

[quote urbanbuddha]**@Oldsu

Can't you put him on Homeswapper?
If his neighbours could help him with the internet he might be able to find a family with a 2 bed who need a 3 bed and his young neighbours could move into the 2 bed freeing up the 1 bed. I think 3-way swaps are allowed.[/quote]
Hopefully my nephew will be able to help him, but the point is why should he have to, why cant the council organise it, surely it's in their best interest, its not that he wants to move for the sake of it he will be freeing up a house in an area that was on television a few years ago about the lack of housing stock

LobsterNapkin · 28/09/2021 02:10

@flippertyop

I agree tenancy for life is ridiculous. It's social housing why should you just be allowed to stay there forever. I'm afraid if you want to benefit from state subsidised housing you don't get to choose where that is
Part of the reason is that when it means moving people into far away places, you run into the same problem of destabilizing communities and support systems.

If there was proper planning where communities had a variety of different kinds of housing, and you could be moved into a smaller flat more or less in your own neighbourhood, it would be much less of an issue. But it requires enough housing.

In a way the idea of social housing works better when the intent is for it to be for a larger portion of the population, rather than just a smaller group of people, so there is a good stock of housing of different types in every community.

urbanbuddha · 28/09/2021 02:01

@Oldsu

Can't you put him on Homeswapper?
If his neighbours could help him with the internet he might be able to find a family with a 2 bed who need a 3 bed and his young neighbours could move into the 2 bed freeing up the 1 bed. I think 3-way swaps are allowed.

Oldsu · 28/09/2021 01:14

Many people have touched on the fact that a lot of older tenants are in social housing too big for their needs, my Dad is one of them, when he moved into his 3 bed social housing house 40 years ago it was because he was working, you had to be working to get one, they even went round his old house and examined his furniture and he had to go before a panel, he is now at 89 on his with mobility problems he would love to move into a smaller property, his house is far too big, he hasn't been able to go upstairs for 2 years, his huge garden perfect for a family is unmanageable he has to get gardeners in to keep it tidy, in short its a house for a family not a pensioner on his own and he feels guilty that he is there, BUT the council will not lift a finger to help him move, all they tell him is to go on the home swapper site, he has no computer and there is no-one near him to help him ( I live 200 miles away).

Over the road from him are lovely one bed flats he is friends with the young family who live in one, they would love his house, he would love their flat but the council say they can't swap as the family are not entitled to a 3 bed, so why cant the council step in, find a family who need to move from a 2 bed to a 3 bed., move the other family to the 2 bed and give my dad the flat, surely something can be done to free up a 3 bedroom house with a lovely garden so that a family can have it, I would love someone who works in housing to explain to me why that cant happen.

Clocktopus · 28/09/2021 00:35

Having always live in x town / paid your rent on time / kept your garden tidy does not mean that you will be offered a property above everyone else

In my area (also NE England) we have a rural allocations policy which means that if you have always lived in a certain area or work in it then you would have priority over other applicants with the same banding as you. The policy states you have to have a connection to the parish for the property you're bidding on either through family, community links, or work. There are some new build houses coming up soon that will be subject to this policy.

I agree however with tenancy review once members of the household leave, people in social housing should update the housing officer when a joint tenant or occupant leaves, at which point discussions should be had about downsizing, and appropriate support for a transfer.

You do have to update the council if the joint tenant leaves so that they can be taken off the tenancy agreement. A lot of councils offer incentives to people to encourage them to downsize when the time comes but they don't force it, plenty of people do take them up on it and there are also mutual exchanges available where tenants can swap their homes with each other. In a lot of cases though there aren't suitable properties for people to downsize to. I know someone who wanted to downsize after their children had left home and the only one bed properties available were second or top floor flats (three storey blocks) with no lift, they had mobility issues so it was no good and all the ground floor flats were two beds so they weren't eligible for them and the available bungalows were all too far from their daughters who helped with their care. They stayed in their three bed house with the stairlift and other adaptations until they passed away.

of course it is subsidised - otherwise you can just rent privately in which case there's no issue is there?

Its not subsidised.

The majority of council houses were built decades ago and the cost of building them has long since been repaid many times over by tenants paying rent to the council. There is no subsidy. Council housing is actually a public asset that brings in more money for councils in rent than it costs to manage and maintain.

As for renting privately, I can't speak for all areas but around here a private rent and a council rent aren't that much different. A two bed property in the nearest town is £375 a month private rent while a two bed council property in the same street is £360 a month.

lalafafa · 27/09/2021 23:52

no idea why people need to live in the centre of a capital city who are never going to work. Move key workers into central housing. As for moving away from support net works, what do people do who move for work?
There isn't gong to be a big social housing explosion, ever.

WildBluebell · 27/09/2021 23:15

Some of us have moved to a foreign country for a better life.
No sympathy for those whining about moving away from their "support network". So much entitlement.

Oldsu · 27/09/2021 23:02

But this is nothing new, when I got married in 1972 we couldn't afford to rent in the area of London I grew up in, 10 years later having saved all we could whilst paying rent, we couldn't afford to buy in the area of London where we were renting so had to move out again, London has always been like that

ShinyThingsDistractMe · 27/09/2021 22:49

[quote OverTheRubicon]@HousingOne I also agree with tenancies for life in principle - however unless there is enough housing to keep up, then surely this just keeps many people in the fear you mention with private rent, but with no end to it and often in far worse financial/logistical positions than those who got a tenancy for life and now have better paying jobs and the financial buffer that comes with over a decade paying below market rents.

It could be something reassessed every 5 or even 10 years, and be somewhat fairer.[/quote]
But whatever "measure" or "threshold" you put in, people will just purposefully stay under it. So everyone complains about the old 16 hour work rule on UC, you'd just be making a new rule to ensure people kept their tenancies. So potentially trapping people in poverty just so they could keep the roof over their head.

LA actually want working people in their homes, they are far better maintained generally and better at paying rent. Which keeps the pennies rolling in.

I agree however with tenancy review once members of the household leave, people in social housing should update the housing officer when a joint tenant or occupant leaves, at which point discussions should be had about downsizing, and appropriate support for a transfer.

Akire · 27/09/2021 22:25

I agree with reviewing tenancies. If you get any help with rent the bedroom tax lands on you like ton of bricks but if you pay rent yourself can have 4 bed for 20y after kids have left home. No one says thrown out on your youngest 18th birthday but making 5-10y plans and juggling so families of 4 in one bed can exchange. Obviously more to it than that but at present we do nothing even when more overcrowding than ever.

OverTheRubicon · 27/09/2021 22:10

@HousingOne I also agree with tenancies for life in principle - however unless there is enough housing to keep up, then surely this just keeps many people in the fear you mention with private rent, but with no end to it and often in far worse financial/logistical positions than those who got a tenancy for life and now have better paying jobs and the financial buffer that comes with over a decade paying below market rents.

It could be something reassessed every 5 or even 10 years, and be somewhat fairer.

purpleneon · 27/09/2021 22:05

I would love to live in St John's Wood but I can't afford it 😂 so tough luck I have to live on outskirts of Greater London & commute in because that's what I can afford.

Why do those who qualify for social housing not understand that's just how life works. Many people who have to rent/buy can't afford to live where their parents lived or where they grew up.

Why would those in social housing be any exception?

HousingOne · 27/09/2021 21:58

Stop comparing it to covid and masks mercy it's a strange argument.

Though I am glad you have posted I was only this morning thinking I hadn't noticed any posts from you and if you were ok. I was even pondering what post I could start to get you to post.

Rhubarbsoup · 27/09/2021 21:53

To be honest the bigger issue is surely that housing in general is unaffordable to a lot of people. Most of my friends either rent or have bought their homes, all have moved away from the town we grew up in as the properties are too expensive; some have stayed local but others have moved further afield where its even cheaper. A lot seem to think being able to afford to rent or buy gives you freedom, and it does to an extent, but a lot of people make tough choices due to affordability of different areas. Most of my friends who grew up in London have had to move elsewhere, away from their support networks because they simply can't afford to rent beyond house shares, and definitely can't buy.

HousingOne · 27/09/2021 21:53

I also work in housing, NE and there isn't as much pressure on housing here as there is in other parts, but it is still very much a case of demand outstripping supply. Like a pp I often wonder if people truly think there is a stack of housing just hidden away that we can immediately give to them. I'm not sure if that's because there is a lower demand in general and therefore a realistic chance of being re-housed, but people then expect this to happen straight away.

There are lots of issues imo:

  1. I do agree with tenancies for life, the absolute downfall of private rent is the knowledge / fear that you can potentially be told to leave at any point. This ends up disrupting not only the tenants but also the neighbours. I do however think the focus should be on the tenancy rather than the actual property. There should be an expectation that once someone doesn't need the size / type of property that they are given the necessary help and support to move to another property.
  2. There needs to be an absolute realism of where you are likely to be offered a property - I am not talking, about like in the OP an expectation to move 100 miles away but there are people who define a very small geographical area or even the particular (high demand) street they want to live on - they are entitled to do this but they also have to realise that this means it will take longer to secure a move.
  3. Having always live in x town / paid your rent on time / kept your garden tidy does not mean that you will be offered a property above everyone else.
  4. Currently (in my area at least) there has been a massive increase in applications since covid, no one is quite sure why though.
  5. Choice based lettings has it's advantages and disadvantages - I think overall it is better than just a list.
  6. New properties can be built, but there is never enough, general housebuilding can't keep up with demand so I am not sure why people think that just building more SH will solve the housing crisis. The historic RTB is also unlikely to be solely to blame, housing has been forgotten about for decades, this is it just being lived out.

I'm not sure about just taking people back off the list but there is also no point if they will never be re-housed, though I also agree with others that if you take them off they then become part of the hidden figures.

I am not sure Gove is going to be of any help at all, no doubt he will make things worse, after all this is the same one who thinks all children should do better than average. Hmm

ComtesseDeSpair · 27/09/2021 21:45

[quote SailYourShips]@sst1234

Don't you agree that children need gardens?[/quote]
No. Children grow up in apartments all over the world and manage to be well adjusted, happy and well socialised. London is full of parks, playgrounds and green spaces.

SailYourShips · 27/09/2021 21:40

@sst1234

Don't you agree that children need gardens?

Bellybootcut · 27/09/2021 21:39

@Suddenlyfamily5

I can understand the frustration. My friend (A) came from Poland with 2 young DC. She was renting privately but was then given notice so applied for a council flat. She was given a spacious 3 bed flat in London near Cannonbury; couldn’t believe her luck

Our joint friend is a Londoner born and bred living with her DM and her toddlers in over crowded accommodation. She’s been waiting years for a CH.

It sadly ended their friendship as friend B couldn’t get over it.

So friend B chose to have children whilst living with her mum resulting in the accommodation becoming overcrowded? See, this doesn't help the argument! Not saying it's right that friend A got housed first mind.