Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think these changes to the housing waiting list are not “cruel” but simply realistic?

492 replies

Eastie77Returns · 27/09/2021 13:49

Our council has announced changes to the local housing waiting list from next month. There are tens of thousands on the list who will never be housed as they are not deemed to be in urgent need so they will now be removed.

The council has said they will be offered “personalised support to explore their options” which probably means advising they leave London, advances to help with private rent etc. I understand in many cases that is really not helpful but a close relative of mine who works in housing has been on the phone to me in tears because of the level of abuse she has faced from frustrated residents who have been on the list for years and are being removed.

Now a parent from DD’s school is organising a march on the town hall to protest all of this and has asked parents for support. She has been offered a council house 100+ miles outside London and is refusing to leave as her support network is here and I fully understand that. However, I do think a dose of realism is needed. There are 15,000 people on the waiting list here and a few hundred council properties become available each year. This parent has been told she does not fall into the 3 bands that will be kept on the list so she will never get a council house and she has responded by accusing the council of unimaginable cruelty Confused

I don’t understand where she expects the council to magically just find thousands of homes and change that situation?

OP posts:
ComtesseDeSpair · 28/09/2021 17:27

I believe most housing in Singapore is social housing?

Public housing in Singapore isn’t social housing as we know it in the UK. A significant proportion (I think even the vast majority of it nowadays) is owner occupied and sold at a slight subsidy to middle-income households, and apartments in major cities can still cost upwards of the equivalent of half a million pounds. It’s more akin to the UK’s Help to Buy and Affordable ownership schemes. It’s also only available to Singaporean citizens, among whom birth rates are among the lowest in the world, so public housing isn’t required to house thousands of non-native poor people.

NailsNeedDoing · 28/09/2021 17:18

@Kendodd

So now we have established that council housing is actually a long term benefit to the public purse, what is the objection to having more of it? I think it's just ideological. As stated in my post upthread, there has been a shift in our thinking and I don't think it's put us in a better place. I believe most housing in Singapore is social housing?
We haven’t established that at all, but even if there were a guarantee that the taxpayer would profit in the long term, that wouldn’t mean we can automatically afford it in the short term.

Being able to afford it isn’t the only consideration in London anyway, there simply isn’t enough space to house everyone that wants to live in London.

I agree with your ideals that low cost social housing should be available to pretty much everyone, but it’s never going to happen because the cost would be huge.

If we were to start a large expansion of SH in London and other popular areas, central government (the taxpayer) would have to pay for expensive land, expensive builders and materials, the administration for all of that, the administration for getting the right tenants in and the ongoing management when they’re in, the maintenance and regular safety inspections needed to comply with the law, and the property would never be sold so making back costs would be impossible that way.

Do people really think that minimum rent being dribbled back over decades is ever going to cover the bill for that? Never mind be a long term benefit to the public purse! There’s just no way it would ever benefit anyone other than the minority of lucky individuals that got a new house.

FanGirlX · 28/09/2021 17:13

[quote BlakeDreary]@FanGirlX I work on a development that has social housing. I'd say 90% of the occupants are not British nationals (and they aren't refugees either). One of the reasons we are struggling to maintain supply with demand is because we are overpopulated. Living in the capital city is a privilege, those who can't afford to live in it don't have a choice but to move further out. The same should be applied to social housing in my opinion. People need to consider moving out of the city for social housing. [/quote]
Thank you for that figure. I do think that we shouldn't be offering social housing to economic migrants, until we have housed local people.

I was an economic migrant in Singapore and Australia for a few years - I wasn't entitled to any state subsidies, nor should I have been.

OverTheRubicon · 28/09/2021 17:02

@ShinyThingsDistractMe

Why do you believe social housing is a massive cost?

The rent I pay, pays for the services from my landlord (the LA).

My social house was built in 1921, the last century has seen it pay for itself over and over again.

How is my house costing you?

It might be that there is a profit on your property - but that's not true of the vast majority.

Social housing means that the council is responsible for massive repair and maintenance bills, often on ageing housing stock and with a small (but not that small) number of tenants who due to various difficulties will cause major issues with damage to property itself or antisocial behaviour that needs management. There is a higher rent default than in the private sector. Then there's the cost of employing people to assess and manage the lists as well at the properties themselves.

Right to buy has not only reduced numbers of properties, but also taken a disproportionate number of higher quality stock out of the market.

Personally though, I don't mind if social housing runs at some loss - it's there for a reason and which of us knows if we might be in need some day. But I do when there's such a shortage that means that some people in deep need aren't being housed, those on lower incomes can't get access, while others on middle and higher incomes can sit pretty with a lifetime tenancy or buy and reap the profits.

NailsNeedDoing · 28/09/2021 17:00

Most people on housing benefit are not paying private landlords, they’re paying not-for-profit housing associations.

EvilPea · 28/09/2021 16:51

I get there isn’t enough. I get that we have to be realistic with our current social housing stock

However,
It’s not right. It’s not good for families, it’s not good for communities.
For those on housing benefit, it’s not good paying private landlords with tax payers money. It is not a good use of public funds either

That’s before you even start to look at the problems with social housing for disabled people

kinzarose · 28/09/2021 16:45

@EvilPea the problem is that many people do receive social housing properties that suit their needs at the time, but they go on to expand their families. I've seen this so many times, people in one beds having 2/3 children and blaming their MH/overcrowding on the council. There isn't enough stock to house those in need in their present day condition, let alone accommodating the growth of those families.
@Kenddod it is my personal belief that the limited SH (ie affordable rents) should be the remit of the most needy of society, not doctors, barristers and other high earners. Of course everyone wants to pay as little outgoings as possible, but we need to prioritise those who are most financially vulnerable.

EvilPea · 28/09/2021 16:33

@lonelyapple

Getting social housing in London is the equivalent of winning several million on the lottery these days.

The Tories won't build more social housing because the £25billion plus paid in housing landlord benefit keeps all their rich private landlords mates rich and voting Tory. That's why they won't divert it to building social homes.

It would be like winning the lottery to have a stable home I don’t risk losing in two months time.
Whammyyammy · 28/09/2021 16:31

The councils should just wave a magic wand and London would grow and more houses should appear, enough to satisfy everybody's wants.

There aren't enough houses, simple. What do you expect them to do in reality?

EvilPea · 28/09/2021 16:30

Making sure people have access to a stable home, helps give children a better start. People feel that they ‘belong’ that they can be and are part of the community.
It builds happier people, happier citizens. It helps people and communities prosper as people want to take pride in where they live.

It seems a basic need to me.

ShinyThingsDistractMe · 28/09/2021 16:26

Why do you believe social housing is a massive cost?

The rent I pay, pays for the services from my landlord (the LA).

My social house was built in 1921, the last century has seen it pay for itself over and over again.

How is my house costing you?

boldbutdire · 28/09/2021 16:24

My work involves a lot of housing issues so I deal with these all the both in london and outside of it. People sense of what's available, what they are entitled vs the reality are often very different. I am constantly managing expectations, especially in London. Out of london is different, the housing is better, more spacious and more readily available. people don't want to move but is often worry about not speaking the language or being accepted.

I will be moving out of london after divorce as I can't afford to stay. No other option, it's just what needs to be done. My family are all london based and I have a good support network here but financially it's not viable.

I do think life long tenancies need to go. A friend is in social housing, as lives with his partner for last 10 yrs. he owns his own property which is rented out, runs a successful business with 300k in the bank and it's a 2 bed for the two of them. Then I have families that are in temporary accommodation for years that are sleeping in the hallway and kitchen they are so overcrowded. Massively unfair. It need a total overhaul.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 28/09/2021 16:24

So how does that work for the 81% of the population of Singapore living in social housing? Are you saying the government are subsidising 81% of households?

I have no knowledge of taxation or the funding of public services in Singapore, nor do I feel it is relevant to the UK. I do have an understanding of the situation here, and I repeat, social housing is a massive cost.

On the bright side we don't have capital punishment, caning etc as they do in Singapore. It is not a country I would seek to emulate in many ways.

Dreamstate · 28/09/2021 16:22

[quote Eastie77Returns]@kinzarose I do agree about the sense of entitlement that SH can create. We have a relative who has lived in various council properties since she was 20. She had 3 small children when she was first housed and so was very clearly in need. However fast forward a couple of decades later, all 3 children have left home and she lives with her partner in a large council property that could easily house a family of 4-6. She will not entertain the idea of downsizing but is very quick to judge anyone else on her estate that she feels doesn't 'deserve' a council house.

The nature of her job means she is able to do quite a bit of work cash in hand. I would guess from what she has told me that their household income is in the region of £100k. She has said she will only consider moving if she is given another council property that meets certain criteria (large garden, dropped curb/driveway for the car..).

On her income she could easily rent privately but on the occasions I've suggested this she has looked at me as if I am crazy. And I get it: giving up an assured tenancy at below market rent to rent somewhere privately just doesn't make sense.

I don't really know what the answer is.[/quote]
And its examples like this that really piss people off and why there is such a backlash now. There will be genuine people in need but unfortunately the ones that take the piss overshadow it.

How disgusting she is benefitting from taxpayers money via a council house and then getting paid in hand of which of course she is not declaring. Makes me sick thinking why do I work and struggle through

BlakeDreary · 28/09/2021 16:20

@FanGirlX I work on a development that has social housing. I'd say 90% of the occupants are not British nationals (and they aren't refugees either). One of the reasons we are struggling to maintain supply with demand is because we are overpopulated. Living in the capital city is a privilege, those who can't afford to live in it don't have a choice but to move further out. The same should be applied to social housing in my opinion. People need to consider moving out of the city for social housing.

Kendodd · 28/09/2021 15:59

Social housing for those who need it is necessary and should be provided, but it is a cost to the public purse, and that is the objection. We should definitely suck that cost up, but pretending it is not a cost is not convincing.

So how does that work for the 81% of the population of Singapore living in social housing? Are you saying the government are subsidising 81% of households?

Kendodd · 28/09/2021 15:56

Why should high earners (doctors, solicitors, barristers) benefit from low cost housing?
Why shouldn't they benefit from low cost housing? Shouldn't all housing be low cost afterall it's an essential need we all have.

kinzarose · 28/09/2021 15:34

@lonelyapple it is probably as likely but it doesn't stop people moving to London in hope of one. I know a handful of people who uprooted themselves and their families to live in overcrowded flats (purposely, as they know this will push them up the list) hoping that London will offer better job prospects. They all think they will get a council/social property at some stage. It's the same with economic migrants from overseas, everyone wants London or another major city.

Eastie77Returns · 28/09/2021 15:20

@kinzarose I do agree about the sense of entitlement that SH can create. We have a relative who has lived in various council properties since she was 20. She had 3 small children when she was first housed and so was very clearly in need. However fast forward a couple of decades later, all 3 children have left home and she lives with her partner in a large council property that could easily house a family of 4-6. She will not entertain the idea of downsizing but is very quick to judge anyone else on her estate that she feels doesn't 'deserve' a council house.

The nature of her job means she is able to do quite a bit of work cash in hand. I would guess from what she has told me that their household income is in the region of £100k. She has said she will only consider moving if she is given another council property that meets certain criteria (large garden, dropped curb/driveway for the car..).

On her income she could easily rent privately but on the occasions I've suggested this she has looked at me as if I am crazy. And I get it: giving up an assured tenancy at below market rent to rent somewhere privately just doesn't make sense.

I don't really know what the answer is.

OP posts:
lonelyapple · 28/09/2021 14:52

Getting social housing in London is the equivalent of winning several million on the lottery these days.

The Tories won't build more social housing because the £25billion plus paid in housing landlord benefit keeps all their rich private landlords mates rich and voting Tory. That's why they won't divert it to building social homes.

FanGirlX · 28/09/2021 14:22

@woodhill

Yes, agreed. Refugees are very different from economic migrants.

woodhill · 28/09/2021 14:12

@FanGirlX

Have to agree apart from genuine refugees.

ComtesseDeSpair · 28/09/2021 12:42

@TheYearOfSmallThings

You're wrong, social housing is not subsidised and it pays for itself via the rents collected

I am not wrong, and I used to work in this area. The rents come nowhere near covering the true costs, and that is where the land and buildings are already owned.

This is broadly true. Social rents are pegged to a specific formula which means they often don’t reflect the true cost of maintaining, repairing and managing the property. At the last housing association I worked for, almost 30% of our stock was loss-making: the rents didn’t cover our costs. This is particularly true of Lindon and other major cities where the majority of stock is blocks of flats which come with high-ticket costs like lift maintenance and exterior repairs.

The reality is, if you wanted a profitable property portfolio, you wouldn’t choose to start with a collection of 1960s system-built tower blocks badly in need of investment and 19th century tenement blocks which were never anticipated to still be standing; and to then rent each flat out for £600 a month in a neighbourhood where the market rent is closer to £2,500 a month, to people whose low incomes mean they don’t always prioritise paying their rent, and who often have social problems and lifestyles which manifest in antisocial behaviour and requires you to employ staff whose specific job it is to manage that. That’s what most council and housing associations are operating with.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 28/09/2021 12:40

So now we have established that council housing is actually a long term benefit to the public purse, what is the objection to having more of it?

Well you are starting with a false assumption there so that might be where the objection comes in.

Social housing for those who need it is necessary and should be provided, but it is a cost to the public purse, and that is the objection. We should definitely suck that cost up, but pretending it is not a cost is not convincing.

Confiscatedpopit · 28/09/2021 12:36

What is the criteria to reach the top?