Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want to use 3rd bedroom for DC?

219 replies

lou4901 · 27/09/2021 13:20

Partner and I don't live together currently, but we're looking at renting a house jointly soon in the town where he lives (4 hours from me). I say jointly, but I'll only be there about 1 week in 4, he'll live there the rest of the time. I'm going to pay towards it.

My children are over 18 but still live at home. They've never been to his town but are keen to visit. He currently lives in a small place where there is no room for them to stay.

My intention - which my DC are keen on - is that when we rent a place with 3 bedrooms, 1 will be mine and DP's room, one an office (both DP and I wfh) and the 3rd room could be for DC when they stay. I was thinking of getting 2 single beds (I think asking them to share a double bed is a bit much!) - one has a bf, so I thought on any visit if he came they would share a room and other DC would sleep on sofabed in living room.

Except when I spoke to DP he was a bit off about it all and said why would we be having a room empty 90% of the time, he thought it would be better for DC to just stay in a hotel if and when they visit, and that as most houses we've looked at the 2 smaller bedrooms are at most 8 x 10 and some as little as 8 x 6, so it would be a struggle to get 2 beds in, let alone have the room for any other purpose.

I don't want to fall out about it before we've moved in but also I don't want them in a hotel...aibu?

OP posts:
Yaya26 · 27/09/2021 23:56

I like your thinking @lou4901. Can't understand some of the comments you're getting. Seems practical and considerate of everywhere.

Have I got this right you want and you're going to be covering any additional costs associated with the third guest bedroom?

As you can afford and it'll not not negatively impact on him then as my mum would have said "whoever pays the piper calls the tune"

lou4901 · 27/09/2021 23:50

I can't stay at his for a week as there's nowhere I can work. So at present I can only visit on weekends or days off. He can't work other than on a limited way from my house either, although I have more room all the kit he needs is at his and can't easily be moved between houses. So really this does seem the best solution all round.

OP posts:
TimeForTeaAndG · 27/09/2021 23:47

Sorry, I assumed they were at uni. But my question still stands, what are their goals and ambitions/where are the jobs?

If neither you nor DP want to live together full time then why bother trying to get him into a bigger house at the moment? By all means a slightly larger place that could accommodate both of you WFH and a sofa bed but honestly, I wouldn't be factoring in two 20-something adult DCs unless they were incapable due to disability of ever living on their own. I would be maybe reflecting on why you feel they are still so reliant on you all living together. Most DC are eithee moving out or at least living independent lives from their parents in their early 20s.

Sweettea1 · 27/09/2021 23:41

Why are you even looking st somewhere together when you will not be loving their?
Just go stay at his for 1week a month makes more sense an then no rent to pay.
Rent together when you are actually ready and able too.

DeepaBeesKit · 27/09/2021 23:17

Bet you a million quid you move and your DC never visit.

You want them to but why would they?! At 20/21 seeing you 3 weeks out of 4 why on earth would they travel to visit you in a rural area 4 hours from london jobs ?

lou4901 · 27/09/2021 23:12

I'm not infantilising them. As their mother my judgment is they still need me around. DP doesn't want me to move in FT with him yet as much as I don't want that either. It will be a big change for both of us. My children are and always have been the most important thing in my life, as I've said they only have me so I've always had to be there, there's never been anyone else to support them.

To a pp who asked if they would visit, yes absolutely. They are very keen, and ask about houses we're looking at. We're a close family, we still go on holidays etc together and days out, so I know they'll come and visit if there's a room for them to stay in.

Neither is at uni, one is doing some work related study so works pt and attends college.

OP posts:
TimeForTeaAndG · 27/09/2021 23:05

@lou4901

I'm not going to sell the house from under my DC (20 and 21 for those that asked). I also can't move permanently away from them. Firstly I think they still need me. They don't have any other family so it's not like I could think oh granny or auntie is just down the road. It's just them and me. Neither is currently in ft work so financially they couldn't support themselves although they certainly should be able to in a couple more years. And also I've never lived with DP. I've not lived with anyone but my DC for over 15 years and I'm not rushing to put my eggs in one basket. DP has also lived alone for almost 10 years and understands my caution. He's also not in a position yet to buy anywhere with me, but again in 3 years or so will be. For now this seems like the best solution all round, subject to us agreeing how to use bed 3. But I'm happy for it to be guest bedroom/ my office and I would hope I can persuade DP to agree that too.
I think your infantalising your DC somewhat, they are 20 and 21! As a PP said, leave them in your family home and charge them nominal rent. You move in with your DP full time. Actually find out if you can live together. 1 week in 4 is not a halfway house to living together, it's visiting and he can be on his best behaviour for that time.

If you and DP don't work out you've still got your family home to move back to and at that point see where DC are with regards to employment.

Though I can't believe that you expect they would want to move to the same area as you so they need taster sessions by visiting you and DP. What are their goals in life? Where are the jobs likely to be when they finish uni?

Thadhiya · 27/09/2021 22:48

@lou4901

I'll only be there 1 week in 4 because the rest of the time I'll be in my own house with my DC, 4 hours away. I don't want to move away permanently yet whilst they are still living at home.

I think his idea was we could have it either as a 2nd office, or home gym, or whatever.

If they're young enough to need you living with them, they need you living with them.

You don't pay rent on a home you don't live in. You visit it.

This whole thing is bonkers, has he got some baffling sway over you? You live with your children, if you move house then your children have a room in the new house and if you pay rent, you live in the rented house. Paying your 'boyfriend's' rent who says your kids, whom you still need to live with full time, aren't family-enough to stay - sounds like a very dismal, weird setup.

timeisnotaline · 27/09/2021 22:45

But, if you need a separate room from dp to work in, wasnt the original plan you shared that the 3rd room be a guest bed and you share the 2nd as home office? How was that going to work?
My concern is if dc come to stay and it’s your office they sleep in, dp works as normal and you get told tough it’s your children.

timeisnotaline · 27/09/2021 22:44

Well, you’ve decided it’s non negotiable. Fair enough, lots of people want their children to visit at holidays and Christmas. Now you just have to tell him this- he might not need the room but he certainly seems looking forward to having it as his home gym etc.
Because he doesn't need a bigger house, so I'm paying a sum roughly equal to the extra costs

lou4901 · 27/09/2021 22:10

I'm not going to sell the house from under my DC (20 and 21 for those that asked). I also can't move permanently away from them. Firstly I think they still need me. They don't have any other family so it's not like I could think oh granny or auntie is just down the road. It's just them and me. Neither is currently in ft work so financially they couldn't support themselves although they certainly should be able to in a couple more years. And also I've never lived with DP. I've not lived with anyone but my DC for over 15 years and I'm not rushing to put my eggs in one basket. DP has also lived alone for almost 10 years and understands my caution. He's also not in a position yet to buy anywhere with me, but again in 3 years or so will be. For now this seems like the best solution all round, subject to us agreeing how to use bed 3. But I'm happy for it to be guest bedroom/ my office and I would hope I can persuade DP to agree that too.

OP posts:
19lottie82 · 27/09/2021 19:12

How old are you kids?

TatianaBis · 27/09/2021 18:40

Well if your kids are going to live with you until they can afford to buy a place that will be another 20 years.

This need to keep the family home is a bit OTT give their ages. They’re adults, the ones at uni need somewhere to come ‘home’ to in the holidays but any who have finished uni and are working a just share a place like everyone else in their 20s.

If you rent out your London house, rent somewhere with this guy big enough for your kids to stay in uni holidays, and to visit from London, see how you both cope cohabiting FT. If it doesn’t work you still have your London place.

Elieza · 27/09/2021 18:08

Would him moving to a house instead of a flat be an option, that wouldn’t cost you anything?

You could then have a campervan in the driveway which dc could stay in if they visit and which you could wfh in using his electricity and broadband.

Or is that more barking mad than fun adventure and extra space.

Bollocks989 · 27/09/2021 17:48

So you will pay for your own property and contribute towards bf having a bigger property....mind boggling..

DiamondBright · 27/09/2021 17:44

Wouldn't it make more sense for your dc to rent your house from you and for you to move permanently in with your DP, with space for guests so they can come for Christmas etc. Until they're able to buy/rent their own homes and then you can sell and buy a home with DP? I understood you not wanting to keep buying and selling but could your DC not live in a two bedroom flat to free up some capital?

I've been with my DFiance for 2.5 years and we're desperate to move in together and are making plans, but we both have school age children, if they were all adults we'd have moved in together by now.

ThatsAllFolks · 27/09/2021 17:24

OP sounds eminently sensible and lovely to boot. Good idea to ease the kids to feeling part of new area. Agree bed situation can be resolved via sofa bed solution suggested, hope it all swimmingly OP, sure it will and good luck to you in the next phase of your life.

crimsonlake · 27/09/2021 17:06

Tbh this makes no sense whatsoever to me. Why not carry on as you are, why the urgency to live together.

TweetyPieBird · 27/09/2021 17:04

@lou4901 We've not moved in together because I did not want to permanently move my children from the home they've grown up in, and he is unable to live in this area. Not really sure how else we could have resolved this?!

Your DC are adults now. You could sell your house and you and DP could get a mortgage together. Live in an area that suits both of you. 1 room can be the office and the other is a guest bedroom (doubles up as your DC’s bedroom when they stay over). If you’re not ready to move in together then you’re not in a serious relationship.

BoredZelda · 27/09/2021 17:03

Seems to me that the OP has thought this through carefully do rather than tell her she is a gullible idiot whose about to be ripped off by an utter bastard, maybe we should turn our minds to the question of the 3rd bedroom?

Exactly. My answer is, if she is paying for the extra room, she has a say in what it is used for. The only thing I’d caution on is to try and get to the bottom of why he doesn’t want the kids to stay. After all, it’s not too difficult to have a room that doubles up as a guest room if required that can still be used for other things when not being used by guests.

BoredZelda · 27/09/2021 17:01

Hang onto your independence (and your money) and put your children first.

How is this impacting on OP’s independence. If anything it is her partner who is more at risk as if they split, she can just walk away and stop paying. He’d be without a home.

MissSmiley · 27/09/2021 16:56

@lou4901 have you actually asked your kids if they want to come and stay? I have older teens and their social lives no not involve spending time with me and a boyfriend, I'd bet if you did this they would always be too busy and never actually use the spare room

Porcupineintherough · 27/09/2021 16:48

Seems to me that the OP has thought this through carefully do rather than tell her she is a gullible idiot whose about to be ripped off by an utter bastard, maybe we should turn our minds to the question of the 3rd bedroom?

OP does your dp have a specific plan for the 3rd bedroom? Perhaps something more neutral - like sofa beds- might be the answer if he just doesn't want it to look like an unused bedroom for 90% of the time? A spare room rather than a room specifically for your kids.

lou4901 · 27/09/2021 16:41

@TweetyPieBird

1. Why do you need to pay for the new house when you’re technically just a guest?
  1. I would not say that this is a committed relationship. You’ve been together for 8 years and still haven’t moved in together.
  1. He just wants your money.
  • Because he doesn't need a bigger house, so I'm paying a sum roughly equal to the extra costs
    1. We've not moved in together because I did not want to permanently move my children from the home they've grown up in, and he is unable to live in this area. Not really sure how else we could have resolved this?!
    1. If he did, I'm sure he'd insist on a joint tenancy. He's insisting on the opposite.
    OP posts:
    whynotwhatknot · 27/09/2021 16:41

    Do your dc pay rent/board are they working ?

    You say theyre not ready for you to leave but you will be leaving one day when is someone ready for that

    if your possibly leaving for half of the time they'll get used to it anyway

    Swipe left for the next trending thread