Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think kids should be able to walk in the rain

361 replies

MiaMarshmallows · 27/09/2021 12:02

To school if it is less than 30 minutes away?

OP posts:
Rosesareyellow · 27/09/2021 17:53

Yes if they’ve got proper coats and footwear on. No if you let them walk out in black ballet pumps and a fleece hoodie. Some of the children in my class arrive with soaking wet socks and tights which they need to take off to dry, damp jumpers that they need to take off - not great for them obviously but I’d argue even worse for my nose… the whole classroom then smells a bit damp.

Plantlady10 · 27/09/2021 17:51

It was torrential rain here this morning- I walked to work (1 mile) and was dripping wet when I arrived, it took till lunchtime for my hair and clothes to dry (and my socks and shoes were still wet at the end of the day). I dont have a car, but dont think it would be unreasonable to drive in that kind of weather!

BlueMongoose · 27/09/2021 17:42

At the risk of 'going all Yorkshireman' I used often to walk that far back from school back in the day, and the only waterproofs we had back then were awful unbreathable cagouls. And I survived.
In fact, I still rather like walking in the rain.
But I did take the bus TO school. It's not healthy to be sitting about in wet clothes all day.

esloquehay · 27/09/2021 17:21

My girls and I always walk the 30 min 'trek' to their preschool come rain or shine. ☺️

Soupseason · 27/09/2021 17:20

Of course they can. But it's also nice sometimes to get an extra 20mins in bed & arrive warm & dry.

rhonddacynontaf · 27/09/2021 17:20

My autistic son absolutely cannot

icedcoffees · 27/09/2021 17:18

@gogohm

I walked to school 40 mins each way from 11-16, the only waterproof thing I had was an umbrella (school coats were wool). We all survived. If you can't afford a £5 umbrella and £20 jacket for your kids (cheaper from charity shop) I doubt you can afford petrol
But you generally need more than that.

Around here an umbrella is pointless as we're by the coast so it's windy and they just blow inside out and break.

So you need a good waterproof coat (which costs more than £20 if you want it properly waterproof), waterproof trousers and waterproof shoes or wellies. So probably £40-50 per child.

Not too expensive, but considering how quickly kids grow, they will need replacing fairly regularly.

Plus most schools (especially secondaries) have nowhere to store any of that stuff, so you have to cart it around in a plastic bag in your backpack all day, meaning it doesn't dry, and meaning when you go home, you either have to get wet, or put on wet, damp, cold clothes which won't keep you dry anyway.

I mean, yes, it's doable but it's not exactly pleasant. And if you can't afford the waterproofs, or your kids won't wear them (and how many teenagers do you know who are going to wear full waterproofs to get to school), it's miserable walking in torrential rain and sitting around all day in wet clothes with wet socks and shoes.

CuriousaboutSamphire · 27/09/2021 17:12

@seaandsandcastles

Why should anyone be walking in the rain if they don’t have to? Confused
Or drive their car when they didn't have to?

Surely the point is about choices.

Walking to school in all weathers is possible. Doesn't have to be the soggy hell many seem to think.

Get wet, add to ozone depletion etc. It's a choice!

RobinPenguins · 27/09/2021 17:10

@seaandsandcastles

Why should anyone be walking in the rain if they don’t have to? Confused
Air quality, excess deaths, pollution, congestion, traffic jams, petrol shortages?

If all the people who drive 1 mile or less on the school run switched to walking it would make a lot of difference to the quality of life of a lot of other people. I’m sure everyone will be along to say that they aren’t contributing to all that because they are just dropping their kids off on their way to work which they couldn’t possibly get to by any other means other than car, but it isn’t true.

seaandsandcastles · 27/09/2021 17:04

Why should anyone be walking in the rain if they don’t have to? Confused

Fl0w3ry · 27/09/2021 16:59

My grandparents walked everywhere from a young age in wind, rain or shine. Even when they were elderly they walked everywhere whatever the weather. They were all strong and resilient people and lived well into their 90s. Walking in rain does no harm at all it promotes resilience, independence and strength. My DC like walking in the rain. They sing, splash in the odd puddle and then dry out.

gogohm · 27/09/2021 16:56

I walked to school 40 mins each way from 11-16, the only waterproof thing I had was an umbrella (school coats were wool). We all survived. If you can't afford a £5 umbrella and £20 jacket for your kids (cheaper from charity shop) I doubt you can afford petrol

DogFoodPie · 27/09/2021 16:50

I used to walk 27 miles to school in the rain, in my day. No shoes or coat and swim across a small river, scale a ravine and fight off wild dogs. Kids these days don't know they're born.

Pigflewpast · 27/09/2021 16:49

We live at the top of a hill, school is at the bottom of it. The roads and paths were flowing water like a stream. An umbrella or hood would not have stopped soaking wet shoes, socks and trousers. Every passing car threw up a splash onto the pavement.
Our secondary school has no lockers so students have to carry everything around all day. They have nowhere to store spare clothes or shoes, nowhere to put soggy coats.
Yes my son could have walked to school, but then he would have had to sit in soaking clothes all day and carry a large soaking coat, along with everything else. Why would I make him do that if I could give him a lift and let him have a comfortable day? If there was no alternative he would have had to do it, but I don’t understand why anyone wouldn’t make life nicer for their dc if they can?

icedcoffees · 27/09/2021 16:49

Waterproof walking shoes stops me getting wet feet, waterproof overtrousers (cost about £12 from Black's about 10 years ago, you could probably get similar from somewhere like Mountain Warehouse) stops me getting wet legs, and a decent raincoat with a peaked hood which I can tighten to fit stops me getting wet hair. I add an umbrella if it's not too windy.

But most schools (especially secondaries) have nowhere for kids to store all that stuff. So they have to cart it around all day, it has no chance of drying, and if it's raining on the way home, they have to get dressed back into damp, cold, smelly waterproof clothes that have been stuffed in an old carrier bag for six hours.

libertyfarmboots · 27/09/2021 16:48

YANBU. Mine walks to school and back every day regardless of the weather. We stay in Glasgow, if you don’t walk in the rain you’d never be out the house 🙂

I understand though that everyone has different circumstances and many parents drop their kids to school on the way to work etc in which case walking in doesn’t really make sense.

NailsNeedDoing · 27/09/2021 16:47

They can, but if it’s uncomfortable and unnecessary then why do it unless they want to?

RichardMarxisinnocent · 27/09/2021 16:45

@MiloAndEddie

I guess they can but tbh as an adult I’d bloody hate it. Wet feet/tights/legs/hair (because hoods never fit!) is miserable. Plus it was windy as hell here this morning and my umbrella turned inside out
Waterproof walking shoes stops me getting wet feet, waterproof overtrousers (cost about £12 from Black's about 10 years ago, you could probably get similar from somewhere like Mountain Warehouse) stops me getting wet legs, and a decent raincoat with a peaked hood which I can tighten to fit stops me getting wet hair. I add an umbrella if it's not too windy.
icedcoffees · 27/09/2021 16:43

@HugeAckmansWife

I think it's great to get kids out in all weathers to play if they can go inside when they're done, get warm and dry in fresh clothes. Sitting around in damp polyester or soaked feet though is a different thing. It's not about being pathetic or wimpy or anything else, why be miseale and gold if you don't have yo?
Exactly.

Being out in the rain in good waterproofs, coming home, stripping off and sitting in a warm room with spare clothes is a very different experience to walking to school in sodden polyester uniform, and then spending six hours in damp clothes with wet feet, then having to walk back home in the pissing rain in wet, cold clothes.

I love walking and regularly do 20-25k steps a day, but I can go home and strip off, have a hot shower and curl up on the sofa under a blanket afterwards. Kids can't do that at school.

icedcoffees · 27/09/2021 16:37

@Antinerak

Healthy, able children in proper clothing should manage 30 minutes in rain. It's rare that you'd get 30 minutes of terrential, freezing rain so they can manage some drizzle.

Unhealthy, unable students obviously shouldn't be forced to- especially if they have risk of getting ill from the cold or slipping on wet floors.

We had six hours of torrential, cold rain this morning and it's due to be the same every morning this week.

It started around 2/3am and didn't stop raining until around 10am. It's very common for it to be like that here in Autumn/Winter.

SMBH · 27/09/2021 16:36

@Goldbar

Loving the idea that people with expensive wet weather gear make do without a car Grin. Does it come with a teleport function for holidays to Cornwall?
Right!
gailplattshairbrush · 27/09/2021 16:34

It's fine if they are properly clothed but a bit mean if they have to sit in soggy clothes for the rest of the school day.

CandyLeBonBon · 27/09/2021 16:34

I drive my lot to school/college when they were younger and if it was tipping down, I'd give them a lift in because walking in the rain to get to work or school is miserable. It also made sure they got there on time and helped avoid meltdowns and was generally just easier all round. For me and them.

My eldest 19, autistic and walks everywhere just fine, in spite of being pampered by lifts for most of his life. My middle one is massively independent and cycles everywhere and my youngest walks home from school unless it's absolutely chucking it down and I'm not in a meeting.

None of them have developed lazyitis, in spite of all the Pearl clutching going on here! And I'm the only fatty amongst us (thanks menopause and arthritis!)

I wouldn't walk in torrential rain to get to work unless I had no choice. Don't see why kids should have to either, as long as they know they need to walk when it's fine we're all good!

fluffythedragonslayer · 27/09/2021 16:32

We don't have a car and no bus goes to my daughter's school. So if it rains, we get wet!

Goldbar · 27/09/2021 16:30

Loving the idea that people with expensive wet weather gear make do without a car Grin. Does it come with a teleport function for holidays to Cornwall?