Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think kids should be able to walk in the rain

361 replies

MiaMarshmallows · 27/09/2021 12:02

To school if it is less than 30 minutes away?

OP posts:
GoldenOmber · 29/09/2021 15:52

I would say so far in 2021 (or since the schools/nurseries reopened at least) I’ve had maybe four school or nursery trips where I’ve thought, hmm, best to get the waterproof trousers out for this one. And a fair few more where it was raining but not that badly, hoods up and don’t dawdle levels of rain.

icedcoffees · 29/09/2021 15:46

@GoldenOmber

it's not likely to be enjoyable

It’s not, really. But I suppose I don’t consider “not enjoyable” to be all that awful as part of a school journey, once you’ve removed wet/cold/in pain? Certainly not on the same level as ‘abusive’ as a pp described it. It’s a bit annoying, but it’s not a horrendous act of suffering.

Oh, I agree it's not abusive (or neglectful as someone else said) but I also don't think it's the worst thing in the world to drive if it means your child doesn't get an absolute soaking.
GoldenOmber · 29/09/2021 15:42

it's not likely to be enjoyable

It’s not, really. But I suppose I don’t consider “not enjoyable” to be all that awful as part of a school journey, once you’ve removed wet/cold/in pain? Certainly not on the same level as ‘abusive’ as a pp described it. It’s a bit annoying, but it’s not a horrendous act of suffering.

icedcoffees · 29/09/2021 15:36

@GoldenOmber

I mean, you might make it work but it doesn't make it any less grim and miserable, lol. I walk outdoors all day in the rain, it's grim even if your waterproofs keep you dry.

Walking for under 30 minutes in the rain is really not the same as being out in it all day, though, is it? Especially if you don’t get wet and cold through inadequate clothes, as various people are convinced that children walking in the rain must do.

Well, it depends on the type of rain.

Light drizzle is fine, but when it's so torrential you can hardly see, it's not likely to be enjoyable no matter what waterproof gear you have at hand.

I'm sure someone will be along shortly to tell me how wonderful it is to trudge along pavements in horizontal rain and 20mph winds, though Grin

GoldenOmber · 29/09/2021 15:32

I mean, you might make it work but it doesn't make it any less grim and miserable, lol. I walk outdoors all day in the rain, it's grim even if your waterproofs keep you dry.

Walking for under 30 minutes in the rain is really not the same as being out in it all day, though, is it? Especially if you don’t get wet and cold through inadequate clothes, as various people are convinced that children walking in the rain must do.

GoldenOmber · 29/09/2021 15:26

@Coffeepants

Did I say other parents are mean or did I say my choice is to drive?
“I don’t understand the perspective at all, kids must just fit into your life and if we managed to walk in snow and hail so should they. I guess we could also still use landlines only and wash clothes by hand.”

“Life is hard enough as it is, don’t think they need any more lessons in resilience from age 4. Also, in my mind, keeping them comfortable and dry where I have the means and ability to, is just common sense.”

Is what I was thinking of.

But as I said, clearly I’m wrong to suggest you were only being sneery because you thought other parents were being in some way mean/unfair/not wanting to keep their children dry and comfortable.

Everanewbie · 29/09/2021 15:22

Couldn't be arsed to read the whole thread, but my two penny's:

Depends. On how bad the rain is, how good the coat is, what they need to carry, how robust the child in question is, what they have on that day, have they got a cold etc.

Yeah if you send them out in hurricane Bob with an art project and ingredients for food tech with a cold and wearing tesco shoes and no coat and no change of clothes - massively unreasonable.

Child well, travelling light, bit of light rain, decent coat, waterproof shoes, meh, just get on with it.

safariboot · 29/09/2021 15:13

In what I'd see as a "normal" situation I'd say YANBU. But I can think of all sorts of cases where the walk wouldn't be suitable. Like a pavementless road with known reckless drivers. Or a school who are pricks about uniform and would give detention to a child who "is scruffy" because they walked in the rain. Or, like a PP mentioned, a school that's known for having cold rooms. Right now feels like the coldest it's been since spring and I bet lots of schools haven't put the heating on because it's not the calendar date for it yet.

icedcoffees · 29/09/2021 15:01

Again: what do people think those of us who can’t just ‘jump in the car’ do, exactly? Stay wet all day? Refuse to go to work/school/nursery? Or could it be, could it possibly be, that we actually do make this work?

I mean, you might make it work but it doesn't make it any less grim and miserable, lol. I walk outdoors all day in the rain, it's grim even if your waterproofs keep you dry.

Umbrellas are no good here as it's so windy so I still get a soaking wet face, my glasses get soaked and I can't see a bloody thing. I can't clear my glasses as if I get a dry t-shirt/cloth out of my pocket it's soaked in seconds.

I mean, it's doable and I do it everyday but I go home to a nice, warm, dry house where I can strip off, shower and change into something clean and comfortable. That just about makes it bearable imo.

icedcoffees · 29/09/2021 14:58

Their call, then, really? I’m not sure that “Mum, I know I could stay dry by putting the right clothes on but I don’t want to do that so please drive me door to door” sounds that compelling, but perhaps I am just a terribly mean parent.

It might not be compelling, but if I could drive my kids and save them from getting a soaking (waterproofs or not) then I would. Walking in the pissing down rain is grim, no matter how much MN tries to spin it as being virtuous and fun and wholesome.

MeredithGreyishblue · 29/09/2021 14:57

@GoldenOmber

See below. (And also a previous comment that implied that, although she has a car and agrees it's miserable, she doesn't want to make other parents look unkind by making a fuss!)

Well, gosh, terribly sorry for saying you were only being sneery because you think other parents are mean and make our kids sit around with wet feet. Clearly you don’t think that and just felt like sneering anyway, I do apologise.

readwhatiactuallysay · 29/09/2021 14:54

I think if you choose to and you can make sure they arrive with dry clothes and feet, then yes crack on.

If others choose not to, hey ho, each to their own, i personally dont enjoy walking in the rain, so i wouldn't be bringing my son along for the journey to make it longer.

GoldenOmber · 29/09/2021 14:50

@MeredithGreyishblue

So, in order not make some parents feel terrible by walking in the rain, we ALL have to walk in the rain and make ourselves late for work as an added bonus.

OK.

This place is bonkers.

Nobody said that, did they? Confused

“AIBU to think kids should be able to walk under 30 mins to school if it’s raining?”
“Yeah, that’s a reasonable expectation.”

Coffeepants · 29/09/2021 14:50

Did I say other parents are mean or did I say my choice is to drive?

FreedomFaith · 29/09/2021 14:48

@icedcoffees

Come on , who the fuck wants to walk anywhere in bouncing rain for 30 minutes?

This is MN - if you admit you hate the rain or being wet and windswept, you're told you're wearing the wrong clothing and just need to change your attitude Grin

But also on MN, you should all be walking regardless to save the environment.

I personally just find it lazy to drive when it's raining if you could walk it in 20 mins. If you can afford a car, you can afford a coat that is waterproof, there's plenty available that don't cost £100 each and are still waterproof.

But the environmentalists aren't wrong. All of this driving short distances is a contributory factor in why earth is screwed. Its just not going to change either because people are too lazy.

womaninatightspot · 29/09/2021 14:47

I think half an hour in the rain sounds pretty miserable. My kids went out the door in salopettes today though. We have a a five minute walk; ten minute wait (varies hugely) for the school bus. I don't mind walking in bad weather didrikson coat and ski gloves and muck boots but somehow standing in the rain is worse.

MeredithGreyishblue · 29/09/2021 14:45

So, in order not make some parents feel terrible by walking in the rain, we ALL have to walk in the rain and make ourselves late for work as an added bonus.

OK.

This place is bonkers.

GoldenOmber · 29/09/2021 14:42

@Coffeepants

She is actually responding to the comments about how we are raising snowflakes, are your children made of paper, etc? She also clearly said you do you, in response to the question, no I will not make my kids walk in the rain. Guess we won’t be winning any awards for powering through, but Idgaf. Next time, address me directly.
Well, gosh, terribly sorry for saying you were only being sneery because you think other parents are mean and make our kids sit around with wet feet. Clearly you don’t think that and just felt like sneering anyway, I do apologise.
Coffeepants · 29/09/2021 14:35

She is actually responding to the comments about how we are raising snowflakes, are your children made of paper, etc? She also clearly said you do you, in response to the question, no I will not make my kids walk in the rain. Guess we won’t be winning any awards for powering through, but Idgaf. Next time, address me directly.

Shellfishblastard · 29/09/2021 14:29

It depends how heavy the rain is and how well dressed the kids are.

One day we left home and it started to pour - a 3 minute walk to the bus stop. My dd had on a heavy rain coat but didn’t have on waterproof trousers. The rain was torrential and by the time she was on the bus we were both soaked through. I even had to change my underwear! All the kids and parents were soaked. I had to take a skirt and tights to school for her.

If you are prepared for the rain then yes it’s fine. Although half an hour both ways might be tiring for a wee one, especially at the end of the day. We walk a lot and 30 minutes home might cause some moans some days!

Anonymous48 · 29/09/2021 14:28

Where I live it rains so hard sometimes that raincoats, wellies and umbrellas are not enough to stop you getting completely soaked. If that was the case, and I was able to drive my child to school rather than them sitting all day in wet clothes, then yes I would absolutely drive them.

GoldenOmber · 29/09/2021 14:26

If you had the choice and you didn't like the rain, surely you'd drive?

Nobody likes the rain, come on.

I probably would drive sometimes if I had a car, because I am a fairly lazy person. OTOH, my children live in a very rainy country, so I really don’t want them growing up thinking that going out in the rain is some kind of horrendous endurance mission that no kind parent would ever subject a child to.

Sunshineandflipflops · 29/09/2021 14:24

@Calendulaaaaa

We biked as usual. The only comment on the weather was them asking if they could take umbrellas Confused not sure how they were imagining that would work
I saw a woman riding a bike the other day, while holding an umbrella. She could barely steer and almost knocked into me jogging as she couldn't see where she was going!
GoldenOmber · 29/09/2021 14:22

@icedcoffees

Come on , who the fuck wants to walk anywhere in bouncing rain for 30 minutes?

This is MN - if you admit you hate the rain or being wet and windswept, you're told you're wearing the wrong clothing and just need to change your attitude Grin

I do hate the rain! I just don’t think it’s worth bewailing the horror of having to go out in it when you have to go anyway. Far easier to say “bugger, it’s raining” and put a coat on.
MeredithGreyishblue · 29/09/2021 14:22

Some people have no choice but to walk.
Some have no choice but to drive.

If you had the choice and you didn't like the rain, surely you'd drive?

Unless you're auditioning your kids for SAS Who Dares Wins, giving them a lift in the rain isn't the end of the world.

Swipe left for the next trending thread