Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not buy a second car we can't afford just to do 0.7 mile school run!

184 replies

Acunningruse · 27/09/2021 12:00

Our second car broke during the first lockdown and we haven't replaced it as DH and I now both do 3days wfh/2 days in office. This means that the parent wfh that day walks the children (9 and 5) to school. We live 0.7 mile away from school and to be honest it's been absolutely lovely over the spring and summer months, having time together on a morning and not fighting for a parking space. However...
This morning was absolutely biblical rain, just torrential. I wrapped kids up as best as I could in waterproof coats, wellies and took ab umbrella (utterly useless in wind!) but we still got soaked. Dd (5) thought splashing in puddles was hilarious but DS (9) was increasingly grumpy, muttering about how 'no-one else' walks (this unfortunately is almost true, 99% families drive) abs then got very upset that his trousers were soaked so now of course I feel horrendously guilty. Not to mention all the playground comments this morning of 'oh goodness, you walked in THIS! You must be soaked!' No shit Sherlock but it's a bit of water I'm not sending them down the mine ffs!!!

AIBU- no, buy another car at once, walking every day will be awful in winter
IANBU- no, buy the kids some waterproofs (where to change them though? School not really set up for it as above no-one else walks far) and tell them when I was a girl I walked to school in rain hail or snow, uphill both ways... Grin

OP posts:
DoctorSnortles · 27/09/2021 12:54

I live in a rural village. We moved here years ago and part of our reason for doing so was so our child could go to a local primary school and would be able to walk there and back, which we always do. I am always shocked to see neighbours driving their kids round to school. Some days they have to park so far away from school they are actually walking further than if they walked from home! One woman, like a PP, told me she just refuses to do cold or damp, so puts her child in her massive Audi and drives 0.5 miles to school so her hair doesn’t go frizzy, then spends ten minutes trying to park.

Ridiculous.

Keep walking, OP. You just need waterproofs and a cheery attitude.

Lovelydovey · 27/09/2021 12:53

Both of mine walked just over a mile each to school - they’ve got decent waterproof jackets. It would take longer to drive them than it does to walk there and back - and even longer at the moment given queues for petrol….

I guess I’m in the mean mummy camp.

Stellaris22 · 27/09/2021 12:52

*teaching kids

Emmacb82 · 27/09/2021 12:52

I walked in the torrential rain this morning with ds5 and ds1 in his buggy. Rain cover on, waterproofs on and off we go. And I have a perfectly good car outside that I refuse to use on the school run. Can’t be doing with the amount of traffic and trying to find somewhere to park. So much easier to just walk.

arethereanyleftatall · 27/09/2021 12:52

If you're not exaggerating, and your school is not in the middle of nowhere, it is INSANE that 99% drive. Awful.

It wouldn't cross my mind to drive 0.7 miles anywhere. Nor anyone I know.

My own experience is that 90% of our school walk, we're all within a mile. Others come from further or on their way to work so they drive. Amounts to about 20 cars.

How big is your school? If it's one form entry, 7 year groups, that's 200 cars every day?!? Just how?

Stellaris22 · 27/09/2021 12:52

Driving that distance, twice a day would be completely ridiculous. Definitely stick to your guns and keep walking, it's great exercise and teaching big kids that you can't just 'jump in a car' for everyday short trips is very important.

We walk about the same distance to school and it's just over a mile (each way) once a week for a swimming lesson.

ChaoBella · 27/09/2021 12:51

Better more expensive waterproof clothing will not always keep everything dry. It is far more important that they fit well and they are tucked in where needed. I also suggest changing shoes and socks upon arrival. A good sized backpack with pairs of shoes wrapped in carrier bags will do the job.

AntiMaskersAreTwats · 27/09/2021 12:50

We got a really small, cheap electric car as our second car. We use it for local runs and for the rare occasion we both need a car at the same time. It’s been a godsend, especially in times of fuel shortage. It has ended up saving us more than it costs us.

MasterBeth · 27/09/2021 12:50

@FabulouslyFab

Don’t buy another car - it will work out cheaper buying good quality waterproof clothing in the long run!
It will work out cheaper in the short term too! How much were you planning to spend on waterproofs!
Coffeepants · 27/09/2021 12:49

We usually walk or scoot but days like this morning, we have driven as kids tend to be so much slower walking in the rain and we do all end up quite wet (waterproof jackets are great but find stepping in puddles is the problem for little ones).

Whoever said these days don’t happen often must be living in a different part of the country to me (London was pouring today, had it a couple weeks ago too and rain expected the rest of the week too).

I wouldn’t especially buy a second car for it but def don’t want children cold and wet by the time we get to school.

ScumbagDave · 27/09/2021 12:48

YANBU

We always walk. We're lucky enough to be about the same distance you are from school and driving is way more stressful. There's nowhere to park anyway.

CharityDingle · 27/09/2021 12:48

Agree re waterproofs. You could take the waterproofs back home with you and have them dry for the return journey, if the weather has not improved during the day.
I definitely would not be buying a second car for such a short journey.

GettingItOutThere · 27/09/2021 12:48

i would buy waterproof pants and jackets - spend the money on that! waterproof pants you can take off and put in your bag and take home to dry? then you walk them back for pick up

no i would not buy a 2nd car for 1.4 mile round trip a day!

VavavoomHenry · 27/09/2021 12:48

Full expensive waterproofs will set you back £500 for the family, much cheaper than a car but spend the money.

Also, if possible get them to take off the waterproofs at school and wfh parent takes them home and puts them on the radiator. So they are dry to walk home with.

Iggly · 27/09/2021 12:48

I think it’s lazy to be honest. It really is.

Be prepared for the weather, and you’ll not go far wrong. Get the kids decent shoes and coats and they’ll dry out. Give them spare socks if you must.

Cupoftea53 · 27/09/2021 12:47

If you live rurally then I imagine you would
already be kitted up with wellies and bad weather gear. As they say, no such thing as bad weather, only the wrong clothes.

HotPenguin · 27/09/2021 12:46

Honestly, you are doing your kids a favour by teaching them how to deal with bad weather. When they get their first jobs or go to university will they be able to afford a car? Will they even have a car parking space at their home or place of work? Much better for them to learn now how to live without depending on a car.

OakPine · 27/09/2021 12:46

If others make comments like "you didn't walk in this!" for a bit of rain, I'd be throwing it right back at them "You drove! Yet again! Really? Don't you just live round the corner? Have you heard of something called climate change?"
No way I'd be made to feel bad for saving money, helping to save the planet, and keeping my kids fit.

Ozanj · 27/09/2021 12:44

They need longer wellies and a longer waterproof coat so their trousers / tights don’t get soaked. It is absolutely ridiculous that anyone would expect healthy kids to be driven 0.7 miles!!!

Cupoftea53 · 27/09/2021 12:42

Also, your kids are quite old and can walk at a normal pace, carry their own bags etc. It’s a bit harder in the rain with a slow meandering toddler.

Cupoftea53 · 27/09/2021 12:40

Blimey, 0.7 miles?! I wouldn’t think of using my car for a distance like that!!

dannydyerismydad · 27/09/2021 12:40

Decent rain coats (knee length if possible rather than hip length and welly boots are all you need.

0.7 miles is no distance. It must take you longer to strap everyone into the car and find a space at the other end than it would to walk.

mayblossominapril · 27/09/2021 12:39

Can the 9 year old walk in wellies and joggers and then nip in and change into school trousers and shoes and give you the wet clothing to take home? Its only a few days a year.
I would ask about taxi firms as there are often a few around even in very rural areas.

Ashitaka · 27/09/2021 12:38

@Availableforbaking

Unless one of you is disabled or has mobility issues driving 0.7 miles is the height of laziness. No wonder the propulsion is obese and roads near schools are chaos. Walk or cycle. Change of clothes if it’s that wet.
I agree with this - 0.7 mile to school!
EatYourVegetables · 27/09/2021 12:37

YANBU.

Get proper clothes, good umbrellas, maybe bring spare socks. We have an obesity crisis and a climate crisis because everyone got used to driving short distances and “cannot cope without a car”. There won’t be torrential rain every day, where I am today was the worst day in probably a couple of years.

As for the poster upthread who “hates walking”, FFS, there are people in wheelchairs and children who walk 5 miles to school every day to get an education, check your privilege.