Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not buy a second car we can't afford just to do 0.7 mile school run!

184 replies

Acunningruse · 27/09/2021 12:00

Our second car broke during the first lockdown and we haven't replaced it as DH and I now both do 3days wfh/2 days in office. This means that the parent wfh that day walks the children (9 and 5) to school. We live 0.7 mile away from school and to be honest it's been absolutely lovely over the spring and summer months, having time together on a morning and not fighting for a parking space. However...
This morning was absolutely biblical rain, just torrential. I wrapped kids up as best as I could in waterproof coats, wellies and took ab umbrella (utterly useless in wind!) but we still got soaked. Dd (5) thought splashing in puddles was hilarious but DS (9) was increasingly grumpy, muttering about how 'no-one else' walks (this unfortunately is almost true, 99% families drive) abs then got very upset that his trousers were soaked so now of course I feel horrendously guilty. Not to mention all the playground comments this morning of 'oh goodness, you walked in THIS! You must be soaked!' No shit Sherlock but it's a bit of water I'm not sending them down the mine ffs!!!

AIBU- no, buy another car at once, walking every day will be awful in winter
IANBU- no, buy the kids some waterproofs (where to change them though? School not really set up for it as above no-one else walks far) and tell them when I was a girl I walked to school in rain hail or snow, uphill both ways... Grin

OP posts:
MsAwesomeDragon · 27/09/2021 14:27

Get some waterproof overtrousers and get on with it. My kids have walked to school with their childminder throughout primary (under a mile each way), and alone now the youngest is at secondary.

On torrential rain days, DD takes a waterproof coat, and a spare pair of school trousers in a plastic bag to change into dry clothes when she gets to school. Yes, she gets wet, but there's not a lot I can do about it when I'm headed in the opposite direction in the car to get to work.

Coffeepants · 27/09/2021 14:26

Agree with this. I don’t personally have the time to also carry spare clothes and help them get changed, etc and then get to work for 9am 🤷🏽‍♀️ Logistics sound painful to me

Paddingtonsmarmlade · 27/09/2021 14:25

Yep decent waterproof trousers / spare trousers/socks so they can change at school if necessary.

BiddyPop · 27/09/2021 14:23

Mountain warehouse are good for DCs.

BiddyPop · 27/09/2021 14:22

Waterproofs for general use, and for a fraction of 2nd car cost, a small kitty for occasional taxis when weather is particularly bad.

ProfSprout · 27/09/2021 14:20

OP I have a second car and we still walked our similar length school run this morning. It’s much easier than driving and trying to park, and better for us too. Nothing wellies and a good coat can’t deal with.

HairyToity · 27/09/2021 14:19

Yanbu

dotdotdotdash · 27/09/2021 14:18

YANBU! Walking and cycling is the way forward... Muddy Puddles does a good range of waterproofs for kids.

I totally agree with @OakPine that you should change the narrative on those people who are exclaiming at you for walking in the rain. You should question how they justify driving short distances!

ProfSprout · 27/09/2021 14:17

@DrCoconut

I'm not sure that schools have the facilities and time for everyone to get changed out of/into and dry head to toe waterproofs. Not to mention all the items getting lost or stolen every day. I'm pretty sure our school would ask you to stop bringing them due to the logistics. It's one of those nice(?) but impractical ideas. The reality is you either drive/get lift/taxi or your kid spends the day soaking wet and miserable. I just missed the rain this morning luckily.
That’s completely ridiculous. It’s absolutely normal for children to have wet weather gear to change in / out of on wet days, and really no bother. I teach y1 children and they can manage it fine. Schools would much rather children walk than deal with all the parents’ terrible driving and parking doing the school run.
KittenSmitten · 27/09/2021 14:16

Look at Polarn and Pyret, they do amazing rain and cold weather coats. Get yourself some nice all weather boots too- Dubarrys or similair. It’s not cheap stuff but compared to a car and all running coasts it’s peanuts! And it will keep you all dry and toasty. Great way to start the day: well done, wish I could do they same!

HTH1 · 27/09/2021 14:15

Not to state the obvious but why doesn’t the one who is working drop them into school? If they work reasonably standard hours, the timing should work and the school run shouldn’t add on that much extra time.

thecatsthecats · 27/09/2021 14:15

My local school has an 800 yard catchment area, but they've still had to put up a special anti-traffic zone around it because of the number of people driving their kids in.

I lived a 1.5 mile walk from work and only ever skipped walking when I had stuff I couldn't carry. It gave good head space from my working day. In fact my vets is that distance away and I find driving and parking more difficult just walking.

steppemum · 27/09/2021 14:13

When mine were primary age, we always walked. So three kids, that is about 12 years. (youngest is now 13)

I think we really only got wet about 2-3 times a year. On those days we wore wellies (dry feet was the most important thing I think).

It was often drizzly, or cold or damp, but very, very rarely actually wet.

Lockdownbear · 27/09/2021 14:13

For the very low number of days when it's raining that heavy I'd taxi.

Back in the day we all walked very very occasionally it was really really heavy rain. On those days we all changed into gym shoes and I think some into shorts too.

But really your talking maybe one or two days a year.

Calendulaaaaa · 27/09/2021 14:11

@DrCoconut

I'm not sure that schools have the facilities and time for everyone to get changed out of/into and dry head to toe waterproofs. Not to mention all the items getting lost or stolen every day. I'm pretty sure our school would ask you to stop bringing them due to the logistics. It's one of those nice(?) but impractical ideas. The reality is you either drive/get lift/taxi or your kid spends the day soaking wet and miserable. I just missed the rain this morning luckily.
This might depend on your school - our school get annoyed by parents driving when there's no need.
RobinPenguins · 27/09/2021 14:10

I'm not sure that schools have the facilities and time for everyone to get changed out of/into and dry head to toe waterproofs. Not to mention all the items getting lost or stolen every day.

It doesn’t rain heavily every day. This is just making excuses.

DrCoconut · 27/09/2021 14:04

I'm not sure that schools have the facilities and time for everyone to get changed out of/into and dry head to toe waterproofs. Not to mention all the items getting lost or stolen every day. I'm pretty sure our school would ask you to stop bringing them due to the logistics. It's one of those nice(?) but impractical ideas. The reality is you either drive/get lift/taxi or your kid spends the day soaking wet and miserable. I just missed the rain this morning luckily.

Mustreadabook · 27/09/2021 14:04

We (almost) always walk to school. I find that actually at least 50% of the time that it looks like you will get soaked it doesn't actually happen, it does rain less than you think it does! Also it probably helps the children be awake and ready for school.
If your son is tall and slim look at decathlon for waterproofs, they all seem to be slim fit and are pretty cheap too.
We also use scooters quite a bit of the time, when they were little it was much faster, now that's not really a problem but I have one too and it's much more fun than walking. The school has a bike shed to leave them in. I wonder if you could try and interest the school in getting their 'green credentials' by encouraging walking and cycling eg somewhere to hang coats, time to change, somewhere to leave bikes. There is a national cycle to school week where our school randomly gives a prize each day by attaching it to a bike in the bike shed.

Mol1628 · 27/09/2021 14:02

10/15 minute walk for us. The rain is really a non issue. Sometimes they get a bit wet. They dry off. On really bad days they put wellies and over trousers on.

They moan occasionally but I explain to them that rain isn’t an acceptable reason to drive a short distance. I have a car and can drive but if it’s a walkable distance, we always walk.

Kids moan about stuff sometimes that’s just what they do.

HarrisonStickle · 27/09/2021 14:01

You could also have an arrangement with another family who do drive, so that on days when it really is too awful to walk, you can give them a ring and they can take your kids to school. These days will be very far and few between, but it'd be good to have a backup if it were needed.

Etonmessisyum · 27/09/2021 14:01

We live 3/4 miles from school it’s not walkable but when it was I loved walking them.

I knew this morning we’d need to leave early as no one would be walking due to the rain. I’ve to cross a city and take dc to 2 schools so need to get there on time. High school was mobbed. Primary school I didn’t see anyone walking. We park a bit away and walk as it’s a nice area but no close parking anyway. My kids actually (weirdly) like the rain so was telling them to do their jackets up etc. When I was a child we didn’t have a car. Mum could drive, dad couldn’t and he was miserly with money so we didn’t have a car. We walked everywhere so no choice. We walked to Safeway with mum and took backpacks for the shopping and carried some bags once a week, walked to beach etc i don’t remember it being awful and it was in the north of Scotland so really cold wet & snowy winters we survived but we’re always well wrapped up always had welly boots and waterproofs etc. I don’t even really like driving my own kids to school but I don’t have a choice due to where we live, I’d enjoy a walk too. That’s the rain back on just in time for home time

LoomBoom · 27/09/2021 14:00

0.7 mile is doable though when chucking down and younger kids preferable to have the option to drive. Perhaps there are mums you could carpool with for those days?

We are 1.3 miles, 30 minute uphill walk, we mostly drive. When the car is at mechanic it is a real pain and all the taxis are contracted for school runs (with loads available outside of school run hours). That said I'd walk everyday if I didnt need to start work by 8/9am.

sunflowerdaisies · 27/09/2021 13:59

We live 0.5 miles away and some of our neighbours drive, it's easier to walk than faff with parking! We have two cars but always walk. They wear wellies and have an umbrella each and that's normally fine. Heavens opened this morning so they put waterproof trousers on with skirt tucked inside.

Skinnytailedsquirrel · 27/09/2021 13:56

You would be being extremely unreasonable to buy a car/use a car to drive less than a mile to school.
This is why there is a global climate crisis, because people feel entitled to do selfish things like this.
Walk. Wear proper clothes. We are not in the Arctic.

BashfulClam · 27/09/2021 13:54

I always find it vex weird how many people drive kids to school. I walked every day, primary schools was half a mile away (I walked myself after a few months but there was always loads of people heading in that direction and no roads to cross) . Secondary school was a mile away and I live in the West of Scotland where torrential rain is common. I remember being wet and/or cold several times. I got picked up once because I nearly fainted.