Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To disagree with NHS only petrol stations?

638 replies

pistachio20 · 27/09/2021 11:08

Some petrol stations around me have now said that they are only allowing in NHS staff to refuel - apparently checking ID.

I find this completely ridiculous and unfair - not only because the majority of NHS staff where I live can easily get public transport to work (most who I know don’t drive to work anyway, and get train/bus anyway due to lack of free parking!).

So many crucial jobs require people to drive, let alone people with caring responsibilities, mobility issues, etc.

AIBU to think that it’s unfair?

OP posts:
tigerlilly22 · 29/09/2021 06:40

So in the same token, if NHS workers can get public transport, how about all the workers too. I'm not disagreeing with you either btw, but who decides who's essential and non essential?

FateHasRedesignedMost · 29/09/2021 06:29

The same ones who were waving NHS badges to skip queues at supermarkets while all the pensioners waited out in the cold. Like my neighbour works 10-2 in a office NHS role but couldn’t possibly wait like everyone else

Why do you think NHS workers mostly have office roles? You know it says on your ID badge where you work eg full time B6 nurse on acute medical ward.

When I had to get to work on time during the pandemic I often used my badge to nip into Tesco on the way… because I needed to pick up an item or two for a patient eg they’d come into hospital with no toiletries.

Was I going to wait behind 20 pensioners with trollies when I’d be in and out in 5 minutes? Should I have made myself an hour late for work?

To the door staff’s credit they did read my badge properly and sometimes asked the name of the ward I worked on. Nobody ever waved me through and I always apologised to the queue and explained I work at the hospital on a covid ward.

JosieJasper · 29/09/2021 00:12

Buses and trains dont always run at the times we nhs staff need to be in work for so forgive us for needing to use cars . I'll raise it with our trust that perhaps they need to provide us with bicycles or at the very least horses . Maybe that would suit you better

What!? So it’s only NHS staff that work shifts is it?

Roxy69 · 29/09/2021 00:05

A friend of mine just filled her tank with using the NHS card, even though her retired husband also has a car, presumably not completely empty. People are just selfish.

Bideshi · 28/09/2021 23:34

@Whitefire

All they're asking in this case is that before people fill their car with just-in-case petrol they might consider that others need cars for life or death jobs. And not just talking NHS here.

Well yes it isn't just the NHS that do vital jobs.

Yes I already made that point several pages ago and more than once.

Neither am I suggesting that everyone in the NHS gets preferential treatment. And, furthermore, I agree that the Health Service is appallingly administered and much money is wasted. Not only that, but the GPs need to get back to work. And everyone should have a carbon monoxide monitor.But there is a distinction to be made between the malaise inherent in the health system, the hagiographical bollocks dished out by Boris and the redtop press, and the poor sods who have to do their best to work the system. All I'm saying is let's consider the poor sods.

OK does that cover everything?

Just maybe a few people might be economical with the fuel they have in order that other people can do their jobs. And community carers and health professionals, emergency tradesmen, undertakers - you name it- are a bit more important than someone's urgent need to go to Ikea at the weekend.

XenoBitch · 28/09/2021 23:03

@Intercity225

Nobody dies at this time of year if their boiler packs up.

Carbon monoxide poisoning - believe you me, even low level poisoning made DH feel like he was dying! All because a cap over a hole in the flue wasn't there, meant the boiler was throwing out carbon monoxide back into our kitchen!

I have lost a friend to carbon monoxide poisoning, and known of others to have issues with low level poisoning too. It is terrifying as you can't smell it or anything.
Whitefire · 28/09/2021 22:59

All they're asking in this case is that before people fill their car with just-in-case petrol they might consider that others need cars for life or death jobs. And not just talking NHS here.

Well yes it isn't just the NHS that do vital jobs.

OhWhyNot · 28/09/2021 22:57

Genuine question. What is the point of giving NHS staff petrol if none of their patients can make it to hospital because they have no fuel

Because many of those most vulnerable are in hospital receiving constant care

Cant even get to see a doctor these days so I can’t see why the nhs should be prioritised?everyone else still needs to get to their work places, teachers, postman,delivery drivers, carers, list is endless

Everyone doesn’t need to absolutely be im work but many NOT just NHS absolutely do

I work in MH if we are not staffed to a level that is needed (and required) that can create a problem that is very difficult to manage and can be detrimental to a number of people (staff and patients)

If a supermarket isn’t staffed to the level quite needed it’s inconvenient to customers

I really don’t get the what about arguments. It’s another bashing for NHS staff why isn’t the anger directed at the companies that have offered NHS staff priority?

It’s been a theme on MN for quite some time now NHS staff bashing (no have never been comfortable with the clapping) direct your anger at the companies not people just getting on with their work

Intercity225 · 28/09/2021 22:55

Nobody dies at this time of year if their boiler packs up.

Carbon monoxide poisoning - believe you me, even low level poisoning made DH feel like he was dying! All because a cap over a hole in the flue wasn't there, meant the boiler was throwing out carbon monoxide back into our kitchen!

twelly · 28/09/2021 22:44

Petrol stations should be able to gave minimum/maximum spend which would stop overfilling and those who continually fill up (must be a minority I think.) To limit stations to NHS only staff is not in my view desirable - I think some NHS staff really suffered during the pandemic and did amazing work. However, there are essential workers in other industries - supermarkets, food production, education, police etc etc - so in my view we should not have NHS petrol stations

user1494334072 · 28/09/2021 22:39

Cant even get to see a doctor these days so I can’t see why the nhs should be prioritised?everyone else still needs to get to their work places, teachers, postman,delivery drivers, carers, list is endless

Wazzzzzzzup · 28/09/2021 22:27

Anyway. Passed through number of counties in last few days and yes, the prices went up in placea, but only 1 station was oot, none had queues, few were fairly busy, but nothing longer than couple of cars in line.
The hysteria is ridiculous. It's obviously a localized issue which is still being blown out of proportion by media and "but your loved onea might diiiiieeeee" people. Everyone should shut the fuck up, stop being special and it will calm down in 24 hours🙄

Ddot · 28/09/2021 22:20

Don't forget it's for the ambulances too, nobody wants them to run out.

OnceUponAThread · 28/09/2021 22:17

@Itsnotover

YABU

I think it's fair. If other people could take what they need instead of filling up endless Jerry cans, thus wouldn't need to happen. But people are vultures & always will be.

Genuine question. What is the point of giving NHS staff petrol if none of their patients can make it to hospital because they have no fuel...
Dreamstate · 28/09/2021 22:15

@Bideshi

Deeply saddened by all the bile being spewed here.

The NHS is struggling, underfunded and understaffed. But so many of the people on the ground are doing the very best that they can under the most difficult of conditions. It isn't the workers in the NHS who set up this notion that the NHS can do no wrong. They more than anyone know the drawbacks and holes in the system. Neither do they want to be sanctified; Many absolutely cringed at the clapping and saucepan banging. They just want the tools to be able to do their job.

Nobody dies at this time of year if their boiler packs up. But somebody may well become gravely ill or even die if their essential health workers can't get through. I don't know of anyone working in the NHS who would use their position to get priority over a a malfunctioning boiler. All they're asking in this case is that before people fill their car with just-in-case petrol they might consider that others need cars for life or death jobs. And not just talking NHS here.

Some shocking posts here.

The NHS is not underfunded its funds are mismanaged. You could pour trillions into the NHS AND IT WOULDNT BE ENOUGH! It'll never be enough unless you sort out of the bureaucracy and ineffective processes that lead to funds being used in effectively.

Oh and where da fuck are th GPS hiding? Eh being funded by NHS and not even doing face to face appointments in many areas, not even returning phonecards picking up their fat wages and not even working full time. Like wtf! Why is money being wasted like that!

In many sectors people are getting a payrise, yet NHS workers are. You can argue they are low paid etc. But end of the day they are still getting a rise. Meanwhile hundreds and thousands of us who aren't will be suffering payouts anywhere up to £1y0 and beyond thanks to NI tax, increasing council tax and now increasing energy costs. We sont get payrises to soak up some of that cost.

So fuck off quite frankly. Trust me last thing anyone wants to be is ill!

Explosivefarts · 28/09/2021 22:10

I would bet they would be on the phone to their local gas board, bleating about "being NHS" and deserving priority. "Sorry love... can't get to you. None of our guys have petrol. NHS only, innit".

The same ones who were waving NHS badges to skip queues at supermarkets while all the pensioners waited out in the cold. Like my neighbour works 10-2 in a office NHS role but couldn’t possibly wait like everyone else.

Wazzzzzzzup · 28/09/2021 22:07

Problem is that in UK there is no separation between healthcare staff and healthcare syatem.
So if someone criticized NHS people take it as criticizm of staff, not of the overal system.
They are not one. Nhs isn't a person

Bideshi · 28/09/2021 22:04

Deeply saddened by all the bile being spewed here.

The NHS is struggling, underfunded and understaffed. But so many of the people on the ground are doing the very best that they can under the most difficult of conditions. It isn't the workers in the NHS who set up this notion that the NHS can do no wrong. They more than anyone know the drawbacks and holes in the system. Neither do they want to be sanctified; Many absolutely cringed at the clapping and saucepan banging. They just want the tools to be able to do their job.

Nobody dies at this time of year if their boiler packs up. But somebody may well become gravely ill or even die if their essential health workers can't get through. I don't know of anyone working in the NHS who would use their position to get priority over a a malfunctioning boiler. All they're asking in this case is that before people fill their car with just-in-case petrol they might consider that others need cars for life or death jobs. And not just talking NHS here.

Some shocking posts here.

MyPatronusIsACat · 28/09/2021 22:01

@SylviaTrench WELL SAID!

MyPatronusIsACat · 28/09/2021 22:01

@XenoBitch

I would bet they (NHS workers) would be on the phone to their local gas board, bleating about "being NHS" and deserving priority. "Sorry love... can't get to you. None of our guys have petrol. NHS only, innit".

That would be some supreme irony!

SylviaTrench · 28/09/2021 21:54

@FrozenWillow

YABU

Pray that you never need the NHS. If you need a community nurse or community midwife, how are they going to assist you at your home without fuel in their car?

I might not have needed the NHS today, or yesterday, or the day before that. I pray I won't need them tomorrow. I sure as hell needed electricity, clean water, and food.

Do you really, honestly think that power generation staff, water treatment staff, people involved in food supply etc etc, should not have priority to fuel?

Are you genuinely happy to sit at home with no electricity?
Are the NHS staff all going to do their jobs with no electricity either?
How will the fuel pumps work?

MyPatronusIsACat · 28/09/2021 21:31

Ditto all of the above. ^ NHS trumping everything is ludicrous. It's crazy that people cannot criticize them without being chastised.

Whitefire · 28/09/2021 21:24

Well there won't be any need for NHS staff to get to the hospitals as no one else will be able to get there for their appointments.

Lots of people's jobs are vital as well.

Explosivefarts · 28/09/2021 21:24

Or all the factory’s where the medical supplies are made for the NHS but no NHS trumps everyone and everything

DecadentlyDecisive · 28/09/2021 21:13

[quote MyPatronusIsACat]@XenoBitch

And if her car blows up, she can't get it fixed because the people working in garages could not get to work either...

Exactly this. ^ And there are plenty more examples of workmen/ tradespeople/ skilled manual workers, who wouldn't be able to get to work, if ONLY THE NHS are allowed petrol!

I bet the people supporting this nonsensical idea, wouldn't be so keen if the gas maintenance man couldn't get to them to fix their heating, or the plumber couldn't get to them to fix their washing machine...

Utterly UTTERLY bonkers idea. For SO many reasons.[/quote]
Or Telecoms - how do they think records, scans, updates etc are magically transported between NHS bodies, trusts, surgeries, even departments!!