Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To disagree with NHS only petrol stations?

638 replies

pistachio20 · 27/09/2021 11:08

Some petrol stations around me have now said that they are only allowing in NHS staff to refuel - apparently checking ID.

I find this completely ridiculous and unfair - not only because the majority of NHS staff where I live can easily get public transport to work (most who I know don’t drive to work anyway, and get train/bus anyway due to lack of free parking!).

So many crucial jobs require people to drive, let alone people with caring responsibilities, mobility issues, etc.

AIBU to think that it’s unfair?

OP posts:
Explosivefarts · 29/09/2021 08:30

[quote toooothacheee]@cricketmum84 that's why I said unless you can prove you are an essential worker that needs fuel for work.

So show your ID and fill up as much as you need in that position.
[/quote]
But how would one prove they are unpaid carer we have no ID for that ?

toooothacheee · 29/09/2021 08:14

[quote cricketmum84]@toooothacheee ah I had missed that but. It's obviously too early for me Grin

Still though I do think a maximum cap will mean more petrol station visits even for non essential workers. So the queues won't go down.

People just need to buy fuel as they normally would before all this craziness started. That's the only way it will stop. [/quote]
In the short term though it would stop fuel running out at stations quite as quickly because not everyone would be permitted to fill their tanks to bursting. Then hopefully people would calm the fuck down when they realise if everyone just fills up as they normally would it should settle down.

There is no perfect solution but something needs to be done to slow down the panic buying. Similar to when certain items in a supermarket were limited to say 2 per transaction to stop people buying crates of beans Grin

cricketmum84 · 29/09/2021 08:10

@toooothacheee ah I had missed that but. It's obviously too early for me Grin

Still though I do think a maximum cap will mean more petrol station visits even for non essential workers. So the queues won't go down.

People just need to buy fuel as they normally would before all this craziness started. That's the only way it will stop.

toooothacheee · 29/09/2021 08:07

@cricketmum84 that's why I said unless you can prove you are an essential worker that needs fuel for work.

So show your ID and fill up as much as you need in that position.

cricketmum84 · 29/09/2021 08:05

@toooothacheee

A more appropriate system would be to have a cap on how much petrol anyone can buy in one transaction.

Say £15/20, unless you have proof you are an essential worker that needs fuel for work.

But then surely that means that if you were, for example, a home carer driving between peoples homes you are going to have to go and sit in that queue for your allotted £15 of fuel every single day.

Similar issues with a minimum amount you can buy. Not everyone can afford to fill their tank every time. But it would stop those pesky panic buyers who are topping up every day refusing to let their tanks drop below the full line!

toooothacheee · 29/09/2021 08:02

A more appropriate system would be to have a cap on how much petrol anyone can buy in one transaction.

Say £15/20, unless you have proof you are an essential worker that needs fuel for work.

Morph2lcfc · 29/09/2021 07:55

@cricketmum84

Come back and update us when your next doctors appointment or hospital visit is cancelled because NHS staff couldn't get to work.

YABVVU

Agree bu, perhaps the poster will come back and update us when they can’t work anyway as there kids are off school and the house is freezing cold as no one can get there to fix the boiler
cricketmum84 · 29/09/2021 07:51

@EmmaGrundyForPM

The nhs is not the only essential service that needs fuel to function.

This.
Most NHS staff work in one location only. Obviously District Nurses, Community physios etc don't, but the majority do. On the other hand, domiciliary care workers all travel considerable distances to visit people who need support with basic care in order to live.

I once shadowed a care worker for a morning. Between 7am and 2pm we visited 12 people and covered almost 100 miles. That was extreme as she was also covering for another worker who was off sick but having to drive 40 - 50 miles a day isn't unusual for a care worker in a rural area. Without those visits, people will go without medication and food, will not be assisted to the toilet and so on.

I would prioritise care workers and community NHS staff over NHS staff who work exclusively in a hospital or clinic. I would also prioritise people working in power stations, HGV drivers transporting food, train and bus drivers etc. The list goes on.

As there is no way of doing that, there shouldn't be any prioritisation.

It needs some sort of system the same as the pandemic where certain occupations were deigned Essential workers. Carers , NHS, fire, police, teachers etc.

Although that does become open to abuse unfortunately. My DH is an office worker with a job he could easily do from home yet his employer wanted everyone in the office so gave them all letters saying they were classed as essential workers!

EmmaGrundyForPM · 29/09/2021 07:48

The nhs is not the only essential service that needs fuel to function.

This.
Most NHS staff work in one location only. Obviously District Nurses, Community physios etc don't, but the majority do. On the other hand, domiciliary care workers all travel considerable distances to visit people who need support with basic care in order to live.

I once shadowed a care worker for a morning. Between 7am and 2pm we visited 12 people and covered almost 100 miles. That was extreme as she was also covering for another worker who was off sick but having to drive 40 - 50 miles a day isn't unusual for a care worker in a rural area. Without those visits, people will go without medication and food, will not be assisted to the toilet and so on.

I would prioritise care workers and community NHS staff over NHS staff who work exclusively in a hospital or clinic. I would also prioritise people working in power stations, HGV drivers transporting food, train and bus drivers etc. The list goes on.

As there is no way of doing that, there shouldn't be any prioritisation.

cricketmum84 · 29/09/2021 07:40

@toooothacheee totally agree.

There is a petrol station on the news this morning that is opening for an extra 90 minutes on a night for frontline workers only. Not just NHS.

Intercity225 · 29/09/2021 07:40

And everyone should have a carbon monoxide monitor.

We did have a monitor, but it's set to go off when the carbon monoxide is above a certain level - our carbon monoxide was below that level, but even at the low level caused both of us poisoning. We both felt ill for months! Apparently, people should have a digital monitor, which shows what the level actually is!

LST · 29/09/2021 07:39

@cricketmum84

Come back and update us when your next doctors appointment or hospital visit is cancelled because NHS staff couldn't get to work.

YABVVU

It is you being unreasonable.
MarshaBradyo · 29/09/2021 07:38

@Ddot

It will calm down, once you have a full tank you have a full tank.
It will head of some petrol organisation this morning

A few things stood out

  • tanker drivers aren’t as in much of shortage as HGV
  • demand went up 500% over weekend
  • there may even be a dip next
But some tankers can’t access to deliver due to demand

It was an example of behaviour change which is understandable imo but this should mean once filled up and can move past it quite quickly

toooothacheee · 29/09/2021 07:34

@cricketmum84

Come back and update us when your next doctors appointment or hospital visit is cancelled because NHS staff couldn't get to work.

YABVVU

What about if you need police support and they don't turn up. Your house is on fire? Nevermind! Or the kids can't go to school because they are understaffed. How about disabled/elderly people who can't get out of bed and washed without a carer? And need their medication? Care homes with no staff?

The nhs is not the only essential service that needs fuel to function.

TinselTitsAndGlitteryBits · 29/09/2021 07:32

@tigerlilly22

So in the same token, if NHS workers can get public transport, how about all the workers too. I'm not disagreeing with you either btw, but who decides who's essential and non essential?
Those who drive said public transport?

No buses/taxis if they can't get petrol. The drivers that can't work from home/walk to work.. because they drive for a living.

cricketmum84 · 29/09/2021 07:30

Come back and update us when your next doctors appointment or hospital visit is cancelled because NHS staff couldn't get to work.

YABVVU

toooothacheee · 29/09/2021 07:28

I disagree with prioritising certain jobs and areas of work for petrol. There are so many roles that are essential, not just nhs workers.

Fire Service
Police
Home carers
Teachers
Delivery/distribution services

Everyone needs to plan ahead for if they run out of petrol and if they need it keep trying stations.

It's a pain, and the country is full to bursting with absolute dick heads panic buying, but limiting an essential item like petrol to one area of work is really stupid.

TinselTitsAndGlitteryBits · 29/09/2021 07:27

@JosieJasper

Buses and trains dont always run at the times we nhs staff need to be in work for so forgive us for needing to use cars . I'll raise it with our trust that perhaps they need to provide us with bicycles or at the very least horses . Maybe that would suit you better

What!? So it’s only NHS staff that work shifts is it?

Makes you wonder what members of NHS staff that don't drive do to get to work?

Does everyone who works at a hospital drive? I doubt it.

Offmyfence · 29/09/2021 07:17

@olivehater

Maybe some are working from home but doesn’t change the fact that’s those working in hospitals are not. Do you need them to prove that that is what they do. How do you suppose they do that. Our id badges don’t specify whether we are clinical or not. I drive to work. I do not work from home. Therefore I need petrol. I am sure you will be the first to complain when there is no one to see you in A&E. But agree care worker should also be govern priority. I would like to think if they showed their badge to a petrol station. They might show some discretion.
I also need petrol to drive to work, as do many and you'd also be unhappy if

Your bins weren't being emptied
Your post not being delivered
No food in the shop
No one to serve you on the shop
No one to fix your car

The list is endless, loads of people need to be physically at work.

HagridHair · 29/09/2021 07:15

This thread is so depressing

TinselTitsAndGlitteryBits · 29/09/2021 07:13

@jwpetal

All of us could get buses, walk, taxi but it's more convenient. Also many are travelling in their cars for home care and on poor wages. I know some take advantage of this but they are more prioriy
Bit tough getting a bus or taxi when they've no fuel either.

My dad drove round for 40 minutes last night before finding diesel at 1.67. If he doesn't have it he cannot work.
Taxi driver. No fuel = no work at all.

He can't walk, get a bus/train, work from home, take a few days off...

He NEEDS fuel. Arguably more so than some, even in the NHS, who could walk/cycle.

Offmyfence · 29/09/2021 07:13

@EdgeOfTheSky

All essential front line workers need to be priorities for fuel needed for them to be able to get to work / do their work.

We should be able to self police this and act responsibly if told not to fill up our tanks irresponsibly.

But people are selfish and stupid.

Ok but what about people, who if they don't get into work, they won't get paid.

No furlough money for these, but they won't be able to pay their bills, provide food etc.

Surely these should be prioritised also?

Offmyfence · 29/09/2021 07:10

@Boood

YANBU. I’m sick to bloody death of the virtue hierarchy of jobs in this country. If your job keeps a roof over your head it’s essential, whether you’re an ICU nurse or an Instagram influencer.
Exactly!
Ddot · 29/09/2021 07:05

It will calm down, once you have a full tank you have a full tank.

Morph2lcfc · 29/09/2021 07:04

@OhWhyNot

Genuine question. What is the point of giving NHS staff petrol if none of their patients can make it to hospital because they have no fuel

Because many of those most vulnerable are in hospital receiving constant care

Cant even get to see a doctor these days so I can’t see why the nhs should be prioritised?everyone else still needs to get to their work places, teachers, postman,delivery drivers, carers, list is endless

Everyone doesn’t need to absolutely be im work but many NOT just NHS absolutely do

I work in MH if we are not staffed to a level that is needed (and required) that can create a problem that is very difficult to manage and can be detrimental to a number of people (staff and patients)

If a supermarket isn’t staffed to the level quite needed it’s inconvenient to customers

I really don’t get the what about arguments. It’s another bashing for NHS staff why isn’t the anger directed at the companies that have offered NHS staff priority?

It’s been a theme on MN for quite some time now NHS staff bashing (no have never been comfortable with the clapping) direct your anger at the companies not people just getting on with their work

I said upthread, I don’t need to be in work as I could work from home and have done for 18 months. However our employer changed rules when the isolation rules changed and now there’s no home working at all everyone is back in. I’m sure lots of ppl are in same position we can’t just not go in or we’ll not get paid for the day and potentially sacked for not turning up for work