Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To disagree with NHS only petrol stations?

638 replies

pistachio20 · 27/09/2021 11:08

Some petrol stations around me have now said that they are only allowing in NHS staff to refuel - apparently checking ID.

I find this completely ridiculous and unfair - not only because the majority of NHS staff where I live can easily get public transport to work (most who I know don’t drive to work anyway, and get train/bus anyway due to lack of free parking!).

So many crucial jobs require people to drive, let alone people with caring responsibilities, mobility issues, etc.

AIBU to think that it’s unfair?

OP posts:
Xenia · 27/09/2021 14:31

I can't work out the issue. Some papers are saying once everyone has filled right up there is no shortage. Others say there is not enough petrol even if that were so? If it is just the former I can sit back for a few days until I am almost down to zero try to go nowhere and once everyone else has their full tank it will be back to normal.

If instead it is that there is not enough petrol coming through the country then we need the army not only to drive it but to go the DVLA where I think there are tends of thousands of heavy goods driving licence applications in a massive back log due to DVLA strikes.

Toddlerteaplease · 27/09/2021 14:31

@AliceAbsolum

Jesus everyone is so obsessed with the nhs. I work for it and don't want special bloody treatment. Emergency service vehicles yes that's just sensible. An OT on his way to work as usual. No.
This!
Ibelieveinghosts · 27/09/2021 14:31

I’m not sure why nhs staff are prioritised over other key workers, what about police, fire, coast guards RNLI staff, off barracks army, farmers, supermarket staff etc. Just as vital (if not more so than 99% of NHS staff).

Explosivefarts · 27/09/2021 14:30

@Icantrememberthenameoftheartis

Belladonna that is a really good point! My sister has to pay to park at the hospital. She used to try and park close to the hospital but kept being abused by homeowners who objected to the hospital staff parking in their roads.
Well can you blame them geez how entitled
LibrariesGiveUsPower45321 · 27/09/2021 14:29

A blanket prioritising of NHS staff still prioritises those who can work from home.

You can say NHS workers won’t take advantage of it, but I know plenty who have before.

What would the NHS do without clean water, working waste water, gas electric, deliveries of supplies, factory workers who make the supplies, farmers, food processors to put dinner on their tables, supermarket workers, teachers/nursery staff to look after NHS workers kids, etc etc etc.

The last thing the NHS needs is the rest of the country grinding to a halt and suddenly facing an outbreak of cholera or whatever.

Icantrememberthenameoftheartis · 27/09/2021 14:27

Belladonna that is a really good point! My sister has to pay to park at the hospital. She used to try and park close to the hospital but kept being abused by homeowners who objected to the hospital staff parking in their roads.

Dreamstate · 27/09/2021 14:27

@DancingQueen2018

I own petrol stations. It’s a nightmare, you try to do the right thing by allowing some people to have fuel, but you get abused, it gets abused by people who don’t really need it. We’ve now had to say emergency vehicles only.

It was exactly the same back in 2000 during the fuel strikes when I was stood at the front with 2 police officers saying yes or no to people.

All I can do is emphasis there is plenty of fuel in the uk, there is no need to fill up unless you absolutely have to (I haven’t, if I run out my children will just get the bus to school). The quicker this happens the quicker it will settle down!

Noone will often to you, so fixated on the idea its all down to brexit blah blah they won't to hear the truth that the media whipped up a frenzy and they themselves feel for it and went and panic bought
Maryann1975 · 27/09/2021 14:27

@AliceAbsolum

Jesus everyone is so obsessed with the nhs. I work for it and don't want special bloody treatment. Emergency service vehicles yes that's just sensible. An OT on his way to work as usual. No.
It’s the whole ‘critical workers’ list from lockdown again. The nurse also needs childcare/schools for her children in order to be able to go to do her job. So do early years staff and teachers get emergency fuel rations too? They might also need police/fire crew to be working in case there is an accident on the way to work, so they probably need fuel too. The nurse also needs to eat, so we need supermarket staff in so nhs staff can buy food. Before you know it, half the country are on the ‘emergency rations’ list and the whole thing is as unfair as closing schools in January when the majority (over 50%) of pupils were eligible for a place and were still going in. And as for showing your I’d badge in order to get petrol for your car, I can guarantee that system will be abused to make sure their spouse/parents/siblings etc all have enough fuel to get them around all week (thinking of one friend in particular).
AliceMcK · 27/09/2021 14:27

@WormYourHonour

So many crucial jobs require people to drive, let alone people with caring responsibilities, mobility issues, etc.

Of the NHS people, by your decree, can get buses, why can't everyone else?

Mobile carers/home help, cleaners, delivery drivers, child minders doing various school runs and collections, people who need to collect their own children straight from work, people who care for relatives on top of working, people who can’t get public transport to work……
MolyHolyGuacamole · 27/09/2021 14:25

@Whitefire

Can I just say in defence of GP's, DH rang this morning regarding ds, spoke to the GP and had a f2f booked for a couple of hours after the call.
And??? How does this affect the availability of fuel?
Belladonna12 · 27/09/2021 14:23

Whilst NHS staff should not be the only people to get priority of course they should have priority. Arguing that would mean NHS admin staff will take all the petrol is ridiculous. The great majority of people wouldn't abuse the system and if they were working at home they wouldn't take the petrol. When I worked for the NHS, the majority of people used public transport to get to work anyway because the wasn't enough parking for everyone. Those that drive really needed to in contrast to many of the others insisting they can only get to work by car.

user1497207191 · 27/09/2021 14:23

@Helenluvsrob

Everyone is an essential worker , pretty much. Covid taught us that surely ?

And I’m not bring ironic. The shelf stacker in aldi is needed in work , just like the a&e nurse.

I’m nhs. I have 1/4 tank. Fortunately I have a pushbike

Exactly. It's why there are shortages of all kinds of things at the moment. Just shows that no single individual works in a vacuum and that everything/everyone is dependant upon everyone else.

If we prioritise one group of workers to the detriment of other groups, it will just cause a knock on effect ("unforeseen circumstances") that eventually come back to bit the "preferred" workers on the bum in other ways.

DancingQueen2018 · 27/09/2021 14:21

I own petrol stations. It’s a nightmare, you try to do the right thing by allowing some people to have fuel, but you get abused, it gets abused by people who don’t really need it. We’ve now had to say emergency vehicles only.

It was exactly the same back in 2000 during the fuel strikes when I was stood at the front with 2 police officers saying yes or no to people.

All I can do is emphasis there is plenty of fuel in the uk, there is no need to fill up unless you absolutely have to (I haven’t, if I run out my children will just get the bus to school). The quicker this happens the quicker it will settle down!

Rhubarbcrumblerules · 27/09/2021 14:20

I work for a taxi comany. If we run out of fuel we wont be getting vulnerable children to their schools, some of which are an hours drive away, or the elderly to their hospital appointments.

Xenia · 27/09/2021 14:20

I remember in Newcastle in the 1970s in a petrol crisis my parents had to buy locking petrol caps because people were siphoning petrol off your car in the night. Just be careful everyone to make sure that dose not start happening. I have very little fuel left and 2 trips at the weekend to 3 petrol stations failed and the queues today are awful so I am going to stick at home. I can always eat sardines I suppose and luckily I do work from home mostly.

Icantrememberthenameoftheartis · 27/09/2021 14:19

It’s a difficult one. I am biased before I begin....

My sister is a theatre and currently also a Covid Ward Sister and works days and night shifts and is frequently on call, she has (from memory) something like 20 mins to get to the operating theatre from the time her phone rings at home. She can drive it in about 8 mins. Walking isn’t an option nor is public transport. NHS staff that hold crucial roles like that should be given priority. Other roles I don’t feel should.

But...where do you draw the line? So many NHS roles are frontline and crucial.

And of course there are the carers visiting people in their homes who are dependant on them.

lifeohhifeee · 27/09/2021 14:17

@OhGiveUp

There are a lot of employees of other sectors whose employment is just as important as NHS employees. Off the top of my head I can think of.... Care / support workers Police officers Prison officers Firefighters Funeral services Refuse collectors Teachers / teaching support staff Breakdown services HGV drivers Bus drivers Train drivers
This exactly!
mydogisthebest · 27/09/2021 14:16

They need to sort something out so there is fuel for ambulances, fire engines and police cars. Bloody ridiculous that they are having to drive round to look for fuel because of all the selfish idiotic morons.

LucyGrey · 27/09/2021 14:09

Oh good another reason for the general public to hate NHS staff. I'd rather queue up with everyone else.

ichundich · 27/09/2021 14:07

@drpaddington

I agree. NHS staff are essential, of course they are. But as we discovered last year with the 'key worker' list, so are many many others! Surely it's obvious that we can't function as a country with just hospitals/ GP surgeries running and nothing else?
Exactly this. You cannot run an economy with key workers only. How do you generate tax revenue in key-worker only mode? If people in 'non-key' roles can't get to work and companies can't sell their goods due to lack of staff and fuel, we are screwed in the long-term. This is a self-inflicted crisis, brought on by decades of underinvestment, the Brexit vote and the utter incompetence of the Tory government. Prioritising the NHS deflects from the real issues and only serves to switch the sheeple to a 'blitz' mentality.
SquareYellow · 27/09/2021 14:07

This is just the media trying to make people hate the NHS so their friends can continue with selling it off and privatise it. And you know when that happens working conditions and pay for NHS staff and poor GPs will be better, but worse for patients, and the NHS want to stay the NHS despite their work conditions being piss poor.

raspberrymuffin · 27/09/2021 14:06

I suppose it'll take some pressure off the NHS in the short term if I can't get DH to his upcoming chemo sessions 30 miles away. (Before someone jumps on, public transport would be a rural bus - every 2 hours and sometimes randomly doesn't turn up - followed by a train journey followed by at least one more bus journey, all opportunities for him to pick up covid and have his treatment postponed never mind that we'd be bankrupt after a couple of months).

drivinmecrazy · 27/09/2021 14:06

Ridiculous idea!!
DH works for arriva In London. If he can't get into work the buses won't be on the roads so no public transport.
He cannot use public transport to get to garages he needs to and nor would his mechanics be able to get into work to get the buses onto their routes.
Many many other occupations are similarly crucial to the infrastructure of the country, we cannot prioritise all of them!!

Rhubarbsoup · 27/09/2021 14:06

@LibrariesGiveUsPower45321

I know people who work for water companies- driving out to rural locations to fix pumps, filters, sluice gates and everything else that is involved in making sure major cities and everyone else have uninterrupted clean water supplies.

But we should prioritise NHS admin staff who actually can work from home? Righto.

Who has said admin staff should be prioritised?

Some people on this site are ridiculous. Probably not even a handful, maybe even just one petrol station has decided to priorities nhs staff and people can't wait to come in and say how much they hate the 'special treatment', how good nhs staff have it, and how everyone else is just as important.

MurielSpriggs · 27/09/2021 14:05

It's going to be the almighty scramble to declare yourself a key worker all over again Confused