Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To disagree with NHS only petrol stations?

638 replies

pistachio20 · 27/09/2021 11:08

Some petrol stations around me have now said that they are only allowing in NHS staff to refuel - apparently checking ID.

I find this completely ridiculous and unfair - not only because the majority of NHS staff where I live can easily get public transport to work (most who I know don’t drive to work anyway, and get train/bus anyway due to lack of free parking!).

So many crucial jobs require people to drive, let alone people with caring responsibilities, mobility issues, etc.

AIBU to think that it’s unfair?

OP posts:
pumpkinsp1ce · 27/09/2021 15:59

My mother is a carer (not NHS) and reckons she's got about 3 days of fuel left in her car max. Without her car she cannot get to work; she cares for several older/disabled people, 5 days a week. Her colleagues will be in a similar position. She also is on a zero hours contract and if she doesn't work, she doesn't get paid. NHS-only seems unfair and blinkered, unless they mean ambulances only or something on that level.

Wazzzzzzzup · 27/09/2021 15:58

It's yet again one big middle finger to all the other essential workers🙄

WandaVision2 · 27/09/2021 15:56

@MatildaIThink It is life and death if our power stations can’t operate because of a lack of staff, many of them can’t legally operate without a certain number of staff members being there Without electricity the NHS won’t be able to save lives.

ichundich · 27/09/2021 15:45

@ichundich

Not this bollocks again! How many more days of lost income can the average and not-so-priviledged family sustain, do you think? Millions of people have already not been able to work for months because of Covid, homeschooling, businesses being forced to shut... This current crisis is not even down to "nature" unlike the virus, but down to poor decision-making and lack of forward-planning by the Tories. People aren't prepared to suck it up any more!
In response to @Matilda.
MatildaIThink · 27/09/2021 15:45

[quote Hoorayhenryyah]@MatildaIThink it would be a disaster for me not getting to work and losing money. Already faced redundancy earlier in the pandemic and barely keeping above water as it is. Don’t think you can tell me how my situation is because you have no idea. Not getting to work and earning money could be a disaster for a lot of people especially in these times.
I think yes, make sure emergency vehicles have fuel but other than that if everyone just calmed down and bought fuel as normal we wouldn’t even be facing such a ridiculous situation in the first place[/quote]
My whole point is that emergency services should get preference, otherwise people will die. I also did not try to tell you how your situation is, other than all of us who are not emergency services and critical workers (not "key" workers) it is not life and death if we do not get fuel, it is not life and death if we don't pay our mortgages or even have to sell our homes. Whilst there is a supply issue it makes sense to prioritise those who if we do not prioritise them then lives will be lost.

I agree that the problem is with the panic buying idiots, unfortunately as much of the last six years has proven, we need to learn to live with the idiots and manage the consequences of their actions where possible.

ichundich · 27/09/2021 15:42

Not this bollocks again! How many more days of lost income can the average and not-so-priviledged family sustain, do you think? Millions of people have already not been able to work for months because of Covid, homeschooling, businesses being forced to shut... This current crisis is not even down to "nature" unlike the virus, but down to poor decision-making and lack of forward-planning by the Tories. People aren't prepared to suck it up any more!

feelingreallysadrightnow · 27/09/2021 15:31

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

user1497207191 · 27/09/2021 15:25

@Belladonna12

Whilst NHS staff should not be the only people to get priority of course they should have priority. Arguing that would mean NHS admin staff will take all the petrol is ridiculous. The great majority of people wouldn't abuse the system and if they were working at home they wouldn't take the petrol. When I worked for the NHS, the majority of people used public transport to get to work anyway because the wasn't enough parking for everyone. Those that drive really needed to in contrast to many of the others insisting they can only get to work by car.
You must be joking when you say the "majority wouldn't abuse the system". Abuse was rife of the NHS priority in supermarkets last year, and remains rife for the likes of NHS discounts for pizzas and other takeaways. Our neighbour, a NHS GP surgery practice manager, offered to do our shopping for us last year to get the discount, she regularly gets takeaways delivered for her other neighbours to get the discount. With covid jabs, she got her whole family booked in weeks/months before they became eligible and offered to get us booked in sooner too.
user1497207191 · 27/09/2021 15:22

@malificent7

Agreed ibelieveinghosts. This is why humanity will die out from climate change. We rely heavily on fossil fuels and cannot cope without cars for 5 minutes. The amount of horror about not having foreign holidays was immense.
It's not just cars, though is it?

Lots of public transport is fossil fuelled. Most lorries are fossil fuelled. Most trades/emergency vehicles are fossil fuelled.

It's easy to take the easy option and blame cars, but basically everyone and everything that has to move is done so mainly by fossil fuel at the moment.

The "real" answer isn't renewables, it's localism. I.e. we need a massive push to get people to go to schools, shops, jobs and recreation, much closer to where they live, and start manufacturing "things" closer to where the consumers live. Just look at the hue and cry about city centres suffering due to people working from home, and the "push" to get people back to working in offices etc - we should be using WFH as an opportunity to cut emissions and yes, reduce public transport if there's lower demand. We need to reverse the centralisation of jobs into a few large cities and get back to employers having regional depots/offices etc so more people can work closer to where they live.

Hoorayhenryyah · 27/09/2021 15:08

@MatildaIThink it would be a disaster for me not getting to work and losing money. Already faced redundancy earlier in the pandemic and barely keeping above water as it is. Don’t think you can tell me how my situation is because you have no idea. Not getting to work and earning money could be a disaster for a lot of people especially in these times.
I think yes, make sure emergency vehicles have fuel but other than that if everyone just calmed down and bought fuel as normal we wouldn’t even be facing such a ridiculous situation in the first place

Explosivefarts · 27/09/2021 15:03

@clara443

I lost all respect for NHS workers when there was a queue of THREE people at Aldi and someone showed up, flashed their NHS badge and pushed in.

it was a five minuet queue...

This pandemic has taught me that everyone is essential and should be treated fairly!

Yep my area was full of those as well jumping infront of a queue with four people in it all of whom were pensioners
malificent7 · 27/09/2021 15:03

Agreed ibelieveinghosts.
This is why humanity will die out from climate change. We rely heavily on fossil fuels and cannot cope without cars for 5 minutes. The amount of horror about not having foreign holidays was immense.

notelegant · 27/09/2021 15:02

YANBU. Vets, firefighters, policemen, carers, lorry drivers, tradesmen and many other occupations all need access to fuel.

Minecraftlover · 27/09/2021 14:59

I agree with you OP. I work at a shop, luckily in walking distance from my house. Today a lady I served, who is a home carer, was in tears worrying how she will get to her clients tomorrow. Elderly and vulnerable who will need feeding/medication/personal care. It's an absolute shit show, there are many many other jobs that are absolutely vital, as well as NHS.

DancingQueen2018 · 27/09/2021 14:58

@onlychildhamster @Xenia we have (until last Friday) had absolutely no problem with our fuel supply chain (don’t get me started on the shops however). The leaked BP report was talking about 5 stations out of 1200.

There’s very little slack in the system, which is why it’s taking a while to get it all back out again, petrol demand tends to be fairly consistent so easy to plan. Make no mistake the shortage of HGV drivers is a huge issue for the food supply but it’s only a tiny part of the fuel. The main part is all the extra buying.

Ibelieveinghosts · 27/09/2021 14:56

One thing this does so is how ridiculously reliant on cars we have become. No wonder the earth and our waistbands are fucked! We need to stop building things which rely on cars, out of town shopping, housing developments in the middle of no where, fear of walking more than 1 mile. Overburdened life’s making us rush everywhere.

MatildaIThink · 27/09/2021 14:52

@Hoorayhenryyah

Absolute joke, I need to get to my work every day, and don’t have the option to work from home. My work is not walking distance and neither is my child’s school. Public transport is extremely limited where I live. I need to get to work or else I don’t get paid and I can’t pay my mortgage and bills. Sick of the glorifying of ‘essential workers’. everyone’s jobs are essential to them to live and earn money
I am sorry, but neither you, nor I, are that important in the grand scheme of things. We will certainly not die, or cause the deaths of others if we lose out on a few days of income, or even if we are unable to pay our mortgage.

If police can not attend crimes then criminals run riot, if fire engines can not attend crashes then people die, or burn to death, if ambulances cannot operate then people die in their homes, if doctors and nurses cannot get to work then people die, or their cancer progresses untreated.

Our jobs might be important to us, but they are not essential, to think they are is incredibly selfish.

clara443 · 27/09/2021 14:49

I lost all respect for NHS workers when there was a queue of THREE people at Aldi and someone showed up, flashed their NHS badge and pushed in.

it was a five minuet queue...

This pandemic has taught me that everyone is essential and should be treated fairly!

MatildaIThink · 27/09/2021 14:48

@amillionmenonmars

How will it help if those very same NHS workers can't drive to work because their child's teachers cannot get into school to teach them, or the car mechanic can't get into work to repair their car.

Lots of people need petrol right now. We all depend on all of the jobs on society to keep it running smoothly. I have several family members who are nurses - I know they will be cringing at this virtue signaling from some garages.

In the largeish town where I live, two independent petrol stations (one at each end of the town) have agreed to sell to emergency services only. They have limited suppliers anyway because of all the panic buyers, but police cars, ambulances, fire engines etc. were having issues getting fuel both because of shortages and the amount of time they had to queue to fill up.

Whilst this might be inconvenient for some, it is probably better that the police are able to attend incidents, that ambulances can get to those in urgent need and fire engines can attend fires or cut people out of crashes than someone else, even if important to wider society, gets to fill up a bit quicker.

onlychildhamster · 27/09/2021 14:45

@Xenia There aren't enough HGV drivers to transport the petrol. Yes there are a lot of HGV applications that take 5 months to process but also drivers have been leaving the profession due to poor working conditions and also the European drivers have left cos of Brexit. Average age of a HGV driver is 55. So yes the army probably needs to transport the petrol. Its a supply chain issue.

But the panic buying has not helped the situation and made it much worse!

Hoorayhenryyah · 27/09/2021 14:44

Absolute joke, I need to get to my work every day, and don’t have the option to work from home. My work is not walking distance and neither is my child’s school. Public transport is extremely limited where I live. I need to get to work or else I don’t get paid and I can’t pay my mortgage and bills. Sick of the glorifying of ‘essential workers’. everyone’s jobs are essential to them to live and earn money

MatildaIThink · 27/09/2021 14:43

@pistachio20
Can’t you understand that other essential jobs also require people to use cars to get into work?
I am sure that most people can understand that, but the thing is if we can take care of a large proportion of those in essential jobs then that makes things easier. Those that work for the NHS also have ID which further makes things easier.

So yes there are some people in other roles or with other employers, but we we can reduce the total amount of essential workers having difficulty obtaining fuel then that improves things.

OuiOuiBonjour · 27/09/2021 14:37

And??? How does this affect the availability of fuel?

Presumably it was mentioned because there is a myth going round on here and in the media/IRL that all GPs are still working from home and it's impossible to be seen in person.

Many posters have mentioned that "Lots of NHS workers are working from home so don't need fuel anyway".

A GP won't be able to see anyone face to face if they can't get to work. It may blow peoples' minds but some of them have also been doing home visits for housebound patients for a few months now. If the poster's husband was seen so soon today, it was deemed urgent. Urgent cases will be missed if doctors can't get to work. Or wrongly end up clogging up A&E or Walk In facilities and putting more strain on the NHS.

Belladonna12 · 27/09/2021 14:37

@LibrariesGiveUsPower45321

A blanket prioritising of NHS staff still prioritises those who can work from home.

You can say NHS workers won’t take advantage of it, but I know plenty who have before.

What would the NHS do without clean water, working waste water, gas electric, deliveries of supplies, factory workers who make the supplies, farmers, food processors to put dinner on their tables, supermarket workers, teachers/nursery staff to look after NHS workers kids, etc etc etc.

The last thing the NHS needs is the rest of the country grinding to a halt and suddenly facing an outbreak of cholera or whatever.

There are always people that are going to abuse the system but doesn't mean the majority will. Most people if reminded that the NHS priority is only for those who really need to drive to work for the NHS are not going to take piss. Obviously NHS workers shouldn't be the only ones with priority but if this continues certain workers will need to have priority.
amillionmenonmars · 27/09/2021 14:36

How will it help if those very same NHS workers can't drive to work because their child's teachers cannot get into school to teach them, or the car mechanic can't get into work to repair their car.

Lots of people need petrol right now. We all depend on all of the jobs on society to keep it running smoothly. I have several family members who are nurses - I know they will be cringing at this virtue signaling from some garages.

Swipe left for the next trending thread