Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To disagree with NHS only petrol stations?

638 replies

pistachio20 · 27/09/2021 11:08

Some petrol stations around me have now said that they are only allowing in NHS staff to refuel - apparently checking ID.

I find this completely ridiculous and unfair - not only because the majority of NHS staff where I live can easily get public transport to work (most who I know don’t drive to work anyway, and get train/bus anyway due to lack of free parking!).

So many crucial jobs require people to drive, let alone people with caring responsibilities, mobility issues, etc.

AIBU to think that it’s unfair?

OP posts:
herecomesthsun · 27/09/2021 17:03

It seems a bit excessive to lose respect for all NHS workers because one person used their card once in ASDA.

NeverDropYourMoonCup · 27/09/2021 17:01

@clara443

I lost all respect for NHS workers when there was a queue of THREE people at Aldi and someone showed up, flashed their NHS badge and pushed in.

it was a five minuet queue...

This pandemic has taught me that everyone is essential and should be treated fairly!

Only FIVE dances? The bastard.
Oldandcobwebbed · 27/09/2021 17:00

I work in a nhs front line capacity and complete home visits in my own car. We are rural so can't do buses, and have had to cancel urgent work including multiple home injections for isolated people due to the size of our patch and petrol concerns. Us not visiting patients will lead to admissions. My car was down as essential on my job application form

My base isn't a hospital, and our local mh unit isn't well served by public transport at times we need staff

It's not to say we are the only people that need petrol (like carers etc) but its naive to think its just about getting to work. Lots of the home visits will be done in peoples own cars in the nhs

PumpkinPie2016 · 27/09/2021 16:56

YANBU not because NHS staff can use public transport as they may not be able to. Buses are often unreliable, don't run at times suitable for shift workers or the routes mean it takes 2+ buses to actually get where you are going.

However, it isn't just NHS staff who are essential. What about fire service personnel, police officers, HGV drivers - particularly those who deliver fuel and food, care home and community care staff etc.

There are many people who need to be doing their essential jobs and for a whole host of reasons can't use public transport. It shouldn't be prioritised for one group only.

user987465321 · 27/09/2021 16:55

My DP - frontline NHS worker - would love to run out of petrol and not have to go to work.
Catch up on all the furlough life they have been watching from a distance for 18 months.
But who will look after all the anti-vaxxers on the Covid ward?

Isitsixoclockalready · 27/09/2021 16:52

It's not the fault of NHS workers if the petrol companies offer it. It seems to lead to resentment when it's not actually the workers themselves that come up with all this.

Isitreallyme177 · 27/09/2021 16:51

One thing that past 18 months have reinforced is that George Orwell was way ahead of his time. When I hear about the NHS getting special treatment for petrol, I just think of this quote "all animals are equal but some are more equal than others". What a sad, depressing, selfish world we live in, we are fighting over who gets priority of petrol, or priority in supermarkets. No one job is more important than another, we all have to eat whether you're a nurse or an accountant working from home, we all have bills to pay.

Wazzzzzzzup · 27/09/2021 16:44

So what do you mean then?

You really can't imagine that some other jobs outside of NHS can't just be stopped?
Who would deliver goods to the hospitals? Train drivers, bus drivers, energy workers (can't heat or light without gas or electricity), workers around food (which would also include skme food for nhs staff and patients), firemen, police, community support officers, teachers.
And...
Petrol station workers🤷🏻

marmaladehound · 27/09/2021 16:43

I work for the NHS in a clinical front line capacity but I would not want this. There are many many other people who need to go out to work, why single the police, teachers, retail workers, transport, and hey just people who need to go to work! Why single out the NHS?

The vehicles that should be able to be a priority to fill up for fuel are emergency vehicles.

Belladonna12 · 27/09/2021 16:42

Re covid jabs, no they were proper appointments at all times of the day. She kept offering to do it for us, but we declined. She said she could just "tick the box" on the system to mark us down as vulnerable and then the system would send a link for us to make an appointment.

That is fraud. Just because you have a dodgy friend who works for the NHS it doesn't mean everyone else is like that.

EmmaGrundyForPM · 27/09/2021 16:40

I don't agree with prioritising NHS workers. There are other essential workers - especially care workers, but also utility workers, funeral directors, HGV drivers for supermarkets - who need to be able to get to work in order for essential supplies and services keep running.

MatildaIThink · 27/09/2021 16:38

@Wazzzzzzzup

I don't think many are "fetishising" the NHS, but taking the pragmatic view that it is better that people who have "normal" jobs stay at home, which may or may not mean some kind of hardship, than doctors, nurses, pharmacists etc. stay at home and people die.

There are millions of people who cannot stay at home. And I don't mean just that they would lose wages.

So what do you mean then?
MatildaIThink · 27/09/2021 16:36

[quote user1497207191]@MatildaIThink But how many people should suffer serious consequences to save a life? Is it fair to expect some people to lose their homes, their livelihoods and businesses to save the lives of other random people? If so, how is it fair that "some" people are protected by their jobs or benefit system so that they don't lose their homes, their livelihoods or their businesses, whilst others are thrown to the wolves and risk losing everything they have? Surely, there needs to be fairness and parity as to who loses and who doesn't when it comes to saving lives of random strangers?[/quote]
Life is not fair, if people are still expecting that as adults then they have already seriously misjudged existence.

The reality is very few people would lose their homes, jobs or businesses. I would much rather we had a better welfare state, similar to Norway (or at least Germany), but we do not, because the majority of the British public are not prepared to pay the levels of taxes needed to fund it.

Society would very soon start to break down if the police stopped policing, the fire brigade stopped attending accidents and fires and the ambulance service stopped responding to medical emergencies, or people were left to die in hospital. The toilet roll, dried pasta, canned goods shortages of last year, the failure of a significant minority to abide by the lockdowns, the current selfishness of the panic buyers etc. already show that many of the public are not willing to play their part, we have to make sure that does not reach critical mass because if it does life will become significantly harder for everyone and it will be a much more sustained, deeper hardship.

That is not to say I do not feel people's frustration because of all of this, I spoke to my brother earlier, he had to get up at five this morning and take a combination of multiple trains and busses to get to a work meeting where he had to attend in person, normally he would have driven, but he does not have enough petrol and can't get any. My best friends husband is a carpenter and he has had to delay a job because he can't get diesel for his work van, his customer understands, it is a pain in the behind as he will likely have to work the weekend to catch up, when he has fuel again, but they accept it and I very much doubt my brother or my friends husband would think that someone should be left to die so they can get to work today.

Wazzzzzzzup · 27/09/2021 16:33

I don't think many are "fetishising" the NHS, but taking the pragmatic view that it is better that people who have "normal" jobs stay at home, which may or may not mean some kind of hardship, than doctors, nurses, pharmacists etc. stay at home and people die.

There are millions of people who cannot stay at home. And I don't mean just that they would lose wages.

user1497207191 · 27/09/2021 16:25

@Reachersloveinterest

YANBU. We're going back to the days of people debating how 'key' a keyworker you are and if you are enough of a keyworker to deserve a school place for your kids.

By this argument an NHS admin worker from our village (which has no bus service) is allowed to buy fuel and go to work booking non-essential appointments, but an unemployed mum of a disabled child cannot buy fuel to take the child to an essential hospital appointment.

Do we need a scales of how important a key worker we are? "Oh you're only on Level 4! You need to be a Level 5 to buy diesel!"

No, we just need to start applying restraint and common sense. And if people can't behave sensibly, then the Govt needs to step in and impose rationing/limits on everyone.

At the end of the day, there is no shortage. It's idiots panic buying that have caused this, and it WILL all be over in a few days. Panic buying idiots can't keep filling their cars that are already full can they? It's a "blip" and will pass once all the idiots have filled their cars and don't need to fill them again for another week or two.

elbea · 27/09/2021 16:23

@Feilin don’t be so ridiculous, there are plenty of people who need to get to work. My husband is a solider and does essential work, people’s lives would be at risk if he didn’t turn up. What about supermarket workers, bus drivers, farmers and nursery workers.

I have no idea why a select few NHS workers think that the rest of the population should worship the ground they walk on, all because they are doing the job they are paid for.

carolinesbaby · 27/09/2021 16:20

YANBU.
We're going back to the days of people debating how 'key' a keyworker you are and if you are enough of a keyworker to deserve a school place for your kids.

By this argument an NHS admin worker from our village (which has no bus service) is allowed to buy fuel and go to work booking non-essential appointments, but an unemployed mum of a disabled child cannot buy fuel to take the child to an essential hospital appointment.

Do we need a scales of how important a key worker we are? "Oh you're only on Level 4! You need to be a Level 5 to buy diesel!"

Biker47 · 27/09/2021 16:17

@malificent7

I hope none of you have heart attacks, strokes or accidents in the next few weeks...those unworthy NHS staff will have to deal with you.
I hope none of those hospitals run on electricity, or that the NHS workers have kids that go to schools because those are the industries my partner and I work in, and if we can't fuel either we can't go in either.
cooliebrown · 27/09/2021 16:14

I wouldn't use my NHS ID to get preferential access to fuel, because I don't need fuel to fulfil my WfH role.

user1497207191 · 27/09/2021 16:10

@Belladonna12

You must be joking when you say the "majority wouldn't abuse the system". Abuse was rife of the NHS priority in supermarkets last year, and remains rife for the likes of NHS discounts for pizzas and other takeaways. Our neighbour, a NHS GP surgery practice manager, offered to do our shopping for us last year to get the discount, she regularly gets takeaways delivered for her other neighbours to get the discount. With covid jabs, she got her whole family booked in weeks/months before they became eligible and offered to get us booked in sooner too.

NHS discounts are offered to all NHS workers so they aren't abusing the system by using the discount. That is entirely different to offering petrol to NHS workers only if they need it to get to the hospital or GP practice and someoone using it even if they are working at home.
As far as Covid jabs were concerned, I bet she was putting them on the list to get jabs at the end of the day rather than waste them. Would you prefer the jabs were thrown away?

It IS abuse when she was using the discount system to buy shopping for people who didn't work for the NHS, and we're not talking vulnerable friends/family/neighbours - we're talking about people perfectly able to do their own shopping.

Re covid jabs, no they were proper appointments at all times of the day. She kept offering to do it for us, but we declined. She said she could just "tick the box" on the system to mark us down as vulnerable and then the system would send a link for us to make an appointment.

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 27/09/2021 16:07

Many NHS staff have to get into work at anti-social hours. Of course there are some people who work from home or get buses but there are many who can't. It's not about pandering to those people, it's about keeping our most essential services running. I'd be in favour of prioritizing many of the most essential workers if needs by. I work in a ward. We are putting desparate measures in place to get staff into work. Because if we don't people will die.

MatildaIThink · 27/09/2021 16:06

@Wazzzzzzzup

People in UK really need to stop almost fetishising NHS and the staff. It's a basic healthcare system like in many other places. Working in it doesn't make someone so special they should have a priority over everyone else in basically any shitty situation🙄
I don't think many are "fetishising" the NHS, but taking the pragmatic view that it is better that people who have "normal" jobs stay at home, which may or may not mean some kind of hardship, than doctors, nurses, pharmacists etc. stay at home and people die.
user1497207191 · 27/09/2021 16:05

@MatildaIThink But how many people should suffer serious consequences to save a life? Is it fair to expect some people to lose their homes, their livelihoods and businesses to save the lives of other random people? If so, how is it fair that "some" people are protected by their jobs or benefit system so that they don't lose their homes, their livelihoods or their businesses, whilst others are thrown to the wolves and risk losing everything they have? Surely, there needs to be fairness and parity as to who loses and who doesn't when it comes to saving lives of random strangers?

Wazzzzzzzup · 27/09/2021 16:00

People in UK really need to stop almost fetishising NHS and the staff.
It's a basic healthcare system like in many other places. Working in it doesn't make someone so special they should have a priority over everyone else in basically any shitty situation🙄

Belladonna12 · 27/09/2021 15:59

You must be joking when you say the "majority wouldn't abuse the system". Abuse was rife of the NHS priority in supermarkets last year, and remains rife for the likes of NHS discounts for pizzas and other takeaways. Our neighbour, a NHS GP surgery practice manager, offered to do our shopping for us last year to get the discount, she regularly gets takeaways delivered for her other neighbours to get the discount. With covid jabs, she got her whole family booked in weeks/months before they became eligible and offered to get us booked in sooner too.

NHS discounts are offered to all NHS workers so they aren't abusing the system by using the discount. That is entirely different to offering petrol to NHS workers only if they need it to get to the hospital or GP practice and someoone using it even if they are working at home.
As far as Covid jabs were concerned, I bet she was putting them on the list to get jabs at the end of the day rather than waste them. Would you prefer the jabs were thrown away?