Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel like a professional failure

71 replies

Bleepingtons · 26/09/2021 18:23

Please be kind in your responses. I am really struggling with this.

In a nutshell, I have always been academically successful. Left uni and got a training contract with an MC law firm where I qualified. After 2.5 years as a qualified solicitor I decided to leave as I hated the hours and the stress. I retrained as a teacher and then worked in a tough state school for 5 years. In this time I did well but didn't go higher than 2ic, mainly through personal preference.

I then met my now husband and we decided to go abroad for 2 years where I taught in a bit of a crap local school. When I came back I was pregnant so took some maternity leave before working 2 days a week as a classroom teacher for a year before going on mat leave again.

I'm now 36 and feel I have nothing to show for myself. Especially when I compare myself with contemporaries who are now partners in law firms etc.

But I'm also completely conflicted because I want to be at home with my kids too and spend as much time with them as possible.

The decisions I made at the time were based on the premise that life is short and there are more kmportant things than work but now I just feel like a failure.

Any advice would be very gratefully received.

OP posts:
Thedogscollar · 29/09/2021 00:52

@Scarby9

You have qualified and worked in two professional careers and had a family. On what possible planet is that a fail? You are still only in your 30s and still have time to do all kinds of things.
This is the post that you need to keep reading. You are no failure. Stop being so hard on yourself. Why do women put so much pressure on themselves?Sad
DinkyDiggies · 29/09/2021 00:46

I think you can be proud of what you’ve achieved actually. You have had two successful careers. The trainees you’ve mentored have gone on to be successful, another sign of your success, plus you’ve traveled and had the opportunity to enjoy your children.
It is said that comparison is the thief of joy for you will always be better than some and worse than others which leads to vanity or bitterness. Enjoy the life you have!

Ledition · 28/09/2021 23:28

I felt similar after I had my DD2, I had excellent qualifications but had drifted between jobs and countries and had nothing to show for it compared to friends who were flying high. I had planned to go back to work when my youngest was two and start really pushing myself but my previous industry also has incredibly long working hours and I would have a significant commute. I would barely see my DC and I simply couldn't do it. Their dad works crazy hours too so they would essentially have no parents around Monday to Friday.

So I decided to get more qualifications instead Grin I applied for a PhD scholarship on a whim and actually got accepted. It's the perfect balance. The flexibility to be around during the early primary years with my DC and do all the school runs etc. yet I have something intellectually stimulating for me, I'm learning lots of new skills and I have a big goal to work towards. Might be worth thinking about if you're academic?

Actupfishy · 28/09/2021 22:10

Comparison is the thief of joy x

WellTidy · 28/09/2021 18:27

So glad that you have taken these words on board about self worth. I heard someone say them about 10 years ago, when resigning from her (the same career) position and I was determined to remember them. I thought it was such a healthy perspective. I’ve resigned from my position recently and they really helped me shift my mindset in the run up to making that decision. It’s not quite a ‘repeat it to yourself until you believe it’s true’ position, but it has really helped me.

Bleepingtons · 28/09/2021 18:12

@Brian9600 thanks for this. Very helpful and kind advice which I totally agree with. I think like others say, my self worth is linked to what I do and earn maybe too much. It would be so nice to be earning squillions but that doesn't take into account the major sacrifices I'd have to make to get there.

OP posts:
needtogetfit21 · 27/09/2021 21:37

Wow this thread really hits home

My scenario is slightly different, I graduated, started working for one of the big firms and then went through a few years of rough health (cancer). By the time my eye was back on my career, people around me had climbed up. I worked hard and was promoted just as I went onto have a family. I then took a second mat leave in a short time and so therefore I feel like I don't have much to show for the last 10 years, career wise anyway. My salary is not in line with the market rate and people who I have trained are now higher than me. It's so frustrating and every so often I do get very down about it. I work part time now which is another way of slowing my career down.

I try and own my choice of having a family / working part time so that I can spend some time with them whilst they are so young but bundle that with the health challenges and it does all seem unfair Sad I wish we could have it all!

Twylar · 27/09/2021 21:36

Comparison is the thief of joy! If you are happy where you are and enjoy your life as is then own it! If you aren't happy and actually want to work in a high ranked job go for it!

Wewereonaspringbreak · 27/09/2021 21:28

@minipie

For any ex City lawyers reading this who do wish they could get back in but think it’s impossible… It’s got a lot easier. Look up Reignite Academy who are doing amazing things getting women “returnships” in City firms and sometimes in-house. The positions are well paid, 4 days a week (who’d have ever thought!!) and the Academy provides lots of support with CV, interview etc. I think what they are doing is wonderful.

That’s not to say OP or anyone else should go back… but just to signpost in case anyone wants or perhaps financially needs to go back.

Women Returners is a good site for similar programmes but non legal (big range of industries). Retraining programmes into tech are around too.

Thanks. I do actually follow Woman Returners and have recently applied for a couple of things unsuccessfully (though not City Law firms as I am ex civil service). I think in my case the fact that I have successfully pursued a second career in teaching weirdly counts against me as I have always been studying or in employment and therefore am maybe seen to be a bit of a failure on two counts rather than just one 🤷🏻‍♀️ I would retrain into another field too, but haven’t seen any of those…
tttigress · 27/09/2021 21:22

I can only recommend don't browsing LinkedIn profiles, it can never make you feel better.

Unless you find that really academic kid at school that hasn't gone very far ;) but schadenfreude is a terrible thing!!

Kittykat93 · 27/09/2021 21:15

You've worked as a solicitor and a teacher..how is that failure? Try being in my shoes, only low paid admin jobs. 😑

TheNinny · 27/09/2021 21:12

I feel the same but it’s worse in that I studied and graduated at masters level in a health science field. I failed the boards 3 times and now have a good but low paid admin job within the nhs. I studied abroad so will unlikely meet and don’t keep up with any of my peers but it feels a bit shit sometimes. However, I’ve still managed to carve out a lovely life for myself and my DH is well paid so don’t struggle financially, but it’s like a dark cloud on my part sometimes. I don’t regret it though and believe things work out how they are meant to. I would’ve been miserable and lonely if I had practiced.

At least you can say you studied, qualified and practiced in a field of your choosing, which in itself is a massive accomplishment and you should be proud 💪 You have chosen to prioritise different things from your peers but that’s not a bad thing, just different. They may look at you and wish they had done similar

user1487194234 · 27/09/2021 21:09

I have a professional career and children
I certainly don't think I am not raising my children
Sometimes it is about compromise but if you want to have a career you will figure out how to make it work for you

MarshmallowSwede · 27/09/2021 21:00

Comparison is the thief of joy. You have to look at your life and your choices as what is best for you. What others chose was best for them. There is no one way to do life, and success is being happy.

The purpose of life is to be happy, not to have a career that you can chat with over a drink at a dinner party.

If someone decided a career is what makes them happy then fine, but we were not put on this earth to have a career and have things that show the outside world we are “successful “.

If you are happy then you’re successful. That’s the point of life.. joy. To have a joyous life and to revel in the happiness of being alive. That’s why you are here.

Enjoy your children and try to be kinder to yourself. You shouldn’t say things about yourself that you wouldn’t dare say to anyone else. You wouldn’t call another person a failure, so why say this about yourself? That’s one thing you can do starting right now. Stop with the negative self talk.

minipie · 27/09/2021 20:55

For any ex City lawyers reading this who do wish they could get back in but think it’s impossible… It’s got a lot easier. Look up Reignite Academy who are doing amazing things getting women “returnships” in City firms and sometimes in-house. The positions are well paid, 4 days a week (who’d have ever thought!!) and the Academy provides lots of support with CV, interview etc. I think what they are doing is wonderful.

That’s not to say OP or anyone else should go back… but just to signpost in case anyone wants or perhaps financially needs to go back.

Women Returners is a good site for similar programmes but non legal (big range of industries). Retraining programmes into tech are around too.

Starface · 27/09/2021 20:38

Another one here feeling your pain. Not a lawyer but trying to tolerate all the younger crapper leapfroggers and wondering where I went so wrong.

Life isn't all bad - in fact its probably fairly good really. I can't quite see what I'd have done especially differently, but I definitely feel dissatisfied and that I didn't make the most of things. However I definitely wouldn't trade time with my kids for a better career. It just would not have been right for me working full time with kids. I would have been very unhappy really.

If you find a solution to the angst, please do update us.

ColourMeExhausted · 27/09/2021 19:40

Gosh this resonates tonight OP. Just been checking out the LinkedIn profile of a more successful peer who (I have just learnt) graduated from the same university i went to in the same year, with a similar degree. And she has children but is higher up the ladder in our shared profession. Like you OP, I have always performed very well academically and now feel I should have, as you say, more to show for it. But after being made redundant in 2013, I chose to go for a lower paid job, then ended up having my children and benefitting from excellent maternity conditions and pay. Eight years later, I am still there. I've stayed because as well as actually really enjoying the job and the creative opportunities it gives me, it is very flexible in regards to childcare - much needed as a parent to small DC. I am too exhausted to even think about what my next move might be, or what I want it to be, let alone look at job ads.

Most of the time I've made my peace with having a job that still pays relatively well but fits in with the demands of parenting. I know I don't have it in me to attempt a more challenging job right now as I feel stressed out to capacity! But then I see others in similar positions achieving more and I feel like a bit of a failure.

So yes...no answers but you are certainly not alone in feeling like this!

FiddlefigOnTheRoof · 27/09/2021 19:30

A huge number of MC trainees will compare unfavourably with those peers who make it all the way. The issue is for you to develop a thick skin and to put enough value (lots!) on what you’ve achieved for yourself. Speaking from personal experience. I have done a lot of soul searching. Feel free to PM me.

Ginger1982 · 27/09/2021 19:26

I'm a solicitor. After qualifying, I moved to a criminal firm and stayed there too long hoping for a promotion that never came then moved to a firm who were good at promoting but because I was just in the door, I was never considered. There were people with way less experience than me who were technically higher up the ladder than I was. I felt I'd missed the boat.

I then left to have DS and was a SAHM for 2 years before getting a job in a slightly different field. I'm not seeing a lot of promotion options in this job as my immediate bosses are either childfree or much younger than me with kids already and I'll probably never earn more than £45k before I retire. But, you know what? I love the job I currently do, a million times more than I ever loved what I did before. The girl I trained with is now a partner in our training firm. I wouldn't want her job for anything and I wouldn't touch crime now with a barge pole.

Own your choices.

Muttly · 27/09/2021 19:04

I don’t think you give yourself nearly enough credit for your achievements of which you have a lot.

mrsmalcolmreynolds · 27/09/2021 19:04

I'm an equity partner in a city firm - I can honestly say I don't think less of any of my contemporaries who went and did different things be that on qualification, at 2.5 PQE or last year! That includes people who have been SAHP, gone in-house and retrained as a textile print artist.

Success should not be measured by whether someone "can hack it". It should be about whether you have done what was best for you and your loved ones, and whether you feel true to yourself. It sounds to me OP as if you're not sure what being true to yourself really involves at this point in your life - I think you need to focus on that rather than assuming that material achievement is what is missing.

Wewereonaspringbreak · 27/09/2021 19:00

@Brian9600

I could have pretty much written your post, OP. I was the same- a high flyer in the same area, then had kids and wanted to spend more time with them than City law allowed, then made a series of decisions (all of which made sense at the time) which have left me with a reasonably paid but far from stellar career but having had the time I wanted with my family. I think what came as a shock was that the decisions I made were permanent- in my head I was a City lawyer just making a few adjustments- but now I've realised that there is no realistic way back into private practice. It's a real shock to realise that all the hopes I had for myself aren't going to be fulfilled and that I gave it all away so lightly.

What I find helpful is focusing on the good stuff and trying to own the decisions- I made an active choice to focus on family at the expense of my career. That obviously involves a sacrifice but also many years with my children which would otherwise have been very different. I'm sad that I had to make a choice, not that I made the wrong choice.

Also remember that you still have your excellent brain and you are still young. I think City law makes you a bit tunnel-visioned: there is one definition of success (partnership) and anything else is failure. The rest of the world does not see it like that- in fact, quite a lot of people would think it sounds pretty dull. You are still more than capable of having something to show for yourself, if that's what you want.

Yes yes yes! The amount of people who have said to me “just get back into law then if that’s what you want”, but it simply isn’t that simple. I think I did know in my heart of hearts that I was entering a one way street when i took the series of manoeuvres (forgive the poor driving metaphor) to get here, but I was so in love with my kids and spending time with them that I thought that would be enough forever, but now they are older I can’t help but feel a bit bitter about all my training years wasted…But as you rightly say, my bitterness should be directed at the fact that I was forced to choose, not at the choice I made.
junebirthdaygirl · 27/09/2021 18:55

I am a teacher. Stayed home for few years until 3 dc in school. I was 40 then. Went back to work in a lovely school and stayed there very happily. There are different stages in life and you have lots more to go through. I was wondering was there any way of combining solicitors training and teaching to create a new interesting job. Teachers unions/ department of education/ taking court cases for schools/advocacy for special needs children... etc. The world is your oyster. Don't panic. Keep an eye out for opportunities and meanwhile make no apologies for being a SAHM as how you view yourself is how others will view you.
I found when l returned to teaching there was huge respect for my previous experience and l was in no way treated as a has been. My experience with my own children only added to the package. Head up..you have a bright future ahead.

Brian9600 · 27/09/2021 18:40

I could have pretty much written your post, OP. I was the same- a high flyer in the same area, then had kids and wanted to spend more time with them than City law allowed, then made a series of decisions (all of which made sense at the time) which have left me with a reasonably paid but far from stellar career but having had the time I wanted with my family. I think what came as a shock was that the decisions I made were permanent- in my head I was a City lawyer just making a few adjustments- but now I've realised that there is no realistic way back into private practice. It's a real shock to realise that all the hopes I had for myself aren't going to be fulfilled and that I gave it all away so lightly.

What I find helpful is focusing on the good stuff and trying to own the decisions- I made an active choice to focus on family at the expense of my career. That obviously involves a sacrifice but also many years with my children which would otherwise have been very different. I'm sad that I had to make a choice, not that I made the wrong choice.

Also remember that you still have your excellent brain and you are still young. I think City law makes you a bit tunnel-visioned: there is one definition of success (partnership) and anything else is failure. The rest of the world does not see it like that- in fact, quite a lot of people would think it sounds pretty dull. You are still more than capable of having something to show for yourself, if that's what you want.

XelaM · 27/09/2021 18:32

Why not teach at a university? That's better paid than an ordinary teaching job. Also, lots of WFH part-time type of work in law at the moment