Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Angela Raynor

889 replies

Pixxie7 · 26/09/2021 17:54

I think her comments today were spot on, although not really professional she makes a valid point.

OP posts:
derxa · 28/09/2021 22:34

@peewitsandy

The thread I like to start is: A.I.B.U to think that Angela Raynor was the Bully that everyone at school was frightened of !
You've got it. I was never bullied at school but I knew who the bullies were. It all happened in the loos.
SensiMuck · 28/09/2021 21:03

@peewitsandy

The thread I like to start is: A.I.B.U to think that Angela Raynor was the Bully that everyone at school was frightened of !
YANBU!!
peewitsandy · 28/09/2021 20:59

The thread I like to start is: A.I.B.U to think that Angela Raynor was the Bully that everyone at school was frightened of !

Newnewnew1179 · 28/09/2021 20:55

@WormYourHonour

I really don’t agree scum is in common usage

It is in my house.
There's fucking scum everywhere. Doesn't matter how poor, wealthy, intelligent or dumb etc. Anyone can be a scum bag and behave in a scummy way.

Saying “oh you scum bag” to your teen who has left a mess is different from saying “you are homophobic, racist misogynistic scum” to him. I’d say the former and definitely not the latter and it jars for me (and I’m not at all precious about robust language)
Againstmachine · 28/09/2021 20:44

Whether or not they are scum people are menat to be professional in the role as a MP, there is much better ways to criticize.

Againstmachine · 28/09/2021 20:44

@Againstmachine care to explain your comment about the rotherham child abuse scandal ?

Kier starmer was in charge of CPS whilst it was happening, also his MP Naz Shah has been uncaring about it. We have a mp.in Rotherham who cares but she is fighting against the party.

WormYourHonour · 28/09/2021 20:34

I really don’t agree scum is in common usage

It is in my house.
There's fucking scum everywhere. Doesn't matter how poor, wealthy, intelligent or dumb etc. Anyone can be a scum bag and behave in a scummy way.

Newnewnew1179 · 28/09/2021 20:29

I really don’t agree scum is in common usage, it’s an offensive way to describe anyone in all classes of society IMO and it might be deserved but I stand by my view that it’s not a good political move to say it in public and it puts off potential voters and unless Labour make themselves electable they are not going to achieve anything.

Add to that I’ve been deeply unimpressed by AR and her TWAW no debate stance and I’m completely bemused by the seeming suggestion by David Lammy that “city lawyers” can help solve the legal aid crisis by doing more pro bono. I hope there’s more detail to this but if that’s a real suggestion by David Lammy and Starmer as opposed to properly funding legal aid with people who know what they’re doing then it’s disgraceful.

Tealightsandd · 28/09/2021 20:19

It creates instability - eventually a tinderbox situation - as well as costing money.

Do people really think that the creation of the welfare state, public schooling, and the NHS was done out of altruism? It really wasn't the main motivation.

elodie77 · 28/09/2021 20:19

Tealightsandd

Agreed.

Tealightsandd · 28/09/2021 20:17

@elodie77

That response just shows how out of touch you are with how many of us small business owners have to operate.

And how would you suggest workers on low wages make ends meet when rents and other living costs are so expensive?

Affordable housing - particularly council and housing association rentals.

Whoever is in government may not care about people struggling, but they will eventually have to be pragmatic enough to deal with the impact on society.

Failure to tackle it doesn't just harm those at the bottom (and now, the middle). It costs the state a lot of money. It's a false economy.

Viviennemary · 28/09/2021 20:17

Locals councils don't actually make money. They need money from businesses to survive. A fact that seems to bypass most left wingers.

elodie77 · 28/09/2021 20:12

That response just shows how out of touch you are with how many of us small business owners have to operate.

And how would you suggest workers on low wages make ends meet when rents and other living costs are so expensive?

Undeuxdrei · 28/09/2021 20:08

@Againstmachine care to explain your comment about the rotherham child abuse scandal ?

fromdownwest · 28/09/2021 20:08

@SpindleWorld

I don't think £15 p/h living wage is extreme, no, personally.

But Cervixgate and Don'tSayItGate - yes, I do that's an extreme ideology of the current left, tbh.

Well, personally it may not appear much to you. Lose staff or close down, resulting in vacant shops, reduncancies and loss of business.

However, as a small business owner, it would result in redundancies, I am unable to pay that sum, plus NI contributions, Plus Pension, plus sick pay, plus SMP and run a business that has been smashed by covid and spiralling costs of products.

That response just shows how out of touch you are with how many of us small business owners have to operate.

p.s - £15 an hour would equate to a band 9 in my local council to put things into perspective!

TheHateIsNotGood · 28/09/2021 19:58

The only thing refreshing about it is her refusal to Apologize - usually the knee-jerk reaction by most party politicians, mostly swept under the carpet whilst it becomes yesterday's news.

I don't think Rayner should say I'll apogize "if" someone else does or says that, there should be no more ifs, buts or maybes - just don't apologize.

"Scum" to describe people is in common usage as well as all Rayner's other adjectives, maybe it would be helpful if politicians did use commonly-accepted language a bit more, but then we must also accept that we might hear some 'language' we'd rather not.

elodie77 · 28/09/2021 19:57

more affordable cost of living, especially secure housing opportunities. To rent as well as to buy.

I completely agree. I don't own property and have always rented. My friend is a single woman with a professional job but cannot afford to rent her own place so is having to flat share in her mid-40s.

Are the Conservatives in any way interested in providing secure housing opportunities, including genuinely affordable rents - NO!!!

Againstmachine · 28/09/2021 19:44

And this is kind of what I mean, that on one hand Labour are accused of being 'extreme left' for suggesting a £15 minimum wage and on the other we have people saying:

The problem is they don't care it's just a sop to be thrown to the masses , Keir doesn't even support it and it would be a. Massive rise it isn't going to happen labour know this and they don't have to deliver it.

Keir Starmers period in charge at the CPS was whilst Rotherham happened, and also one of his MPs thought people should shut up about abuse and has been suspended.

This is why they are losing in the north people don't trust them at all.

Tealightsandd · 28/09/2021 19:32

@elodie77

Off the top of my head £15 p/h minimum wage?

Do you really think that is extreme?

Housing and living costs (with energy costs going up) are now so extortionate that people doing essential jobs like, you know, cleaning, working in shops or caring for your kids or parents etc cannot exist without an actual living wage. How can you call that extreme?

And yet £15 p/h still won't be enough to meet the spiralling costs, particularly of housing.

Smaller businesses will go bust. Far better to have lower wages - but more affordable cost of living, especially secure housing opportunities. To rent as well as to buy.

TooBigForMyBoots · 28/09/2021 19:07

[quote fromdownwest]**@TooBigForMyBoots* - What are your thoughts on an MP threatening to use acid against a woman she believed to be in a relationship with her partner, calling her a slg and threatening revenge porn?[/quote]
I think its fucking horrendous. I hope she has been arrested and charged. Why do you ask @fromdownwest?

x2boys · 28/09/2021 18:55

@elodie77

Off the top of my head £15 p/h minimum wage?

Do you really think that is extreme?

Housing and living costs (with energy costs going up) are now so extortionate that people doing essential jobs like, you know, cleaning, working in shops or caring for your kids or parents etc cannot exist without an actual living wage. How can you call that extreme?

Well It's not extreme unfortunately a lot of companies just wont be able to afford it and have to make redundancies Its a about seven years since i worked in the NHS but as a top band five nurse i was on just under £15 /hour.
Blackberrycream · 28/09/2021 18:49

@elodie77

Woke = alert to injustice in society, especially racism.
That’s great.
  • Labour aren’t particularly diverse.
  • Some Labour supporters love to claim the moral high ground. I’m not that convinced. When there are repeated incidents of Labour members intimidated for various reasons and unable to attend the conference, their may be a case for examining that don’t you think? Or are we just allowed to justify this in various ways as has been the case- victim blaming?
  • You said Labour have ‘good people’ . I agree. Keir Starmer is one of them. They also have a significant contingent of pretty nasty bullies and also people who have failed to speak up about the bullying.
  • I hate the word woke. I am concerned about racism but am currently worried about encroachments on women’s rights. Am I woke? It’s simplistic. We can have different opinions on different subjects. I also object to Angela Raynor calling someone a racist when I don’t remember her being one of the members who spoke out during the anti semitism scandal.
elodie77 · 28/09/2021 18:49

But we have no idea what the alternative system is - obviously even labour don't know what it is - I meant to point out that there ARE alternatives, that it isn't necessarily pie in the sky and a reason to write Labour off!

And this is kind of what I mean, that on one hand Labour are accused of being 'extreme left' for suggesting a £15 minimum wage and on the other we have people saying: The problem is labour no longer stands for the people working factorys, care low paid jobs they focus on other stuff and target the middle class, the low paid no longer have a part that represents them.

A lot of it is down to people not caring to find out what Labour OR the Conservatives actually stand for and what their track record in introducing policies is, they just believe whatever Daily Mail churns out. And get upset when they are called out on not being very well informed.

Women's and trans rights...it's difficult and I do think the rights of both should be taken seriously. But do you really think the Conservatives have women's rights at heart?

reprehensibleme · 28/09/2021 18:37

Uhhuh, but last time I looked we were talking about the Labour Party in the UK (more specifically England) and as I posted above, the manifesto talked about designing an 'alternative' system, not bringing in a ubi.

UBI is a really interesting idea but there haven't really been enough big studies to see how it would work long term. It's the kind of thing which could be effective but it could have many unintended consequences (and over the last 18 months, we've encountered plenty of those).

SpindleWorld · 28/09/2021 18:32

That's an good and interesting pilot but it's not Labour Party Policy is it? (Mores the pity.)

I'd like to know what the plan is. Back to tax credits? Basic universal income? Pilot schemes, and if so for now many years, and where?

But most of all - women's rights.