Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Angela Raynor

889 replies

Pixxie7 · 26/09/2021 17:54

I think her comments today were spot on, although not really professional she makes a valid point.

OP posts:
MarshaBradyo · 29/09/2021 16:08

@Blossomtoes

And then you’ll have a ripple effect. It’s pretty bloody obvious to me.
Really? I doubt it.

No ripple effect here between one school worth £1.5 plus houses and other people move away from.

Good luck if you think it has a chance of raising standards with meagre amounts. It’s a dud and unfortunately appeals to some for obvious reasons.

Blossomtoes · 29/09/2021 16:04

And then you’ll have a ripple effect. It’s pretty bloody obvious to me.

MarshaBradyo · 29/09/2021 16:02

@Blossomtoes

Why force more into state as a result for little financial gain. It’s a bad strategy.

Is it? Or is it a recipe for greater social mobility? Sharp elbowed parents are an excellent way of forcing standards up.

They are good at getting places so yes you might see house prices rise in certain catchment areas. We have this already in London. Or good at getting grammar through prep school / tutoring first.

It skews the mix in a school but it also creates schools people avoid.

If say 10 to 20% leave private they will use that money for better results in state but not necessarily in the way people would like.

elodie77 · 29/09/2021 16:01

Wouldn't scrapping business rates help businesses pay their workers a proper wage?

*Charitable status removal worries me due to

  • students moving to state as schools close or additional fees push people out increasing strain in sector
  • ‘soft power’ for U.K. as independent sector is well regarded and attractive. Generally people can afford it if they are o/s but the sector is an asset to U.K. so tinkering with it should be well thought out
  • bursaries stopping - will they? That is very sad if so. Also outreach too. Schools have big bursaries here it’s no small thing for the children*

I thought the idea was also to redistribute private school assets and bring them into the state sector so it wouldn't necessarily mean the state sector would be overburdened.

I'm not sure I entirely understand your second point.

Bursaries wouldn't necessarily have to stop. It would probably mean that only the very wealthy could afford the full fees but the schools could still sponsor some pupils via generous bursaries.

Blossomtoes · 29/09/2021 15:58

Why force more into state as a result for little financial gain. It’s a bad strategy.

Is it? Or is it a recipe for greater social mobility? Sharp elbowed parents are an excellent way of forcing standards up.

Porridgealert · 29/09/2021 15:57

Labour’s business tax reform would look to shift the burden from the high street to online giants,

I don't think anyone would disagree with this but no country has yet been able to do it, even by adjusting their own tax laws. There are international tax agreements that means certain things can't be done. So if none of the western economies have been able to do it to date, how is KS promising to do it. If he knows a way, he should contact the Inland Revenue. Its just another politician's empty promise that can't be delivered. Haven't we had enough of those?

MarshaBradyo · 29/09/2021 15:54

@Blossomtoes

Make state more attractive without downsides

How? Where will the money come from? The only way state education will get better is if parents insist on it and vote for parties that prioritise it. It’s never going to be a priority for a party whose MPs predominantly pay for their kids’ education.

Well people seem to think business rates can be scrapped and online giants will pay more
  • so there?

Why force more into state as a result for little financial gain. It’s a bad strategy.

It appears to a certain psychology and that’s it.

Blossomtoes · 29/09/2021 15:52

Make state more attractive without downsides

How? Where will the money come from? The only way state education will get better is if parents insist on it and vote for parties that prioritise it. It’s never going to be a priority for a party whose MPs predominantly pay for their kids’ education.

MarshaBradyo · 29/09/2021 15:52

Also £15 min wage - what impact on inflation and businesses that need to pay it. Will they survive, how?

MarshaBradyo · 29/09/2021 15:48

If they can get money from online giants without repercussion on business here - I’d be interested I’d need to know more what impact it has.

Charitable status removal worries me due to

  • students moving to state as schools close or additional fees push people out increasing strain in sector
  • ‘soft power’ for U.K. as independent sector is well regarded and attractive. Generally people can afford it if they are o/s but the sector is an asset to U.K. so tinkering with it should be well thought out
  • bursaries stopping - will they? That is very sad if so. Also outreach too. Schools have big bursaries here it’s no small thing for the children

How much per state student will it raise? £27 per head for example and you won’t get this idealistic result promised

It feels punitive. Someone said the other day Blair focussed on improving education without doing this and I think it’s a far better way

Make state more attractive without downsides

elodie77 · 29/09/2021 15:15

How do you see removing charitable status from private schools as something that would have a negative effect?

And the proposals to scrap business rates to support small businesses sound good and workable to me:

Labour’s business tax reform would look to shift the burden from the high street to online giants, and end the tax relief afforded to private schools due to their charitable status.

The party would also aim to raise £440 million by closing the carried interest loophole which relates to private equity fund managers and the share of profits made by investment deals. Ms Reeves said: “Labour will tax fairly, spend wisely, and get our economy firing on all cylinders.”

MarshaBradyo · 29/09/2021 14:57

The three I’ve heard

  • £15 min wage
  • remove charitable status from schools
  • scrap business rates

Money from where? What knock on effects both here and with international investment?

Maybe detail will help but it doesn’t fill me with confidence. It’s easy to make things sound attractive but they have to work

Sunak has done some bold moves which have worked - even if some have unfortunate downside (fraud was one imo, but he’s pretty thorough so maybe best way)

elodie77 · 29/09/2021 14:52

it’s so pie in the sky. What is?

With their pledges they sound apart from reality - such as?

BJ is the one for wild schemes that have consistently proved a failure.

MarshaBradyo · 29/09/2021 14:42

Who would you rather trust with the country's finances?

Sunak had done a good job imo

Spent a lot but stopped unemployment from spiralling. Clear, reasonable and I pretty much agree with him when he explains it.

When I listen to Labour I get concerned it really could be bad for the country economically, it’s so pie in the sky.

Someone asked what I wanted from Labour to vote for them - positivity, non insularity, lack of infighting, opportunity at each level - and really not stuffing up finances. With their pledges they sound apart from reality

Blossomtoes · 29/09/2021 14:41

@MarshaBradyo

It might sound fairer but it has to stack up financially.

Labour did this last time under Corbyn.

And what happened? The wonderful low tax Tory government that everyone voted for embarked on the biggest spending spree for decades, with its mates the main beneficiaries. While we now have worse public services. At least with Labour I approve of what they’re spending my money on and I’m pretty sure it’s not going into millionaires’ pockets.
elodie77 · 29/09/2021 14:33

It might sound fairer but it has to stack up financially.

Of course, but what makes you think his plans won't?

Who would you rather trust with the country's finances?

www.cer.eu/insights/cost-brexit-may-2021

www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2021/may/30/boris-johnson-plans-to-sink-200m-into-new-ship-of-state

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-london-47228698

www.theguardian.com/politics/2019/jul/16/boris-johnson-accused-of-costing-taxpayers-1bn-on-london-mayor-projects

MarshaBradyo · 29/09/2021 14:28

It might sound fairer but it has to stack up financially.

Labour did this last time under Corbyn.

elodie77 · 29/09/2021 14:25

I don't agree - his ideas were sound and pragmatic, aiming to create a fairer society that works for everyone.

MarshaBradyo · 29/09/2021 14:10

They seem to be doing wishing list finances again

peewitsandy · 29/09/2021 14:02

After the comedy show of the last four days of the Labour Party Conference we hear more epic stupidity.

This time suggestive of a minimum wage of £15 per hour or about £29,000 a year based on a 37 hour week.

That is not only about the average salary in the U.K but about what Graduates who have been in the workforce two or three years will typically earn

Do these people not understand that this is just idiotic . I think minimum wages that are placed at stupid and unrealistic rates actually of the effect of bringing down wages. Example a job that should be a £12-14 Pound Per hour is reduced to minimum wag of £8.91.

Whydoyouneedtoknow · 29/09/2021 13:45

@elodie77

That response just shows how out of touch you are with how many of us small business owners have to operate.

And how would you suggest workers on low wages make ends meet when rents and other living costs are so expensive?

If the minimum wage is £15, how much will I have to pay for skilled workers... and then this price will be passed back on to the customer as I will have to raise my prices, thus earning £15 a hour will mean that due to inflation you would be no better off.

Stop buy to let and have rent caps maybe. Housing shouldn't be used to make wealthy people richer.

elodie77 · 29/09/2021 13:37

Go Keir - agree with all he said! Liveability and sustainability!

Undeuxdrei · 29/09/2021 09:30

@Againstmachine what did starmer do wrong ? Certainly some tory mps doctored an interview to suggest he was dismissive about child grooming gangs. This has now been deleted. And Naz Shah won legal action and an apology from an anti EU group accusing her of being an apologist for child grooming. They accepted in court that she was a vociferous campaigner against it......

Ibelieveinghosts · 29/09/2021 06:22

@elodie77

That response just shows how out of touch you are with how many of us small business owners have to operate.

And how would you suggest workers on low wages make ends meet when rents and other living costs are so expensive?

Probably better than they would do if they were unemployed which is basically the alternative in many cases.
Porridgealert · 29/09/2021 00:47

I don't really have any strong feelings about Angela Rayner and I don't care that she called Conservatives scum. And I doubt the Tories will either. I guess they'll have their own words to describe her. We'll see if it raises the LPs standing with the public but I guess her only concern will be whether it raises hers.
Like her I come from Manchrster and I've lived there and in Lancashire my whole life. I really object to her saying that the word scum is commonly used in northern working class towns because it really isn't. I've never heard people referring to other people as scum either at work or out socialising. I'm sure it happens but it is not an everyday occurrence and a bit of a laugh. Just because AR has a foul mouth, she shouldn't tar the rest of us with it. I feel disgusted by her trying to cool the heat of her words by condemning northern people as being as foul as her. As a northern person she is not encouraging me to vote Labour.