Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Angela Raynor

889 replies

Pixxie7 · 26/09/2021 17:54

I think her comments today were spot on, although not really professional she makes a valid point.

OP posts:
Andante57 · 29/09/2021 17:49

Some of the 600,000 or so children currently in the private sector would probably be priced out, but there will be many more who would just dig into their pockets and pay the difference

Alexashutup how do you know this?

Andante57 · 29/09/2021 17:48

@Porridgealert

Labour’s business tax reform would look to shift the burden from the high street to online giants,

I don't think anyone would disagree with this but no country has yet been able to do it, even by adjusting their own tax laws. There are international tax agreements that means certain things can't be done. So if none of the western economies have been able to do it to date, how is KS promising to do it. If he knows a way, he should contact the Inland Revenue. Its just another politician's empty promise that can't be delivered. Haven't we had enough of those?

This. Elodie, Everyone would like Amazon to pay more tax. How is Labour going to make Amazon etc pay tax when no other country has managed?
AlexaShutUp · 29/09/2021 17:45

X post

AlexaShutUp · 29/09/2021 17:45

@Blossomtoes

This will add further burden to state. Why does £850 per child sound good but not the extra tax that isn’t currently used?

I’m not being rude but I don’t understand what that means.

She means that the state doesn't currently have to fund education through tax for the kids who are currently in private schools. And that this would change if lots of privately educated kids suddenly had to move to the state sector.

We don't know how many would be in this position. Some of the 600,000 or so children currently in the private sector would probably be priced out, but there will be many more who would just dig into their pockets and pay the difference. Plus, of course, a significant proportion of private schools aren't registered as charities anyway, so their pupils wouldn't be affected.

MarshaBradyo · 29/09/2021 17:42

@Blossomtoes

This will add further burden to state. Why does £850 per child sound good but not the extra tax that isn’t currently used?

I’m not being rude but I don’t understand what that means.

I mean private pay tax for a state place and don’t currently use it. A bit like those who pay private insurance and NI and don’t use NHS. It relieves the state system and if they were to switch it would add burden to state.
Blossomtoes · 29/09/2021 17:39

This will add further burden to state. Why does £850 per child sound good but not the extra tax that isn’t currently used?

I’m not being rude but I don’t understand what that means.

AlexaShutUp · 29/09/2021 17:33

@MarshaBradyo

The assets could be sold to government- how much will that cost?

I want Labour to do better. But I’m so disappointed with the three policies I’ve heard.

It’s as if a party has decided to put anything forward - no matter how unrealistic.

I don't disagree with the disappointment re Labour. I've long since given up on them having anything really exciting to offer.

I'm not even that bothered about what they do with the charitable status of private schools. There are more important concerns in my view. I just get irritated by the arguments to keep charitable status because some schools give a paltry number of bursaries to kids who quite often aren't from the most disadvantaged backgrounds anyway.

I also don't buy the argument that there would be hoards of kids flooding back into the state sector. There would be some, undoubtedly. But I don't think there would be enough to cancel it out altogether.

Porridgealert · 29/09/2021 17:32

@Blossomtoes

Make state more attractive without downsides

How? Where will the money come from? The only way state education will get better is if parents insist on it and vote for parties that prioritise it. It’s never going to be a priority for a party whose MPs predominantly pay for their kids’ education.

Like Diane Abbott?
MarshaBradyo · 29/09/2021 17:29

I’m not cynical or bitter. As I say I’ve voted Labour and liked Blair’s approach, but the policies need to work.

AlexaShutUp · 29/09/2021 17:28

@MarshaBradyo

Not to mention where do they go? We are bursting already in London state sector

New buildings? Staff, resources. It’s not cheap

Either there will be loads switching to state or there won't.

If there a loads, then many of the existing private schools won't survive. They will have to close or merge. Perhaps their buildings could be used and staff could be transferred.

MarshaBradyo · 29/09/2021 17:28

The assets could be sold to government- how much will that cost?

I want Labour to do better. But I’m so disappointed with the three policies I’ve heard.

It’s as if a party has decided to put anything forward - no matter how unrealistic.

elodie77 · 29/09/2021 17:27

It seems that Conservative supporters are very cynical and bitter and incapable of believing in anything better than what you currently have which I suppose isn't at all surprising since all Boris's promises have got you is blue passports, empty shelves and no fuel.

'Levelling up' and 'taking back control' indeed!

MarshaBradyo · 29/09/2021 17:25

Not to mention where do they go? We are bursting already in London state sector

New buildings? Staff, resources. It’s not cheap

AlexaShutUp · 29/09/2021 17:25

@MarshaBradyo, I don't believe that that many would jump ship, but if they do, a lot of private schools will need to close so perhaps their assets could be sold and donated to help fund the difference?

And if all the private school kids do suddenly get moved to state, then in the longer term, it will create more political pressure to invest in state education, which can only be a good thing.

MarshaBradyo · 29/09/2021 17:22

Actually maybe I should phrase that as a child will use up £5k per year that isn’t currently doing so.

MarshaBradyo · 29/09/2021 17:20

[quote AlexaShutUp]@MarshaBradyo, I think there are around 2 million pupil premium kids at the moment, so around £850 each if it was split evenly between them. Quite a big increase on what they get now, so it would be significant. It's up to individual schools to spend it in ways that are tailored to the individual child. At the school where I'm a governor, it funds a variety of things including 1:1 or small group interventions with the children in question - both academic and pastoral - as well as breakfast clubs to ensure that they get a decent meal at the start of the day, support for stuff like music lessons, participation in residentials etc.

Of course, it won't be enough to raise standards across the board - we need to do more from general taxation too. But it would help.

And yes, there may be a significant number who move to the state sector if they can no longer afford the fees. So be it. There will be plenty of others who continue to pay their private fees.[/quote]
But how can it be ‘so be it’?

They currently pay £5k per year? Tax that will then be used for the child that attends

This will add further burden to state. Why does £850 per child sound good but not the extra tax that isn’t currently used?

AlexaShutUp · 29/09/2021 17:17

@MarshaBradyo, I think there are around 2 million pupil premium kids at the moment, so around £850 each if it was split evenly between them. Quite a big increase on what they get now, so it would be significant. It's up to individual schools to spend it in ways that are tailored to the individual child. At the school where I'm a governor, it funds a variety of things including 1:1 or small group interventions with the children in question - both academic and pastoral - as well as breakfast clubs to ensure that they get a decent meal at the start of the day, support for stuff like music lessons, participation in residentials etc.

Of course, it won't be enough to raise standards across the board - we need to do more from general taxation too. But it would help.

And yes, there may be a significant number who move to the state sector if they can no longer afford the fees. So be it. There will be plenty of others who continue to pay their private fees.

sst1234 · 29/09/2021 17:07

@elodie77

I don't agree - his ideas were sound and pragmatic, aiming to create a fairer society that works for everyone.
Fabulous soundbite. So what?
MarshaBradyo · 29/09/2021 17:04

@AlexaShutUp

How much per student will the policy raise?

Not a huge amount. The estimate I have seen suggests about £1.7billion in total. I'm sure people will debate this but none of us really know for sure. Not sure how much that works out per pupil - £150ish per year? However, if it was focused on pupil premium kids rather than all pupils, it could make a significant difference to the most disadvantaged pupils.

Ok good to see a figure - if it was only spent on disadvantaged pupils what would they get and how would it help?

And how do you raise standards for other students

Plus make sure that students leaving the private sector don’t just use up the tax they pay (but currently don’t use the place) and add burden to state system?

AlexaShutUp · 29/09/2021 16:59

How much per student will the policy raise?

Not a huge amount. The estimate I have seen suggests about £1.7billion in total. I'm sure people will debate this but none of us really know for sure. Not sure how much that works out per pupil - £150ish per year? However, if it was focused on pupil premium kids rather than all pupils, it could make a significant difference to the most disadvantaged pupils.

Clavinova · 29/09/2021 16:49

September 2019
Angela Rayner: 'MPs need to dial down their language.'

Andrew Marr spoke to Labour's shadow education secretary, Angela Rayner.

www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/p07pmq61

24 October 2020

Conservative MPs have faced "widespread abuse" after Labour's Angela Rayner used the word "scum" in a Parliamentary debate, the party's co-chairwoman says.

Amanda Milling has written to Labour leader Sir Keir Starmer asking if he will take action against Labour MPs "who perpetrate abuse."

Ms Milling, in a letter signed by more than 100 Tory backbenchers, wrote that Ms Rayner's use of the word "scum" towards Mr Clarkson was "unacceptable".

She said it had resulted in the phrase "Tory scum" trending on Twitter and had caused "widespread abuse towards members of our parliamentary party", including abusive phone calls and MPs' offices being targeted.

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-54675232

MarshaBradyo · 29/09/2021 16:34

@AlexaShutUp

What about the parents who are already there...what are they doing to raise standards?

Well, personally I volunteer as a governor at one of the local schools in order to do my bit. I know others who help to raise funds for schools and others who volunteer in the classroom etc.

Personally, I'd prefer the government to invest more in state schools than to fund a handful of bursary places at private schools through tax relief.

How much per student will the policy raise?
AlexaShutUp · 29/09/2021 16:32

What about the parents who are already there...what are they doing to raise standards?

Well, personally I volunteer as a governor at one of the local schools in order to do my bit. I know others who help to raise funds for schools and others who volunteer in the classroom etc.

Personally, I'd prefer the government to invest more in state schools than to fund a handful of bursary places at private schools through tax relief.

Franklin12 · 29/09/2021 16:24

Labour have been bleating on about removing charitable status from private schools for years and years. It's the politics of envy and why only sharp elbowed parents raising the standards if they go back into the state system? What about the parents who are already there...what are they doing to raise standards?

My DS's school is very well known, there were boys on scholarships and full bursaries and to say that schools would still give them out if the charitable status was taken away have no idea how business works. If you look at the history of Labour Cabinet Ministers and where they sent their children I think most be shocked. Its not just Abbott who says one thing and does the complete opposite. Look up Shirley Williams who effectively abolished grammar schools.

All that would happen is that house prices would shoot up in the more popular areas and nothing much would change.

As a PP says - other countries have been trying for ages to get the online giants to pay more. So far they have failed. How will Labour do this? Its a reasonable soundbite but realistically if they do have to pay more in taxes it will be us funding this through increased prices.

CrumpleHornedSnowcack · 29/09/2021 16:18

pretty disgusting imo - there would have been absolute uproar if it was the other way around & Boris had said these things about her