Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Angela Raynor

889 replies

Pixxie7 · 26/09/2021 17:54

I think her comments today were spot on, although not really professional she makes a valid point.

OP posts:
elodie77 · 29/09/2021 19:55

And listening to people here moaning about having to pay people a living wage...

elodie77 · 29/09/2021 19:52

Porridgealert I'm not holding myself as any kind of gold standard, but as someone just trying to manage and hope my children can do better than I did. As someone who has worked in minimum wage jobs, lived in bedsits and even squatted. I worry about my child having that kind of future.

Most Tories sending their kids to private school probably have safety nets that would protect them anyway and I doubt they have to worry particularly about their kids' future. If they did why wouldn't they vote for a fairer society overall?

Porridgealert · 29/09/2021 19:47

But, @elodie77, you're critical of conservatives being without principles and acting in their own self interest, but haven't you acted in self interest and abandoned your principles by sending your child to an independent school? Perhaps tories who have well behaved children like yours send their children to private school for the same reasons as you.

roarfeckingroarr · 29/09/2021 19:33

She's such an embarrassment.

elodie77 · 29/09/2021 19:32

Andante57

Thanks.

You don't think it's possible to have some principles and still to want to do what you can to give your children the best chance? I worry about my child's future and I believe the best way to go about trying to change things for the better is by voting for a party that can offer that. The Tories never will, just look at their track record.

My child did in fact go to a state school before, which was very run down, they were completely ignored and written off as 'well behaved' and nothing more. I think this is because the state system is underfunded and teachers are not valued and remunerated properly so many struggle with motivation. They just don't have the resources.

I'm hoping my child's school will motivate them to learn and do the best they can and I tell them that they should also grow up to give something back for all they have received.

It's the best I can do in an uncertain and unfair dog eat dog society, not having any savings, property or connections to help my child in the future.

What I would ask though is why can nothing be expected of the Tories? They can lie, cheat and swindle their way out of anything and people still vote for them and view them completely uncritically.

RufustheBadgeringReindeer · 29/09/2021 19:31

No worries 💐

Lucyccfc68 · 29/09/2021 19:31

@RufustheBadgeringReindeer

Lucyccfc68

That poster was quoting Boris Johnson…obviously your point still stands

Thank you for pointing that out.

Apologies to @Limejuiceandrum for calling you scum (unless you agree with Boris of course).

RufustheBadgeringReindeer · 29/09/2021 19:19

Lucyccfc68

That poster was quoting Boris Johnson…obviously your point still stands

Andante57 · 29/09/2021 19:15

That was to Elodie.

Andante57 · 29/09/2021 19:14

would still vote for Labour even if it meant my child couldn't continue at her private school. I would much rather the society was generally fairer and offered my child better opportunities so I didn't feel the need to send them to a private school to give them the best chance in life

Then if that’s how you feel you shouldn’t have sent them to a private school in the first place. You’re a complete hypocrite.

Lucyccfc68 · 29/09/2021 18:56

@Limejuiceandrum

Liverpool had made scapegoats of the police in the Hillsborough disaster, while refusing to acknowledge the part played by “drunken” fans “mindlessly” trying to fight their way in.
Complete myth that ‘drunken’ fans were trying to fight their way in. It has been proven and shown time and time again that the failings at Hillsborough were the responsibility of the police and Sheff Weds and their H and S failings. Add to that, the 160 police statements that were altered to make it look like the police were blameless.

To pinch one of Angela’s phrase - if you are that uneducated about what happened at Hillsborough, you are scum.

So, back to the point in hand. I agree with everything she said, but don’t like her as a person or politician. She refuses to acknowledge women and the need for single sex spaces and has no issue with her minions threatening and intimidating women at feminist meetings.

elodie77 · 29/09/2021 18:46

I will admit I am one of those parents whose child is at a private school on a significant bursary, because I felt it offered them the best education and therefore a better chance in a society that is so competitive and unfair, where housing and jobs are scarce.

I would still vote for Labour even if it meant my child couldn't continue at her private school. I would much rather the society was generally fairer and offered my child better opportunities so I didn't feel the need to send them to a private school to give them the best chance in life.

Porridgealert · 29/09/2021 18:44

@elodie77. Amazon made $44b in Europe but I Luxembourg where it is HQed, it managed to make a loss so it paid no corporation tax. In the UK Amazon already is charged a 2% digital tax. It paid 0.37% in tax so it doesn't even pay that. So it will find a way around paying this 12% tax by how it structures the company. However, lots of other struggling and small companies will get caught in it and go under. Its troublesome that the shadow Chancellor doesn't understand what's happening and the repercussions her tax will have.

AlexaShutUp · 29/09/2021 18:36

And I would add, I too know of some people who have benefited from 100% bursaries. I don't begrudge those individual children in the slightest, but honestly speaking, they were not the kind of kids who were ever going to struggle in the state sector in any case.

My primary concern is for the kids that really don't have a chance in the current system. Of course, I know that a bit of extra cash on pupil premium is not going to fix their disadvantage, but it would be a step in the right direction.

AlexaShutUp · 29/09/2021 18:31

@MarshaBradyo

I think I’m skewed as the school I know well really does reach out and ensure that some students get 100% (or more). It’s very well done

The way I see it private pay tax and don’t use it - which is more of a benefit than the tax relief on the status. It’s a different perspective but it switches it from - these people are getting something they shouldn’t to - they are paying for something they are not using.

Because whilst I’d like to see state improve, Blair won off back of this, I really dislike Starmer for not caring about the reality.

It reminds me of when he said ‘nurseries should probably close’ with no thought to women impacted.

Do it another way imo.

Yes, I can understand those perspectives. And tbh, I'm not ideologically committed to taking the charitable status away from private schools if there is a better way of doing it. I just don't think it's an awful idea and I haven't heard of any better ones yet. From any party!
MarshaBradyo · 29/09/2021 18:24

I think I’m skewed as the school I know well really does reach out and ensure that some students get 100% (or more). It’s very well done

The way I see it private pay tax and don’t use it - which is more of a benefit than the tax relief on the status. It’s a different perspective but it switches it from - these people are getting something they shouldn’t to - they are paying for something they are not using.

Because whilst I’d like to see state improve, Blair won off back of this, I really dislike Starmer for not caring about the reality.

It reminds me of when he said ‘nurseries should probably close’ with no thought to women impacted.

Do it another way imo.

AlexaShutUp · 29/09/2021 18:20

@Andante57

Alexashutup Thank you for answering my question.

Another question:

don't believe that that many would jump ship, but if they do, a lot of private schools will need to close so perhaps their assets could be sold and donated to help fund the difference?

If the private schools close who would decide if their assets are sold and donated to help fund the difference?
Presumably the government could only insist on this by seizing the properties.

It's an interesting question. As they are currently charities, I'm not sure what would happen to their assets if that status was lost. The trustees wouldn't be allowed to take any financial benefit. The normal process when winding up a charity is to pass on any remaining assets to another charity which shares a common cause, but there wouldn't be any private schools left as charities, so who knows?! Personally, I think it would be reasonable for those assets to go to the state, but no idea what the legal position would be.
AlexaShutUp · 29/09/2021 18:17

@MarshaBradyo

I feel for bursary children. I know people seem not to care but I do. What a shame to shut that door.

Re business rates - I don’t know how staff wages compares to the rate

Yes, on an individual level, I feel for them too. However, at a macro level, it's hard to justify that level of tax relief for the benefit of so few children. Also, in my experience, there are very few bursary children who are genuinely what I would call disadvantaged. Not least because it takes a certain degree of knowledge and engagement on the part of the parents to secure those bursaries in the first place. I want to see resources going in to support the kids who don't have knowledgeable or engaged parents.
Andante57 · 29/09/2021 18:14

Alexashutup
Thank you for answering my question.

Another question:

don't believe that that many would jump ship, but if they do, a lot of private schools will need to close so perhaps their assets could be sold and donated to help fund the difference?

If the private schools close who would decide if their assets are sold and donated to help fund the difference?
Presumably the government could only insist on this by seizing the properties.

MarshaBradyo · 29/09/2021 18:10

I feel for bursary children. I know people seem not to care but I do. What a shame to shut that door.

Re business rates - I don’t know how staff wages compares to the rate

AlexaShutUp · 29/09/2021 18:05

@Andante57

Some of the 600,000 or so children currently in the private sector would probably be priced out, but there will be many more who would just dig into their pockets and pay the difference

Alexashutup how do you know this?

It's a reasonable assumption to make. Firstly, because a significant proportion of private schools don't have charitable status anyway, so their pupils will be unaffected. Secondly, because removing the charitable status of schools would not make the cost of a private education for individual children vastly more expensive, relative to the overall cost that people are already willing to pay. You only have to look at the massive increases that some schools apply to their fees year on year to understand that the prices are pretty elastic. And thirdly because there are significant numbers of international students currently in private schools who would not be eligible to transfer to the state system.

Yes, there will be quite a few families who can only just afford private education and they will be priced out of the market. However, I don't think the number is anything like as high as people like to suggest it is.

(And of course, if private schools are no longer required to invest the vast amounts in bursary schemes to support the poor, as we are assured that they all do in order to earn their charitable status, then the schools will be able to pass these savings back to parents in order to ease the burden. Wink)

elodie77 · 29/09/2021 18:03

And the £15 min wage. Can someone talk about why it won’t collapse businesses who have to pay it and cause inflation?

As I was saying earlier if business rates are scrapped that would free up funds to pay their employees properly.

elodie77 · 29/09/2021 17:56

"Ms Reeves made the remarks as she called on the Government to increase the digital services tax to 12% for the next year, to make sure online companies like Amazon are paying their fair share.

Ms Reeves insisted the whole system of business taxation is not “fair” or “fit for purpose”, adding: “How can it be when bricks-and-mortar, high street businesses are taxed more heavily than online giants? High street businesses pay over a third of business rates, despite making up only 15% of the overall economy.

But when Amazon’s revenues went up by almost £2 billion last year, how much did their tax go up? Less than one per cent. If you can afford to fly to space, you can pay your taxes here on Earth.”

The shadow chancellor also said the digital services tax rise would help the Government freeze business rates – a move that would give small and medium-sized businesses a discount next year.

She said: “Today we are calling on the Government to freeze business rates next year to increase the threshold for small business rates relief, giving small and medium-sized businesses in all sectors a discount next year.

“To pay for those measures, the Government should increase the digital services tax to 12% for the next year, to make sure online companies that have thrived during this pandemic are paying their fair share.”

MarshaBradyo · 29/09/2021 17:56

Labour have the attention of the public and actually seem to be getting rid of the red card hecklers.

But when it’s I imagine the world will follow us in solving a difficult tax issue then it shows how they are just promises atm

And the £15 min wage. Can someone talk about why it won’t collapse businesses who have to pay it and cause inflation?

Blossomtoes · 29/09/2021 17:51

How is Labour going to make Amazon etc pay tax when no other country has managed?

It’s a global problem which can only be tackled globally. I imagine a Labour government would make co-operation with other countries more of a priority than a Tory one.