Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Angela Raynor

889 replies

Pixxie7 · 26/09/2021 17:54

I think her comments today were spot on, although not really professional she makes a valid point.

OP posts:
elodie77 · 30/09/2021 11:34

I'm not commenting on my child's school again, there is no point. I don't owe you any explanation for that.

Labour believe in the common good do they? Righto.. 'male raspists should be allowed in to womens prisons' - Lisa Nandy. Do you believe that is the common good? Are you really going to vote for that?

Lisa Nandy did not say that. But trans rights/women's rights is a very complicated and divisive issue and the conversation needs nuance, not hysterical scaremongering.

I have also felt aligned quite strongly to the 'only born women are women' school of thought, but I've started questioning myself recently and the reasons why I think that. I do think, and always did, that trans people deserve rights and dignity too, and there have been appalling instances of violence, murder and discrimination of trans people.

I do think that some of the examples given of a trans woman in a women's prison are extreme examples - most trans women live normal lives and are in solidarity with women.

I think that the only way forward is to think more progressively about the rights and dignity of everyone.

Evesgarden · 30/09/2021 11:26

@elodie77

Why on earth would you risk their education by having the rug pulled under them if Labour got in Elodie77!

Because I believe they would make the society better and fairer than it is now.

Its a sound bite to make you feel better but realistically there is no way you would give up their place without a fight. As a PP says - you must have spent ages putting an application together.

WRONG on both counts.

By all means think I'm a terrible person, no problem, I am not trying to be perfect nor do I think I'm a particularly good person, but I DO strongly believe in a fair and equal society that gives opportunities for all, not just those born to privilege.

Again - hypocritical.

but I DO strongly believe in a fair and equal society that gives opportunities for all, not just those born to privilege

So you there hand over months and months worth of bank statements/wage slips and contractually agree to be transparent in your spending and wage rises to get your child a private education Grin

You fair and equal society mean you handing over your bank account so your kid can join in the top tier education system. Jesus this has really made me laugh Grin

Look vote Labour all you want but feck off with your fair and equal shite because you dont even believe in yourself Grin Grin

MarshaBradyo · 30/09/2021 11:25

There are other possibilities

The dc will finish school by the time the election happens

The pp is a Labour SM sound bite person - they sound like sound bites

It’s unlikely imo a parent wouldn’t mind taking a bursary child out - there’s a reason they wanted to avoid the state system to start with to apply.

Evesgarden · 30/09/2021 11:19

[quote elodie77]**@elodie77 You're a hypocrite. in fact worse than a hypocrite as your happy to take for free what many parents pay a small fortune ( people like me) to send their kids to private, yet claim to happily pull your child out if labour shut them down. Bull shit. You went above and beyond to get that bursary - including handing over all your financial details and bank statements, declaring any big buys and wage rises, reapplying and submitting documents every year, securing a bursary is incredibly intrusive. A bursary that can be pulled at any time and doesn't secure your kids future at the school at all. This is not the behaviour of some one who would happily vote a party in to have their kids school place taken away.

Who said for free? And you know next to nothing about me and my motivations. The school offers bursaries, my child is nowhere near the only one - do you resent bursaries in general, or are the recipients obliged to vote Tory? I think here we have genuine politics of envy. And luckily we only had to submit the application once, they haven't asked again. And no 'big buys' here! Grin

And don't you think children whose parents can't afford it are not deserving of a top quality education? If all schools offered that, there would be no need for private schools! In some countries that is the case...

I never said I would happily remove my child from the school - I said I would still vote Labour even if in the end that is what it meant.

A vote for Labour doesn't in my view automatically mean my child would lose their place. I doubt this particular school would go bust and I think they would continue to offer bursaries for less well off families.

But even if it did mean that yes I would absolutely 100% vote Labour because I believe in the common good. Do you?[/quote]
Absolute hypocrite

I can not take anything you say seriously Grin

And bursaries are always means tested so you will be asked to show your financial documents again. It seems you have not been in the school that long.

Labour believe in the common good do they? Righto.. 'male raspists should be allowed in to womens prisons' - Lisa Nandy. Do you believe that is the common good? Are you really going to vote for that?

elodie77 · 30/09/2021 11:16

Why on earth would you risk their education by having the rug pulled under them if Labour got in Elodie77!

Because I believe they would make the society better and fairer than it is now.

Its a sound bite to make you feel better but realistically there is no way you would give up their place without a fight. As a PP says - you must have spent ages putting an application together.

WRONG on both counts.

By all means think I'm a terrible person, no problem, I am not trying to be perfect nor do I think I'm a particularly good person, but I DO strongly believe in a fair and equal society that gives opportunities for all, not just those born to privilege.

RestingStitchFace · 30/09/2021 11:14

I'm no fan of Boris and I don't vote Tory. Yes I absolutely do think he should apologise for many things. However, I don't agree with Raynor's approach. I want politicians who model good conduct and I want an opposition who take the moral high ground when the Government's behaviour needs holding to account. Raynor's name-calling just weakens her position, rather than strengthens it.

GianaSister · 30/09/2021 11:13

do you resent bursaries in general, or are the recipients obliged to vote Tory?

The irony.

Franklin12 · 30/09/2021 11:10

Having paid full fees myself for my children. Why on earth would you risk their education by having the rug pulled under them if Labour got in Elodie77!

Its a sound bite to make you feel better but realistically there is no way you would give up their place without a fight. As a PP says - you must have spent ages putting an application together.

You either believe in private education or you dont. You are worse because you say you dont believe in it but are getting it for free!!

elodie77 · 30/09/2021 11:00

Typo above, but I think you get my meaning. The best education shouldn't just be for those who can afford it.

elodie77 · 30/09/2021 10:58

@elodie77 You're a hypocrite. in fact worse than a hypocrite as your happy to take for free what many parents pay a small fortune ( people like me) to send their kids to private, yet claim to happily pull your child out if labour shut them down. Bull shit. You went above and beyond to get that bursary - including handing over all your financial details and bank statements, declaring any big buys and wage rises, reapplying and submitting documents every year, securing a bursary is incredibly intrusive. A bursary that can be pulled at any time and doesn't secure your kids future at the school at all. This is not the behaviour of some one who would happily vote a party in to have their kids school place taken away.

Who said for free? And you know next to nothing about me and my motivations. The school offers bursaries, my child is nowhere near the only one - do you resent bursaries in general, or are the recipients obliged to vote Tory? I think here we have genuine politics of envy. And luckily we only had to submit the application once, they haven't asked again. And no 'big buys' here! Grin

And don't you think children whose parents can't afford it are not deserving of a top quality education? If all schools offered that, there would be no need for private schools! In some countries that is the case...

I never said I would happily remove my child from the school - I said I would still vote Labour even if in the end that is what it meant.

A vote for Labour doesn't in my view automatically mean my child would lose their place. I doubt this particular school would go bust and I think they would continue to offer bursaries for less well off families.

But even if it did mean that yes I would absolutely 100% vote Labour because I believe in the common good. Do you?

Andante57 · 30/09/2021 10:49

I can't quite make out whether you're an idiot or just a wind-up

Can you stop attacking me personally

Elodie maybe take your own advice.

Evesgarden · 30/09/2021 10:33

@elodie77

I will admit I am one of those parents whose child is at a private school on a significant bursary, because I felt it offered them the best education and therefore a better chance in a society that is so competitive and unfair, where housing and jobs are scarce.

I would still vote for Labour even if it meant my child couldn't continue at her private school. I would much rather the society was generally fairer and offered my child better opportunities so I didn't feel the need to send them to a private school to give them the best chance in life.

@elodie77 You're a hypocrite. in fact worse than a hypocrite as your happy to take for free what many parents pay a small fortune ( people like me) to send their kids to private, yet claim to happily pull your child out if labour shut them down. Bull shit. You went above and beyond to get that bursary - including handing over all your financial details and bank statements, declaring any big buys and wage rises, reapplying and submitting documents every year, securing a bursary is incredibly intrusive. A bursary that can be pulled at any time and doesn't secure your kids future at the school at all. This is not the behaviour of some one who would happily vote a party in to have their kids school place taken away.

Do as I say but not as I do hey?

Harrydresdenssidekick · 30/09/2021 09:53

Rufus

Totally agree

RufustheBadgeringReindeer · 30/09/2021 09:39

Labour say (paraphrasing) “if you don’t believe X like we do then we don’t want your vote”. A number of Lab MPs are on record saying this with no consequence

Lib dems said this in 2019…easiest vote decision for me ever

elodie77 · 30/09/2021 09:35

Andante57 Freedom of speech Hmm

bylinetimes.com/2021/08/19/the-government-is-crying-crocodile-tears-over-free-speech-on-campuses/?fbclid=IwAR3OkBNU6pc3MzxHVMHYxgfdiqOBdOXYmavDgIUzcGDYfMzTuTqNyrQFw6c

Are for the rest of your post, I can't quite make out whether you're an idiot or just a wind-up. As you can probably tell, I'm a bit fed up trying to argue with the likes of you.

GianaSister · 30/09/2021 09:33

[quote Einzweitrois]@elodie77 I absolutely agree with you. Really good post.
So much pearl clutching on this thread. People 'offended' by the word parroting Hmm I think you need to get a grip. People do 'parrot' that Labour are unelectable whilst the current government is essentially corrupt. Constant refrain that Labour don't listen but then can't qualify in what way and imply the tories do. Banging on about the 'red wall' voters when few have ever stepped out of their little london bubble. I don't like AR 's politics or her public demeanor but to call her common, gobby, thick as pig shit and then bang on about tories understanding the w/c beggars belief. Plenty of hypocrisy on here.[/quote]
The majority of this country doesn’t live in a little London bubble, yet Labour still took a battering in the last GE. If they’re not, at the moment unelectable, why aren’t they reaching any where near the level of being elected?

Constant refrain that Labour don't listen but then can't qualify in what way and imply the tories do.

Labour say (paraphrasing) “if you don’t believe X like we do then we don’t want your vote”. A number of Lab MPs are on record saying this with no consequence. No listening, no compromise. I’ve never heard a Conservative say the same but I could imagine if they did they’d be pulled into rank pretty sharpish. Along the same lines I’ve seen plenty of times, both on here and elsewhere, including in “real life” conversations “if you voted Tory, remove me from your friend list/we are no longer friends/would never date a Tory” etc yet never see the same from the other side. Disagreement, yes. Scorn, yes. But never a blanket “you’re dead to me”.

Andante57 · 30/09/2021 09:27

attacks on academic freedom

Elodie - insisting on freedom of speech in universities is hardly an attack on academic freedom.

Everything else you mention could apply to a communist government (apart from ‘ trying to remove people's right to vote by the voter ID measures’ as people don’t have the right to vote with or without ID in communist countries).
But I suppose ‘fascist’ has a more emotive ring to it.

RufustheBadgeringReindeer · 29/09/2021 22:50

Where have i said I objected to crude language

Its not my priorities that are the problem

RufustheBadgeringReindeer · 29/09/2021 22:49

@Einzweitrois

Don't understand *@RufustheBadgeringReindeer*. More importantly are you happy with the Tories ? What's worse, spaffing billions of taxpayers money on test and trace to cronies or crude language ? what's worse - bunging 40 million to a property developer (Jenrick) or using crude language ? Get your priorities right maybe ?
What part of the tories are utter utter shite are you struggling with?
Einzweitrois · 29/09/2021 22:42

Yes I agree. I think you could liken elements of momentum with UKIP. Just different ends of the spectrum, equally fervent and misguided, maybe emanating from the same frustrations tbh.

Einzweitrois · 29/09/2021 22:40

Don't understand @RufustheBadgeringReindeer.
More importantly are you happy with the Tories ? What's worse, spaffing billions of taxpayers money on test and trace to cronies or crude language ? what's worse - bunging 40 million to a property developer (Jenrick) or using crude language ? Get your priorities right maybe ?

Tealightsandd · 29/09/2021 22:38

Yes his speech wasn't bad.

I think, although, overt socialism will never appeal to many, the main problem with Corbyn wasn't that. It was the racism and aggressive militantism.

Einzweitrois · 29/09/2021 22:34

@Tealightsandd did you watch Starmers conference speech ? Many commentators were impressed, even right leaning ones. Corbyn has gone now thank god. An old style socialist leader like him will struggle to be elected from now on. People need to move on and let KS make labour electable again, give him a chance but also be more critical of the Tories.

RufustheBadgeringReindeer · 29/09/2021 22:32

And what tealights said both times

RufustheBadgeringReindeer · 29/09/2021 22:31

So much pearl clutching on this thread. People 'offended' by the word parroting hmm I think you need to get a grip

Oh wait

Is this what elodie means by parroting?

Ahhhh i getcha now