Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Angela Raynor

889 replies

Pixxie7 · 26/09/2021 17:54

I think her comments today were spot on, although not really professional she makes a valid point.

OP posts:
Laquila · 28/09/2021 07:21

Interesting points, @BreadInCaptivity

ChardonnaysPetDragon · 28/09/2021 07:03

I think she’s going for Keir Starmer’s job.

She clearly parked her tanks on his front lawn with the Times interview. Calling people scum is how she thinks she’ll get i because she’s passionate and has fire in her.

saleorbouy · 28/09/2021 07:00

You would hope that someone that high up in party politics could be more eloquent with her language especially if she is a future party Leader.
I find her remarks inflammatory and uncouth which she has used for headlines rather than addressing the issue.
If Labour actually got their act together and became an opposition party that would challenge the government that would be much more beneficial to the country and the electorate

TheIrritableGoldfish · 28/09/2021 06:57

I also think she's having a real push at the minute to brand herself as 'one of us' and I'm not sure it's working.

I think she has an outdated view of what being 'one of us' actually is.

ohfook · 28/09/2021 06:28

I think both - I can't get the cognitive dissonance of people who look down on 'these African countries' with corrupt governments who run a country into the group by handing state money over to their cronies, when that is exactly what we have. And I wish people would understand that in some other countries (Sweden for example) there is a real sense and expectation that your government works for you. Their role is to improve quality life for everyone in that country. I don't think even the most die hard Tory could think that sums up the conservative's ethos.

However I think she worded it poorly and made herself look unprofessional. I also think she's having a real push at the minute to brand herself as 'one of us' and I'm not sure it's working.

I do think she should apologise immediately after boris apologises for his letterboxes and picaninnies comments and for the billions of pounds worth of pointless contracts that were handed out over covid whilst vastly decreasing school budgets and for the whole fucked up process of applying for pip and for every company that is allowed to operate in the uk whilst avoiding paying corporation tax.

SensiMuck · 28/09/2021 06:17

@Malteser71

Vicky pollard
Ha! So true.
MarshaBradyo · 28/09/2021 06:10

ThatSunny I agree this ‘pearl clutching’ mn typical insult is to stop women having an opinion on a politician.

A diversion

lannistunut · 28/09/2021 05:26

She's right, the current Tory government are scum.

But she needs to elevate her tone, to avoid distracting people from the fact that the current Tory government are scum.

merrymouse · 28/09/2021 05:13

she’s won her seat in three elections now, so she must be doing something right.

Her seat has been held by Labour since 1935.

As deputy leader of the party she needs to worry about all the other seats.

Yes of course the Tories will make hay out of her comments. That is politics.

Tinpotspectator · 28/09/2021 04:42

She doesn't fit in with the labour right swing.

Tinpotspectator · 28/09/2021 04:41

The fuss is just an excuse to vilify her:

As Zoe Williams has written, quite clearly:

https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2021/sep/27/angela-rayner-called-tory-ministers-scum-and-now-theyre-weaponising-it?CMP=ShareiOSAppp_Other

Ibelieveinghosts · 28/09/2021 04:22

I don’t see any misogyny here. Many people take exception to that kind of behaviour amongst people who are one day hoping to lead the country. That kind of behaviour is not acceptable on the domestic or world stage. It’s the sort of behaviour we saw from Trump, calling people names because you don’t agree. It is nothing to do with her gender. The Labour Party are repeatedly missing the mark at a time we need a viable opposition. Starmer is falling over himself to be woke (who else has a cervix???). Yes we’ve seen some amazing cock ups from the Tories but Labour are going to take some major work to be in a position to overcome the bad taste left by the anti semetic conspiracy theorists (in the words of momentum founder, Jon lansam) that were prolific under Corbyn. In other words they need to be on their best behaviour to turn round the opinion of the majority voters.

As for all these calls for “sisterhood” etc. I will support or criticise an individual for what they do, not because of their gender. An MP doesn’t deserve my support purely because she happens to be in the same diversity box as me be it gender, race, religion, bodily status, sexuality in fed up of this trope of herding groups of individuals under an arbitrary banner and telling them its them against the rest of the world. It’s that mentality which is causing even more division.

LobsterNapkin · 28/09/2021 02:27

I don't really think it's appropriate to call any entire party slurs of that kind. It's not the same to criticize specific policies, at all - to say, these measures are bad for the poor, is not the same as, these guys hate the poor and would like to see them all dead, to exaggerate a little, but not all that much really.

I don't really think a democracy can operate effectively with that kind of rhetoric being normal, and it is unprofessional. There is a good reason you can't say stuff like that in the House, and it pretty much alienates anyone who has voted for the people you have branded as bigots and scum, so it's a big political liability.

Porridgealert · 28/09/2021 01:17

@TooBigForMyBoots

I would wonder about the reason why posters don't see James Gray's Gray's disgusting "joke" as worthy of comment, but I know why: hes a Tory man and they can say whatever they like.Angry
That is not true. What he said was inappropriate and he apologised for it immediately and took down the comment. He recognised that what he had said was wrong. Angela Rayner just doubled down on her comments and said she hadn't gone far enough.

To be honest as a woman in her sixties, who's lived through quite misogynistic times, I have earned the right to call out any politician whom I think is in the wrong. And that includes women as,well as men.

BreadInCaptivity · 28/09/2021 00:59

IMHO there are (broadly speaking) two types of MP's.

You have your typical party loyal "career" MP and then you have your "activists".

Much like Corbyn, Raynor is the latter.

They can be very useful within a party in terms of holding a mirror to itself, forcing uncomfortable debate and being somewhat fearless (or reckless depending on your view) with their own public image because fundamentally they are fuelled by a sense of righteousness re: their cause(s).

Yes, they may well garner some loyal supporters with whom they really resonate but they repel in equal (if not more) measure.

The issues arise when these MP's are elevated above the back benches.

They forget they are no longer just representing themselves, their constituents, their causes, but the party as a whole and now they have the platform where ALL the electorate is listening (not just the niche fringe groups).

If Labour were to win the next GE you would expect that AR as deputy would get a significant role in govt.

Whether you agree with what she said or not, most voters will not want the potential next Foreign Secretary (for example) to think it's ok to call the French (or any other) President scum, regardless of if it's true or not, because that's not appropriate statecraft.

As a member of the Shadow Cabinet you have to think of it as a bloody long job interview.

In other words you have to behave in a way that's appropriate to the position of power you aspire to hold.

AR does not do this. It's nothing to do with her accent, background or sex. Corbyn did not do this either and Starmer isn't doing a great job let's face it.

Having policies and fronting your party with people that are decidedly "marmite" doesn't get you elected, especially when the rhetoric is one of moral superiority whilst using aggressive language and in some cases trying to suppress reasonable debate.

Labour lost so many voters in the last election and I cannot see how anything they are doing right is is going to win them back.

Rather they are just making many "deserters" like myself feel more comfortable about not voting for them again.

Undeuxdrei · 28/09/2021 00:48

So going by the cadence of previous comments she’s a horrible mouthy working class woman. Awful northern accent. Common as muck in her cheapo flashy pound shop clothing. Single mother at 16, no qualifications to speak of, terrible mother, how on earth did she manage to be nominated and then actually win an election. Repeatedly ?
Funny how a government can happily cause thousands of people demonstrable hardship and pain through shit decision making and ineptitude but call them out and crikey you are a threat to the fabric of society Confused I thought her language was crude and unnecessary but let’s be honest who are the real villains here ?
And Lol at the idea of the sisterhood.

Snoozer11 · 28/09/2021 00:47

If I went to work and called my colleagues scum, I would lose my job.

Snoozer11 · 28/09/2021 00:44

@Iggly

I can't be the only one who thinks that's bullshit? Surely you'd be able to tell that something that looks and smells like shaving foam, and which is on the shelf away from all other foodstuffs isn't actually a food itself?

Having grown up in a severely chaotic household with a mum with severe mental health issues, I can absolutely see that this could happen.

My mum used to serve us cheap and nasty pizzas which were still frozen at her low points. I remember, I was about 10, and quietly putting them back in to the oven to cook for me and my brother. I have plenty of other examples.

It was shit. And shocking on reflection. So yes I believe her. Why the fuck would she lie?

Some people are so narrow minded that they can only understand life being lived as how they experience it.

A pizza that's still frozen is still food!

Shaving foam isn't!

OhWhyNot · 28/09/2021 00:35

What is misogynistic about calling AR unprofessional ?

I expect the party I have for years been a member of (I did have a break) and want in power to be a party led by intelligent MP’s who are able to take on the opposition without resorting to name calling and have moved on from student politics.

Was it professional of her to call an MP scum when he was making a speech?

Thankfully she shall be gone soon back to the benches with her lefty friends planning the revolution.

TooBigForMyBoots · 27/09/2021 23:53

@MiladyBerserko

She has thrown women under the bus. I dont care how working class she is, she is no friend to women. And women are allowed to say so.
Women, including AR (who is a real woman and not a "caricature" of one as mentioned upthread)should be able to say what they like without being subjected to the kind of misogynistic bollocks that has been written on this thread. All women, not just the ones we agree with or who fall under the category of People Like Us.Hmm
sst1234 · 27/09/2021 23:36

@MiladyBerserko

She has thrown women under the bus. I dont care how working class she is, she is no friend to women. And women are allowed to say so.
So true. A misogynist foul mouthed hypocrite.
MiladyBerserko · 27/09/2021 23:31

She has thrown women under the bus. I dont care how working class she is, she is no friend to women. And women are allowed to say so.

Malteser71 · 27/09/2021 23:31

Vicky pollard

TooBigForMyBoots · 27/09/2021 23:30

It isn't Whataboutery. Its discussing a very similar thing that happened at the same time and comparing the two @ThatSunnyCorner.

TooBigForMyBoots · 27/09/2021 23:25

Yes @PersonaNonGarter I have read the thread. Off the top of my head I have read that AR is:
Unprofessional
Uncouth
Common as muck
Unhinged
If she hadn't said anything or said it nicer...
Whining
Mouthy
Should be representing all women/working class people.
Is responsible for the current Conservative government.
Is responsible for the demise of the Labour Party and the reason they will never hold power again.
Is sleeping with another woman's husband.

I'm sure I've missed out quite a lot but this thread is Misogyny Bingo.Hmm

Swipe left for the next trending thread