Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Angela Raynor

889 replies

Pixxie7 · 26/09/2021 17:54

I think her comments today were spot on, although not really professional she makes a valid point.

OP posts:
Marguerite2000 · 28/09/2021 14:08

@Undeuxdrei

To listen to some of the posters on here it seems like we are living in an alternative reality, a tory utopia, where public services are well funded and functioning, where food banks don’t exist, where the homeless aren’t on every street corner and set of traffic lights, where people aren’t forced to accept zero hours contacts and the minimum wage clearly isn’t a living one, where all kinds of legislation isn’t being eroded to cut costs and there aren’t shortages of food, key workers and petrol. And actually to think that an mp who let her mouth run away with her is a far greater danger to society than the lying corrupt politicians in the government. Wow what a country !
Of course we're not living in a utopia, but neither are the vast majority of people living in the kind of hell hole that seems to be depicted on mumsnet. I think it's a mistake to over state that position. As regards Ms Rayner's language yes, people do expect a certain degree of professionalism from MPs, same as they would from a teacher, doctor or lawyer. If she doesn't want to adhere to the usual standards of behaviour perhaps she shouldn't be a public official.
Barbadossunset · 28/09/2021 14:07

Drakeford making it illegal for Tesco to sell paper and books during the lockdown

Fromdownwest why on earth did he make that illegal?

fromdownwest · 28/09/2021 14:07

@Eviebeans

It still feels like we don't have a viable alternative party to vote for. Looks like Labour are once again wasting their chances.
This!

I am not a Tory, nor a left wing leaning Labour.

I feel like I sit in the middle, and have no one to pin my vote onto.

Barbadossunset · 28/09/2021 14:06

I think a more centre left party without infighting would do very well

It still feels like we don't have a viable alternative party to vote for

The curliest and Eviebeans - I thought Gina Miller was starting a new party called True & Fair?
Maybe that’s the party that so many former Labour voters are looking for?

fromdownwest · 28/09/2021 14:06

@Undeuxdrei

To listen to some of the posters on here it seems like we are living in an alternative reality, a tory utopia, where public services are well funded and functioning, where food banks don’t exist, where the homeless aren’t on every street corner and set of traffic lights, where people aren’t forced to accept zero hours contacts and the minimum wage clearly isn’t a living one, where all kinds of legislation isn’t being eroded to cut costs and there aren’t shortages of food, key workers and petrol. And actually to think that an mp who let her mouth run away with her is a far greater danger to society than the lying corrupt politicians in the government. Wow what a country !
Try living in a Welsh Labour Lead Welsh country.

The NHS is massivley under funded, worst in the UK, 12k less beds under their administration.

OECD figures but welsh children at the bottom of literayc and numeracy figures

Money being spent on inane projects such as buying a failing airport, failing rail service.

An obession with destroying inner cities with the building of poorly designed and often dangerous cycle paths, hitting small busuinesses.

Talk of a tourist Tax on Welsh Rentals, with not thought to the greater impact oon the tourist sector.

£114m of public money spent on report after report on the much needed M4 relief road, to then be axed

Drakeford making it illegal for Tesco to sell paper and books during the lockdown.

Please don't think Labour = Good Tories = Bad Automatically

They are all equally as awful and self serving.

Tinpotspectator · 28/09/2021 14:00

God, aren't politicians so often dirty players and backstabbers.

Eviebeans · 28/09/2021 14:00

It still feels like we don't have a viable alternative party to vote for.
Looks like Labour are once again wasting their chances.

TooBigForMyBoots · 28/09/2021 14:00

@merrymouse

The right wing press are playing the feminists here like a fiddle

No, feminists here already think Rayner doesn’t represent their concerns because she doesn’t think women need specific rights and services because of their sex. The ‘scum’ remark is just politically stupid.

Your suggestion that women on MN are incapable of independent thought seems in line with current Labour Party thinking, and that too is likely to lose them votes.

Feminists on this thread seem to have checked their feminism in at the start of it between using misogynistic, not seeing them when they are blatantly obvious and of course ignoring the state the country is in, ignoring similar/worse comments about sending a bomb to a female MP or blaming AR for everything because it's all women's fault.🙄
sst1234 · 28/09/2021 13:59

[quote Clavinova]That was Emily Thornberry

Gets better;

Labour frontbencher Emily Thornberry suggests deputy leader Angela Rayner had been DRINKING when she made 'Tory scum' jibe...

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10032215/Jeremy-Corbyn-wades-Angela-Rayner-Tory-scum-row.html[/quote]
Honestly you could not make this shit up. This is what this woman wants you to believe working class people are like. Loud mouth vile drunks. Way to go if you want to endear northern voters.

Tinpotspectator · 28/09/2021 13:50

Also, unprofessional? What an interesting word that is! Ill defined and ambiguous, expect to the speaker.

If you want to talk "unprofessional ", look at Johnson, and look at Hancock previously, with their record on consultants and love affairs.

And for those who think that British university education is never mediocre, you are ignorant of the sector. Although it's far more mediocre these days than it was.

elodie77 · 28/09/2021 13:50

I do agree that they are scum though, but maybe just say it in your head next time Angela....

I think you're probably right, but come on, people, why the focus on this when you have empty shelves in shops and no fuel?

Do Conservative policies improve the quality of life of anyone but the wealthy and privileged? Is it any wonder that people are angry?

Marguerite2000 · 28/09/2021 13:48

@Blossomtoes

the way she mocked the man with the England flags and the white van

That was Emily Thornberry.

Ok, my mistake. My point about her stance on trans rights not conflicting with women's rights still stands though.
Thecurliestwurly · 28/09/2021 13:40

Is it just me, or does it seem like the far left of the Labour party are deliberately trying to sabotage the Labour party in its current format, before splitting off and forming their own party? It does seem that way to me.

I agree with some of the more far left leaning of the party's ideas, but I do think they are being absolute tits right now. They are causing lasting damage to the only opposition we have to our current shitty leaders. It's like they are deliberately sabotaging. As someone who grew up in poverty myself, I want wise, respectful working class people representing me, not someone who appears brittle, self righteous and confrontational. I get she may be passionate about her cause, but you cross a line sometimes where you can look a bit narcissistic and unyielding to new ideas, even if you are not like that at all.

I just hope that they go off in their separate directions so out of the two of them a decent, credible opposition is formed that actually matches the ideals and values of the many people in this country, not just the people who happen to have a polarised opinion on something and spend their days on SM. I think there is more chance of ousting the Tories this way as we were seriously lacking a middle ground option last time. I think a more centre left party without infighting would do very well. Mind you, none of these politician actually bother to ask what normal moderate people want any more, so I'm not getting my hopes up.

I do agree that they are scum though, but maybe just say it in your head next time Angela....

Undeuxdrei · 28/09/2021 13:34

To listen to some of the posters on here it seems like we are living in an alternative reality, a tory utopia, where public services are well funded and functioning, where food banks don’t exist, where the homeless aren’t on every street corner and set of traffic lights, where people aren’t forced to accept zero hours contacts and the minimum wage clearly isn’t a living one, where all kinds of legislation isn’t being eroded to cut costs and there aren’t shortages of food, key workers and petrol. And actually to think that an mp who let her mouth run away with her is a far greater danger to society than the lying corrupt politicians in the government. Wow what a
country !

elodie77 · 28/09/2021 13:33

Shes also saying how lucky she was she didnt have to worry about tuition fees
That will be because they were brought in under Labour....

True, and I felt betrayed by New Labour for this and other reasons! I hope the current Labour Party doesn't swing back to the right!

Clavinova · 28/09/2021 13:32

November 1997
Blair backs Harman over cut in lone-parent benefit.

www.independent.co.uk/news/blair-backs-harman-over-cut-lone-parent-benefit-1295256.html

March 2005
Blair: Single mothers 'piling up problems' in Britain's inner cities.

www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/blair-single-mothers-piling-up-problems-in-britain-s-inner-cities-529604.html

March 2007
Tony Blair and Gordon Brown will jointly unveil proposals for lone parents with children aged over 11 to seek jobs or else face potential benefit sanctions.

www.theguardian.com/society/2007/mar/04/socialexclusion.politics

whenwillthemadnessend · 28/09/2021 13:30

Like or loath Boris she is unprofessional and an embarrassment with her comments.

She thinks she is right on with the people of this country and what we want and think, but she needs to act like a grown up not a spice girl from the 90's. Even they are grown up now

She needs to be able to discuss at the top level with reason and clarity.

She comes across as loud mouthed and deranged huge leftie and I will never vote Labour will she is near the top. (Swing voter).

wink1970 · 28/09/2021 13:29

She is a liability and if Kier Starmer doesn't get rid of her then the LP can wave goodbye to the next election and stay in opposition forever.

Yep, she's the gift that keeps on giving for the Conservatives.

I'm middle ground and as I get older I lean further to the left than the years before but she has pushed me right back, not just with this particular tirade.

x2boys · 28/09/2021 13:25

@JaniieJones

'That’s what I just said. You’re losing the plot.'

www.express.co.uk/showbiz/tv-radio/1207317/General-Election-news-Labour-Party-Angela-Rayner-MP-Twitter-Shadow-Cabinet-manifesto-UK

She had a great education! a council house waiting for her. Lovely. All thanks to the tory government.

Shes also saying how lucky she was she didnt have to worry about tuition fees That will be because they were brought in under Labour....
elodie77 · 28/09/2021 13:15

@JaniieJones

'That’s what I just said. You’re losing the plot.'

www.express.co.uk/showbiz/tv-radio/1207317/General-Election-news-Labour-Party-Angela-Rayner-MP-Twitter-Shadow-Cabinet-manifesto-UK

She had a great education! a council house waiting for her. Lovely. All thanks to the tory government.

All thanks to the tory government Really?

"In 1919, Parliament passed the ambitious Housing Act which promised government subsidies to help finance the construction of 500,000 houses within three years. The 1919 Act - often known as the ‘Addison Act' after its author, Dr Christopher Addison, the Minister of Health (a member of the Liberal and Labour parties). It made housing a national responsibility, and local authorities were given the task of developing new housing and rented accommodation where it was needed by working people...

The Addison Act provided subsidies solely to local authorities and not to private builders. Many houses were built over the next few years in 'cottage estates'. The Housing, &c. Act 1923 (Neville Chamberlain Housing Act - Conservative) stopped subsidies going to council houses but extended the subsidies to private builders...

In the immediate post-war years, and well into the 1950s, council house provision was shaped by the New Towns Act 1946 and the Town and Country Planning Act 1947 of the 1945–51 Labour government. Simultaneously, this government introduced housing legislation that removed explicit references to housing for the working class and introduced the concept of "general needs" construction (i.e., that council housing should aim to fill the needs of a wide range of society). In particular, Aneurin Bevan, the Minister for Health and Housing, promoted a vision of new estates where "the working man, the doctor and the clergyman will live in close proximity to each other"...

For many working-class people, this housing model provided their first experience of private indoor toilets, private bathrooms and hot running water, as well as gardens and electric lighting. For tenants in England and Wales it also usually provided the first experience of private garden space (usually front and rear). The quality of these houses, and in particular the existence of small gardens in England and Wales, compared very favourably with social housing being built on the European continent in this period...

The 1951 Conservative government began to re-direct the building programme back from "general needs" towards "welfare accommodation for low income earners" The principal focus was on inner-city slum clearance, completing the job that was started in the 1930s. Harold Macmillan's task, as Minister for Housing, was to deliver 300,000 houses a year. These were 700 square feet (65 m2), 20% smaller than a Tudor Walters Bevan house, usually built as a two-bedroom terrace called "The Peoples House". From 1956, with the Housing Subsidy Act 1956 the government subsidy was restricted to only new houses built to replace those removed by slum clearance, and more money was given to tower blocks higher than six stories. With this subsidy, neighbourhoods throughout the country were demolished and rebuilt as mixed estates with low and high-rise building. At the same time the rising influence of modernist architecture, the development of new cheaper construction techniques, such as system building (a form of prefabrication), and a growing desire by many towns and cities to retain population (and thus rental income and local rates) within their own boundaries (rather than "export" people to New Towns and "out of boundary" peripheral estates) led to this model being adopted; abandoned inner-city areas were demolished, and estates of high-rise apartments blocks proliferated on vacant sites. Whole working class communities were scattered, and the tenants either relocated themselves to neighbouring overcrowded properties or became isolated away from friends in flats and houses, on estates without infrastructure or a bus-route...

The last major push in council home provision was made under the Wilson (Labour) government of 1964...

Laws restricted councils' investment in housing, preventing them subsidising it from local taxes, but more importantly, council tenants were given the Right to Buy in the Housing Act 1980 offering a discount price on their council house. Proposed as policy by Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher and carried out under the remit of Secretary of State for the Environment Michael Heseltine, the Right To Buy scheme allowed tenants to buy their home with a discount of 33–50% off the market value, depending on the time they had lived there. Councils were prevented from reinvesting the proceeds of these sales in new housing, and the total available stock, particularly of more desirable homes, declined..."

Social Housing and the NHS, both built by Labour!

Clavinova · 28/09/2021 13:12

Blossomtoes
She couldn’t do any worse than Johnson who, as Foreign Secretary, managed to get Nazanin Zaghari-Ratcliffe‘s sentence extended

Did he?

Nazanin Zaghari-Ratcliffe was arrested in April 2016, sentenced to 5 years imprisonment in September 2016, lost her final appeal in April 2017 - Boris Johnson's erroneous comment was made in November 2017 - she was already serving 5 years:

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-39697016
www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-41972704

deadleaves · 28/09/2021 13:05

My point was she was praising the support she received from benefits etc in 1996 when the conversatives were in, once again making a tit of herself

I think her point, to be fair, was that the conservative government have absolutely devastated council housing under right to buy meaning single mums (or indeed anyone) can no longer rely on council housing and certainly not in an area free from multiple problems of social and economic disadvantage.

deadleaves · 28/09/2021 13:00

@derxa

twitter.com/BBCPolitics/status/1442472425183010824 Here's Emily Thornberry telling everyone that it's not just women who have cervixes. Why do Labour do this? They need a Neil Kinnock-type leader(male or female) telling them to get a grip.
I wish that clip did not finish there - I would like to know how Emily responded.

Note Emily said 'There are men who have cervixes' (wrong Emily!) but the interviewer effectively corrected this to ' there are females who live as men who have cervixes. ' It shouldn't be hard for the Labour party to understand and develop policy based on this fact-based distinction.

SueSaid · 28/09/2021 13:00

'So you think a mediocre education, finishing at 16, and social housing after being thrown out by your stepfather when you’re pregnant are great opportunities? You need to raise your standards.'

No it certainly isn't the path I'd have chosen, I do have higher standards correct. However fortunately for Angela she had a good education and social housing was available to accommodate her. My point was she was praising the support she received from benefits etc in 1996 when the conversatives were in, once again making a tit of herself.

We can't be held responsible for her life choices can we.

Tealightsandd · 28/09/2021 12:57

^reaction.life/rayner-mixes-up-sadiq-and-sajid-twice/^

Well no surprise there. It's not as if Labour has a good record on racism.