Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Residential trips.

34 replies

kakeya97 · 26/09/2021 17:02

Are they compulsory? Surely not? Ds is in year 6 and they have a 4 night residential trip. Ds has asd and he does not want to stay. He's pretty adamant on this. School suggested staying one night but still not keen. When he doesn't want to do something, you know about it. He says he can't manage the sounds of the kids - which is true - needs complete silence to wind down ready for bed. School then said he could have his own room but then when he asked about a lamp as doesn't like the total dark, they said it'll be dark. Also, routine is really important to him and he won't get any of his usual routine there. It's also things like self care that he struggles with.

I have tried to encourage him but when DS wants to do something he really does but equally if he doesn't want to. He's very stubborn.

Although I have said he doesn't want to go and I'm not forcing him to do it, they are pretty damn adamant he should try it. Going against what I've said and trying to encourage Ds to go although we've already agreed no.

I'm not against him going but I can't manage if Ds changing his mind last minute because we couldn't afford to pay for it! If he wanted to go we would have spread the costs but it's pretty soon.

School have suggested me bringing him to and from each day which sounds like a great idea if it was closer to home but it's not feasible with work commitments, younger children to get to school and it being so far away (1.5 hours away so 3 hours there and back which would be twice a day so 6 hours travelling a day!). It would be exhausting for everyone including me, dp, DS and younger kids who will be adding on considerable time to their day travelling. Younger Dd is also ok the spectrum.

What am I meant to do? Teacher has been incredibly sarky with me regarding this saying he will miss out. I don't think it's affected the kids who haven't been able to go on residential due to covid has it?!

I never went on residential trips. I wasn't suddenly less independent from not going.

I don't think the school realise how much of a thing it would be for DS. He very rarely has a meltdown at school now so what if something triggered him there? He's extremely selective with food. What if he doesn't eat? There's water activities and he's not a strong swimmer which worries me too.

To add, I think he would hate the activities! He's not an outdoorsy kid at all! Not the best at physical activities and he often doesn't try new things over the fear of not being able to (working on that). I just think he would spend half the day watching the other kids if he's not encouraged.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
lljkk · 26/09/2021 18:33

I have huge regrets about talking DS into going on a residential trip (end of yr5). He hated it. Don't do it.

MadMadMadamMim · 26/09/2021 18:22

Cannot imagine why the teacher would be 'sarky' over this, to be honest.

I couldn't think of a bigger nightmare than taking an asd primary aged child on a residential course that they don't want to be on, and that parents have made it clear they won't cope with.

It's a nightmare taking other people's kids over night - never mind for several nights in a strange place when lots of them are homesick.

It surprises me enormously that his teacher should be pushing for this.

gingerbiscuits · 26/09/2021 18:19

I'm a Year 6 Teaching Partner & they're absolutely not compulsory! We have a couple of kids every single year who don't go for a wide variety of reasons.

On the one hand, it's great that the school is trying to be inclusive & come up with suggestions, but on the other, you know your child best & it's 100% your/his choice. If you can find a workable option, then great. If not, don't put him, you & everyone else on the trip through something upsetting & unnecessary. It's just not worth it. He'll in no way be at a disadvantage from not going. Seriously.

Are they open to sharing the proposed activity timetable with you? If there's a day where you think he might participate & enjoy himself, then maybe you could take him up & back just for the day? So that he feels that he's been a part of it? You could either stay with him or base yourself nearby, in case he needs to come away early? I appreciate that's a lot of inconvenience for you though. And I guess a 'day cost' might not be possible - it does tend to be an 'all in' fee with these places.

If it won't work for you/him, then don't do it. Don't let them pressurise you either, as that's out of order.

liveforsummer · 26/09/2021 18:18

Yes many of the kids that don't go miss out, many of the kids that didn't go because of covid missed out however I've never known them to be compulsory and it doesn't sound like your ds as an individual would enjoy or benefit from it. How far is it, can he attend for the day and come home?

Kite22 · 26/09/2021 18:11

It might be that, due to her own family circumstances, she is able to go and another member of staff can't, so he will get 1:1 from a different member of staff that week. Still 1:1 though.

kakeya97 · 26/09/2021 18:11

@kakeya97

Thanks everyone. On another note, my son has an EHCP with 1:1 help... if he doesn't go and stays back at school with an EHCP in place would you expect his 1:1 to stay back in school with him to support him? School said she's going on trip due to staffing numbers at residential but it seems naughty to me?!

Not being nit picky. He'll likely cope in another class with familiar adult so not a huge issue.. but may cause a few issues if he finds the work set if he stays behind too complicated.

To add, he will not have another ta with him in another class I don't think. So there won't be anyone else jusy familiar teacher.
OP posts:
kakeya97 · 26/09/2021 18:08

Thanks everyone. On another note, my son has an EHCP with 1:1 help... if he doesn't go and stays back at school with an EHCP in place would you expect his 1:1 to stay back in school with him to support him? School said she's going on trip due to staffing numbers at residential but it seems naughty to me?!

Not being nit picky. He'll likely cope in another class with familiar adult so not a huge issue.. but may cause a few issues if he finds the work set if he stays behind too complicated.

OP posts:
user7012893145776 · 26/09/2021 18:04

In a similar situation myself op.

My sons not going. School are adamant he will enjoy it but he won't, he's told me already he won't.

santabetterwashhishands · 26/09/2021 18:00

I said my asd son wasn't going and met with a lot of attitude from staff but he wouldn't enjoy and I wasn't prepared for taking him back and forth each day! That's a special school too.
His sister is being assessed and she's in mainstream but wouldn't cope with a residential either so I'm sure I'm going to get the same hassle again 🤷‍♀️ but tough I know my children's limitations and will voice my opinions whenever needed x

PrimaryMumma · 26/09/2021 17:55

I never went on residentials (except 6th form work experience in France) and never felt like I’d missed out. I wasn’t massively outgoing, hated sports and camping and loved being home with my family. I went on almost every theatre and museum trip the school offered, but never the exchanges or residentials.

I’m now a proper grown up, went to a good uni and studied languages, lived abroad, worked abroad and travelled a fair bit. It has made no difference to my life that I didn’t go on the Y6 French trip, the Y9 German exchange or the Y11 river trip residential (etc). I did all these things when I was ready and not when school told me to. I think they thought I was weird for not going, but my mum was adamant and always told them where to go.

Amusingly… I did my first camping trip this summer and hated it. I like museums, not tents and bracing walks! Plus ca change! :-)

CiaoForNiao · 26/09/2021 17:53

If he doesn't want to go then he doesn't want to go.

DS1 has never been on a residential. He knows he'd hate it. His primary school tried to make me send him on the yr 6 one. Told me I could pick him up on day 2 I he wasn't happy. Conveniently forgot I don't drive so couldn't get there without asking other people.

DS2 otoh has been on residentials with Primary and secondary school. Plus boys brigade and kids camp with the local church.

Not all children enjoy being away from home.

kakeya97 · 26/09/2021 17:53

@Tooembarrassingtomention

What diagnosis of SEND does he have? Sounds like the school are trying to be inclusive.
He is diagnosed asd. He has an EHCP with mainly leaning needs outlined in his plan. I appreciated they are being inclusive but they are very dismissive of some of his needs. On the year 3 residential (didn't stay) they were very dismissive of concerns I had and of course what I mentioned did happen (a sound triggered him that he wouldn't have ever heard in school before).

Being inclusive one thing, not he just doesn't want to go....

OP posts:
Tooembarrassingtomention · 26/09/2021 17:46

What diagnosis of SEND does he have?
Sounds like the school are trying to be inclusive.

Lookwhoseinsideagain · 26/09/2021 17:45

Could you look at the schedule, pick the 'best' day, and go up with him for the day? You could stay as a volunteer/chaperone, and both leave at the end of the day (or earlier if he's struggling).

That way he gets to try one or two new activities but without the stress/fear/anxiety of thinking about staying over night.

I'm not whether you could make that work with the rest of the family, but it could be a potential compromise?

kakeya97 · 26/09/2021 17:45

I am all for promoting independence but I didn't turn out too bad considering I never went on many trips either 😅 Mine was more my mum not letting me though and a mixture of being ridiculously home sick. I don't think it affected me too badly. I used to get homesick terribly, wouldn't even stay at my friends house over the road from our house but I moved out alone at 18 and never looked back!

OP posts:
kakeya97 · 26/09/2021 17:43

@Whiskyinajar

Definitely not compulsory. My son has Asd and in Y6 he DID attend tj residential but only because my sister was a TA in his class and was going too. I doubt I would have got him on the bus otherwise.

School also offered to fund a B&B for me to stay nearby in case DS needed me but as I could get to the place inside three hours if necessary I declined. He had a great time ....the Duke of Edinburgh residential in Y 9 however ......he screamed the field down . We got him back in the car and took him home.

Glad it worked out okay in year 6! School have suggested that I could stay for the day with him but it's not that easy at the drop of a hat. It's miles away!

I must admit that I felt the same at duke of Edinburgh in year 9 😅 I only did the practise bronze and swore never to do it again. I remember being home sick, covered in blisters, sunburnt, tired and hungry. Didn't enjoy the experience at all. Cried myself to sleep!

OP posts:
Whiskyinajar · 26/09/2021 17:39

Definitely not compulsory. My son has Asd and in Y6 he DID attend tj residential but only because my sister was a TA in his class and was going too. I doubt I would have got him on the bus otherwise.

School also offered to fund a B&B for me to stay nearby in case DS needed me but as I could get to the place inside three hours if necessary I declined. He had a great time ....the Duke of Edinburgh residential in Y 9 however ......he screamed the field down . We got him back in the car and took him home.

kakeya97 · 26/09/2021 17:36

@UndertheCedartree

No, not compulsory. At my DD's school they have a 5 day residential in Y6. For the children who don't go they take them on local trips and do fun activities with them.
This was the thing when I was in year 6. Those who didn't go had other fun activity days. Doesn't seem to happen there though... 😏
OP posts:
PastMyBestBeforeDate · 26/09/2021 17:32

Dd has ASD and her primary was brilliant about her y6 residential. We were able to sit down with them and work out what the barriers would be and how we could work around it. She did go and had fun. The adaptations worked and we had her home for one night in the middle and she went back the next morning with a teacher who was going.
Unless the school are willing to make adaptations and listen to you then it's not going to do him any good to go.

BelfastSmile · 26/09/2021 17:31

I was in your DS' position at primary school. Didn't want to go on a trip, but everyone said "Go, go, you'll love it when you get there".

I absolutely hated it and got sent home on day 2, having not eaten anything since I got there, and having hyperventilated several times. It put me off trips for a long time (the year after, I point blank refused to go, and since I was the only one left behind, I got to spend the week in the school library doing a project - bliss!).

I wouldn't force it if he's not ready. There'll be more trips.

romdowa · 26/09/2021 17:26

Email the school and make it clear he has no interest and that they need to stop pushing.

poppy1973 · 26/09/2021 17:24

They are not compulsory. However, the school probably don't want him to miss out out on the experience.

However, if you aren't happy sending him and he won't be happy, then don't. The school will pop him into a different year group while the Y6 are away. He probably won't be the only one not going.

Clymene · 26/09/2021 17:23

No, the teacher is being ridiculous. He doesn't want to go.

UndertheCedartree · 26/09/2021 17:23

No, not compulsory. At my DD's school they have a 5 day residential in Y6. For the children who don't go they take them on local trips and do fun activities with them.

BlueSussex · 26/09/2021 17:22

Definitely not compulsory.

I would just reassure him he does not have to go. Have a word with the teacher and tell her to pack it in.

Swipe left for the next trending thread