Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To support Kier Starmer’s school policy even though I would usually vote Blue…

168 replies

Blankspace4 · 26/09/2021 10:58

www.mirror.co.uk/news/politics/keir-starmer-vows-tax-private-25072816

(Original article I read was on the BBC but they seem to have merged it in to another about general tax policy now)

I haven’t voted Labour at any point during my working life and in general am in favour of a meritocracy, free market, and low regulation

However this policy has touched a nerve, in a good way. I think it’s astounding private schools remain ‘charities’ and don’t pay tax. If parents can afford to send their children to private school, I’ve no real issue with it, but let them pay an additional 20% to properly contribute in line with their privilege.

Of course there is the counter argument that private school families already pay tax and therefore are funding schooling their own kids aren’t using.

But still, on balance I’m supportive.

What does everyone think?

OP posts:
Blankspace4 · 26/09/2021 12:45

To be clear, I don’t agree the policy should apply to SEN schools where there is a clear

I’m talking about blatant elitism

I may sound as if I have a chip on my shoulder (I don’t) - I now work in a relatively high paid career with lots of peers who were privately educated and the networks and confidence they have really give them a huge leg up that state educated kids often don’t benefit from.

I repeat I’m not totally against, but the Tory agenda to ‘level up’ is never going to touch public schools as so many of them benefitted from it and they remain ‘old boys’ (Hmm)

Additionally - many private schools have huge endowment funds / investments on their balance sheet in addition to their annual fee income. What do they contribute to wider society? I’m just left thinking they could do more and shouldn’t be shielded by charitable status

OP posts:
MarshaBradyo · 26/09/2021 12:38

@arethereanyleftatall

Like them or not, private schools already save the government a fortune. They'd have to pay out of the government pot if any of these children go to state. You'd have to make sure more would stay and pay the VAT than you'd lose from some switching to state because of it. From a financial perspective
As per the other thread financially it is suspect

It will not bring much material benefit to state

Fund state but don’t make it punitive against independent

Imo it’s counter productive and using children as a political pawn not in a good way.

CiderWithLizzie · 26/09/2021 12:35

It wouldn’t necessarily lead to a 20% increase in fees as VAT on costs could be recovered. Although the 80% business rates relief would also be lost. I can see it encouraging the more well off public schools investing heavily in new facilities in order to recover the input VAT. It would almost certainly mean more independent schools leaving the Teachers’ Pensions scheme too.

Babymamaroon · 26/09/2021 12:27

As parents privately educating children, you are already paying tax for a service which you don't use.

You're likely to already be contributing via the highest tax brackets.

Just how much pressure does society want to keep piling on those who earn well but aren't multi-millionaires and likely make many sacrifices in order to privately educate?

How would the state sector cope with the extra pupils that would inevitably end up there as their parents would be priced out.

I'd far rather see a return of grammar schools. That would be a policy I would vote for.

Artichokeleaves · 26/09/2021 12:25

It seems merely an attempt at waving the politics of envy in the hope of a voter carrot, and a bit of a smear of 'well anyone using independent education is swimming in gravy and deserves a kicking for it'.

Make private schools less affordable and many kids will just flood back into LA schools which just spreads the already thin resources thinner for all. A lot of those kids went out of LA schools in the first place because of additional needs the LA won't and can't afford to meet. Plenty of parents are either struggling often with wider family members to fund a place for their kid, are trying to get a place in any school at all or have given up and taken them out of school altogether, as the SEND situation is so bad. Not because the schools aren't trying, just because there aren't enough resources.

As with most things with Labour, this hasn't been thought through and is just intended to be an advertising soundbite.

catzfur · 26/09/2021 12:24

My DS goes to a private specialist school, it’s funded by my LA as are most children who attend. This would push up the prices for LA making their SEN budgets even tighter, there would be less funds to then support SEN children and make places at schools for SEN children even harder for families to access.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 26/09/2021 12:18

I can’t help wondering where all the extra state school places will come from, for the children of parents who can no longer afford the fees. Not exactly a minor detail.

Though having said that, fees for all independent schools are relatively a lot more expensive than they were even a few decades ago, and much more a prerogative of the very well off or frankly loaded. Fewer and fewer of the sort of middling, MC people who would have paid fees (say) in the 80s, can now afford to do so. The vastly increased cost of housing now is of course another factor.

AmericanTie · 26/09/2021 12:14

If they don't give children an advantage there's no point having them so no loss if they go.

Taciturn · 26/09/2021 12:14

YABU - not all parents who choose to privately educated are rich and they stretch themselves to afford school fees. They also still pay full taxes despite not drawing from the education "pot" unlike in Australia where you can offset private school fees against taxes. A 20% increase in fees might see a pouring of privately educated children into the state school system thus stretching resources and increasing classrooms sizes. Do you really think the extra tax from the remaining privately educated will compensate, or is it perhaps another Labour policy which will most negatively impact the group of people they claim to protect?

ketchupman · 26/09/2021 12:12

@Blankspace4 those things though often cost ££ on top of school fees and I really question (having put children through prep school) how much of an advantage things like extra piano lessons would really give the kids that much of a step up. I know the extra sports provision for example is still nowhere near as good as going to local specialist clubs (hockey, swimming) and these things are accessible for state school children. It's just easy to assume paying for private schools automatically gives your children an advantage but that's simply not true, they still have to work hard.

AmericanTie · 26/09/2021 12:11

Just how much money does educating 6% of the population using state trained teachers actually save? As much as 20% of their income?

arethereanyleftatall · 26/09/2021 12:07

Like them or not, private schools already save the government a fortune. They'd have to pay out of the government pot if any of these children go to state. You'd have to make sure more would stay and pay the VAT than you'd lose from some switching to state because of it. From a financial perspective

Blankspace4 · 26/09/2021 12:07

But ‘maintaining the school’ is inclusive of offering vast extra curricular sports, music, drama etc all of which state school children are largely squeezed out of in comparison. And likely the ‘facilities’ are a swimming pool and tennis courts and full auditorium.

Again, I’m not totally anti private education (although never benefitted from it myself or have anyone from my direct family that has) but those kids get SUCH a step up, i do feel the schools should do their bit, just like the rest of the economy has to.

OP posts:
ketchupman · 26/09/2021 12:04

I think this would just make private schools even more elitist, as those serving middle class working families would be unlikely to survive the impact of such a tax. If you look at the accounts of charitable private schools, the little money they do make goes back into maintaining the school, no one is "profiting".

Blankspace4 · 26/09/2021 11:59

@Buttons294749 totally agree with you there

OP posts:
Buttons294749 · 26/09/2021 11:55

As I said in the other thread I hooe this would exclude special private schools (the children are paid for via their EHCP) otherwise we are removing disabled children's access to education

Awalkintime · 26/09/2021 11:52

If it went to the kids and funding education I would too. However as we know with Labour it will not go to schools but to create more and more jobs to 'manage' schools. It will have very little impact on schools directly.

bingoitsadingo · 26/09/2021 11:50

I don’t really know tbh, I can see good arguments on both sides.

I do hope the maths stacks up though. It wouldn’t surprise me if a 20% increase in fees pushed a lot of extra kids into the state sector. It might end up costing the government more than they make back from it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread