Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To support Kier Starmer’s school policy even though I would usually vote Blue…

168 replies

Blankspace4 · 26/09/2021 10:58

www.mirror.co.uk/news/politics/keir-starmer-vows-tax-private-25072816

(Original article I read was on the BBC but they seem to have merged it in to another about general tax policy now)

I haven’t voted Labour at any point during my working life and in general am in favour of a meritocracy, free market, and low regulation

However this policy has touched a nerve, in a good way. I think it’s astounding private schools remain ‘charities’ and don’t pay tax. If parents can afford to send their children to private school, I’ve no real issue with it, but let them pay an additional 20% to properly contribute in line with their privilege.

Of course there is the counter argument that private school families already pay tax and therefore are funding schooling their own kids aren’t using.

But still, on balance I’m supportive.

What does everyone think?

OP posts:
AndSoFinally · 26/09/2021 17:58

Daft idea.

The elite for whom 20% fee hikes make no difference will continue to use them, meaning the gap between state and private will widen even further.

It will push the middle class back into an already stretched state system, but won't even level the playing field for the less well off as the MC will just use their money to buy in tutors and extra curricular activities and improve their children's education that way.

At least at the moment, when it comes to university applications, you can see which children have benefitted from private education and adjust accordingly in the way Oxford are starting to positively discriminate against private pupils. If we take this path you'll no longer be able to tell who was a state school pupil and who was a state school pupil with huge extra benefits.

It's just typical Labour: it's unfair that some kids are benefitting from a private education which is superior to state school education. Should we improve state school provision? No, let's take away private provision for all but the richest so everyone has it shit and it's fair for everyone🤦🏻

LadyWithLapdog · 26/09/2021 17:35

YABU for calling yours a Blue vote. It’s not more palatable than Tory.

EmmaGrundyForPM · 26/09/2021 17:34

As parents privately educating children, you are already paying tax for a service which you don't use.

I hate this argument. The whole of society benefits from having a high level of education. Without state education for the vast majority of people, the country would be ruined. Just imagine of 93% of people were uneducated - shops, factories, hospitals, everything would fail. There would be no electricity, gas, water or other basics as the people running those utilities on the ground all need a certain level of education.

And to claim that most people who send their children to private school aren't rich is also laughable. If you put two children through private education you are talking about £30k per year AFTER tax just on school fees. That's pretty rich.

justasking111 · 26/09/2021 17:21

@movingonupagain

I had no idea that private schools got free money from the government! Hmm

Caveat: SPECIAL NEEDS private schools

Private school I know takes SEN boarders. The local authority of the child pays. It's impressive how children that would have had little chance in the state system blossom, but it's not cheap
Limejuiceandrum · 26/09/2021 17:14

Charities can pay board members, pay for good and services (land is a prime one for schools) buildings, you also can make a profit over a certain amount, though you will have to pay some tax on that.

It’s really not as simple as “oh I want to help kids, let’s set up a school, but no thanks I don’t need to make any money from it”

MarshaBradyo · 26/09/2021 17:10

[quote Limejuiceandrum]@MarshaBradyo
You know charities are allowed to make a profit for whoever owns them![/quote]
I don’t know the regulatory rules but on a quick google

Profit
Charities can make a profit or surplus. But all the surplus funds have to go back to the charity. Similarly, charities can and do invest their money in order to generate a return. But that return can only go back to the charity to spend on its cause.

Motherdare · 26/09/2021 17:07

Divisory politics of envy from the left as usual.

Parents who pay for private schools are also tax payers. They contribute towards state schools without ever using them.

movingonupagain · 26/09/2021 17:06

I had no idea that private schools got free money from the government! Hmm

Caveat: SPECIAL NEEDS private schools

Limejuiceandrum · 26/09/2021 17:05

@MarshaBradyo
You know charities are allowed to make a profit for whoever owns them!

MarshaBradyo · 26/09/2021 17:05

@Limejuiceandrum

My friends parents “run” a school They are fucking insanely rich. And the level of help they get as a charity is fucking disgusting.

We are basically paying for wealthy people who own and run schools that prop up elitist ideals to make a HUGE Profit

Does the school make a profit? How does that work with not for profit
Limejuiceandrum · 26/09/2021 16:57

My friends parents “run” a school
They are fucking insanely rich. And the level of help they get as a charity is fucking disgusting.

We are basically paying for wealthy people who own and run schools that prop up elitist ideals to make a HUGE Profit

Limejuiceandrum · 26/09/2021 16:55

All these people saying, I couldn’t afford it and the school would go bust!
Why on Earth should the U.K. tax payer prop up failing businesses.

It’s a well known fact that taking all the middle class kids away from standard schools means the school goes down, it’s not just about money.

Also, fuck off with the argument “I don’t take tax payers money for schools” and I pay tax for schools and I don’t use them.

I pay tax for a fuck tonne of stuff I don’t need or use.

olivehater · 26/09/2021 16:55

They normally are the squeezed middle because they are normally paying for via family money not their own!

VladmirsPoutine · 26/09/2021 16:52

Apart from anything else it still remarkable that parents who can afford private school view themselves as some sort of squeezed middle Confused

olivehater · 26/09/2021 16:51

I think they should pay tax on the education side of things between the hours of 9 and 3. But anything after that, sports etc, wrap around care should be taxed. Why should I be taxed to send my kids to swimming lessons and they not be?

PugInTheHouse · 26/09/2021 16:48

IME bursaries and scholarships are 2 very different things. Bursaries are means tested and up to 100% of fees, the parents wouldn't be able to afford it normally. Scholarships are not means tested and awarded on talent - academic/music/sport etc. There is a separate trust fund for these at my DCs school so I don't think they would be affected if they were doing worse financially however it may be affected if it was linked in some way to their charitable status.

LizzieW1969 · 26/09/2021 16:10

Having said that I totally agree that the schools are businesses and should be treated that way for tax. They should be banned from charitable status, and fees should be subject to standard VAT (possibly with an exception for SEN).*

^I agree with this. It’s always been ridiculous, private schools being treated as charities, they’re clearly not. I do get the practical problems with changing this, though.

jcyclops · 26/09/2021 16:01

The UK's private education system is world renowned for its education and apolitical teaching. Approx 1 in 5 pupils at independent schools have parents who live abroad or are foreigners based in the UK. It is one of the UK's best examples of "soft power". In no way should it be scrapped.

Having said that I totally agree that the schools are businesses and should be treated that way for tax. They should be banned from charitable status, and fees should be subject to standard VAT (possibly with an exception for SEN).

6% of children are privately educated, but 14% of teachers work in the private sector, and the private sector accounts for 16% of education spending.

CiderWithLizzie · 26/09/2021 15:55

A bursary without providing financial information aimed to attract the brightest is a scholarship. We have to differentiate between the two in the accounts as one provides a public benefit snd the other doesn’t.

MarshaBradyo · 26/09/2021 15:47

Do they advertise bursaries as non means tested on their website?

Or is it under the counter so to speak

It sounds scandalous to me - in the sense it’s enough for a story in a paper / Panorama type thing if they were to get hold of bursaries with no financial info at a well known school.

Grammar schools I get as they are still state and it’s broadening to that sector even if unpalatable

TeenTitan007 · 26/09/2021 15:46

I have one in state and one in private. I'd rather see all private schools be abolished and all the private parents help lobby for better state provisions rather than see the fees go up. Just why should private schools 'help' state schools funding? Unless they are being run for profit - which most are not.

2021Vision · 26/09/2021 15:42

I know it is Marsha however honestly it's true. Sorry but I cannot name the schools, I guess that's what is difficult about forums, you don't know if I am telling the truth, but I can assure you I am.

It is similar in a way to Oxbridge are now evidently widening access. The reality is that the places are going to grammar schools whose pupils have more often than not 'bought' their place through tutoring and a priviledged home life. What are Labour doing about improving this access?

You can set criteria however you like however parents will still be pushy and establishments will remain in control of access.

Buttons294749 · 26/09/2021 14:58

I do agree though that mainstream private and public schools can convey a huge, unfair advantage. Where I work the British people in the top jobs are almost all privately educated. Funnily enough a lot of the Dutch, German, Swedish etc are not.

The note about forces children and children who need SEN provision but would not "qualify" for a specialist school should also be taken into account. These children need to be planned for

MarshaBradyo · 26/09/2021 14:53

@2021Vision

My DD had a scholarship and bursary to a very well known school. We did not have to provide any financial information, we would not have qualified for the bursary if we had. They were buying in talent.

A nephew had a bursary to a private school. His parents would not have been able to afford the fees but are comfortable, think own house in expensive area, 2 cars etc.

Sorry but these bursaries are not going to the poorest. The schools buy in talent/results and want an easy fit.

A bursary without providing financial information is unusual

Which school or area even?

2021Vision · 26/09/2021 14:52

My DD had a scholarship and bursary to a very well known school. We did not have to provide any financial information, we would not have qualified for the bursary if we had. They were buying in talent.

A nephew had a bursary to a private school. His parents would not have been able to afford the fees but are comfortable, think own house in expensive area, 2 cars etc.

Sorry but these bursaries are not going to the poorest. The schools buy in talent/results and want an easy fit.

Swipe left for the next trending thread