Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To support Kier Starmer’s school policy even though I would usually vote Blue…

168 replies

Blankspace4 · 26/09/2021 10:58

www.mirror.co.uk/news/politics/keir-starmer-vows-tax-private-25072816

(Original article I read was on the BBC but they seem to have merged it in to another about general tax policy now)

I haven’t voted Labour at any point during my working life and in general am in favour of a meritocracy, free market, and low regulation

However this policy has touched a nerve, in a good way. I think it’s astounding private schools remain ‘charities’ and don’t pay tax. If parents can afford to send their children to private school, I’ve no real issue with it, but let them pay an additional 20% to properly contribute in line with their privilege.

Of course there is the counter argument that private school families already pay tax and therefore are funding schooling their own kids aren’t using.

But still, on balance I’m supportive.

What does everyone think?

OP posts:
Tanith · 26/09/2021 21:21

I do wish Labour would stop these ridiculous Student Politics initiatives and start talking about what really matters to voters.

People are worried about food shortages, the petrol crisis, the economy, the NHS.

What are Labour blethering on about?
How to choose their leader, Identity politics and attacking private schools.
Their Leader wastes a valuable TV interview turning himself into a laughing stock and their Deputy Leader behaves as though she's still in the school playground.

Blossomtoes · 26/09/2021 21:21

@Sweetnhappy1

I think getting private schools to pay tax is a fair enough request.

But if we're talking about getting rid of them all together thinking this will better fund the state system, can we get rid of the CofE schools and the grammar schools too! Because despite me paying a high level of tax, my kids won't be able to access them.

We’re not talking about getting rid of them altogether. We’re talking about businesses paying VAT and not being treated as special cases. Your children could access a faith school or a grammar school if you lived in their catchment area.
Sweetnhappy1 · 26/09/2021 21:18

I think getting private schools to pay tax is a fair enough request.

But if we're talking about getting rid of them all together thinking this will better fund the state system, can we get rid of the CofE schools and the grammar schools too! Because despite me paying a high level of tax, my kids won't be able to access them.

Ijustreallywantacat · 26/09/2021 20:53

*Is it really beyond the realms of possibility to believe that someone who could afford £2500 a month for something couldn’t afford to pay £3000 a month? An extra £6000 a year?

Yet everyone should be up in arms about someone paying £5 a month more NI as it’s “a tax on the poor?”*

Of course i can believe that some people will have to give up the private school. Just difficult to have that much sympathy. Charging extra NI to some will mean a choice between heating and eating. Not the choice between private and state school.

OhWhyNot · 26/09/2021 20:44

No one pays 40% tax

It’s 40% tax over £50k you pay 40%

Which higher than the average wage which is around £31k

OhWhyNot · 26/09/2021 20:41

I’ve recently managed to pay an extra £200 a month for a tutor

I don’t earn what you pay a month

That is a privilege that I can afford and I’m grateful for that it’s tighten my belt but it’s a choice I can afford to make. I couldn’t of a year ago and well aware that many couldn’t even think about it

I’m sure you shall find the money if needed.

Schools can help out families if it comes to this (sadly probably won’t)

The pleading of poverty or having to cut back is something I am used to hearing in the playground it’s quite sickening so many are so out of touch. I making sure my ds is well aware how lucky and privileged he is

zafferana · 26/09/2021 20:38

The politics of envy.

Private school parents ALREADY pay a tax that pays for state school places, because they're the 40% taxpayers who are funding public services. And since they aren't using those state school places for their own DC, ergo they're paying to educate the DC of other people.

Fortunately, I can't see Keir and his cabal of loonie lefties getting into No 10 any time soon. Listening to him tie himself in knots this morning when Andrew Marr asked him whether only women have cervixes was hilarious.

DoNotGetADog · 26/09/2021 20:29

@OhWhyNot

Oh my how out of touch some are if they think that others believe they struggle to pay £2500 a month. That is a choice

The average wage isn’t even that it’s a considerable amount less

The money will be found the schools will help families out and their profits will be less

Good it’s a business a hugely profitable one for many many private schools that some of the most elite schools have charitable status is outrageous

Is it really beyond the realms of possibility to believe that someone who could afford £2500 a month for something couldn’t afford to pay £3000 a month? An extra £6000 a year?

Yet everyone should be up in arms about someone paying £5 a month more NI as it’s “a tax on the poor?”

HugeAckmansWife · 26/09/2021 20:26

I work in a private school that is small, non selective, not in the SE and has a wide mix of intake and socio-economic status. We do not have spare swimming pools to decommission or luxury facilities of any kind. We do have small classes and staff that routinely work til 6pm or later (boarding) on state school teachers pay. That allows us to give the biggest resource we have, which is time, to run over 100 extra curricular clubs and activities, most of which don't cost anything or very little and to me, this is what makes it worth the fees, compared to the well performing comps who shut the gates at 3pm. I get why, workload is horrendous which 1500+ kids in a school, but my point is that you simply cannot have a meaningful discussion about this because all schools are different. Yes there are some with massive endowments, lots of land, billionaire alumni etc but most really aren't. A case by case, school by school assessment of tax due might be reasonable but to simply assume that all or even most could absorb it, or that most parents could cover it if passed on to them is far too simplistic.

millymolls · 26/09/2021 20:18

People forget that as well
As not charging vat the school
Also cannot reclaim vat

Terrible idea, politics of envy which would undoubtedly force many private schools to close

And it 100% will not raise the quality of education in a state school

DuesToTheDirt · 26/09/2021 20:17

If parents can afford to send their children to private school, I’ve no real issue with it, but let them pay an additional 20% to properly contribute in line with their privilege.

That's not much of an argument. I could say, "If you can afford to buy a house, you can afford to pay 1% more income tax to go towards homeless shelters." Or, "If you can afford to get a takeway, you can afford a £5 surcharge on top to fund food banks."

Blossomtoes · 26/09/2021 20:13

You’re not. A private school not paying tax on something they’ve never paid tax on is not you subsidising them

I am. Private schools are businesses. They should pay tax just like every other business. They should lose their charitable status and the proceeds go into the education budget.

OhWhyNot · 26/09/2021 20:13

Oh my how out of touch some are if they think that others believe they struggle to pay £2500 a month. That is a choice

The average wage isn’t even that it’s a considerable amount less

The money will be found the schools will help families out and their profits will be less

Good it’s a business a hugely profitable one for many many private schools that some of the most elite schools have charitable status is outrageous

cansu · 26/09/2021 20:11

Private schools are businesses in the main. they should not be given tax breaks. The exception are those that do not make profits.

MarshaBradyo · 26/09/2021 20:10

@Blossomtoes

It is envy politics as someone has said upthread

No, it isn’t. Why should I subsidise your decision to buy your children privilege?

Yet the tax paid isn’t used in state system

Which will go towards state education not used

DoNotGetADog · 26/09/2021 20:09

@Blossomtoes

It is envy politics as someone has said upthread

No, it isn’t. Why should I subsidise your decision to buy your children privilege?

You’re not. A private school not paying tax on something they’ve never paid tax on is not you subsidising them.

But if you think that, then maybe people who send their children to private school should get a tax reduction for not using any state school places, which they could use towards paying the VAT?

OhWhyNot · 26/09/2021 20:08

Such a terrible term envy politics Hmm ridiculous snobbery

Children that are able to be sent to private schools are very privileged. I dislike this pretence that this should not be acknowledged. The reason being for the vast majority is that they are from families that can afford this privilege

Blossomtoes · 26/09/2021 19:57

It is envy politics as someone has said upthread

No, it isn’t. Why should I subsidise your decision to buy your children privilege?

DoNotGetADog · 26/09/2021 19:48

I don’t know why people think it’s unbelievable that a family could be paying say £2500 a month for 2 children to go to a private school, and that suddenly having to pay an extra £500 a month would present a difficulty. Going to a private school doesn’t immediately confer a family with unlimited money, in fact it eats up so much of your money!

It is envy politics as someone has said upthread. When the National Insurance increase was announced their was horror that some lower-earning families would have to pay an extra £10 per month. However the same people think it’s just water off a duck’s back for more well-off people already paying high fees and high taxes to pay hundreds of pounds extra every month - and that’s in addition to the £1000+ extra NI they’ll be paying a year.

Everyone but the super-rich has limits to what they have available to spend. There are many people at private schools who spend all the money they earn every month (or close to it) and 20% on top would push them over the edge financially.

Blossomtoes · 26/09/2021 19:43

I entirely agree with you @Blankspace4. Why would anyone would think it’s in any way fair that taxpayers should subsidise the parents of 7% of children to buy privilege for them? It should have been stopped decades ago.

starray · 26/09/2021 19:38

@AmericanTie

Most bursaries go to parents who would have used the school anyway: it's just a little discount. It's not like private schools are there hauling ragamuffin orphans out of poverty with those schemes.
You're confusing bursaries with scholarships.
Merryoldgoat · 26/09/2021 19:18

If we started charging vat we could reclaim it on purchases also.

A well performing school would make around 8% net profit so fees would only have to increase to cover the marginal cost.

During the first wave of the pandemic we made financial assistance available to all who needed. Only 20 families applied. 5 the following term. After that zero.

Independent school is now so expensive that there aren’t many who have the luxury of making ‘sacrifices’ to send their children to independent school.

We have several families with three children at the school - nearly £60k a year in fees alone. Those are not families who are struggling.

Empressofthemundane · 26/09/2021 19:02

It’s true that a 20% fee hike would stimulate some parents to make a different choice.

Would it be enough children to make a noticeable difference in state schools? Who can say?

I do think this policy is less about raising funds, and more about signalling values.

VladmirsPoutine · 26/09/2021 18:48

Exactly! If you can afford to put kids through private school you are rich. Whether or not you 'feel' rich is a separate issue but they're not the 'squeezed middle'.

Ijustreallywantacat · 26/09/2021 18:45

And to claim that most people who send their children to private school aren't rich is also laughable. If you put two children through private education you are talking about £30k per year AFTER tax just on school fees. That's pretty rich.

YES. Thank you. MN does me laugh sometimes with the 'but we can barely afford private school bollocks. It's a choice!

Swipe left for the next trending thread