Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To support Kier Starmer’s school policy even though I would usually vote Blue…

168 replies

Blankspace4 · 26/09/2021 10:58

www.mirror.co.uk/news/politics/keir-starmer-vows-tax-private-25072816

(Original article I read was on the BBC but they seem to have merged it in to another about general tax policy now)

I haven’t voted Labour at any point during my working life and in general am in favour of a meritocracy, free market, and low regulation

However this policy has touched a nerve, in a good way. I think it’s astounding private schools remain ‘charities’ and don’t pay tax. If parents can afford to send their children to private school, I’ve no real issue with it, but let them pay an additional 20% to properly contribute in line with their privilege.

Of course there is the counter argument that private school families already pay tax and therefore are funding schooling their own kids aren’t using.

But still, on balance I’m supportive.

What does everyone think?

OP posts:
Macncheeseballs · 27/09/2021 06:58

Moveahoy, don't all kids 'need' smaller classes?

Ijustreallywantacat · 27/09/2021 06:55

Is it ok for the state to effectively punish parents for wanting a different kind of education for their kids, or for doing their duty as parents in taking responsibility for their kids education?

Bizarre statement.
Do you think the plebs who send their kids to state do not want the best for their kids? They they're not taking responsibility?

Threads like these are a really unfortunate window in to how the other half think and live, I've got to say.

Marchitectmummy · 27/09/2021 04:17

I think it's a bad idea. Private schools share a lot of their facilities with local state schools, whether that be their swimming pools, astro turf pitches or halls. Ours also provide access to various areas of the school to the community for free including art rooms. All of that will go.

Not all schools are full of wealthy people and not all private schools are wealthy and able to subside a tax change. Don't underestimate thr number of private school children being moved into state education should fees raise 20 percent.

Pixxie7 · 27/09/2021 03:26

Totally agree should have been done years ago. Upperclassman privalage.

LobsterNapkin · 27/09/2021 02:53

I think you have to ask yourself, what are schools for, fundamentally?

Are they an institution that the state imposes on as many as possible in order to achieve some kind of equality of outcome? Or are they a way for parents to make sure their kids get a good education? Who ultimately should get to decide about kid's education, parents, or the state? Is it ok for the state to effectively punish parents for wanting a different kind of education for their kids, or for doing their duty as parents in taking responsibility for their kids education?

There's also a tendency to think in terms of elite institutions, but that doesn't describe all private education, nor what it could be. It could equally be a group of people who for some reason object to the state education provided, and band together at some local church hall to provide something they feel is better. If you objected to what the state education looked like, how would you feel about having to shell out an extra 20% to educate your kids, when you were already doing your part with regard to supporting state schools?

MoveAhoy · 27/09/2021 02:40

@Limejuiceandrum

Education aside from sen is a business not a charity in my personal opinion
Here we must agree to disagree. Tertiary education I could concede but primary and secondary, yeah.. nah.. very debatable.

If I couldn’t pay my taxes my business wouldn’t be viable. It’s fuck all to do with affordability for parents
again yeah... nah... a shoe is a shoe. shouldn't matter who is wearing it, we should all pay the same taxes on it? yeah... nah. for kids the VAT is removed. sometimes, concessions are made based on affordability, especially when money is changing hands over something children require. taking affordability into account already has precedents set where services to children are concerned.

It feels like there is astonishment that private schools are not dying a natural death.
the growth of the private education sector signals that something is wrong in the state system but instead of fixing it, it seems labour is just thrashing around like a headless chicken screaming that something is wrong with the state system. Most children who go through the state system do well but it does not cater for all.

This does seem to be about bashing the parents not really about fixing a tax loop hole. Private schools are not hoarding cash like the Amazons and Apples of this world.

There seems to also be an annoyance that children who were middling in the state system, switch to private and then end up with this air of inexplicable confidence.
Well in my anecdotal experience, a child surrounded by attention will eventually believe in its ability to achieve. Yes some schools have the added bonus of having famous names rolling off their tongues but even for the ones that don't have this, having someone believe in your ability (even if it is only because they were paid do it) has an effect on children. it is not necessarily about rubbing shoulders with power. State schools do aspire to this but quite frankly it is unachievable for ALL children with the current ratios and demands on teachers. punishing those who dare to demand this for their children whilst not actually providing the service they require is a recipe for increasing the number of children who simply fall behind in school.

sst1234 · 26/09/2021 23:23

@Getawaywithit

I now work in a relatively high paid career with lots of peers who were privately educated and the networks and confidence they have really give them a huge leg up that state educated kids often don’t benefit from

Only 7% of young people are privately educated. How is making their parents pay more fees going to improve the networks and confidence of 93% of young people?

It’s not. It’s just another irrelevant, hair brained idea from yet another focus group, I am sure. It’s a fringe issue that only the ideologically driven care about. The general public is pragmatic, not ideologically driven.
sst1234 · 26/09/2021 23:21

The truth is that these kind of policies are just pointless and tinkering around the edges. Private schools are an obsession for Labour. In the real world the voting public has bigger fish to fry. Does anyone really think that red wall voters stay awake at night worrying about private schools or would go back to labour because of this policy. Labour have well and truly lost the plot if this counts as policy.

Livpool · 26/09/2021 23:17

YABU for usually voting for the Conservatives ; they are are decimating the NHS

Fr0thandBubble · 26/09/2021 23:15

I’m pretty right wing but I have always felt very uncomfortable about private schools (even though I will probably end up sending mine to one, in the interests of doing what is best for them). But if I had my way they would all be abolished. I hate this social apartheid that private schools create. So I have voted YANBU, even though Labour’s policies generally are as far away from my political ideology as it is possible to get.

CiderWithLizzie · 26/09/2021 23:07

If independent schools lose their charitable status then I suppose they won’t need to provide any public benefit going forwards? That will mean the loss of bursaries and letting their facilities out to the community for public use. I’m not sure this policy will achieve what the headline sets it out to.

Getawaywithit · 26/09/2021 22:37

I now work in a relatively high paid career with lots of peers who were privately educated and the networks and confidence they have really give them a huge leg up that state educated kids often don’t benefit from

Only 7% of young people are privately educated. How is making their parents pay more fees going to improve the networks and confidence of 93% of young people?

Limejuiceandrum · 26/09/2021 22:28

@MoveAhoy
I own a company
I pay the appropriate tax.
Education aside from sen is a business not a charity in my personal opinion

If I couldn’t pay my taxes my business wouldn’t be viable. It’s fuck all to do with affordability for parents

Blossomtoes · 26/09/2021 22:25

@ufucoffee

Ridiculous idea that hasn't been thought out and assumes everyone who sends their children to private schools is rich.
It’s got nothing to do with parents being rich. It’s about business paying the appropriate amount of tax and not being subsidised by the tax payer.
safariboot · 26/09/2021 22:14

I think it's positive that you don't oppose every idea the "other side" proposes just because they're the other side. We need more of that in politics.

As for the policy itself, I haven't made up my mind.

ufucoffee · 26/09/2021 22:12

Ridiculous idea that hasn't been thought out and assumes everyone who sends their children to private schools is rich.

LadyWithLapdog · 26/09/2021 22:10

www.ft.com/content/28ce1fb5-f1a3-4bfc-bed1-954172f7200c
42 private schools closed in 2020 versus 6 in a typical year

MoveAhoy · 26/09/2021 22:00

There's a daft assumption on here that every private school is eton-like.

Most of these schools operate on very low margins. Quite a few closed during the pandemic creating pressure on the schools around them. Most don't have their own sports grounds and have to share with other schools.
Some don't have full time sencos and have to rely on ambulant provision.
The kids I know who go private don't do it for the privilege. They need smaller classes I.e. more support than state could provide with a ratio of 1:30 (or in reality 1:32 with a part time ta)
Not everyone is looking as far ahead as gcse to choose going private. They just want their kid to make it through the current school year.
Not everyone rocks up in private helicopters and holidays in the Swiss alps. It's mostly cycling and butlins.

This move sounds like a "we want to tax the rich" move without actually identifying what "rich" looks like. It is like a stab in the dark and hope we hit the right pockets kind of move.

Honestly a blanket policy on private schools will never be fair because of this assumption.

Blossomtoes · 26/09/2021 22:00

the VAT this is mad, seeing as it’s considerably LESS that it would cost the state to educate those children in the first place.

Do you have some evidence for that or are you making an assumption?

astoundedgoat · 26/09/2021 21:41

We don’t need to remove the privilege - we need state schools to be every bit as good so that private becomes pointless.

Too many of the arguments against private come across as suggesting that their high attainment is somehow immoral and should be cut down to match the rest. What’s immoral is that state school attainment doesn’t blow the private schools out of the water.

I do agree that private schools should have their profit taxed, absolutely, but the VAT this is mad, seeing as it’s considerably LESS that it would cost the state to educate those children in the first place.

astoundedgoat · 26/09/2021 21:37

@bingoitsadingo

I don’t really know tbh, I can see good arguments on both sides.

I do hope the maths stacks up though. It wouldn’t surprise me if a 20% increase in fees pushed a lot of extra kids into the state sector. It might end up costing the government more than they make back from it.

This in spades. We make HUGE sacrifices to go private and couldn’t afford a 20% hike - it’s touch and go as it is, so we’d have to go state, which means no VAT revenue AND the government will have to find the money to educate my children.

But although I wouldn’t vote Tory in a million years, I don’t think they’re going anywhere this side of my kids’ GCSEs.

PeachesPumpkin · 26/09/2021 21:33

@ketchupman

I think this would just make private schools even more elitist, as those serving middle class working families would be unlikely to survive the impact of such a tax. If you look at the accounts of charitable private schools, the little money they do make goes back into maintaining the school, no one is "profiting".
But it’s no bad thing if some private schools close - those middle class children would go to the state schools, which would benefit society overall, as it would remove some privilege and level things up. I agree the very top private schools would survive, but it would be a good start, and hopefully shine a spotlight on the surviving inequalities of private schools.
Lostmarbles2021 · 26/09/2021 21:32

I think charitable status is absolutely shocking to be honest. I think taxing private schools is right. It redresses the balance a little.

Mind you, I don’t really think they should exist - I would much rather all children got the same chances and state education was better resourced - and I say that as someone’s whose DC went to a private school for a few years. I always felt a bit bad that our DC were having a much better education than their peers just because FIL could afford it. It just seems wrong. Children can’t help which family they are born into and inequality starts so early and it makes it so hard to change the status quo. I’d fully support anything that levels the playing field a little and gives us, as a country, a better chance of reducing social inequality. Even if it means we, as a family, are a bit worse off.

Sweetnhappy1 · 26/09/2021 21:27

But I agree with you on taxation though

Sweetnhappy1 · 26/09/2021 21:26

@Blossomtoes I live 600 metres from a CofE secondary school, my children could walk there in 15 minutes but won't get in. Most places go to church goers, you practically have to live on the same road as the school to get in on an open space. So no, wrong religion, we can't access the school.

Swipe left for the next trending thread