Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To support Kier Starmer’s school policy even though I would usually vote Blue…

168 replies

Blankspace4 · 26/09/2021 10:58

www.mirror.co.uk/news/politics/keir-starmer-vows-tax-private-25072816

(Original article I read was on the BBC but they seem to have merged it in to another about general tax policy now)

I haven’t voted Labour at any point during my working life and in general am in favour of a meritocracy, free market, and low regulation

However this policy has touched a nerve, in a good way. I think it’s astounding private schools remain ‘charities’ and don’t pay tax. If parents can afford to send their children to private school, I’ve no real issue with it, but let them pay an additional 20% to properly contribute in line with their privilege.

Of course there is the counter argument that private school families already pay tax and therefore are funding schooling their own kids aren’t using.

But still, on balance I’m supportive.

What does everyone think?

OP posts:
Comefromaway · 27/09/2021 11:33

It would also hit vocational schools badly where there are children on MDS and DaDa awards

MarshaBradyo · 27/09/2021 11:31

Those sums sound about right though?

If the numbers don’t stack up then they don’t.

Unless any part of those figures is incorrect

Blossomtoes · 27/09/2021 11:25

I’m not interested in your maths @astoundedgoat. I was after a verified official source. Which clearly doesn’t exist. I’m not just going to take your word for it.

OhWhyNot · 27/09/2021 10:24

Reading some of these replies just shows out out of touch some people are

And why so many children who go through the private school system become so entitled

It’s a privilege, tighten your belt a bit more and you will find the money

Others are having to to feed their children and heat their homes ffs

astoundedgoat · 27/09/2021 10:24

@Blossomtoes

the VAT this is mad, seeing as it’s considerably LESS that it would cost the state to educate those children in the first place.

Do you have some evidence for that or are you making an assumption?

Well, it's just maths.

The government spends £6000 per secondary school child per year. £5200 per primary school child.

In my non-London city in the SE, private secondary school is about £18000 pa, so VAT on top of that would be in the region of £3600, which is less than £6000.

Primary school is a bit less, more like £15,000, so VAT is £3k.

The 615,000 children in the UK in independent schools are saving the government roughly £3.56 billion per annum.

That's a pretty good deal, surely?

It's worth repeating that that's 18k pa of SPENDING per child in independent secondaries, compared to £6k in state school, which is derisory. Imagine what state schools could do with a TRIPLED budget. But it's easier to demonise privates than to raise the quality of states, right?

zafferana · 27/09/2021 10:23

It won't happen. Every time Labour has a conference they throw red meat of the 'soak the rich' variety to the rabid left of the party, but we all know that many of these pledges made at conferences never go anywhere (whichever party it is). But it generates headlines, it gets people all frothed up (either cheering or booing), and that's what the party wants - headlines.

Remember, Labour have actually got to WIN an election first, something they've only achieved in the past 40 years under Tony Blair and New Labour .... which is a hell of a long way from where they are now politically.

Buttonmoomin · 27/09/2021 10:16

Why does no one ever question the fairness of state funded grammar schools? How can it be fair that parents pay their taxes and some children get the privilege of a tax pay funded excellent education, on a par or better than many independent schools?
Why is it fair that people can afford to buy a house near to an excellent state funded comprehensive and other people either cannot afford it or can‘t move?
The vast majority of independently educated children are not attending Eton, Harrow etc and the parents are not in the socioeconomic group of Johnson et al.
This is an easy vote winner for Labour but won‘t make up for their apparent contempt for their core voters and their obsession with fringe politics.

sst1234 · 27/09/2021 10:05

Once again, what’s the point of this policy. It’s about as irrelevant as Labour is nowadays. Does anyone really believe that red wall voters in Grimsby or Tyneside care about this nonsense politics of envy. This is a middle class problem for metropolitan class warriors who are so out of touch that they make it their mission to rage against private education. It’s frankly politically illiterate.

thepastisanothercountry · 27/09/2021 09:55

@LadyWithLapdog

Why is everyone talking about 20%? What is the source for that?
Its a case of VAT being added to school fees
HappyPlacemat · 27/09/2021 09:27

B.o.o. h.o.o.

edwinbear · 27/09/2021 09:16

I have 2 DC in private, an extra 20% increase in fees would mean they would have to leave and our LA would need to find them 2 state school places, in our already over subscribed schools. Given the demographic of our school, I could see easily 30%-40% of parents in the same situation. There are 1,200 children at DC's school so that's an extra 400 state school places that would need to be found, in our borough within about a year. If the school ended up closing because it was no longer viable, it's 1,200 state school places that would need to be found at short notice.

The £4k a month I spend on fees would be diverted to tutors and extra curriculum activities.

LadyWithLapdog · 27/09/2021 09:12

Why is everyone talking about 20%? What is the source for that?

MoveAhoy · 27/09/2021 09:09

@Macncheeseballs

Moveahoy, don't all kids 'need' smaller classes?
My point exactly. This move will not accomplish that. It instead tries to simply get money out of those whose children will not survive never mind thrive in the current state system. All while implying that the state system only needs a little bit of a propping up to meet the same ratios. An acknowledgement that the current system has faults and a massive rethink with overhaul is needed. Not a cash grab which won't raise much and cause more pressure.
Pottedpalm · 27/09/2021 08:49

Well, don’t stress, Labour won’t get in anyway.

ElliottSmithsfingers · 27/09/2021 08:27

Also - when my daughter moved to secondary school, she passed the entrance exam and was offered a place at the local grammar school. We didn't take it, as she preferred the selective private school she also had an offer for. If the fees for the private had been (even) higher, we may have taken up the grammar school place, potentially depriving a child from a less well-off household.

thepastisanothercountry · 27/09/2021 08:18

Its not just the children whose increased fees can not be paid that will flood back into the state system but also that lots of smaller schools will be forced to close down because of loss of fees so those children will come back into state system too. Families who can afford it will buy around the best state schools which will effectively become state funded privates as a result. They'd have to move to a lottery system for schools. Private schooling would become more and more elitist - which is exactly what the politics of envy is trying to prevent

StatisticallyChallenged · 27/09/2021 08:07

We've got one at private, and an extra 20% on fees would probably tip it out of affordability for us. From what I know of the other families I'd guess a substantial proportion would be in the same boat - there are some parents who are properly rich as hell and wouldn't notice, but there are plenty others who are stretching themselves to do it. And I grew up on a council estate, on benefits, so I understand that we are wealthier than average and that it's not even an option for many, but that doesn't mean that my pockets are bottomless and that the extra £££ could be easily found. Unless there's a snap election timing would mean that our eldest would only have a couple of years left to go (I'm assuming late 2024 election, probably wouldn't so actually come in to tax regs until April 2026) and we'd probably end up getting in to debt to avoid disrupting education in the exam years, but we absolutely wouldn't be sending our youngest (big gap means they won't be there simultaneously)

In our nearest city it's nearly 30% who are in private by high school. Some travel in but it's probably still about 25% of those who live in the area. The state schools are in many cases already over capacity (especially in the areas where most of the private school kids live and would be entitled to a space) and there is already a list of schools waiting for funding to allow them to be expanded just to cope with the current state school pupil numbers. A reduction of, say, 20% in private school pupils (which is perfectly possible over a few years as people not only pull out existing pupils but don't send future ones) would leave the local education system utterly fucked. They'd need significant extra funds that the local council do not currently have, and they would need it both upfront (to cover expansion costs) and on an ongoing basis (to cover the roughly £7k a year per extra pupil).

I'd be fairly surprised if the numbers would actually stack up to have a financial benefit once everything was taken in to consideration. In theory it might improve equality, but it would overall lower standards for years as too many pupils are squeezed in to schools with inadequate space, resources and funding.

Other areas will be different, but the state primary our DC was at before we moved them had already had to be expanded twice and the council openly admitted that a reduction in kids being sent private after the financial crash was the main reason that it was needed. That school is full again, and there's no more space to extend it. Which is fairly typical of the schools which would be the worst affected around here.

ElliottSmithsfingers · 27/09/2021 08:05

My children's school offers free places to 20% of the student population, based on parents' income. It's a very selective school, so this helps clever children whose parents would not be able to afford the fees. If the Labour proposal went through I would expect the school to reduce or eliminate this type of financial support before the fees for those who pay are increased. The result would be that poorer children are pushed back into an already overcrowded state system. Be wary of unintended consequences!

Tresal · 27/09/2021 07:56

I think you do have a chip on your shoulder because you are envious. Why have you excluded SEN schools? There are lots of children with SEN who can’t go to a private school? What level of SEN does your exemption extend to? Is it because you feel no threat from SEN children as you don’t think they will achieve more than your own DC?

Tanith · 27/09/2021 07:52

It won’t matter a jot to the well endowed schools. Their investments will keep them going. They’re not going to close, they’ll simply become more elite, shutting out children from this country who can’t afford their fees and attracting overseas students.

Is it a coincidence that girls’ schools will be the ones most affected? They haven’t been established anything like as long as the Harrows and Etons and don’t have those reserves and investments.

Runssometimes · 27/09/2021 07:48

I’ll support it when faith schools - funded by taxpayers - are abolished. That’s the reason our one DC is in private school as our closest schools were faith based and we weren’t prepared to pretend order for him to get in. All schools are oversubscribed in our area so faith schools fill up on the faith criteria and looked after children. We couldn’t afford an extra 20% on fees just as we couldn’t afford to move or have another child so the school is just about doable. We were - after 6 months on state school waiting lists - offered a state school 45minutes by tube and bus away. In the opposite direction to work so even when we did get a state place it wasn’t viable.

I resent paying tax for some of the biggest landowners in the UK to swell their coffers by using schools admission as an incentive to get families attending worship. If you want to raise your child in a faith you still can. Faith in schools is divisive and die shy make you any better at maths etc. Get rid of that and I’ll be able to send my kid to a local school. Raise the bar on the standard of all schools and resource them properly.

I am actually opposed to needing private schools but they do fill a gap in demand as our situation shows. So if this policy comes in then extra capacity in state is needed.

Our school does a lot for charity collects kilos of food for food bank every Friday, several fundraising drives and shares facilities and music programmes etc with other local schools. Also took in non pupil keyworker kids during lockdown. We are well aware of our privilege that we had the option. Still don’t think private schools should exist but given our alternatives I’m glad they do.

Brian9600 · 27/09/2021 07:38

I’m confused about what’s being proposed. Education services are vat exempt AFAIK- that’s not related to charitable status and applies to all education providers, including EFL tutors, universities etc. Taking away charitable status wouldn’t affect that, as far as I’m aware, unless he’s also planning to take away the vat exemption for education in which case it will affect far more businesses than private schools. Any tax people know exactly what the proposal is?

I’m happy for private schools to lose charitable status but hope it will be done in a way that doesn’t lead to even more pressure on the state system, and I’ve yet to hear how that will be done. I’m also far from convinced that it will do anything to solve the problems in the state sector. The amount of media focus on private schools at the expense of the state sector has always appalled me, likewise the media focus on Oxbridge at the expense of the rest of higher and further ed.

Macncheeseballs · 27/09/2021 07:24

Yes inequality can indeed breed resentment

Onandoff · 27/09/2021 07:13

The politics of envy and resentment.

In reality this would mean schools moved from charities to businesses. It’ll take some years to work out the red tape on that.

Once they’re no longer charities schools won’t need to fund bursaries. At our school half the pupils are on reduced or no fees. So it will no longer accommodate children from less well off families. I suspect it will lead to a fee reduction rather than increase for full payers.

Ijustreallywantacat · 27/09/2021 06:58

Ridiculous idea that hasn't been thought out and assumes everyone who sends their children to private schools is rich.

If you can afford private school, and you haven't had a substantial scholarship or whatever, then you ARE RICH.

Swipe left for the next trending thread