Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand why voters aren't angry about all the lies Tories and Brexiteers told them and the resulting mess they've created?

190 replies

Kendodd · 26/09/2021 10:44

Voters still seem to love them and are absolutely welded to their vote despite the evidence all around them that they were lied to.
I would be absolutely furious with them if their lies had persuaded me to vote Leave and Tory.

Yanbu - I would be angry as well
Yabu - everything else

OP posts:
Newrumpus · 26/09/2021 18:19

@Papershuffle

Nope it is you who don't get it Newrumpus.

Even the most dim witted can distinguish between things being conveniently blamed on something and direct consequence. But what exactly is your point? All of the organisations working at the coalface of transport have contradicted Grant Shapps and said that Brexit has had a massively negative impact on the logistics governing the supply chain? Are you denying that?

You say political will can overcome supply chain difficulties but it will take more time, money and have a greater environmental impact than if we had stayed in the single market. It will be the consumer who ends up paying. Is it better in terms of food standards and the environment to import a chicken from Thailand or from the Netherlands? Which is more costly in terms of transport?

No doubt you will answer these questions in a nebulous non-specific way!

Ahhh. So you are moving the goalposts. As you indicate, there are ways around the issues. We, make the decisions, we cause social things to happen - they are not inevitable.
Papershuffle · 26/09/2021 18:18

The solution is very simple.

Pay drivers what they are worth, treat them with respect and put in decent services that will not only serve good food, have showers/toilets and security that prevents them from being attacked from those that wish to steel from the back of the wagons.

But its easier and cheaper to get EU drivers that have fewer costs, two people in the cab and don't stop.

Lorry drivers working conditions definitely need improving but it is the EU that is introducing new rules regulating better enforcement of cabotage rules, posting of drivers and drivers’ rest times. The difficulty to date has been that individual EU nations implemented these regulations differently.

BelleHathor · 26/09/2021 18:11

@FrippEnos

Whitefire ....are both saying that it is specifically Brexit that is limiting the options for solutions.

I think this is the crux of the issue, so whilst Brexit may not have caused the difficulties, it is making them harder to resolve.

The solution is very simple.

Pay drivers what they are worth, treat them with respect and put in decent services that will not only serve good food, have showers/toilets and security that prevents them from being attacked from those that wish to steel from the back of the wagons.

But its easier and cheaper to get EU drivers that have fewer costs, two people in the cab and don't stop.

But then this is an issue that predates brexit but its easier just to blame brexit.

This right here. A lot of the working class who voted for Brexit knew that they would be poorer. They still did it because it was their wages which had been decimated for years by the over supply of cheap labour from the EU.

Blair achieved what his donor class wanted in the early 2000s, allowing unscrupulous employers to reduce working standards and rights. It was a political decision to allow unlimited migration (cheaper than training new staff and additionally had the effect of keeping the A6 countries out if the influence of Russia.)

P.s a lot of EU drivers are not returning solely because of Brexit, quality of life and wages have increased so much in their "home" countries they no longer want or need to work in the UK.

Papershuffle · 26/09/2021 18:10

Nope it is you who don't get it Newrumpus.

Even the most dim witted can distinguish between things being conveniently blamed on something and direct consequence. But what exactly is your point? All of the organisations working at the coalface of transport have contradicted Grant Shapps and said that Brexit has had a massively negative impact on the logistics governing the supply chain? Are you denying that?

You say political will can overcome supply chain difficulties but it will take more time, money and have a greater environmental impact than if we had stayed in the single market. It will be the consumer who ends up paying. Is it better in terms of food standards and the environment to import a chicken from Thailand or from the Netherlands? Which is more costly in terms of transport?

No doubt you will answer these questions in a nebulous non-specific way!

Barbadossunset · 26/09/2021 18:06

Because it’s not just about Brexit and hardly anyone will post if it’s there. I never go near the Brexit or Covid boards, they’re loon magnets

KenDodd how do you feel about your favourite board, the Brexit board, being described as a ‘loon magnet’?

Newrumpus · 26/09/2021 18:05

“Nope. You wanted the Europeans to go”

Well you got that wrong!

Blossomtoes · 26/09/2021 18:05

BP and the other companies want their slave labour back, rather than paying the existing drivers a decent wage.

This is such a ridiculous thing to say. They haven’t got enough existing drivers. They could pay them £100k a year and it wouldn’t make any difference. You can’t solve a skills shortage overnight by throwing money at it.

DecadentlyDecisive · 26/09/2021 18:04

@Kendodd

What do you hope to gain out of these repeated threads OP? You keep asking why people vote Conservative and whether they should feel angry and betrayed and lied to or not and keep getting the same answers. Do you hope to change peoples minds? Get a new perspective you haven’t heard before?

Because honestly, every day I grow more and more astonished by the shit you'll put up with and even defend. Really, it's just unbelievable. And as for changing anyones mind, the scales feel from my eyes a long time ago on that, there is NOTHING that will change Brexit voters minds and it's this that I really don't understand. The DUP are the best example of this.

Don't you get it?

As a Tory voter, I have a rough idea of the sort of shit I'll have to put up with from a Tory Government - and it's weighted in my favour.

If we had a Labour Government, there would be a whole different level of shit to put up with, but it wouldn't suit me as well.

So I vote for the people who will give me shit I can survive.

And until there's a credible opposition party offering a whole new raft of shit that benefits more people (or even no shit) that's the way it's going to be....

AlexaShutUp · 26/09/2021 18:03

I think people just don't like having to admit that they made a mistake so it's easier to pretend that they're happy with how things are panning out. It's hard to see exactly what they're happy about, but at least if they continue to assert that everything is fine, nobody can say "I told you so".

Never underestimate how incredibly invested people are in not admitting that they screwed up.

DecadentlyDecisive · 26/09/2021 18:00

@FrippEnos

Whitefire ....are both saying that it is specifically Brexit that is limiting the options for solutions.

I think this is the crux of the issue, so whilst Brexit may not have caused the difficulties, it is making them harder to resolve.

The solution is very simple.

Pay drivers what they are worth, treat them with respect and put in decent services that will not only serve good food, have showers/toilets and security that prevents them from being attacked from those that wish to steel from the back of the wagons.

But its easier and cheaper to get EU drivers that have fewer costs, two people in the cab and don't stop.

But then this is an issue that predates brexit but its easier just to blame brexit.

Spot on!

BP and the other companies want their slave labour back, rather than paying the existing drivers a decent wage.

DecadentlyDecisive · 26/09/2021 17:58

@Kendodd

FFS give it up about Brexit.

Why?
We will be living with the consequences for decades, why shouldn't we talk about it?

You're not talking about it though are you?

You're whining about it.

Continually....

bozzabollix · 26/09/2021 17:54

If I’d voted for the kind of Brexit sold to voters during the Referendum campaign I’d be furious now, but the Leave voters see it as nothing, Corbyn’s beard will have got them more raging. Like you OP I don’t get it, what’s frustrating is that whilst people are engaging in whataboutery, blaming the general public for supply issues and giving politicians get outs for lying nothing will change.

It’s enough to make your head explode.

Poetrypatty · 26/09/2021 17:51

Brexit could have been a success but the government has cocked it up at every opportunity. Labour should be focussing on that rather than Brexit itself.

It was a stupid idea and was always going to have a crap outcome. But the Tories have mismanaged it and made everything worse, largely because the cabinet is full of buffoons chosen to make the PM look good in comparison.

FrippEnos · 26/09/2021 17:48

Whitefire
....are both saying that it is specifically Brexit that is limiting the options for solutions.

I think this is the crux of the issue, so whilst Brexit may not have caused the difficulties, it is making them harder to resolve.

The solution is very simple.

Pay drivers what they are worth, treat them with respect and put in decent services that will not only serve good food, have showers/toilets and security that prevents them from being attacked from those that wish to steel from the back of the wagons.

But its easier and cheaper to get EU drivers that have fewer costs, two people in the cab and don't stop.

But then this is an issue that predates brexit but its easier just to blame brexit.

CuteOrangeElephant · 26/09/2021 17:47

Brexit could have been a success but the government has cocked it up at every opportunity. Labour should be focussing on that rather than Brexit itself.

YouMeandtheSpew · 26/09/2021 17:47

Take the shortage of drivers - there is no doubt that Brexit played a part in this but it isn’t the only factor. Political will can overcome this issue. It is the same with trading and investments.

Nope. You wanted the Europeans to go and not come back. So they left, and they can’t come back.

There are some catalytic factors at play (Covid being the obvious one - it caused Europeans to leave faster than expected) but it’s still straightforward cause and effect.

tulippa · 26/09/2021 17:41

I completely agree with you OP and go between feeling depressed angry. Everyday we learn that something else will be more expensive, unavailable, more difficult etc etc and no-one cares.
Also annoyed with Kier Starmer who keeps missing these political open goals and is becoming more ineffective day by day.

Barbadossunset · 26/09/2021 17:40

I don’t imagine anyone who pays for their kids’ education is likely to vote Labour

Shami Chakrabarti
Diane Abbott
Anas Sarwar
Polly Toynbee
Alan Rusbridger
(I don’t know for certain that Polly & Alan, in the privacy of the polling booth, voted Labour, but they claim they do).

Also I’ve read quite a few posts on here from parents who vote Labour and would vote against private education in a heartbeat, but because their children are so intelligent and superior , it would be too unfair on the little darlings to expect them to go to state school.

Moonface123 · 26/09/2021 17:35

If you expect any politician to keep their word, more fool you.
I don't bother voting, l couldn't care less who is supposedly in charge,
I just focus on my own everyday life, living peacefully and simply and let the rest of the circus get on with it.

YouMeandtheSpew · 26/09/2021 17:35

I bet it won't. Everything and anything will be blamed except Brexit and the Tories.

You are probably right. My dad’s a Brexiteer and you should hear him flapping about trying to blame it on anything but Brexit (while he queues at the pumps for fuel he doesn’t need). It’s the evil EU, it’s a conspiracy by the haulage industry, it’s Covid. But I do wonder if having to have baked beans on toast for Christmas dinner will be the thing that gets through to him.

littledrummergirl · 26/09/2021 17:33

People are past anger, disillusioned with the lack of good governance and lack of a credible opposition.
The government seems to have learnt no lessons from history.

Newrumpus · 26/09/2021 17:32

@Papershuffle

You don’t seem to have got it first or second time. I didn’t say that Brexit would help would with driver shortages. I said there is a difference between things being conveniently blamed on Brexit and things a direct inevitable consequence

I have understood that you have resorted to pedantry Newrumpus!

No. You just haven’t got it.
Yarnandneedles · 26/09/2021 17:27

The voters got what they voted for.

Don’t blame the Tories.
It’s up to us as voters to do the research and vote appropriately.

Remainers warned of this but the electorate didn’t listen. They’ve brought it on themselves.

Kendodd · 26/09/2021 17:25

But I suspect that when the shelves are bare at Christmas (it’s too late to save Christmas now) the tide of public opinion might start turning.

I bet it won't. Everything and anything will be blamed except Brexit and the Tories.

OP posts:
Papershuffle · 26/09/2021 17:24

You don’t seem to have got it first or second time. I didn’t say that Brexit would help would with driver shortages. I said there is a difference between things being conveniently blamed on Brexit and things a direct inevitable consequence

I have understood that you have resorted to pedantry Newrumpus!