Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand how children bring anyone joy?

239 replies

Bluerainbow86 · 26/09/2021 10:26

I know, I know, no other love like it. But that’s not especially positive is it? Because it just leads to worry and stress.
One of my children has additional needs, which likely doesn’t help, but how does anyone ever enjoy anything with their children?
The only way I can see it is possible is if you have one child, NT, hands on partner, plenty of cash.

No other situation seems to lend itself to anything particularly positive.

OP posts:
mydogisthebest · 26/09/2021 15:21

[quote Teapiggies]@mydogisthebest I’m sure they prefer their dogs at times because they’re easier and there’s less emotional attachment. But I would be surprised if they genuinely preferred them to the extent where they would save the dogs from a burning building rather than their kids.

It’s fine to say you think dogs are better than kids, but you’ve only had dogs, and I’ve had both. So you can’t really say that with any personal anecdotal experience.[/quote]
I wouldn't be surprised if some of them chose their dogs over their kids to rescue from a burning building.

I am talking grown up children here. Lots of my friends just seem to have so much grief from their children. One has a son who has been to prison, one has a son who is a drug addict, another has a daughter who is an alcoholic. Quite a few have children who are always asking for money.

Even quite a few of the grandchildren are problems. Again, asking for money or items like trainers, phones etc. I am talking grand children old enough to be working.

Lots of posters have quite young children so no experience when they are older. Friends say on the whole they get worse as they get older.

I am glad if you get joy from your children but I just know I wouldn't. Almost every day I am thankfully we chose not to have any. I don't think we would have the happy and loving marriage we have had for over 40 years if we had had children

MaryShelley1818 · 26/09/2021 15:20

I found going from 0-1 incredibly difficult. I was shell shocked and the adjustment was overwhelming. I also have an Anxiety disorder and the constant worry caused me to develop PND.

That child is now 3 and his baby sister is 7mths and its a million times better. DS is the absolute light of my life and brings me so much joy and happiness. I find DD a little more difficult but now I know each phase passes and things will only continue to get easier. I've just returned from a week in Spain with them which was filled with sheer joy and happiness. It was lovely to spend so much quality time together. My husband is an excellent hands on father though which helps.

ancientgran · 26/09/2021 15:19

@LadyMaid

When they put their little arms around you and give you the sweetest smile or a kiss. Or tell you they love you. Without you initiating it.

You cannot compare that to any other feeling in the world.

That doesn't last though. After 40 odd years of being a mother I realise I'd have had an easier life if I hadn't bothered.
LukeEvansWife · 26/09/2021 15:17

Of course I will. It’s my opinion. She is free to ignore it and tell me cats are better.

I doubt it - you are telling her that not having children will condemn her to a shit life stuck in the past.

Some people having children because they feel they should and attitudes like that don't exactly help. Then they realise they don't enjoy parenthood but it's too late.

Still, it's clear why some people consider the childfree as less than them

Teapiggies · 26/09/2021 15:16

@Dancingonmoonlight a very interesting/honest post. I have an only. It’s fantastic for us - but I’m also lucky financially & having a husband who truly pulls his weight and happily looks after her if I want a weekend away with friends or a night out. I feel like I’m winning in being a mum and being ‘me’.

But, but, but… sometimes I feel selfish. Like I’m depriving her of a sibling for my own comforts. We could financially have another child, we just choose not to.

She has lots of cousins close in age and very close aunties, and a fantastic relationship with grandparents. So I’m hoping that’s enough?

Is a happy, chilled mum more important than a sibling?? It’s hard to know Sad

Dancingonmoonlight · 26/09/2021 15:12

I think having one is the answer.
I remember when I had DC1, I was incredibly happy. I felt completely content. Then I thought it would be lively for DC1 to have a sibling and with the arrival of DC2 came drudgery and every day was a relentless Groundhog Day with financial/practical/emotional stress and worry and arguments.
There are some nice moments but the scales are definitely balanced in the unenjoyable side.

Maybe it will change when they are teens but I think it will get worse, much worse.

To have children comfortably, we d ssc joule have been in the right school catchment, in a house we could grow old in, have support nearby or else afford paid childcare to free up one evening a week so we could remember who we were before kids and what we liked about one another. And a minimum of 150K per year.

Teapiggies · 26/09/2021 15:11

@mydogisthebest I’m sure they prefer their dogs at times because they’re easier and there’s less emotional attachment. But I would be surprised if they genuinely preferred them to the extent where they would save the dogs from a burning building rather than their kids.

It’s fine to say you think dogs are better than kids, but you’ve only had dogs, and I’ve had both. So you can’t really say that with any personal anecdotal experience.

mydogisthebest · 26/09/2021 14:59

[quote Teapiggies]@mydogisthebest

I didn’t say all childfree couples.

My dogs force me to get up in the mornings and they are far more enjoyable than most children. They don't argue with me, they don't give me any grief. I will never have to worry about them taking drugs, smoking, drinking, getting pregnant or getting a girl pregnant.

Yes but they’re dogs. You don’t have the same depth and quality of relationship with a dog that you do as a child. You can’t ask their opinions, joke with them, ask them to help you out, listen to interesting things they have to tell you.

I’m a huge dog lover, but the way in which we have to outwardly accept the view that pets are comparable to children in order to seem polite is ludicrous.[/quote]
Lots of parents don't have a deep or quality relationship with their children though.

Children can decide to have no contact with their parents or just move far away and have very little contact. Many do.

I have friends with children and dogs, some of whom say they prefer their dogs.

To me dogs and children are not comparable simply because dogs are far better and nicer.

MrsTesfaye · 26/09/2021 14:50

I have four, the older two are 11 and 8, the youngest are 5 and 2.

The older 3 bring me immense amounts of joy! They are so loving and caring, and are independent enough to not need constant running around after, especially the 11yo. My 2 year old however is really hard work and much harder to enjoy. But they were all like that when they were 2.

I've realised in my experience the years 0-4 are the hardest, and after that it's incredibly enjoyable. But mine are all NT aswell which undoubtedly makes things a trillion times easier

Teapiggies · 26/09/2021 14:45

@LukeEvansWife

Children keep you looking forward & in touch with the world. A lot of the older childless/childfree people I know, their lives basically froze in time the moment their parents died & they haven’t moved on since. One of them talks like her parents died last week, when they did in the late 90s blush

Wow. Just wow. Please don't pass your opinion on to your own children -

Of course I will. It’s my opinion. She is free to ignore it and tell me cats are better.
Teapiggies · 26/09/2021 14:44

@mydogisthebest

I didn’t say all childfree couples.

My dogs force me to get up in the mornings and they are far more enjoyable than most children. They don't argue with me, they don't give me any grief. I will never have to worry about them taking drugs, smoking, drinking, getting pregnant or getting a girl pregnant.

Yes but they’re dogs. You don’t have the same depth and quality of relationship with a dog that you do as a child. You can’t ask their opinions, joke with them, ask them to help you out, listen to interesting things they have to tell you.

I’m a huge dog lover, but the way in which we have to outwardly accept the view that pets are comparable to children in order to seem polite is ludicrous.

mydogisthebest · 26/09/2021 14:39

@Papershuffle

Because anything remotely rewarding and worthwhile is usually incredibly challenging and hard. But it is ultimately fulfilling.

Imho children hold up a mirror to ourselves and sometimes what we see is not particularly pretty! They challenge and stretch us. And that's generally a good thing.

It's not talked about often in films or the media, but genuine love; the sort where you would catch someone else's vom in your hands, or wipe their bum, or happily walk in front of a tram for your child, that sort of love really is the only thing that matters in life and that is what brings you joy, besides things related to health and money.

So there's your answer op... it's love ...and it's very simple and terribly hard all at the same time.

I have love. Love for my DH which brings me untold happiness. Love for my siblings, my nieces and nephews. Love for my dogs.

One thing that jumps out to me here is just how many posters who say they are happy with their children are single.

I would 100% rather have a happy marriage than be single with children.

Heartofglass12345 · 26/09/2021 14:37

I find it hard, I love my children and would do anything for them. But my oldest is autistic and everything is a battle and he doesn't want to do anything apart from sitting and playing games on my old phone that he uses. If we go anywhere he does usually enjoy it but getting ready is usually met with him throwing things, saying he doesn't want to go and not wanting to get dressed. It puts a dampener on the day really, but it isn't his fault. Luckily I don't mind staying in but I feel like his brother is missing out as he does like going out and doing things although he seems happy. I spend most of my time feeling guilty Sad

LukeEvansWife · 26/09/2021 14:36

Children keep you looking forward & in touch with the world. A lot of the older childless/childfree people I know, their lives basically froze in time the moment their parents died & they haven’t moved on since. One of them talks like her parents died last week, when they did in the late 90s blush

Wow. Just wow. Please don't pass your opinion on to your own children -

mydogisthebest · 26/09/2021 14:32

@Teapiggies

Children keep you looking forward & in touch with the world. A lot of the older childless/childfree people I know, their lives basically froze in time the moment their parents died & they haven’t moved on since. One of them talks like her parents died last week, when they did in the late 90s Blush

I’m naturally quite lazy so having a child forces me to get up, out of bed, to do things with my day & to make future plans. I waste so much less time now.

She’s also hilarious, cute, stubborn and fiery - a right little character who makes everything more interesting (for me!).

I love seeing her little face as she wanders in for a morning cuddle, and also thinking ‘phew’ when she goes to bed so I can go downstairs and have a chat with DH and a nice meal.

I had her youngish so when I’m 40 she will be well into her teens - I hope she keeps me feeling young & modern, and that we can do lots of interesting things together.

Yes some days are tough but isn’t everything worth doing?

What rubbish that children keep you looking forward. I know many couples who chose to be childfree and none of their lives have frozen in time.

My dogs force me to get up in the mornings and they are far more enjoyable than most children. They don't argue with me, they don't give me any grief. I will never have to worry about them taking drugs, smoking, drinking, getting pregnant or getting a girl pregnant.

Bluerainbow86 · 26/09/2021 14:31

I very very very rarely about. Occasionally I snap. Sometimes when he’s really mean I will snap or get upset. He always then says he’s joking.
He cannot bear anyone else to do well, very competitive.

OP posts:
Bluerainbow86 · 26/09/2021 14:29

It doesn’t matter how much time dc1 has he wants more, nothing is ever enough and he’s never satisfied with anything.
He’s very jealous of dc2 and I believe he’d have coped quite a bit better as an only one.
He’s vile to dc2 as well - part of what sparks him with me is when I stand up for dc2.
I find the negativity from him very hard, he is extremely critical of everyone and has a superior attitude, even though I know actually his self esteem is low.
He does a lot of ‘come on, how stupid can one person be?’ and ‘how much of an idiot are you.’
It’s hard to mitigate because it is ALL THE TIME.
I’ve tried speaking to him about it but he just doesn’t get it. He’s not brilliant with his dad but he is definitely worse with me and women in general. Contempt a lot of the time, I’d say. Does a lot of ‘yeah well, you’re only an X’ about my job.

OP posts:
LukeEvansWife · 26/09/2021 14:22

@Ambersand

I guess I'll be heavily criticised for this but anyway, Jordan Peterson wrote a whole chapter on this subject in his book 12 Rules of Life- something along the lines of 'don't raise children that you don't like'. The point being of you don't like them then no one else will and they will be condemned to live a life of loneliness and isolation. I know your ds has special needs and yet we, on a societal level, need to confront the fact that so many unlikeable children are being raised
The same Jordan Peterson who said that you don't mature until you have a child? The right wing arsehole? Yup, definitely take his advice Hmm
SylvanasWindrunner · 26/09/2021 14:22

I have to say, OP. Your posts sound almost like you're in an abusive relationship. It sounds like your son is bullying you Sad so I'm not surprised you're finding it hard to find the joy in things right now. I hope there's somewhere you can get some help, but I agree that SEN or not, he can't be allowed to treat you that way. Presumably he doesn't talk to others like that?

I actually find it interesting/depressing how often young men funnel their rage onto women. It's very rarely the father or male siblings who are bullied and verbally abused in the same way. It makes me wonder if violence against women is really so ingrained within humankind Sad

SpidersAreShitheads · 26/09/2021 14:21

I have 2 DC, both with additional needs - they are twins aged 11. DS has quite high needs, still in nappies aged 11 - DD could more easily pass for neurotypical but she’s got a tween attitude yet still couldn’t cross a road on her own and panics if I’m out of sight. Other kids her age are travelling to school on their own - I couldn’t even send her into a shop while I sat outside.

I work full time, self employed, so I gave tight deadlines. Also - for long and complicated reasons I won’t bore MN with - I now home educate them both. They are literally here with me 24/7. So I get how hard it is. I really do.

It is relentless and exhausting. DS is autistic and has dyspraxia, DD is autistic, has a separate language processing disorder and is being assessed for ADHD. But I’m also neurodiverse so I feel I have a good insight into how they think and feel.

Despite it all, I love being with them and they bring me enormous joy. Yes it’s hard work. They can be blunt and don’t always understand that I have a limit, but I bloody adore the bones off both of them. Switching to home ed has been the best thing I ever did as it removed the anxiety and stress that prompted so many meltdowns. Life is calmer these days.

Teen hormones mixed with autism/ADHD can be tricky. When your DS is rude to you OP, what do you do? What do you say? What have you tried? I don’t do “punishments” in my house but actions and words have consequences. Outbursts at trusted loved ones is a common feature of autism/ADHD but that doesn’t mean you’re expected to blithely accept very personal insults.

My daughter has a strong element of PDA so put on the spot, she can appear to be difficult. I know she needs time and space to make a good choice - but I’ve learnt this the hard way over the years!!

I don’t do raised voices - it doesn’t help anyone. But I have very clear boundaries in what I expect and accept - and that helps with the black and white thinking of my DC.

Just wondering - does anyone talk down to you in front of your DC? I’m utterly crap at certain things but I still consider myself intelligent and very capable in other ways. I’m happy to joke about my crapness and my DP often does too. Then I noticed it was reflecting on the way DC spoke to/about me - they are too immature to realise the subtlety of the joking - so I nipped all that in the bud.

Is there any way for you to reconnect with your DS? You’re not enjoying his company so could your relationship do with some work? Could some 1:1 time be found - even if it’s after younger DC is in bed?

I’m sorry you’re having such a tough time.

Comingup · 26/09/2021 14:20

Sorry it's tough for you. In my experience of really hard times, very little money and no support, I have enjoyed my children. One has been a massive challenge especially but I haven't ever regretted it,ever. They have brought me more joy and given me a reason to live than I have ever known. You sound depressed, I get that but try to seek counselling or see your GP, you deserve to be enjoying your life too.

NotPersephone · 26/09/2021 14:20

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

rhonddacynontaf · 26/09/2021 14:18

My AN son brings me immense joy constantly. Until I fully accepted him being who he was I was wracked with anxiety, guilt and fear. Now we take each day as it comes and we are both much happier for it.

It's been years of tough mental labour to get my thinking to a place where I can live with myself and his needs. I really had to put a lot of leg work in. Extensive reading about his conditions and discussions with adults with his conditions. Lots of reading about ableism and the social model of disability.

I like lists (because I'm autistic) so this is what I've done to get us to a pretty good place:

  • fought to get DS into a specialist school from Year R, the fight was awful but every day since we have reaped the benefits
  • accepted that our family can't and don't do things that other families do, and that an hour trip to the local park is as much of an achievement for us as a packed day out for other families
  • read up on ableism and realised that many of my child's issues are actually about lack of access and inclusion and not their fault at all
  • been very clear with family members (who don't really understand) about what my child can and cannot manage and been unapologetic if that disappoints them
  • equip my home with lots of sensory toys and occupational therapy equipment (peanut ball, swing, trampoline etc etc) to ensure DS can have his sensory needs met at home
  • used a 'less is more' approach with language, simplifying my own language, which has really helped DS with his speech and understanding

I wouldn't feel bad about struggling. I still struggle! But you can get yourself to a better place with it all.

SylvanasWindrunner · 26/09/2021 14:12

DD brings me a lot of joy, but it is as you say in your OP. She's currently our only, she's very easygoing and chilled, easy to take places, my DH is very hands-on, we don't have money worries ... it's a lot easier to get joy out of something when the variables go your way.

LaurenKelsey · 26/09/2021 14:10

You are not unreasonable to have these feelings. I am a retired teacher as well as a mum of three children now grown. Two of my children were lovely but one was very difficult and caused so much tension and upset in the family. You are dealing with a very difficult child, and need help with your particular situation. Please see your GP for advice because that is where you will get the real help you need to feel better and parent a difficult child.