Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Slave underclass; No voice, no money, no hope.

132 replies

HomeSliceKnowsBest · 26/09/2021 09:45

Posting for a non Mumsnetter friend...

AIBU to think I am now part of the burgeoning slave underclass in England?

There is no political party which represents my interests or will stand up to the Tory juggernaut, nor does it seem likely there will be one in the near future.

I am stuck in a low pay job with no hope of owning a home nor living in a reasonable quality rental property.

I cannot access help with my increasingly dire mental health as the waiting list is huge.

I live hand to mouth each month, I have no social life or treats as money doesn't permit it and have budgeted down to the last 1p. I do not have the time nor energy to 'take in ironing' , 'do matched betting' etc between kids, work and (badly) running my home.

I will be worked to death, as by the time I am old enough to draw a pension I doubt I will last all that long due to the lifestyle that poverty forces me into.

AIBU to say there is a slave class of people in our population and ask if you think this is deliberate on the part of the Government, to ensure an adequate supply of workers to feed into the machine and earn their peers big money, while keeping us so miserable or strung out on medication that we quietly comply? We are disposable, despised and unheard.
There is not the possibility of working or educating our way out of this situation as there was in the past.
I feel entirely nihilistic and numb plodding through this daily grind for the next 30 years.

OP posts:
VelvetChairGirl · 26/09/2021 12:26

not being unreasonable but I think your reasoning is wrong, the rich treat us with disdain unaware of the consequences because they are thick and completely out of touch as well as blinded by selfishness and greed.

its the same old history repeating WW1 caused a shift in social welfare because the war brought reality to the fore, the landed gentry suddenly realized the kids they were trying to send off to war were inferior to the enemy, poor, weak and sickly. so that necessity started the push towards improved health and living conditions, social housing and the NHS, social security system and so on.

now those who suffered in ww2 are gone the landed gentry to back to grinding people into the dirt again and expecting them to be greatful, they have learned nothing, if you want productive workers you treat them well, if you want to save the nation money you make sure the people remain in good health for a long time etc. its just greed and stupidity.

Shehasadiamondinthesky · 26/09/2021 12:26

You have to remember that nobody is going to help you, not the government or anyone else, you have to actively seek a better life and figure out how you are going to do it.

IceCreamAndCandyfloss · 26/09/2021 12:23

but for many they are stuck in the situation of never being able to buy

I’m not naive enough to think everyone can but it’s a matter of priorities for some. I wanted to have the stability of my own home and would never have parental help nor an inheritance so I made choices that allowed that. I worked hard and many hours as is possible before having children, went without lots of luxuries etc on order to save the deposit and didn’t max out a mortgage or look in expensive areas.

Unless very well paid, the time to get on the property ladder is pre children when careers and hours worked can be focused on. Trying after having children, going part time or having an adult not working at all is obviously going to make property ownership harder for many.

Shehasadiamondinthesky · 26/09/2021 12:21

I worked my way up from the gutter, a victim of toxic stress, complex trauma, depression and anxiety and being a single mum surviving on just a few pounds a week after paying for everything.
I found good medication far better than talking therapy, medication really lifted me out of the tunnel I was in, NHS talking therapies did nothing. I found self help books I took out from the library more useful.
I went to university as a single mum and did an NHS degree - it was extremely hard, nursing wasn't appropriate as it would have meant paying for childcare I could not afford.
I had nobody at all to help me, my family all live abroad.
Now I earn almost 50k and own my own home.
You can do it, you just need to believe in yourself and find something to do that you love. I chose a profession where I would only be working 9-5 with weekends off because of my DC so obviously nursing is not suitable.

Mynameismargot · 26/09/2021 12:20

@IceCreamAndCandyfloss

A slave implies no choice in what you can do and usually no wage.

Job choices, hours worked, number of children etc are down to the adult. Everyone has to live within their budget and take personal responsibility, it’s not the governments job to fund people’s choices if they can’t afford what they want.

I would argue that it is the governments job to ensure that everyone has a good standard of living. The level of poverty in the UK is disgraceful. What is the governments job if not to look after it's citizens, that means all of them, not just the ones like them.

Someone has to do the low paying jobs, look where you are now with no truck drivers, where has that left you? It is the governments job to ensure that the people who do those jobs can lead nice lives too.

Porcupineintherough · 26/09/2021 12:19

What's weird is that you are talking as if this is a new thing, rather than representing the way the majority of people have lived throughout history.

Difference is you have had access to free education, have free education for your kids and have free health care. So hardly a slave.

If you feel there is no political party to represent you then you need to do something about that. As you say, you are one of a great number of people in the same position and all with a vote.

SandysMam · 26/09/2021 12:15

I think there are a lot of posts at the moment egging people on to believe life is completely shit. Your post sounds very dramatic! Sorry you are struggling but writing this kind of narrative will become a self fulfilling prophecy.

PlanDeRaccordement · 26/09/2021 12:14

I voted YABU because you used the term “slave”

You are working class/working poor but that is still far better and privileged compared to a slave. You are also far better off and privileged compared to the working class/working poor of prior generations.

Babyroobs · 26/09/2021 12:11

The totally inadequate housing issue in this country absolutely needs to be addressed. there is a huge divide between those who own property/ have second homes to rent out/ have benefited from inheritance because relatives had property etc and those who are at the mercy of insecure private tenancies with ever increasing rent, and will never own or benefit from inheritance.
We are lucky, my dh inherited money from his parents house being sold and we will use this to help our kids buy property when they are ready to but for many they are stuck in the situation of never being able to buy or access secure council housing leading to worse mental health.

ItsSnowJokes · 26/09/2021 12:08

@ClareBlue

It's true to a certain extent but you still have freedom to make some choices. There are areas in UK where your money on minimum wage will go further and you can rent or even buy on low income. There are areas where local services and facilities are better or more focused at low income households. Where state schools are fine, crime is low and community is well developed. There are plenty of opportunities to get qualifications or experience and training. All involve change and risk, but you do have the freedom to make them, so technically you are not a slave.
And when all the low income people move to this magical place who will work in your local area in a low income job that is really expensive to live in? The local society would collapse as everyone would be moving off elsewhere.
IceCreamAndCandyfloss · 26/09/2021 12:07

A slave implies no choice in what you can do and usually no wage.

Job choices, hours worked, number of children etc are down to the adult. Everyone has to live within their budget and take personal responsibility, it’s not the governments job to fund people’s choices if they can’t afford what they want.

Dozer · 26/09/2021 12:05

YANBU to be angry and upset about your economic circumstances, political matters and poor UK mental health services.

YABU using the terms ‘slave’ and ‘worked to death’.

emuloc · 26/09/2021 12:04

@EverNapping

Whilst I agree with what you are saying, slave is not the right word.

You have control & freedom of choice, not to mention some coverage of basic human rights.

A slave has nothing. No choice what to eat, where to live, who to sleep with, whether to leave the house for a walk, talk to whoever they want. A slave can be beaten, raped, bred or killed. And that's only a basic comparison.

This. Also a slave can be sold, and certainly does not get paid for their labour.
KingsleyShacklebolt · 26/09/2021 12:02

@user1473878824

I think using the word slave here is actually quite offensive when we have an actual problem with people being trafficked and used as actual slaves.
Completely agree. Slavery isn't something which died with Abe Lincoln.
anothermansshoes · 26/09/2021 11:59

Education has not improved social mobility in the last decade

We have more graduates , doing jobs that don't need that level of education

The good jobs are not there for bright kids with no parents to pay for doctorate level training which is now needed to access good jobs in many scientific sectors

ItsNotMeAnymore · 26/09/2021 11:57

Social mobility through education has improved immensely over the last ten to twenty years. It’s still nowhere near good enough but it is better.
Education or training is the way out. Unfortunately you need teens to be motivated to work hard and make the most of the opportunities they have. You can lead a horse to water…..

Obviously it’s a whole other issue for some people with disabilities.

LunaAndHerMoonDragons · 26/09/2021 11:47

I'd say you and your friend ANBU about the general sentiment. But the comparison to slaves is really inappropriate. Peasant under class might be a more accurate term. Peasants had some freedom of movement and choice, but would only earn small wages and there was no social mobility. They would always be the working poor.

There were big underclass of working poor at various times over the course of recent history, particularly during the Industrial revolution. They tended to have very few rights and many worked jobs that would have significant negative impacts on their quality and length of life and that provided insufficient income to live in a safe comfortable home or to achieve adequate nutrition. Working poor in this context would also be an appropriate term.

Kpo58 · 26/09/2021 11:41

@EverNapping

Whilst I agree with what you are saying, slave is not the right word.

You have control & freedom of choice, not to mention some coverage of basic human rights.

A slave has nothing. No choice what to eat, where to live, who to sleep with, whether to leave the house for a walk, talk to whoever they want. A slave can be beaten, raped, bred or killed. And that's only a basic comparison.

Actually there isn't much of a difference between a poor person and a slave. They often don't have a choice on where to live or what if anything to eat because they don't have the money. If they were beaten/raped/killed then they can't afford to bring any kind of justice or just are ignored by the police.
Comedycook · 26/09/2021 11:38

You're not a slave....but I take your point

Theendoftheworldisnigh · 26/09/2021 11:36

Flowers OP.
How many hours a week do you work / commute to work?
How old are your DCs? Do you have a partner / any support with the DCs so that you have some time to do other things?
As the DCs get older, you should get more time to yourself. Can you find a hobby you love and which costs nothing or very little? Can you find a sport or other exercise which you can do - to help with depression, physical health and social life?
Is there anywhere beautiful near you, where you can go to enjoy nature and recharge your batteries?
Can you soak in the bath and lose yourself in a book?

Tresal · 26/09/2021 11:24

The argument that slavery is the same as being a low paid employee has been, and is sometimes still, used to justify slavery. It is very wrong.

Tresal · 26/09/2021 11:13

I doubt any government is going to make your life better. If you are in a low paid job, you are not a slave.

ClareBlue · 26/09/2021 10:49

It's true to a certain extent but you still have freedom to make some choices.
There are areas in UK where your money on minimum wage will go further and you can rent or even buy on low income. There are areas where local services and facilities are better or more focused at low income households. Where state schools are fine, crime is low and community is well developed.
There are plenty of opportunities to get qualifications or experience and training.
All involve change and risk, but you do have the freedom to make them, so technically you are not a slave.

user1473878824 · 26/09/2021 10:47

I think using the word slave here is actually quite offensive when we have an actual problem with people being trafficked and used as actual slaves.

EverNapping · 26/09/2021 10:45

Whilst I agree with what you are saying, slave is not the right word.

You have control & freedom of choice, not to mention some coverage of basic human rights.

A slave has nothing. No choice what to eat, where to live, who to sleep with, whether to leave the house for a walk, talk to whoever they want. A slave can be beaten, raped, bred or killed. And that's only a basic comparison.

Swipe left for the next trending thread