Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Slave underclass; No voice, no money, no hope.

132 replies

HomeSliceKnowsBest · 26/09/2021 09:45

Posting for a non Mumsnetter friend...

AIBU to think I am now part of the burgeoning slave underclass in England?

There is no political party which represents my interests or will stand up to the Tory juggernaut, nor does it seem likely there will be one in the near future.

I am stuck in a low pay job with no hope of owning a home nor living in a reasonable quality rental property.

I cannot access help with my increasingly dire mental health as the waiting list is huge.

I live hand to mouth each month, I have no social life or treats as money doesn't permit it and have budgeted down to the last 1p. I do not have the time nor energy to 'take in ironing' , 'do matched betting' etc between kids, work and (badly) running my home.

I will be worked to death, as by the time I am old enough to draw a pension I doubt I will last all that long due to the lifestyle that poverty forces me into.

AIBU to say there is a slave class of people in our population and ask if you think this is deliberate on the part of the Government, to ensure an adequate supply of workers to feed into the machine and earn their peers big money, while keeping us so miserable or strung out on medication that we quietly comply? We are disposable, despised and unheard.
There is not the possibility of working or educating our way out of this situation as there was in the past.
I feel entirely nihilistic and numb plodding through this daily grind for the next 30 years.

OP posts:
Barbadossunset · 26/09/2021 15:29

@GettingUntrapped please answer my and a pp’s question about the revolution that you desire.
The super rich will bugger off pdq but there will be lots of rich people left.
Will you organise Stalin style ‘show trials’ or will you just shoot anyone who you think might have more money than you?

gogohm · 26/09/2021 15:26

@anothermansshoes

Doctorates in science are funded by government agencies, the places are competitive but on academic ability not parental income. You receive a decent stipend as a PhD student in stem. Exh has 2 funded PhD places each year, he has 1-2 private funded students too, usually overseas and rarely any good

gogohm · 26/09/2021 15:22

I can understand your current frustration and agree with you about the politics but you are not a slave, longer term you can change your life, it takes time, but you are in control of your destiny unlike slaves. Many of us periods in our lives where we feel we are on a conveyor belt through life with no options but there truly is. Nobody is permanently stuck in any job, it takes time but you can gain skills or qualifications to get you up the job ladder from which you can improve other parts of your life and remember kids are only young for a short time.

20 years ago I thought like you, but with kids in university I look back and realise that life was really tough but it wasn't for ever. I've since got a masters and whilst I don't personally earn a lot I have a job I love

LukeEvansWife · 26/09/2021 15:13

But having children is going to restrict choices in a lot of jobs. A lot of better paid jobs expect flexibility which of course you can't necessarily have if you have to factor in childcare.

RedRiverShore · 26/09/2021 15:00

A lot of the vacancies in hospitality and other low paid sectors are not being filled because employers are looking for the perfect candidate and there is no compromise regarding experience, hours the candidate can work, many people don't have the correct type of references, especially if they haven't worked for a while. A lot of these jobs expect you to be available 24/7 for what is often 8 hours of work a week so people can't easily get other employment at the same time or childcare. There was a thread recently where this was mentioned a lot.

Maverickess · 26/09/2021 14:46

is kept in a trap hmm people are free to make their own choices.

Yes there will always be jobs that pay less than others so less of a budget to play with but that doesn’t over ride personal responsibility if making lifestyle choices that don’t match the salary.

Firstly, you're assuming that the lowest salaries cover the no choice elements of the cost of living (admittedly assuming full time hours here), rent/mortgage, travel to and from work, council tax, water, fuel, food etc - though some of these things can be cut back on like living in a cheaper area or using less gas and electric, there's still a minimum that needs to be outlayed. And some, like council tax you can't cut back on at all.
When what comes in doesn't match what has to go out, as a minimum, that's where things start going wrong.
You're assuming that anyone on a low income can't manage because they choose a lifestyle they can't afford, which although no doubt true in some cases, isn't across the board and a forgone conclusion, unless of course you need to think that to justify why people working full time hours for minimum wage (it's not a living wage if people can't live on it, calling it that doesn't make it so) can't make ends meet and as I said in my first post, it's easier to blame someone for that, citing 'personal choice' than look at the actual reasons why it's happening.

Students, second household earners, those wanting a second job etc may be happy to pick up the hours so we wouldn’t be left with no workers just because some need to earn more money,

🤔 So where are all these students, second household earners and people wanting a second job? Why aren't they filling the 77,500 hospitality vacancies out there? Or the 76,000 hgv driver vacancies? Or the 112,000 (and rising) social care vacancies?

We have a well publicised shortage in those industries, and not caused by Brexit or Covid, those things have drawn into focus the shortfall already there and sent it from just about managing to there now being a difference seen in terms of service provided.
People are doing exactly what you suggest and going for the better paid positions because they're on offer..... And this is the result.
That doesn't change the fact that we need the services provided.

I think this is very short sighted perspective. Pay has increased and conditions have improved relentlessly for generations. You may not see much difference in your career, but generation to generation the rates of absolute and relative poverty of households in FT work is the lowest it has ever been in human history. The problem is you want pay and conditions to improve at a faster rate than society is capable of. It’s not easy to level up tens of millions of workers.

Pay and conditions have increased, but then so have expectations on employees and the cost of living, and in some cases outstripped the improved pay and conditions to result in ft working households needing things like tax credits or food banks while companies profit margins either stay the same or increase year on year. It's all about 'the needs of the business' rather than the physical needs of the people who actually keep the business going.
And to boot you get to blame them for not being aspirational enough or living beyond their means, if they don't just put up and shut up like good little skivvies.

Resilience · 26/09/2021 14:11

Flowers OP, you sound significantly depressed.

As someone who crosses paths with MH services a lot professionally, I really empathise with your situation. MH services have been chronically underfunded for so long they really only swing into action when someone is an active danger to themselves or others, anyone else just has to queue. When you're already struggling the energy required to fight this just isn't there. But please keep trying.

I think people underestimate how mentally wearing poverty can be when you're in it long term and can't see a way out. I'm well off now but I've been poor to the point of being unable to put the lights on or eat. However, I knew it was only temporary. Even so, the 4 years it took to turn my life around nearly drove me to the edge. I remember sobbing because an old friend asked me to meet for coffee and I couldn't even budget in £2 for that. When that's your daily existence, year after year, it takes a real toll, and even if there is a way out your mental strength can be too run down to search for, find and take the opportunities out.

Please keep trying with MH services and also go to CAB (or your local council can sometimes help). Make sure you're getting every break you can (e.g. Water rates can be as little as £3 pcm if you qualify). It won't change your life but it may give you enough breathing space to take stick and see what you can change. Good luck. Flowers

HarrisonStickle · 26/09/2021 13:43

You are very unreasonable to use the word slave and to consider your life akin to that of a slave.

Bonheurdupasse · 26/09/2021 13:39

Using the word slave here is offensive.

Also at least some of your outcome is due to your choices - not least reproductive choices. E.g. you might be in a different situation had you had fewer or no children.

MereDintofPandiculation · 26/09/2021 13:36

Job choices, hours worked, number of children etc are down to the adult. that's very much not true. An increasing number of areas are closed to those not able to afford an unpaid work experience period. The importance of connections in your chosen area cannot be overstated. Even hours worked is a problem - many jobs at the bottom end are "flexible" - ie you are contracted for, say, 16 hours, but expected to be on call 16 hours a day, 7 days a week - if you turn down offers for extra hours you very soon won't get offered any. And this flexibility for the employer makes it hard for you to take on another fixed hours contract to make up a full working week. I grant that children are a choice but do we really want a society where only the well-off can have children?

sjxoxo · 26/09/2021 13:33

YANBU. I agree 1000000% with the pp who said labour should allow an alternative party if they cannot get their act together. IMO there will be a new party emerge fairly soon as within a few years there will be literally zero opposition and people will not stand for it anymore. I think there is a serious lack of political understanding and education in our schools and therefore people do not understand how the system works.

My advice to you personally would be to try and see if you can find another job. You may well be able to. It’s a small thing, it’s unfair but the only way you can change your day to day life in the current climate is to change your job. Don’t give up on trying that as this is something you can change, but I know that’s not easy but you can try and find something better that will give you some more money. Life is a struggle you are right but please don’t give up hope- find hope in small steps you can take, in the long term it will change the future for you. Good luck xxxx

Seasidemumma77 · 26/09/2021 13:30

Perfectly put @maverickess

Stompythedinosaur · 26/09/2021 13:23

I work with women and children who are subject to modern slavery. You have no idea what it is to be a slave.

I agree the situation for some people in our country is awful though.

LukeEvansWife · 26/09/2021 13:21

Oh and slaves don't have access to Internet forums to complain about it

spotcheck · 26/09/2021 13:20

@user1473878824

I think using the word slave here is actually quite offensive when we have an actual problem with people being trafficked and used as actual slaves.
I agree.

OP

What is the biggest barrier to earning more?
Is it childcare constraints? ( Which will ease)
Do you need additional training?

LukeEvansWife · 26/09/2021 13:17

The word slave is inaccurate and offensive.

Ironically that makes you look privileged if you think that being poor is the same, you are so wrong. Do you belong to anyone? Do you get beaten if you don't do your job? Can you be sold? Are you so terrified by consequences that you don't dare step out of line? Are you forced to work for no pay at all?

Thought not.

PlanDeRaccordement · 26/09/2021 13:16

It's far cheaper and simpler to keep people in a trap, and blame them for it, than to look at the overall problem and increase the pay and conditions for these jobs, and acknowledge that they're essential and necessary for society to function.

I think this is very short sighted perspective. Pay has increased and conditions have improved relentlessly for generations. You may not see much difference in your career, but generation to generation the rates of absolute and relative poverty of households in FT work is the lowest it has ever been in human history. The problem is you want pay and conditions to improve at a faster rate than society is capable of. It’s not easy to level up tens of millions of workers.

VladmirsPoutine · 26/09/2021 13:12

@Maverickess That was such a well written post and I agree with every word of it.

IceCreamAndCandyfloss · 26/09/2021 13:03

Nobody is kept in a trap Hmm people are free to make their own choices.

Yes there will always be jobs that pay less than others so less of a budget to play with but that doesn’t over ride personal responsibility if making lifestyle choices that don’t match the salary.

Students, second household earners, those wanting a second job etc may be happy to pick up the hours so we wouldn’t be left with no workers just because some need to earn more money,

Maverickess · 26/09/2021 12:43

I too think slave is the wrong term, but I do agree with the sentiment of your post totally.

I've described myself, as a care assistant, as society's skivvy before, because it's how I feel we're treated. I'm not a slave because I don't live under those conditions, but obviously there's an incentive to keep me doing the job I do, and others who do similar jobs under similar conditions, because we're essential to supporting the rest of society. Without the people at the bottom of the ladder holding it up, the whole thing comes down.

Yet, if you bring up you can't afford to live, barely survive on the pay you get, the 'get a better job' brigade start talking about personal choices, and I'd bet some of them rely on the services provided of the low paid to enable them to actually be able to do their better jobs in the first place.

While me, or you OP, getting a better job will improve our individual circumstances, someone else will need to fill the role we currently do under the same conditions, which solves nothing and shunts the problem onto someone else, and when there's no one else, because they don't want to, or can't afford to work under those conditions we start having issues like people not getting care who need it because there's no one to provide it, or empty shelves because there's no one to deliver the food, or not being able to go out for a meal because the restaurant needs to close early due to lack of staff.
So when it starts affecting those who have a voice, suddenly it's a problem, and people demand something is done, so we get things like a rise in NI.
Keeping people in low paid, but essential roles benefits society, and everyone knows this really, but some don't like to admit that. Because we're all in some ways, part of the problem.
The opportunity to better yourself is open to anyone, to a certain degree, but it can't be open to everyone, because then who's going to do the jobs that need doing like driving the trucks or caring for the elderly if everyone has moved on to a better job?

Of course there's an incentive for government and society to keep us where we are, it means that these services are provided as cheaply as possible, yet they are still available to be used by those who need and want them, that in someway benefit their own lives.
It's far cheaper and simpler to keep people in a trap, and blame them for it, than to look at the overall problem and increase the pay and conditions for these jobs, and acknowledge that they're essential and necessary for society to function.

AICM · 26/09/2021 12:43

@GettingUntrapped

You have a point. Also about medication -antidepressants - propping people up, yet not solving much about their unsatisfying lives. We need a revolution, but not many have the strength or awareness.
How do we decide who runs the country after the revolution?
PattyPan · 26/09/2021 12:38

There is a slave class, of actual slaves. Being in poverty is obviously bad but is not comparable. Yabu.

VladmirsPoutine · 26/09/2021 12:37

I understand and agree with the use of the word "slave" in this context is completely uncalled for and outrageous.

noprofessional · 26/09/2021 12:30

You want to get yourself a book or do some googling and find out what actual slavery is. People are still being trafficked right now. Get a grip.

PlanDeRaccordement · 26/09/2021 12:28

Actually there isn't much of a difference between a poor person and a slave.

This is so offensive. Poor people get paid for their labour and their pay cannot go below a legal minimum. Poor people are not forbidden to be literate, but can pursue an education with full student finance to fund it. Poor people cannot be legally raped, killed or subjected to extreme punishments or mutilation at a whim. Poor people can marry and have the comfort of a family, slaves cannot. Slaves can be “bred” like livestock forced to birth new slave “stock” for their master/mistress. Poor people cannot be sold on to new owners, they have the freedom to choose where to live and who to work for. Poor people can flee as refugees and get asylum in another country, slaves that “run away” are either captured and sent back to their owners or hunted down and killed like an animal. Poor people can refuse to be used as guinea pigs in scientific experimentation, slaves cannot and were often used in such a manner. Poor people can keep their organs, slaves get their organs harvested and sold off, sometimes owners would rather get the money for a slaves organs than resell or keep the slave so these people are literally killed and their organs harvested and sold off.

Swipe left for the next trending thread