Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Don’t know what to say about my best friend’ crappy husbands?

58 replies

SquarePeggyLeggy · 25/09/2021 22:48

I have two really close, life long friends who I adore. They are clever, hard working successful women who are wonderful mothers.
My closest friend, we talk every day and have for almost 30 years, doesn’t have a great husband. He’s fine, not actively a bad man, but he is selfish. We are in lockdown, they both work full time, but he states his job is stressful so locks himself in the home office and doesn’t come out, leaving all domestic duties, home school and work to her. We had a wine zoom planned, she couldn’t commit because she couldn’t ask him to put their kids to bed. On a Saturday at 8:30pm.
My other friends husband is the same but he also drinks too much and writes himself off for the next day meaning she also has to cancel plans whenever he is supposed to be supervising the kids, or has to bring them to places because he’s in bed hungover.

These women are not happy or respected by their partners. But they also accept it and want to talk about how annoyed they are with them and how unfair it is. But would never leave them. I find these conversations so hard to take.

My husband isn’t like this. We both do the chores, we both feel completely comfortable when the other has the kids. I think that is normal and how adults should be. We aren’t perfect of course but it doesn’t feel unfair.

I don’t know what to say to my friends when they start complaining. I feel enraged at what they’re putting up with and I find it hard to not say something that would damage our friendship (like: “your husband is a dick!”).

So I don’t say anything and just get off the phone. But then I want them to feel supported. They’ve both invited us to go on holiday with them as families. I do not want to spend time with their husbands and the dynamic that they have as glorified domestic slaves.

AIBU to not be more supportive? I find the way that sometimes groups of women get to the complaining about their husbands part of the conversation very depressing.

OP posts:
EmeraldShamrock · 26/09/2021 08:11

It's sad how so many women are brainwashed in marriage when it comes to looking after the DC.
You really can't say anything even if they ask you, they're not going to dump them on your advice only cause a rift in the friendship.

Phineyj · 26/09/2021 08:11

I think like attracts like. So if you have an equal relationship you will probably have/attract friends who do too. Also your family may have role modelled this for you.

I have seen comments like nana's on here before and while I don't disbelieve them, my experience is that there are many many relationships like the OP's friends' and very few like the OPs'.

I have an equal-ish relationship but it takes a lot of work to keep it so and I can't say I can look to any other relationship at all as a role model. I am nearly 50, educated, in a professional career. I have not met one other couple with a genuinely equal division of labour. Even when the men are "hands-on", it is always, always the woman doing the thinking ahead.

Actually that's not true. I do know a few gay couples without this power imbalance.

FirewomanSam · 26/09/2021 08:11

Your description of your first friend describes one of my friends to a tee. They might even be the same person. It’s so depressing. Every few months she will come to me upset about the same things but I know she will never ever leave him.

I saw an article recently by a relationship therapist which said that men (and women) have been brought up to think that a stressed out, disgruntled, unsatisfied, ‘nagging’ wife is normal, which is why conversations with these kinds of husbands never seem to make a difference. Look at pretty much any sitcom and any number of TV shows (Marge Simpson immediately springs to mind) and you’ll find the dynamic between useless husbands and long-suffering wives played for laughs. These kinds of people think an unhappy wife is just how marriage is.

I’m in a Facebook group with hundreds of women for a hobby of mine, and once a woman posted an off-topic post moaning about her husband. Cue dozens of sympathetic posts from other women about how their husbands just ‘don’t see mess’ or ‘he’ll help out if I ask him but I have to leave him exact instructions’ or ‘I let him do the laundry once and he turned everything pink, haha what are they like!’. I was one of two or three women who piped up to say this wasn’t acceptable and that I would be decidedly unimpressed if my husband was this lazy and incompetent (thankfully he isn’t!) but it fell on deaf ears.

All we can do is to keep pointing out that it’s not OK and try to non-smugly make it clear that our own husbands don’t act like this, to try to drive home that it’s not how all marriages are. But when it gets too much I think it’s ok to gently say ‘I’m sorry, I can’t listen to this any more right now, I am getting too upset for you’ and hopefully that might make them think too.

Mynextname · 26/09/2021 08:08

@Nanananani perhaps it is an area, class and cultural thing too. The area I currently live in there seems to be many more men that do their bit but still not the majority although they do tend to work full time (middle class area).

The area I grew up in and I am still connected to (deprived council estate), I don't know of a single man that does the housework or regularly watches their own kids. Most of the women feel relieved if their partners get a part time job.

Goldbar · 26/09/2021 08:07

@Nanananani. It's not nonsense. If you look at the UK figures, women took on the bulk of homeschooling and chores during lockdown.

This is so much more than an issue with individual men. Pretending that it is a problem confined to a few 'bad apples' does women a disservice because it implies that they could have avoided it by choosing a partner more wisely.

JetRocket · 26/09/2021 07:58

I would call it out. I couldn’t stop myself.

‘Honestly X your DH is a total shit and I haven’t a clue why you just put up with it and accept it. There are lots of men who pull their weight and manage to work and actually parent, they aren’t magical unicorns. Your DH is just totally SHIT but at this point you’re kind of enabling him by staying with him so either leave him or stop complaining about it.’

However, I should add I don’t have many long term (10 year+) friends and I suspect my saying things like this is why.

Nanananani · 26/09/2021 07:57

Total nonsense! Peddling that kind of shut is what keeps women in relationships with useless men. There are PLENTY of men out there who pull their weight. Of all of the couples I know I’d say at least 80% of them do and almost all of them do way more than OPs friends husband who would be better with even 70:30 than the 99:1 situation she’s in now

Goldbar · 26/09/2021 07:51

I agree with @Mynextname. The majority of men exploit women to some degree. If you have a relationship where it is truly 50/50, then that's fab for you, but ime most men don't pull their weight. So, yes, your friends' husbands sound shit, but it's not necessarily the case that they could have chosen a relationship with someone who did pull their weight equally as there aren't many men out there who do.

And of course the inequalities in relationships often don't become apparent until after you have children. Then the women faces an unpalatable choice...put up with it or break up the family and become a single parent (which is hard!!!). It's not surprising that some women choose to put up with husbands who are just a bit shit (as opposed to actively unpleasant and abusive), especially as getting the financials and logistical arrangements in place for Ieaving can feel like an uphill struggle if you're already doing everything. When are they meant to organise their exit? Maybe your friends are biding their time until the kids are older. One human being can only deal with so much.

Dontforgetyourbrolly · 26/09/2021 07:46

I have a friend who oh is a complete twat who controls her , tbh I don't see her much these days and it makes me feel glad I'm single!
Definitely don't go on holiday with them and next time they complain suggest if they are that bad why are they with them then ? If they are not going to do anything about it then quit complaining.

chocolateorangeinhaler · 26/09/2021 07:40

Nothing you can say. Your not a counselor and it's unfair of them to treat you as one. They are being martyrs, they could leave, divorce, whatever but choose not to.

Hubby a workaholic and doesn't spend all way washing the nets and scrubbing the floor then hire a bloody cleaner.

Other hubby goes on a bender. So don't plan any social events the next day.

I think they just enjoy moaning at you. Moaning and complaining is a habit that some don't realize they are doing.

There is an old book called 'feel the fear and do it anyway' by Susan jeffers that describes this exact behavior. Worth a read.

Heatherjayne1972 · 26/09/2021 07:36

Sometimes both partners believe this is normal
He works
She does everything else and works
If that’s how you were brought up you’d believe this is normal too

Alifemadelessordinary · 26/09/2021 07:25

You're not being unreasonable at all.
My oldest, best friend is in an awful relationship. It's really quite draining offering her the same advice every time we speak. I've had to become a little bit more distant recently as I was so worried it was affecting my own mental health and as I'm pregnant I had to put myself and my baby first.
I've told her that she deserves better, that her children deserve better, that my door would always be open for her and the kids to stay as long as they needed, should she need/want to get out in a hurry.
It's so difficult and I can already see the kids picking up on the way he speaks to her.

Beenheresincethebook · 26/09/2021 07:25

Yanbu by not being more supportive there isn’t much you can do except as another pp said ; maybe rephrase the “ why don’t you leave” to “ I would be here to help if you did” .

I am the woman in the relationship. To a shitty Abusive lazy dh. I don’t leave because I feel like I can’t. Kids/finances/ would never escape him properly anyway and would still have constant grief so what’s the point. I’m sure your friends probably WANT to leave and resent it all every day. I will leave once kids have grown up hopefully your friends will too but they most likely feel trapped and that’s why just putting up with it.

I try not to moan about it too much as my friends see it from your perspective- why don’t I just leave. But it’s not that simple.

Your a great friend for caring about them and still listening to it all the time , i can see why it’s irritating from your side too

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 26/09/2021 07:23

They make comments about how I’m lucky, or my husband is such a great husband. He is a good husband! But so should every husband be

I've had the lucky comments made to me too. I just respond along the lines of "it's nice you think that, but I think it's more that some people are unlucky. I've just got a husband who does his fair share"

MoiraNotRuby · 26/09/2021 07:22

This is such an interesting thread. I am in process of separating from my husband who is very much like your friends DHs but likes to put on a different public persona.

For the sake of the kids we are being amicable (she says through extremely gritted teeth) and not saying anything negative about each other.

Our wider friendship circle/acquaintances are 'shocked and sad' and will 'be there for both of us' etc etc. And just can't believe it.

My close friends that I have confided in, and know the truth of it all, are overjoyed and being so emotionally and practically supportive, I feel more loved/safe/held/protected than I have in a long time.

OP I know the moans from your friends are hard for you to hear. But the longer you are a shoulder to cry on, you are giving strength and support which will hopefully build for your friends like it did for me.

Good luck.

Lockeddownagain · 26/09/2021 07:17

When I started going to baby groups I was utterly shocked and the amount or women that have to put up with that crap. My husband was working and keeping me alive at the start of parenthood.
He works long hours and I do most of the chores but I work less I had an accident recently and couldn't even dress myself for weeks he had done everything.

I remember really struggling with this and I think one day I just said why do you do it all?
I've worked with women ehos husband done even give them a birthday card but except this on their bday
I know women who can't go out because their husbands can't be with the kids.
If I was you I'd say look I hate this you are my best friend and I can't take how u are being treated be honest its so tough

Getyourownback · 26/09/2021 07:10

I’d be tempted to go on the holiday just to see if the husbands behave as selfishly as they have always done and so somehow your equal relationship throws theirs into sharp relief. The scales might just fall away from somebody’s eyes. Might not be the most fun holiday ever though and would use up valuable leave.

LouLou789 · 26/09/2021 07:02

Firstly, do not go on holiday with them! Maybe saying “no” to that is the way to open a conversation about the relationship? I agree it’s not as easy as saying “Well, just leave him” but there’s something about helping them to see that it’s not that there’s no choice, and that staying, or not forcing the issues with their partners, constitutes a “choice” in itself. And of course, it’s up to them: they may each feel that the reasons for not leaving (kids, money, somewhere to live) far outweigh the reasons for doing so.

The constant complaining would wear me down, OP. Keeping communication going is a way of making sure either/both of these women feel supported if they decide to make big changes/LTBs but it depends how long you can stand it. YANBU.

MultiStorey · 26/09/2021 06:59

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Mynextname · 26/09/2021 06:51

The thing is though so many men have grown up in a world where their rights have been deemed more important than women. So yes there are men around who do their fair share but there are probably more men around who don't. Why are we blaming women for this? Yes, you could say well it's up to them to leave but the reality is if women ever want a relationship or a family then a huge majority of them in society will end up putting up with this behaviour.

Also, sometimes the behaviour only becomes more amplified once children are brought into the mix or perhaps these decisions have been made at a young age when they haven't had much guidance in life. Once children come along it isn't easy to leave for all kinds of reasons. Then, what happens if a women does leave, she is the one facing the stigma of being a single parent and let's face it her practical situation still wouldn't be much better either.

We can blame women all we like for putting up with this, is it really their fault though if they try to work through these situations and the men choose not to corporate. For most women it is a lose lose situation.

Men doing their fair share shouldn't be seen as lucky, but unfortunately in the world we live in it is.

Just listen to your friends. That's what friends are for. Even if you have heard it all before. One day they maybe the ones who are picking up the pieces in your life.

Mistyplanet · 26/09/2021 06:47

Agree with parrotonthesofa. There might be alot of reasons they cant easily leave. I think you need to be patient with listening to the stories. One day they might get the courage to leave but they obviously dont have the strength right now and its easy to say from the outside looking in what someone should do when you haven't walked in their shoes.

UnsuitableHat · 26/09/2021 06:46

I have a friend whose partner I think is abusive - sits around at home whilst she does everything, discourages her from working then calls her ‘lazy’ and occasionally cheats then blames her. it’s awful for her self esteem, but ultimately she’s made her own decisions about the relationship. I think there has to be a point where you step back, or just listen rather than giving opinion - to preserve your own friendship as much as anything else. However I think you’d be right not to go on holiday with them.

parrotonthesofa · 26/09/2021 06:31

I think it's not as simple as why don't they just leave.
Be happy that you're not in that relationship.

Porridgealert · 26/09/2021 06:02

I don't know why people get angry with these women. They're capable of making decisions and they've made them. If it were my friend (and it has been!), I would say, if you're not happy leave him because he is a selfish arse. If she chooses not to do that, I would say, I've given you my advice so I don't want to discuss your husband or marriage anymore. Then you have to let it go. Intelligent, grown women are responsible for their own lives. Of course if they later approach and need support to leave, I'd be there to help as much as I could.

SquarePeggyLeggy · 26/09/2021 05:39

I just suggested they could benefit from counselling. I said I can tell she hasn’t been happy for a while and they might need help to communicate. She didn’t say anything but there wasn’t a blow out either.

OP posts: