Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Don’t know what to say about my best friend’ crappy husbands?

58 replies

SquarePeggyLeggy · 25/09/2021 22:48

I have two really close, life long friends who I adore. They are clever, hard working successful women who are wonderful mothers.
My closest friend, we talk every day and have for almost 30 years, doesn’t have a great husband. He’s fine, not actively a bad man, but he is selfish. We are in lockdown, they both work full time, but he states his job is stressful so locks himself in the home office and doesn’t come out, leaving all domestic duties, home school and work to her. We had a wine zoom planned, she couldn’t commit because she couldn’t ask him to put their kids to bed. On a Saturday at 8:30pm.
My other friends husband is the same but he also drinks too much and writes himself off for the next day meaning she also has to cancel plans whenever he is supposed to be supervising the kids, or has to bring them to places because he’s in bed hungover.

These women are not happy or respected by their partners. But they also accept it and want to talk about how annoyed they are with them and how unfair it is. But would never leave them. I find these conversations so hard to take.

My husband isn’t like this. We both do the chores, we both feel completely comfortable when the other has the kids. I think that is normal and how adults should be. We aren’t perfect of course but it doesn’t feel unfair.

I don’t know what to say to my friends when they start complaining. I feel enraged at what they’re putting up with and I find it hard to not say something that would damage our friendship (like: “your husband is a dick!”).

So I don’t say anything and just get off the phone. But then I want them to feel supported. They’ve both invited us to go on holiday with them as families. I do not want to spend time with their husbands and the dynamic that they have as glorified domestic slaves.

AIBU to not be more supportive? I find the way that sometimes groups of women get to the complaining about their husbands part of the conversation very depressing.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
JoeyMuzzo · 28/09/2021 16:03

And I probably said this, but most importantly, don't go into the conversation already knowing the best course of action. She knows herself and her husband better than you do, even if you feel very confident you know what's best for her. As a friend, your job is just to give her space to explore and choose her course.

JoeyMuzzo · 28/09/2021 16:00

I would suggest reading about motivational interviewing to help you in your interactions with your friends. There are videos on youtube.
Your friends sound pre-contemplative, they are not even thinking about taking action and feel hopeless things can change. At this stage, you just want to try to shift them to the next stage on the wheel which is contemplation (after contemplation, then you will do the strategies to shift them to the next stage and so on. People don't just go from pre-contemplative to action). So how do you get someone to go from pre-contemplative to contemplative? You want to ask them questions with a genuinely curiosity and a non-judgemental voice. For example

  • you have said in previous conversations that you would never leave him and that it's not worth bringing the topic up. What would be the signs for you that things were serious enough that you had to talk to him about it, even if that would lead to unrest in the house?
  • if you just keep things the way they are, what do you think will happen? Could you sustain it?
  • what do you like about keeping things this way? (by contrasting this with the next question about the downside, they may realize the benefits of staying the same do not outweigh the costs). When they say the benefits just agree eg. ""yes, I can see how keeping the house peaceful and getting jobs done properly would be appealing. What else is good about just keeping it the way it is?" When they can't tink of anything else, ask whats not so good about keeping things the way they are?
  • do you think that the situation is ok or do you think something needs to change? (If they say something needs to change, follow up with ""what do you think needs to change" if they say ""he needs to help more"" ask "what things does he need to do/how do you think you will approach the conversation with him". Ask don't tell, they know the answers already or will find them if you give them quiet space to think. If they answer "i don't know"" you have actually struck gold! Because you are bringing their awareness to something they have been too busy to pause and contemplate. Don't jump in! reply in a kind voice "if it's something you haven't had time to think about, maybe take a few minutes now to think about what might be a solution?"".
  • don't come at them as an expert, have humility, perhaps the decision they make to suck it up IS the best outcome, be open to that but also help them explore it
  • ask what they think the next step would be
  • ask what the situation has prevented them from doing
  • ask what she has tried in the past to rectify the situation (again, don't suggest your own, they are smart and it's much better if you let them come up with solutions. Anything you suggest will be shot down trust me)
  • raise awareness and doubt through your questions
  • you might even ask "are you worried how observing this status quo may impact your children when they are adults". If they say "I hope my daughter doesn't follow my footsteps and end up in this situation, it's a perfect opportunity to ask "if she did, what advice would you give her".
Good luck.
shivawn · 26/09/2021 12:55

Sounds like a crappy situation for your friends. I guess my friends circle is very lucky in that they all have great supportive relationships. Most of my husband and I's closest friends are mutual and are couples so we'd hang out in groups and go on double dates and weekends away often. I guess we just gravitate towards people similar to ourselves. I'd be very good friends with most of my friends husbands. I would find it really awkward if either side of one couple started bashing the other.

Macncheeseballs · 26/09/2021 12:19

Go on holiday with them and shame the bastards every time

Apricotblue · 26/09/2021 12:14

It’s definitely a can’t do right situation but be careful that they aren’t using the DHs as an excuse to cancel at short notice. I’ve seen friends do this to other people, they say ‘oh I’ll just say my husband can’t look after the kids’ and then it into a bit of a useless DH joke. If you know they are genuinely lazy rubbish DHs I just talk about ex’s I’d ditched for being the same or other mutual friend who have a crap DH so I’m sympathising without mentioning my DP.

Youdoyoutoday · 26/09/2021 09:31

Same here. I go out for dinner with my friends and they start the husband bashing part of the evening and I can't join in because I have nothing to complain about, my DP is wonderful, helpful, kind and caring. I find it awful they put up with such crap from their husbands.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 26/09/2021 09:11

I know plenty of women that do more than their share of home stuff, but for a man to refuse to get involved at home to the point where they wont put their own kids to bed once a week is genuinely awful! And it shows how downtrodden she is that she thinks that women who are with men that do this kind of thing are 'lucky'.

I'd be honest about the holiday. No you dont want to go and live with someone even for a week that refuses to do his share as you will struggle not to say something and you dont want to fall out. Or from what she has said, she will be doing everything and you wont even see her so what's the point. Or the way she has described her husband at home has put you off etc.

I think telling people to leave wont work. Asking questions might though. How do you feel about that? Do you think thats fair? How do you think the kids feel about their dad never putting them to bed / treating their mum like that? What do you think they are learning about relationships? Have you looked into benefits / maintenance calculator/ solicitor in case you ever do decide to leave? How do you think your life would be different if he wasn't around etc? Not all at once but if the subject comes up.

lottiegarbanzo · 26/09/2021 09:06

Can I drill into that a bit TintinIsBack ? If a friend merely pointed out that her home life was different from yours, so she wasn't quite sure what to say about yours, you would think you had a lost a friend?

Do you expect all your friends' lives to be exactly the same as yours?

Do you expect friends to agree with you unwaveringly and back you up on everything you think and do, even when you're obviously wrong, never questioning gently why you might have made a particular choice? (This seems to be a common model of friendship, the 'you're so right', 'your bubz your rules' type) but I don't think it's actually very friendly, supportive or helpful.

Do you recognise that if you don't know that her life is different from yours and how, you're in no position to be a good friend to her? You can't listen openly and offer thoughts on her situation, because you'll only really be talking about your own. You might do unhelpful things like calling her lucky, when she wants to vent?

In both cases, a bit of listening and understanding, a bit of critical commentary, could be helpful, couldn't it?

I find that people like OP's friends, miserable people generally, become very self-absorbed and only able to talk about themselves. They become a drain, not a friend.

dottiedodah · 26/09/2021 09:00

I hear you.however I think society is still so skewed towards couples and families, that many women accept this shit . They often feel unable to leave for financial reasons ,or feel they are breaking up the family .we have often been conditioned to put ourselves and our happiness last. I would say to be there for your chums but realise its not always as simple as ltb sadly

lottiegarbanzo · 26/09/2021 08:56

I had this experience in one group I was in. Half the women going 'oh aren't men useless' and agreeing with each other, the other half thinking 'no they're not' and letting that sub-group get on with it.

I think it is important to say out loud 'that's not how it works in our house, we take turns doing x, y, z' so that that example exists for the others. But gloating or sounding superior about it would not help.

Onlinedilema · 26/09/2021 08:56

I agree with Mynextname
It's not easy being a single parent, the majority of single mothers are viewed in a negative light whereas a single father is held in high regard for doing basic caring for his child.
I work with lots of married mothers.
During the pandemic and the whole home schooling debacle, the only women who did not ring in work saying they could not come in and needed time off were management. Even then some of them had th he get out of jail card if working from home. Ever other woman had to take emergency time odd to sort out their kids. Did their husbands? Hell no, their job was far too important.
There are numerous threads on here about child care and whenever it is suggested the child's father actually looks after their own child, it's met with a tumbleweed response.
Op- I would let them know their marriages are flawed just comment on one aspect. Let the thought sink in with your friends that their relationships are far from ideal.

TintinIsBack · 26/09/2021 08:54

@lottiegarbanzo

I think you need to be honest, gently and factually, as you have been here. Say that you find it difficult to know what to say, as you can see her husband is lazy and selfish and is not going to change.

Say that your home life is not like that, so you're not able to offer like-minded commiserations, though you do feel sympathetic towards her and recognise that she's having a difficult time.

Say that you don't want to go on holiday with them, because you don't like her husband's selfishness and the way he expects her to do everything and being around that behaviour would make you angry and uncomfortable which is the opposite of being able to relax.

If you were expected to join in with a 'women do all the domestic work' dynamic (a self-catering holiday? women putting kids to bed while dads relax? men doing their own thing in the day, while women run a kids club?) you and your DH wouldn't play ball. How would that make her and her DH feel?

You can be honest without being unkind. Especially if you talk about your own feelings, less so your experiences, which could sound like gloating.

If someone had talked to me like that, I would have assumed I had lost a good friend and sharing my issues wasn't welcome.

I. have been on both sides of that situation. In. the. OP’s place, the first thing to do is to stop solving issues for the friend and to stop judging.
The way they organise their life isn’t her problem and shouldn’t have an impact if it doesn’t also mean she and her DH are expected to behave the same way.

2Hot2Handle · 26/09/2021 08:47

@Mynextname that’s brilliant advice and insight. I completely agree with you.
Most of my friends, myself included, are in marriages or relationships with men, who don’t do their fair share of domestic chores and childcare, even though their wives work too. Venting to our friends, while seemingly disloyal to our partners, is a way to validate our feelings, where a partner may be dismissing them, to feel like we have backup and support, and to understand that we’re not alone. After these kind of chats with friends, I often feel a lot better and happier with my lot in life. I don’t want to leave my husband and raise my son in a single family. We have many happy days together. It is frustrating to be so unequal, but I work at us and myself everyday to make the balance more equal.
Looking around at all the couples I know, I’d be hard pressed to find a better situation.
Perhaps what you have is rarer than you think and you should feel blessed. Show compassion to your friends. Duck out of conversations that you don’t feel you can be a part of.

TintinIsBack · 26/09/2021 08:47

If leaving a relationship was as easy as ‘he is a dick. I’m kicking him out ‘ there would be no need for a relationship threads on MN.

From my own personal experience of not leaving a crap relationship, they need individual counselling, not couple counselling.
Thé issues here are varied and can. include fear, lack of self esteem, unhelpful views on divorce, pressure. from family etc etc.
They might also need someone to acknowledge that the way they see things is ok.
Eg Yes, I agree. When he is doing xxxx, it’s unacceptable.
My own experience is that people staying silent meant i thought they were actually thinking I was over. reacting. I needed to hear someone telling me I had good grounds to be upset.

Fleshmechanic · 26/09/2021 08:44

I can't believe the stereotype of marriage is "the ball and chain" and hating each other. How is that normal 😂

lottiegarbanzo · 26/09/2021 08:44

I think you need to be honest, gently and factually, as you have been here. Say that you find it difficult to know what to say, as you can see her husband is lazy and selfish and is not going to change.

Say that your home life is not like that, so you're not able to offer like-minded commiserations, though you do feel sympathetic towards her and recognise that she's having a difficult time.

Say that you don't want to go on holiday with them, because you don't like her husband's selfishness and the way he expects her to do everything and being around that behaviour would make you angry and uncomfortable which is the opposite of being able to relax.

If you were expected to join in with a 'women do all the domestic work' dynamic (a self-catering holiday? women putting kids to bed while dads relax? men doing their own thing in the day, while women run a kids club?) you and your DH wouldn't play ball. How would that make her and her DH feel?

You can be honest without being unkind. Especially if you talk about your own feelings, less so your experiences, which could sound like gloating.

Fleshmechanic · 26/09/2021 08:43

It sounds like they just want to vent and don't want any solutions. So all you need to do is be a listening ear. But it's obviously hard to swallow that kind of bullshit. I also have an incredible partner, incredible in comparison to other shit men lol. Like you say, the bar seems so low for a lot of people that he's practically a god compared to those ignorant, misogynistic, selfish, low key abusive types.

WendyYourExcellency · 26/09/2021 08:34

My close friend once told me her partner called her names when they argued, and added she thought it was normal. I said no, I don’t think that’s normal or acceptable, do you? She didn’t of course, and eventually left him, but I know she found that challenge helpful in making her decision.

I don’t think it’s my job as a friend never to challenge and I always will when I can, kindly and with support. I would ask your friend ‘how does it feel when he shuts himself away/you do bedtimes every day’ etc. There can be a horrible imbalance and we can support our friends to come to terms with this themselves.

Also - I was invited on holiday with a family like this and refused being totally honest with them, i said ‘I like you very much and our kids get on well but your husband can boss you around and demean you and I don’t want to be around that, happy to go away with just you and kids.’

peridito · 26/09/2021 08:32

Mmm - when I moan my friend says to me "well he's not going to change is he ? "

Nothing's going to change until you change it.

I think a lot of people have low self esteem and few aspirations .Coping with a selfish,unloving partner sadly gives them a role to play and a purpose in life .

Phineyj · 26/09/2021 08:23

nana it just all seems 'just the way it is' doesn't it? It 'makes sense' for the women to do more homeschooling because they work pt. It 'makes sense' for them to work pt because 'he earns so much more' or 'childcare is so expensive'. It 'makes sense' for her to do XYZ task because 'she's good at it/knows where it is/the school phoned her/he's so busy at work'.

No-one will blame him. Plenty of people will blame her.

It is fecking exhausting fighting the patriarchy!

Auroreforet · 26/09/2021 08:22

I think a lot of men would not bother having dc and see them as their wife's choice and therefore responsibility.
My dh was raised by a very old fashioned dm who thought women kept the house and men dug the garden.
However he was and is a very hands on df and dgf. He happily cooks and probably does more in the home now than I do.
Men don't have to perpetuate stereotypes.
My dh chose to be a different/better type of husband.

ThinWomansBrain · 26/09/2021 08:22

I had a friend that whinged constantly
Issues with abusve daughter - listened patiently for years, gave advice & trips to hospital when needed. (I did get a bit irked when once she'd moved out and the violence finally stopped, she miraculously became the brilliant perfect daughter that could do not wrong).
Issues with workplace that she kept repeating with one role after another? Eventually just used to change the subject - would listen on repeat a couple of times with each new role, then change the subject & not engage.

If they want to whinge about their partners, change the subject & move on.

workwoes123 · 26/09/2021 08:17

I’m just n a similar position with a couple of friends OP. One of them is married to a selfish alcoholic, the other to an emotionally stunted bully. Neither are in a position to leave.

I just try to bring a little lightness to their lives, though I do sometimes feel like I’m partly enabling them to stay put in these crappy situations because I don’t raise it unless they do. It’s definitely put a damper on our friendships - their crappy marriages become the elephant in the room: what’s the point in talking about holidays or plans or whatever, when we both know her husband's pissed at home every day from lunchtime onwards, and all her energy goes towards protecting the kids and trying to do the work of two parents? Neither of them do that «aren’t men hopeless?» complaining thing, both of them know this isn’t normal.

Idk. I love and value my friends, I try to just keep off the subject until they raise it. I don’t lie about my own (gem of a) husband and pretend he’s bad in some way though.

notanothertakeaway · 26/09/2021 08:15

Relationships are complicated

My friend often talks about her lazy arse of a husband. But she doesn't want to leave. So I nod and smile, and listen. I think she just wants to vent

Nanananani · 26/09/2021 08:12

Maybe their is a socio economic element I hadn’t thought through. And I didn’t mean 50:50 of every specific task, just 50:50 as a whole. Yes many women did more homeschooling but for those I knew that’s because the worked part time or we furloughed. For the majority of our friends both partners work full time and shared the burden in a way that suited them.

Swipe left for the next trending thread