Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the NHS isn’t fit for purpose?

197 replies

BrendaBubbles · 25/09/2021 21:14

There’s a story on Mail Online right now about a woman with breathing difficulties who was left on hold for hours with her GP who died during the call. There have been a lot of stories recently about people with cancer that wasn’t picked up due to resource limits and a DH of a friend of mine has been told there is a six month waiting list for an MRI.

I know the people in the NHS are true gold but despite record amounts of money the service is getting worse. It was also in the news earlier that the number of people seen at A&E within four hours was 95% in 2010 and has fallen to 67% now and I’m sure we’ve all felt this when we’ve attended ourselves.

It’s clearly not just about money but is the NHS even fit for purpose now when people are dying through simple negligence and lack of reasonable diagnosis and in person access to GPs?

OP posts:
Minfilia · 26/09/2021 10:14

YANBU.

It’s a fucking shit show.

I couldn’t get a 2 week cancer referral as the appointments didn’t exist anywhere in the region so I had to go private.

My autistic brother was left for 9 hours on a hospital waiting bench with no food or water because he had to transfer to another hospital (epilepsy and a head injury) but they wouldn’t let me take him the ten minute journey in the car!

I can’t get a GP appointment for my DD so tomorrow I’m going to have to go private for that too.

It’s a disgrace.

applesapplesapples · 26/09/2021 10:13

Stopped reading after “Mail Online”.

TheKeatingFive · 26/09/2021 10:12

I think perhaps the more pertinent question is what is (and what should be) the purpose of the NHS in the first place. I think that people expect it to cover everything (and the expectations placed on it widens every day) and it really wasn't set up to cover such a vast array of services. Nor does it have the funding to do so. I think there is an argument for a slimmed down NHS which can then allow it to concentrate its funding and resources into more essential services.

This. Excellent post.

It’s totally unrealistic to expect all the services at the price we’re paying for them.

So is there appetite to pay more? And if not, what should we prioritise?

stairway · 26/09/2021 10:10

Katyppp they shouldn’t be using trained nurses to stand at the door asking people to gel hands. That is a waste of resources. I also think sending an old man to A and E for a blood transfusion was a bad idea, he should have been admitted straight to a ward. However I can totally see how staff may not have time to make or take phone calls. You really have to work on a busy understaffed hospital to get this.

CoralBells · 26/09/2021 10:07

@NantesElephant

I am hiding these threads as they are usually started and or get piled on by Tory shills who want to whip up sentiment that the NHS is failing and there is no alternative but to sell it off. I suggest you do the same.
Definitely
Crumble012 · 26/09/2021 09:57

Funding has increased and is at record levels. The population has increased by several million, the proportion of elderly has increased and we lack the frontline staff to care for all of us.

CharityDingle · 26/09/2021 09:50

@SoloISland

If you think NHS is bad come out here to Ireland and try HSE!

I now only have token so-called medical are because they are trying to stop me taking them to court. A GP here did something truly unprofessional and dangerous to me that they are refusing to deal with the formal complaint I made as the dr concerned would get struck off, and they are desperately short of GP. HSE are in court almost monthly re negligence cases and have to pay out huge sums on compensation. Oh and my nearest hospital has been declared unsafe by the unions/ For some true horror stories look up Mayo News Mayo University Hospital Castlebar.

@SoloISland Yes, our health system here in Ireland is very far from perfect. I'm puzzled though as you seem to dislike Ireland and Irish people so much, that you have chosen to live here.
CoralBells · 26/09/2021 09:45

@FangsForTheMemory

The government has been defunding the NHS for a decade in order to get people like YOU to think it is not fit for purpose so that when they sell it off - which they are doing, bit by bit - there will be no outcry.

Every time I see a thread like this started, I assume the OP is a Tory shill. If you're not, don't play into their hands.

Agree with this
FuckingFabulous · 26/09/2021 09:43

Sorry. Messaging on their phones or dithering about for about half an hour between patients, leaving the locums to manage the lists. Similar with consultants

FuckingFabulous · 26/09/2021 09:42

@Cocomarine

Enough with the “true gold” shite. Plenty of staff in the NHS are lazy jobsworths. A minority it’s true - and no more so than other workplaces - but can we just have a serious discussion about the NHS without romanticising all the staff?
This.

When I worked for the NHS, some of the band 6 and over employees were the laziest fuckers I've ever worked with. So many nurses who would rather stand gossiping at the desk than tend to patients. They left that to the auxiliaries and students. So many sonographers sitting in their room messaging in the

eeyore228 · 26/09/2021 09:38

@Katyppp the problem I unless you know why they are there its a bit unfair to say its a waste. We have 3 staff at our door directing patients. One directs the huge queue to either covid.or non covid areas so that patients are in the safest area. The other takes vitals and bloods. Another calls the people who need to see patients which in itself is difficult. The other issue is that all of our staff are in scrubs and aren't actually all nurses. Many often are mistaken as nurses and aren't and I say that as someone not a nurse. I really wish that people could.work a shift in a hospital because it's awful. DH is a nurse and he has panic attacks now going in because it's never enough.

Mrswalliams1 · 26/09/2021 09:31

Totally unfit for purpose. It's an embarrassment. I'm shocked everyone thinks it's underfunded. It has billions pumped into it but it haemorrhages money needlessly. Drugs chucked away, lazy staff, huge pensions, inefficient administration is just a start. It needs totally reforming but it'll take on a brave person to do it.

eeyore228 · 26/09/2021 09:28

There are multiple issues that keep being ignored. The population has expanded, build, build, build and we don't expand our public services to meet the needs of the population. I work in a hospital and we have had days with nearly 500 patient a day. We have a shortage of staff because no one acknowledges the effect the pressure and the last few years is having on staff. No one has a clue, aggression is up as is violence. Staff get it from above and the patients and I've never known it to be this bad. Each year is worse than the previous. No physical space for all the people needing help and not enough staff to cope with the numbers. The next issue is we don't want to accept that lifestyle has meant an increase in poor health. Obesity, smoking are having an impact on long term health. Then there is the fact that people want an instant fix, medicine often takes time but we want to be cured now and we don't know what is a genuine emergency. This poor lady seemingly had difficulty breathing but waited on the GP. Did no one with her realise that it was bad? That would be a hospital visit, no way a phone call. Yet people rush to A&E for a bout of D&V that's happened twice in a day. The NHS website is actually quite good at advising when to seek help. What we need is more room, more staff and perhaps a re-education to help people understand what the services are for.

PomRuns · 26/09/2021 09:27

@Katyppp why not write to the chief exec with your experience ?

Some very familiar names on this thread who always seem to have had yet another negative nhs experience.
Often also found on the nhs pay threads too ..

loopylauren · 26/09/2021 09:24

@FangsForTheMemory

The government has been defunding the NHS for a decade in order to get people like YOU to think it is not fit for purpose so that when they sell it off - which they are doing, bit by bit - there will be no outcry.

Every time I see a thread like this started, I assume the OP is a Tory shill. If you're not, don't play into their hands.

^ This ^
Katyppp · 26/09/2021 09:17

@PomRuns oh OK. I must have misread the name badges. Silly me.

WiseUpJanetWeiss · 26/09/2021 09:16

@Katyppp

Because they had name badges and job titles on them. Next question?
If it’s true, and they were actually employing registered nurses not HCAs to do all of this, then I am equally as shocked as you are.
PomRuns · 26/09/2021 09:14

There are a few familiar names on this thread that like an nhs moan.

More than likely was a health care assistant or admin handing out notes or checking hands were gelled.

WiseUpJanetWeiss · 26/09/2021 09:10

@BrendaBubbles

I don’t want a different system. By any data it was far better fifteen years ago so let’s start by merely getting back to that. What would that take? Maybe some more funding but I think mostly intelligent management and focus.
I agree with you on this. But don’t you see that lack of funding and constant political meddling are the root causes?

Lansley’s “reforms” were a predictable and predicted disaster which Simon Stevens spent his entire leadership (of NHSE) stealthily unpicking. Admin and non-clinical support functions have been stripped out as “bureaucracy”, and we wonder why the systems in place are inefficient and ineffective.

Again, propagating the Daily Hate’s viewpoint on this is playing into the hands of the government, softening us up for a US style system. And before anyone says “but European systems…”, these are not on offer and will not be on offer.

NantesElephant · 26/09/2021 09:09

I am hiding these threads as they are usually started and or get piled on by Tory shills who want to whip up sentiment that the NHS is failing and there is no alternative but to sell it off. I suggest you do the same.

Schoolsucks · 26/09/2021 09:06

@Cocomarine

Enough with the “true gold” shite. Plenty of staff in the NHS are lazy jobsworths. A minority it’s true - and no more so than other workplaces - but can we just have a serious discussion about the NHS without romanticising all the staff?
Yes exactly
Theluggage15 · 26/09/2021 09:04

The NHS is terrible and as for the government trying to sell it off, they’ve just increased NI by 1.5 percent to dole out more billions to be mismanaged with no strings attached. Hardly the actions of privatisation. The NHS needs to be reformed along the lines of European health services, that’s the only thing that will improve it. No one else in Europe would put up with this shambles.

Katyppp · 26/09/2021 09:02

Because they had name badges and job titles on them. Next question?

WiseUpJanetWeiss · 26/09/2021 09:00

[quote Katyppp]@stairway. I do appreciate that, honestly. But how can this, waste and lack of compassion be justified? Why were four nurses being used in unnecessary roles? Why was everybody 'too busy' to let te family know what the hell was going on? I am busy, we're all busy. Can you think of Any other situation where it woukd be acceptable to be too busy to make a phone call? I can't[/quote]
How do you know they were nurses?

ithinkilikeit · 26/09/2021 08:56

I am getting suspicious now. There is a new one of these threads every few days once a similar one has fallen of the front page of AIBU. @FangsForTheMemory is very tight and I am so sad to see so many people falling for the Tory’s plan to make it so terrible that people will sit silently as it is privatised.

The Tory’s and their friends only care about money so we are not going to get a European system instead or an Australian one or even a Canadian one, we will get an American one and if we get that then people will have wished so badly that they did not complain about the NHS at that point.

I am not someone who believes the NHS is perfect or that people cannot criticise it but I’m getting really suspicious about the motivations of some of the posters of these threads now.