Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

In Laws and Christmas

370 replies

TurkeyTescos · 25/09/2021 21:06

Background I've been with DH for over 15 years and DH has always had Christmas dinner with my family. The reason for this is because MIL spent it with her parents and six siblings. Their family tradition is once all the siblings children (DH and his cousins ect) turned 17 they weren't allowed to go their anymore and where expected to have dinner with friends or relatives from the other side of the family. My DM even hosted sister in law when she turned 17 because she had no where to go for dinner, even though her own mum was a few streets away having a fab time with her own parents and sisters.

2020/21 has been hard for MIL she lost her father to covid and her mother has recently gone into residential care, her childhood home was also sold over the summer. Last week MIL called in to see me and announced that since she no longer has anywhere to go her and two of her sisters will be having Christmas dinner in my house, she then handed me a few pages of printed instructions on how to cook it the way they like it and a running order for the day. I told her it wasn't happening but she (and only her) would be welcome to spend the day with us at my mum's house.

Today at the supermarket my DM ran into MIL and one of her sisters The sister started shouting at my DM that she'd ruined Christmas for them by purposely keeping them apart, that she was greedy for expecting DH and I to spend this Christmas with them when we'd spent every other Christmas together. MIL also shouted but DM glazed over it and said she spent most of the time crying hysterically while her sister done the shouting. I suspect DM doesn't want to upset me with what was really said.

I'm fuming, but I know it's best to sleep on it before confronting her tomorrow. She will need to be told that she was completely out of line speaking to my mum like that, who has quite rightly rescinded the invitation for dinner

AIBU by telling MIL she isn't welcome to spend any part of Christmas day with us? I'm feeling guilty because they are right, we've always spent it with my family. Should I just host MIL and her sisters this once and make it clear that they'll need to find somewhere else to eat together next year ?

DH is quite adamant that MIL be left to her own devices, that all the sisters are in their 60s, have their own homes, can and should cook for themselves. They all also have children so I don't know why I've been singled out tbh.

OP posts:
MyCatHatesWhiskas · 25/09/2021 21:40

SIL is low contact with her? I wonder why.Hmm

Honestly, it all sounds completely batshit! Your poor FIL. (Although I guess he may enjoy the peace and quiet…but still.)

Your DM sounds great! What a classy lady.

I’d let your DH deal with it. His mum, his problem. And he’s right. They can sort themselves out. This is not a trio of infirm, newly widowed 90 year olds where you just might cut them a little slack.

I just can’t get past the sheets of printed instructions….go on, what did they say?!

ajandjjmum · 25/09/2021 21:39

@pelosi
.....need to make your own plans with your sisters this year and in the future!

Notaroadrunner · 25/09/2021 21:39

Let MIL and her sisters sod off and fend for themselves. They sound unhinged with their batshit traditions. Don't attempt to invite them near yours or your DM's house. Let Dh be the one to tell her that she's uninvited and he doesn't want to hear another word about it. If you cannot stand up to her, don't answer any of her calls or don't open the door to her unless Dh is home.

BananaPB · 25/09/2021 21:38

I'm pleased to hear that SIL isn't a pushover.

I bet that these women don't even acknowledge the cruelty of their age 17 rule.

blubberyboo · 25/09/2021 21:38

They have somewhere to go… their own kitchens!

Dinoroaraus · 25/09/2021 21:37

there is a FIL who MIL lives with and he just has Christmas dinner alone with his cat, he always told me he didn't like to have dinner with them all but I'm starting to wonder if he was ever invited.

Tbh if I were him I'd be glad of the day off. It's like a bizarre cult.

Abouttimemum · 25/09/2021 21:37

Thank goodness your DH has the good sense to see right through his mother. Don’t take on this burden.
Who on earth chases their own children away from Christmas dinner!? Weird.
Your poor mum.

FYI my mother hosts Xmas dinner and my father in law attends each year, but this is mutually beneficial for all involved and he’s no bother and generally appreciative!

DanielRicciardosSmile · 25/09/2021 21:35

So I may aswell mention there is a FIL who MIL lives with and he just has Christmas dinner alone with his cat, he always told me he didn't like to have dinner with them all but I'm starting to wonder if he was ever invited.

Weirder and weirder. Were the siblings' partners ever included?

Porcupineintherough · 25/09/2021 21:34

Are you seriously contemplating inviting your MiL against your dh's wishes? That would be a huge thing to do even if she behaved normally.

pelosi · 25/09/2021 21:32

does anyone have any tips on how to do the awkward phone call tomorrow or should I just leave it to DH?

“MIL, you and your sister were completely out of order shouting at my mum in the supermarket. My mum has been more than kind offering to invite you for Christmas and you’ve thrown that kindness in her face by insulting her in public for not inviting your sisters as well. It’s not my mum’s responsibility to host you all. I can’t expect my mum to host you at Christmas now given your behaviour so you will need to make your own plans with your sisters this year.”

TurkeyTescos · 25/09/2021 21:31

@BananaPB

If you give in this year, it'll be harder to refuse next year plus you'll have the dread of having to check that she has made alternative arrangements.

Definitely say no. Their behaviour at the supermarket helps you case tbh. Does your h's sister have somewhere to go?

There's 3 of them - why don't they celebrate as a trio?

SIL is low contact with her.
OP posts:
TurkeyTescos · 25/09/2021 21:30

It seems that most of DH cousins feel the same about being turfed out at 17 and that's why two of the sisters + MIL are struggling to find somewhere to go. The other sisters do have somewhere and one is going on a solo retreat instead.

I always found there Christmas set up strange but reading this thread has made me realise it really is super odd and have most likely outed myself Grin.
So I may aswell mention there is a FIL who MIL lives with and he just has Christmas dinner alone with his cat, he always told me he didn't like to have dinner with them all but I'm starting to wonder if he was ever invited.

OP posts:
DanielRicciardosSmile · 25/09/2021 21:29

She left her 17 year old daughter with nowhere to go on Christmas Day, apart from her brother's in-laws taking pity on her?

Well, lucky her. She can now see how that feels.

I'm sure that, between the seven of them, her and her precious siblings can figure something out. Cheese on toast is easy enough.

Rainbowqueeen · 25/09/2021 21:28

I’d just say we will be continuing with our usual Christmas plans that have always suited you in the past. I understand your invitation has been rescinded due to your poor behaviour and I support “Jane” in that decision.

Don’t give in to bullies.

Jubaju · 25/09/2021 21:28

Well…. MIL is batshit 😱

Ellie56 · 25/09/2021 21:28

MIL and her sisters sound batshit.

And how dare they be so rude to your poor mum? Shock

Nobody is being left out or left on their own, and if MIL is capable of writing instructions for you to cook Christmas dinner, she should be quite capable of following her own instructions.

I agree with your DH. Carry on with your plans as normal and they can sort themselves out. If you give in this year, you will be doing it for evermore.

You don't need to speak to her at all. Let DH ring her up and give her the bollocking she deserves.

violetbunny · 25/09/2021 21:27

Why on earth can't MIL just invite her sisters over to hers? Then they can have Xmas dinner cooked to their exact specification Confused

Dinoroaraus · 25/09/2021 21:27

she said she wished them both a good day and walked off. your mum's a legend. Learn from her and take no shit.

Svalberg · 25/09/2021 21:26

@TurkeyTescos

I know it's mad. I can see now after reading it back the reason why they're targeting me is because I'm such a push over. If the general consensus here is I'm not being unreasonable does anyone have any tips on how to do the awkward phone call tomorrow or should I just leave it to DH?
Yep, you sound a right pushover if you're even considering it. Anyone who behaved like that towards my DM would be told where to go & never be seen again.
Neolara · 25/09/2021 21:24

Definitely don't reward your MIL and her sister's appalling behaviour by offering to have them for Xmas. If you do, you're opening yourself up to similar behaviour in the future.

nixso29 · 25/09/2021 21:24

Your poor mum! I actually am genuinely shocked by the whole weird tradition from start to finish!

Absolutely do not host MIL or her sisters in any way shape or form. She has made a rod for her own back in choosing how to spend every previous Xmas so now has to deal with the consequences.

Good on your husband for not giving in to her demands, that must have hurt in his younger years practically being abandoned by his mum on the one day of the year which is supposed to be spent with loved ones!

QueenBee52 · 25/09/2021 21:23

Uninvite MIL...

and leave them to it 🤣

HomeSliceKnowsBest · 25/09/2021 21:22

If anyone behaved towards DM like that they'd be gone from my life.

pelosi · 25/09/2021 21:22

YANBU, MIL was remarkably short sighted not to have realised this day would come.

You and your DM have been more than kind offering to have MIL. Them trying to impose MIL’s sisters on you is a joke.

Don’t host them, if you do, it will be expected every year!

I’d tell MIL that as everyone is upset about what happened in the supermarket, it’s best she spend Christmas with her sisters this year and then let’s see what the next year brings.

Bananarama21 · 25/09/2021 21:22

She sounds like a bitch ditching her dc once they are 17 and then demanding how the dinner should be cooked. Il be fuming if she bullied my mother like that.