Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

In asking for opinions on whether to ignore my ex's families wishes for DD3s education.

117 replies

peewitsandy · 25/09/2021 20:24

My ex husbands family are very wealthy but also incredibly controlling. DD 3 was adopted by myself and ex husband when she was 2.

the two most important reasons I moved to Essex from Cheshire six years ago was firstly to escape the toxicity of my ex's family secondly , secondly the Grammar schools. My ex's family would only pay fees if I and the children had decided to stay in Cheshire. Fast forward six years and DD1, DD2 and DS are all at grammar schools DD3 who has just taken her 11+ exam is unlikely to pass. Consequently ex husbands family have decided DD 3 needs to go to Boarding school but only one that is located in the North of England and want her start next September when DD 3 will be 11 years, she is a very immature 10 and half year old at present. The 'family' again refuse to contemplate funding a Private school Prep or Senior near where we live.

Should I suggest to them that perhaps DD 3 can go at 13 and that they fund a Local Prep school for her . Alternatively should I tell them to get lost and send DD to the local Comprehensive.

This is also complicated by the fact DD 3 is a talented sportswoman in both Tennis and Hockey . Therefore, with good facilities and coaching she would probably flourish both academically and sportingly in a Public School environment.

I WOULD REALLY LIKE TO SAY FUCK OFF TO THEM !

However, if I do will I be destroying DD3s future life prospects.

OP posts:
QueenBee52 · 26/09/2021 17:14

I clicked YABU, purely for not telling your Ex-Inlaws to piss off..

Your Mum sounds wonderful... good on her.. Flowers

KleineDracheKokosnuss · 26/09/2021 16:51

Good on your mum!

If the in laws are so desperate to pay, you can let them know what the local options are that would suit dd3 (day school only) and they can agree to pay. No boarding, no being sent away.

MerryMarigold · 26/09/2021 16:31

It's good you have a Mum who understands children, and particularly those who are vulnerable. Do think about whether grammar is the best option for her even if she passes. It may not be. Maybe look round a few local schools and get your DD's input on what she'd like to do. I have 2 children with very different abilities and they are in different schools to stop the natural sibling comparisons (not to do with 11+, neither are at grammar). How is her self esteem generally? I would prioritise this above all else in your decision making.

peewitsandy · 26/09/2021 13:27

I have just got off the phone from mum and dad , who have just offered to pay for a local Independent School if that is required. Mum has unbeknown to me been planning DD3s future education having a number of school prospectus sent to her . Mum being aware that DD 3s personal circumstances are different thus is totally against boarding school for her. However, mum thinks DD 3 is going to pass the 11+ and she probably has more idea than me.

OP posts:
Amiwronghere · 26/09/2021 11:38

No adopted child should be sent to boarding school. My mind is blown you would even consider this.

gogohm · 26/09/2021 10:16

Dp went to boarding school, he did not choose this for his DD's (money wasn't an issue). Tell them that she will not be boarding so young, you are open to it 13 if dd is keen but prior to that she will be attending a school local to you.

PicaK · 26/09/2021 10:12

Hang on... The most important thing here is she's adopted - and about to transition schools.
You must know from your adoption training how tricky the teenage years are going to be. More than for your NT kids.
Plus for attachment reasons boarding school is a no go.

Chloemol · 26/09/2021 10:12

Nope sorry they would be told to do one

You chose whatever local school you want, and she stays at home with you

PermanentTemporary · 26/09/2021 10:00

I think you can separate out bits of this.

It's quite clear that boarding school would be the wrong choice for her given that you have doubts - I think any doubts on that score for a child in her situation rule it out.

I'd also question whether a grammar school is right for her but that's based on my grammar school years ago plus a friend's son at an Essex grammar who has just left - very very very focused on academics. Not much fun being at the lower end of this.

I would look at a nurturing school for her with good sport and a head teacher with a spark. I think you're more likely to find this in the private sector given that you're in a grammar school area but maybe not. It's quite possible that when you identify the right school, your ex's family will be more open to helping financially.

CallMeNutribullet · 26/09/2021 09:50

Funnily enough I, and most people I know have managed to be successful in life without going to grammar or private school (grammar school being rare in Scotland)

FatAnkles · 26/09/2021 09:31

Don't send her to boarding school.

If there is a good comprehensive nearby, send her there. And find local tennis and hockey clubs/coaches for her.

It's obvious she prefers to stay with you.

SammyScrounge · 26/09/2021 00:38

In the first place, I don't understand why you would obey instructions from your in-laws which will affect your daughter's present and future. Let them ride off into the sunset waving their cheque book while you sit and consider how cruel they were in wanting to send your little girl away to the north. Are they generally so dismissive of her?

She won't die if she sets foot in a local comprehensive. And she will stay close to you which may well be more important to her than a boarding school.

peewitsandy · 25/09/2021 23:47

cocomarine: I also moved to Essex to support my parents who moved there.

Cocomarine, if you remember that my mother was a Governor at my school and a senior teacher at a boys Grammar School (St Olaves).

The reason my parents live in Essex now is because my mother in her early 50s had a change in her educational attitude (who she wanted to teach). In doing so she became a Headteacher at a failing comprehensive school and turned it round in four years.

Thus, for the record I don't believe non selective state schools are rubbish, I just like the option of different schools to be available .

OP posts:
wellards · 25/09/2021 23:46

Why be worried about her prospects if she is already well supported financially. She will be fine.

wellards · 25/09/2021 23:45

Don't accept money off them, it's not worth being beholden to them.

Cocomarine · 25/09/2021 23:17

And frankly you’ve got a bloody cheek accusing them of thinking state (non selective comprehensive) education isn’t very good - given that you moved to Essex for the grammar schools. So that’s clearly your opinion too.

Cocomarine · 25/09/2021 23:15

@peewitsandy

Thank you: Dramalamma for your wisdom on the subject

Regarding DD3 passing/failing the 11+ I was told it was about 60/40 against her passing, so I have deliberately downplayed DD3 chances ! I have also been told if DD3 is quite close to the required score, she might be in line to receive a 'Contextual' offer for Grammar School based on her personal circumstances.

Is that correct or a myth.

However, because DD3 is adopted I am far more involved in little things that never concerned me with the other three.
The other kids I was fairly confident they would all pass the Essex 11+which they did, but I would have had no issues sending them to Boarding Schools, paid by the in laws.

The in laws and ex husband are so Public School and ignorant they had no idea what a state 'Grammar School' was. They were amazed that the state had selective schools. Hence, I think their opinions about the point of state schools was only to provide the workforce for the elite, thus no more education for the masses than absolutely necessary .

The first time I met them they asked me where I came from and I said Kent via Manchester University . Then when they asked about my school, (Newstead Wood) noted that the only Schools she knew of in Kent or nearby where Benenden or Wycombe Abbey !

I know they sound horrific, but when they get to know you they are actually quite nice. It is just that the Upper Classes are among the most ignorant and stupid people in the country.

Person in Cheshire correctly identified one of Kent’s most famous girls’ schools but incorrectly also names Wycombe Abbey. I don’t see why that’s so shocking. You might be obsessed by the wonderful Newstead Wood (I’ve remembered your bizarre tennis thread now!) but that doesn’t mean that people at the other end of the country should be 🤷🏻‍♀️

They don’t sound horrific, just in a bubble - like very many people are.

I know plenty of “ordinary” people (meaning: state school and no Spanish villa) who don’t like in grammar school counties and didn’t know that they still existed. For those outside of grammar counties, there is often the expectation that state school is non selective.

EdgeOfTheSky · 25/09/2021 23:13

And an extra curricular tennis club is likely to be better than any school provision.

EdgeOfTheSky · 25/09/2021 23:12

Good grief.

You don’t think an adopted child who, unlike her older siblings did not pass the 11+, might see being sent away as a major failure and subsequent rejection?

OP, you have bought into this, with your focus on grammar schools and financial and ‘prospects’. What children need is love, security and a good enough education supported by the home environment.

A boarding school and ‘prospects’ will never make up for any feelings of abandonment or rejection.

Starface · 25/09/2021 23:11

I haven't heard of contextual offers, but have seen that being a LAC or in receipt of pupil premium is usually very high up the list of selection criteria in the admissions policies. I assume, as adopted, she qualifies as a LAC. This would be her favourable treatment. So e.g. an area like Bexley the top 180 get whichever school they want, then LAC/pupil premium seemed selective get to choose, then so on.

Remember she can move at year 12 too.

Can I totally echo the posters talking about attachment trauma, and how boarding school can be seen as another attachment trauma (boarding school syndrome - there are books, and documentaries which are now available on YouTube - it might make some sense of your in laws behavior). Your "clingy" (safety seeking) adopted child is not a good candidate for this sort of separation. It could well be massively damaging, and boarding schools are staffed and populated by people who collude with such damage so are unlikely to be able to mitigate it if they can even bring themselves to see it. Money will not make up for it. Choose a lifetime of good relationships and mental health. This is also an investment in her future success and happiness, and imo more important than exposure to money or an academic grade or two.

So in conclusion: follow your instinct wrt her emotional health. A local comprehensive will serve her far better than boarding school at 11.

Twofurrycats · 25/09/2021 23:08

They don't get to make this decision.
If DD passes the 11+ fine. If she doesn't the local school will be fine.
The 'we'll only pay for school if it's boarding and in the North' in laws can sod off. It's blatant manipulation and not based on the child's best interests. If it was they'd pay for a local school.

urbanbuddha · 25/09/2021 23:03

If they're going to dangle sports provision as the carrot tell them it would be better to for your DD if they were to pay for lessons and summer holiday clubs.

KatherineJaneway · 25/09/2021 23:02

Sounds like your ex's family want DD3 out of the way

Ifyoudontlaughyouwillcry · 25/09/2021 22:57

I am adopted, so is my beautiful
Sweet daughter who is 12. If either I or her was sent away to a boarding school quite frankly it would break me and her. Remember everything you went through to adopt this precious individual - more than anything she needs you right now to be her MUM. Sod the wealthy fuckwits who think they can buy her life on their terms. If she fails that exam and you send her away what message will that send. If she is truly gifted at her sports - the grass root sports will find her and guide her. Remember a lot of the finest footballers in the country haven’t had the best education. PLEASE don’t send your daughter away. Stand firm and tell the to FUCK OFF and when they come back tell the to FUCK OFF again. And repeat. Xx

TartanJumper · 25/09/2021 22:54

Straight from the thread title I thought YANBU. They shouldn't even have a say in it.
Do what you feel is best for your child, and consider going NC (for yourself). Their father can maintain the DCs relationship with them.

Swipe left for the next trending thread