Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To advise my friend to seek family lawyer advice in this situation?

112 replies

thecatmother · 25/09/2021 19:14

My friend is married to her soulmate and they have a perfect marriage, she is SAHM and he is a high earner, and they are settled on having just one DC, who is 5 now. Or so she thought... They have a "best couple " that they go on holidays together, celebrate all the major events together and generally are very close to. The lady in the couple is also a high earner and she works for the same company as my friend's husband. So the "best couple " lady has just had her 3rd baby (roughly 3 months ago), same sex as my friend's DC (yep, that's where its going) and my friend has obviously been delighted, supportive and generally very involved... and so has her DH. My friend is driving herself mad because the new baby has an uncanny resemblance to her DC and her DH. She has been digging a little in her DH phone and did find flirty messages and very caring messages between those 2, but nothing more.... and on top of that her DH is getting a massive severance from his job, so he literally never has to work again.
She is scared to ask questions, and I am advising her to seek legal advice, just in case she might find out that not only her DH has been cheating on her, but also is responsible for another child out there.
I think that forewarned is forearmed.

OP posts:
HeartsAndClubs · 25/09/2021 22:30

Sounds like you’re trying to sabotage their marriage. Why is that exactly?

You say they’re happy, are you jealous?

jacks11 · 25/09/2021 22:25

Firstly, please do not advise her to get a dna test on the child. Obtaining tissue (including hair/nail etc) with intent of getting dna analysis without the consent of at least one of the parents (or those with parental responsibility) in a child below the age of consent is an offence under the Human Tissues Act. Convictions can lead to significant fines or even up to 3 years imprisonment. People really should think through before suggesting such things.

It sounds like your friend should seek some advice regarding her legal position in the event she chooses to proceed to divorce.

RedMarauder · 25/09/2021 22:09

The issue is if she divorces and the kid is his, it screws up the child maintenance she is going to get off him. Her child maintenance will be reduced as his other child(ren) will have to be taken into consideration.

Best thing for her to do is to get her ducks in a row and most importantly collect, hide and keep up to date evidence of her husband's assets while still married to him. Then if she does decide to divorce him for any reason she gets a reasonable share of the marital assets - she will need to go for a clean break to avoid him screwing her over later.

thecatmother · 25/09/2021 22:06

@BlankTimes

What if the guy who should be the father had a vasectomy or otherwise couldn't father another much wanted child for the couple and your friend's husband was a sperm donor for them, at their invitation.

It could explain how he's more involved with the baby with the blessing of the other guy.

I know, I know, I watch too many TV detective series Blush

That is a sweet thought. Only the friend of mine would certainly be a part of that decision and as much as I am aware the "best couple" wife is a very motivated career woman who already had children and as far as my friend was aware wasn't pining for another baby and/or struggling to conceive it. So seemed that it was an unplanned but welcome situation.
OP posts:
BlankTimes · 25/09/2021 21:54

What if the guy who should be the father had a vasectomy or otherwise couldn't father another much wanted child for the couple and your friend's husband was a sperm donor for them, at their invitation.

It could explain how he's more involved with the baby with the blessing of the other guy.

I know, I know, I watch too many TV detective series Blush

PegasusReturns · 25/09/2021 21:41

Taking three weeks off is indicative of the baby being his

thecatmother · 25/09/2021 21:37

Thanks for such diverse replies, I went through an extremely dragged out and traumatic divorce and feel that if only I had done a little research before the process I would have been more prepared. I am also very self aware and have strong opinions about marriages without prenuptial agreements now, and therefore not the most neutral advisor. I just want to be a good friend, a good listener, and if I can suggest something to make my friend feel better and more in control I'm taking any advice!

OP posts:
toocold54 · 25/09/2021 21:17

I don’t think it sounds like he is sleeping with this women but if your friend thinks he is then she needs to do some digging and confront him else she will be paranoid forever.

Lotusmonster · 25/09/2021 21:06

I guess if your friend is sure they as a couple only want one DC, she could casually ask her DH if a vasectomy might be a sensible shout….see how he responds to that…..

Lotusmonster · 25/09/2021 21:03

Surely the ‘best couple’ DH must have doubts too, if there are really any to be had….particularly around conception dates. At the mo, it’s rather flimsy and an extrapolation of one ‘game changer’ remark, which could mean literally anything!!!! You sure you’re not shit stirring here OP?

GettingItOutThere · 25/09/2021 20:58

he took 3 weeks off for someone elses baby?!

wtf - 100000000% he is hiding something, probably that babys parentage?!

I would want a DNA test, and at the very least this blown up and sorted out, i could not live like that!

RobinPenguins · 25/09/2021 20:57

Well hopefully a she would be advised to stop being in a position where she’s totally financially and emotionally dependent upon her husband. She doesn’t trust him, therefore it seems like the relationship is on shaky ground whoever ends up being the baby’s father.

Genevie82 · 25/09/2021 20:57

.. I think the reality for your friend is that if her DH is that dishonest fathering a child with their friend he’s likely to be pretty sneaky when it comes to divorce and money. Your friend does need to get her ducks in a row before she confronts him and get good legal advice as there will be financial documents she will need. She can see a solicitor or direct access barrister and pay cash. It is possible to do a covert dna test but properly not that ethical on a child that isn’t hers! I would agree that babies do look atlot like their dads in the first few weeks and months .. no man would normally help out with another mans child like that !! It’s abit odd especially since he’s the type that likes his shirts warmed up Jesus!! Xx

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 25/09/2021 20:55

This whole thing stinks.

Asking your wife to get up half an hour before you so you have a warm shirt is insane. Taking 3 weeks holiday for someone else's (who has support from their partner) baby, when you've got your own kids that you're not that involved with, is insane.
She has already found messages that she found uncomfortable.
Yes babies don't always look like their parents. But they don't usually look like their best male friend either (and my daughter was the spitting image of my husband at 3 months, she later grew out of it and now looks like my mum).

Normally when you add all these things together, mumsnet would be saying to get your ducks in a row and that usually involves seeing a lawyer.

She could do a DNA test or speak to them but they are unlikely to admit it and how would she get a DNA sample from her husband to compare? (Lateral flow test maybe?).

In any case if she speaks to a lawyer she needs to know the basics or she will get nothing out of it. All assets and debt and pensions etc. Make sure she has all this before she goes. And make sure she pays cash or he doesn't read her accounts. And point her to one of the 'ducks in a row' threads on here. There is no harm in being prepared

Quartz2208 · 25/09/2021 20:51

I used the word perfect, because that is what she always described her marriage as. I always thought that they were both suited to each other, because she had a comfortable life with the husband that she adores and a beautiful home and he was very well looked after and very much respected and prioritised.

That sounds odd it is all about him and his needs where is she is all of this. How can something be perfect if one is so far ahead of the other.

thecatmother · 25/09/2021 20:43

@nowwhat50

Your friend could strategically get advice from a few of really top shit hot lawyers in her city. Then if they do divorce, he won't be able to consult them as there is a conflict of interest IIRC.
That is truly an amazing idea. I would do that, not so sure she can afford that though.
OP posts:
whynotwhatknot · 25/09/2021 20:32

Obliged to help another couple with their baby-what man does that

i stayed with my dsis for a week to help out that was it wouldnt do it for a friend who had a partner for 3 weeks

thecatmother · 25/09/2021 20:29

@Quartz2208

This isnt the perfect marriage your friend sounds in awe of him and it seems completely inbalanced

Who on earth wakes up early to iron a shirt and make coffee. She sounds like she has no voice

I used the word perfect, because that is what she always described her marriage as. I always thought that they were both suited to each other, because she had a comfortable life with the husband that she adores and a beautiful home and he was very well looked after and very much respected and prioritised.
OP posts:
Summerfun54321 · 25/09/2021 20:27

This sounds like some kind of “real housewives” plot. Just stay out of it.

nowwhat50 · 25/09/2021 20:26

Your friend could strategically get advice from a few of really top shit hot lawyers in her city. Then if they do divorce, he won't be able to consult them as there is a conflict of interest IIRC.

ChequerBoard · 25/09/2021 20:26

Is friend living in Stepford? Why is she behaving like a doormat?

She needs to start working on her self esteem and build herself a richer life outside of her claustrophobic sounding marriage.

Whatever the truth behind this frankly odd sounding obsession with someone else's newborn, her marriage isn't healthy.

Mayhemmumma · 25/09/2021 20:24

Yeeeash 3 weeks off for a friends baby?! Wtf??

Maybe I'm just jealous my DH was not off for more than 3 days and the kids were his!

Quartz2208 · 25/09/2021 20:20

This isnt the perfect marriage your friend sounds in awe of him and it seems completely inbalanced

Who on earth wakes up early to iron a shirt and make coffee. She sounds like she has no voice

thecatmother · 25/09/2021 20:19

Yes the 3 weeks leave was originally 1 week and then just kept getting extended. He is in a high position in his company and does get a lot of annual leave. The "best couple" husband is going to share the paternity leave after the baby is 5 months, so her DH kind of felt "obliged" to help out, allegedly. I do also find it strange, as he is not very hands on with their own DC. Another thing she did mention that didn't sit right with her, how her DH kept repeating that their friend being pregnant is a "game changer", originally she thought it was because of her career, and them going away on holidays etc.

OP posts:
toocold54 · 25/09/2021 20:18

You are obviously a good friend but honestly I would try and stay out of it.
If you persuade her to see a lawyer and the DH finds out, he could leave her and she could blame you for splitting up their family. I’m not sure what seeing a lawyer would actually achieve other than he might tell her to start working so she has some finances of her own.

Yes this does happen but if they were having an affair why would they not just be together and wouldn’t her or your friends DH be acting weird or suspicious around the baby.