Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

House living arrangement

38 replies

birdbybird · 25/09/2021 17:52

My husband and I are renting. We have a small child. My husband and I split rent and all bills.
My husband’s sister lives in a house he owns, the mortgage for which is paid off . His sister pays bills but she doesn’t pay any rent to my husband.
He doesn’t want to kick her out as she’s lived there for 20 years. However she can’t afford to rent the whole house. And we can’t sell it or get any equity.
Some of my husband’s stuff is still there but he only goes there about once ever couple of months for the weekend to visit his parents.
What can we do in this situation? At the moment we can’t access any equity from the house.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Elieza · 27/09/2021 14:46

Agreed. I meant the husband as this is his problem to sort!

Cocomarine · 26/09/2021 23:44

The OP doesn’t need speak to her SIL. Her husband does.

Elieza · 26/09/2021 11:23

I’m presuming the OP used to live in the house with his sister. When a partner came along the OP moved out to be with them and the sister remained behind.

The only thing we don’t know is if family money paid for the deposit on the original house, or even all of it.

If that’s the case then the sister could get some of that money as then it’s fair. Presumably. Then they both have benefitted equally from family money.

That could be done by the OP as monthly rent payments towards the sisters rent (if she rents a nice house/flat which her housing benefit won’t completely cover.

Or the OP could make contributions to the sister’s mortgage payments if she has enough earnings that a mortgage company would give get a mortgage.

Or if the OP wanted to pay a lump sum as a deposit on a mortgage to help her (as opposed to giving her cash as that could invalidate her eligibility for means tested benefits).

I don’t imagine for one second the sister will have thought about being kicked out and doubt she will have any savings.

The OP needs to speak with her ASAP to see what her thoughts are.

LawnFever · 26/09/2021 09:06

Can’t you move into the house as a family? It’s his house, renting somewhere else is crazy!

His sister needs to move out and either buy something with all the money she’s saved in rent or rent her own house, the fact she’s lived for 20 years paying no rent is ridiculous!

Where do your in laws live? You mention your husband visiting them? Do they live near his house where the sister currently lives?

Thehop · 26/09/2021 09:01

What does your husband want to do?

user1471538283 · 26/09/2021 08:51

He needs to sell that house so his family can settle somewhere. If you are in a position to do so I would get my own home and leave him to it.

TweetyPieBird · 26/09/2021 08:47

Why are you renting (paying someone else’s mortgage) when DH has a house his owns outright? You should move there and that’s an excuse to kick sil out. She needs to rent elsewhere.

KingdomScrolls · 26/09/2021 07:49

@Cocomarine no one lives in someone's house for twenty years without paying rent and with no obvious plan to move on without being a CF

Notimeforaname · 26/09/2021 00:10

Get another lodger to move in and pay some rent.

Elieza · 25/09/2021 23:33

She won’t get housing benefit if she’s staying in the house if a family member.

Hence she needs to find somewhere else. Then she can apply.

Cocomarine · 25/09/2021 23:01

@KingdomScrolls

If she hasn't saved a sizeable amount of money in twenty years without rent to pay, that's her fault, even on NMW you'd be able to save enough to have a good savings pot after two decades of free housing. She's taking the piss.
Unfair to say she’s taking the piss! For all we know, her brother only has to say, “I’m going to sell up sis” and she’ll say, “OK”. He chose to let her live in the house, and plenty of families share their good fortune around each other. It sounds like he’s wealthier than her if he’s managed to pay off a mortgage - and he’s kindly shared the love around. I’d reserve judgment on her pisstaking until he actually asks her to move out!
KingdomScrolls · 25/09/2021 22:44

If she hasn't saved a sizeable amount of money in twenty years without rent to pay, that's her fault, even on NMW you'd be able to save enough to have a good savings pot after two decades of free housing. She's taking the piss.

Cocomarine · 25/09/2021 22:38

Well, it’s his property so it’s his choice really.
I’d just get on and buy somewhere. Ideally buy a place yourself, as then you don’t have the second hone stamp duty or later CGT concern. Even if you can’t afford to buy without him, he’s surely made a huge amount of money on the value of the house in 20 years? So even if you do now have to pay extra stamp duty, you’re still quids in on overall finances. It would certainly annoy me too - but he made those decisions years before he met you. You could suggest that he sell and buy a smaller property outright and support her in the same way still - but freeing up the remaining money from the sale as a deposit on another house. You still get the second home issue, overall he’d be paying less mortgage because of the bigger deposit.

XenoBitch · 25/09/2021 22:27

Getting the the sister to apply for UC housing element is no good. She might not get it as this arrangement may be seen as a "contrived tenancy". If she has been living rent free for years already, then chances of getting housing benefit are next to nil.
I am living in this scenario myself (I am the tenant).

Twofurrycats · 25/09/2021 22:22

You have a few choices.
Tell her you are selling.
Charge her rent. If she is on a low income is she entitled to uc rent element.
Suggest she shares with someone and they both pay rent.
Personally I'd go for selling. Otherwise you might end up in difficulty with her paying a low rent/not paying.

HairyScaryMonster · 25/09/2021 22:01

I’d suggest offering for her to stay at x rent and encourage her to get a lodger or two.

JustLyra · 25/09/2021 20:25

And the reason I mentioned mortgages at all was your comment about rent and equity mortgages - there are a lot of other options beyond that one.

Good luck.

JustLyra · 25/09/2021 20:24

@birdbybird

I don't think it will go to court. I think she's sensible enough to realise that my husband may have used it as a base for some years but for 6 years its been her on her own. My SIL works but the salary is quite modest. My husband doesn't want to sell but he has to think about what will happen if we buy somewhere and then at some point in the future he does decide to sell that property. In which case he may not get the primary residence tax relief.

Thanks all... (although one or two have been unnecessarily bordering on rude. Someone said "no point people giving you advice on mortgages..." I wasn't asking for financial advice on mortgages. Simply responding to an early question. My original post was a bit ranty so perhaps posting here wasn't a good idea.)

I'm happy to consider this thread closed.

There was nothing rude in my statement "no point in giving advice on mortgages" @birdbybird

It was quite clear my point was that there was no point in that if your husband wasn't prepared to do anything with regard to the house or his sister then the issue you have is a DH issue rather than a financial one.

Brollywasntneededafterall · 25/09/2021 19:56

Air B & B a few rooms? Sil can hardly complain if you need to make some money given she isn't paying any rent...

birdbybird · 25/09/2021 19:53

I don't think it will go to court. I think she's sensible enough to realise that my husband may have used it as a base for some years but for 6 years its been her on her own.
My SIL works but the salary is quite modest. My husband doesn't want to sell but he has to think about what will happen if we buy somewhere and then at some point in the future he does decide to sell that property. In which case he may not get the primary residence tax relief.

Thanks all... (although one or two have been unnecessarily bordering on rude. Someone said "no point people giving you advice on mortgages..." I wasn't asking for financial advice on mortgages. Simply responding to an early question. My original post was a bit ranty so perhaps posting here wasn't a good idea.)

I'm happy to consider this thread closed.

OP posts:
RandomMess · 25/09/2021 19:36

If she can't afford to rent then she needs to move to a cheaper area/earn more/apply for benefits.

She may have to lower her standards and move into a house share.

He could sell it and choose to give her some money towards renting somewhere different as a one off but at some point in time she need ms to take on full adult responsibility for herself.

Cherrysoup · 25/09/2021 19:14

Does your husband want to sell? He’ll need to give her notice, even tho there can’t be an AST in place. If she refuses to go, he will need to go to court. Can she afford to rent somewhere smaller?

Elieza · 25/09/2021 19:08

Does the sister have any money? Does she work?

JustLyra · 25/09/2021 18:43

@birdbybird

My husband is confused and this is causing friction between us. She started living there when she was in her 20s and my husband’s work took him to far flung places around the world so he used the house as a base. However we’ve lived together for the last 6 years. He said he thought she’d eventually find a partner and move out but it’s been 20 years and it hasn’t happened. There’s no cultural reason for him to do this. The house is big for one person. It’s not in the same city as us and it’s not somewhere we want to live. The equity mortgage (I think) is based on how much rent you get… right now the rent is zero.
The equity would only be based on rent for a buy-to-let mortgage. There are other options that your DH could look into.

Firstly though, your DH has to decide what he's going to do regarding his sister. Is he going to ask her to leave or to pay rent? What is their plan for the future? Has she been saving?

There's no point in people giving you advice on mortgages and the likes if he's simply not prepared to do anything regarding his sister.

Elieza · 25/09/2021 18:38

Help find her somewhere local to rent and you move into his house yourselves.