Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to think the student loan is a graduate tax that you can avoid if your parents are wealthy enough?

160 replies

Tryingtryingandtrying · 25/09/2021 10:57

Was it designed deliberately this way by people with wealthy parents? Can you pay the fees up front each year if you have enough money?

OP posts:
BasicDad · 25/09/2021 11:47

YABU.

It's a pretty fair system.

Rhubarbsoup · 25/09/2021 11:45

I still earn way above what I would without a degree, even taking off the deductions for student loan repayments, so I don't mind. It doesn't seem to be unique or a shocker that people who have money can afford more.

Comefromaway · 25/09/2021 11:44

And over 30 years that would mean repayments of £35,000 just under half of the original debt based on full loan.

Comefromaway · 25/09/2021 11:42

Your maths is out.

I earn about £40k per year but I started off on much less. But for arguments sake lets say my graduate salary was £40k and I had student debt. Under the current system I’d pay my normal tax of 20% on my earnings above £12,500 then I’d pay an extra 9% tax on my earnings above £27,000

So £12,500 is tax free
£14,500 is 20% tax
£13,000 is 29% tax

Hardly 50% tax as you stated.

LivingDeadGirlUK · 25/09/2021 11:40

I finish paying my loan off this year, 20 years after my first day of uni. Tax was no where near 50%, its been very managable and I think its a good system tbh.

Elwynne · 25/09/2021 11:38

Student loans in the UK, plan 2, are problematic for the reason that there's a sweet spot in earnings where you get really bashed by them.
If you earn under the threshold or not too far from it, then it is quite reasonable and a good deal. If you earn a very high salary (which you are more likely to do statistically if you grew up with wealthy parents, went to private school etc) then you can realistically pay your debt off quite quickly and not accrue too much interest. The problem hits the good earners who aren't on mega bucks and also people who want to move internationally. They are paying a hefty chunk every month just for the interest and this will continue for 25 years before the loan is written off.

Chessie678 · 25/09/2021 11:31

Very few people pay fees upfront because it rarely makes financial sense to do so. We could probably afford to pay university fees for our DS in future but that is the last thing I would choose to spend money on for him - much better to pay for a house deposit or extra post-grad training than pay uni fees which he may never have to pay back in full anyway and where cheap finance is available. You need to be a very high earner for a long period to pay off the whole of your student loan now. Most people won't clear it. So actually students who go on to make a high income are subsidising those who don't. It is essentially a graduate tax.

NailsNeedDoing · 25/09/2021 11:31

It’s not a tax in any way, it’s paying for the cost of tuition received or normal living expenses. Whether it’s paid for by parents upfront of via a loan makes no real difference, it has to be paid for somehow.

The real injustice right now is that students are paying (either through loans or their parents) for inadequate teaching as it’s been online for so long, and for accommodation that they have been unable to use.

lljkk · 25/09/2021 11:30

Given the large % that will never pay anything back plus further large % who never pay back the full amount, I can't support assertion that this funding system unfairly benefits 'offspring of rich parents who can pay it all off up front'

I also humbly submit that £25k/annum is a lot more than most private schools charge.

InvincibleInvisibility · 25/09/2021 11:29

But again, whats your point? Theres lots of things that rich people in effect pay less for as they pay less interest.

We took out a 15 year mortgage cos we can afford higher payments than someone else who would need a 25 year mortgage. At the end they will have paid more interest.

Ozanj · 25/09/2021 11:28

The wealthiest people I know (income in millions) encourage their kids to apply through a student loan too as it’s often a lot cheaper (even with interest) than dipping into lucrative investments. But their salary expectations after graduation are much higher too so they may not miss the monthly payment

ShinyMe · 25/09/2021 11:28

As @Seeline says, if you had to pay back the loan regardless, lots of people from poorer households and people on courses which lead to poorly paid jobs would just not go, and that causes huge problems. I graduated over 20 years ago and am still not paying back my loan (although I think I am just over the threshold on the newer loan payment terms, but I had an OLD OLD loan with better terms) and I don't see that I will ever repay mine. My wage is below the national average, even though I see it as comfortable for me (I earn more than most of my friends) so why should I be repaying the same as say, a law graduate earning four times my salary?

INeed2P · 25/09/2021 11:27

I'm not sure where you've got the idea it means someone is paying 50% tax from at all - student loan repayments are fairly small on a below 30k wage, then increase as wages do. It doesn't put tax up to anywhere near 50%?

Hmmph · 25/09/2021 11:27

I am more cross about how they are unfair on women. Or more specifically, women who have children.

Interest still accrues during maternity leave. Therefore a woman who takes a year maternity leave when they have a baby will end up having to pay back more than a man who doesn’t suffer this gap. Shared parental leave does exist, granted, but it’s is 99% taken by a woman.

Not to mention that women are more likely to take more time off work or go part time after having children...

I think student loan interest should NOT accrue when someone is on maternity (or paternity or adoption) leave.

MitheringMytryl · 25/09/2021 11:25

What? They are still paying, they are just doing upfront rather than in installments.

I agree that it's unfair in the sense that people with rich parents could have no student loan, and everybody else has to pay one, but surely that applies to absolutely everything? Every time parents pay for something for their children they are providing them with something that another parent somewhere else can not or will not pay for. It sucks but it is just life.

Tryingtryingandtrying · 25/09/2021 11:24

Young people are paying the equivalent if nearly 50% tax because of the student loan. The interest accumulating means few ever pay it all off. (but would have covered the actual money)
Ultimately it should either be a graduate tax or interest free loan. If I had been paying £25000 a year in school fees £9000 is a lot cheaper and my child won't be on effectively a higher tax code for 30 years.

OP posts:
WoozySnoozy · 25/09/2021 11:23

Even the wealthy people should consider taking out the loan. Its one of the best rates you'll ever get.

Seeline · 25/09/2021 11:20

@IceCreamAndCandyfloss

There’s no obligation to go to uni nor take out a loan.

What I do disagree with is the option to not pay the loan back by either not working or keeping below the salary threashold , repayments should start from six months after the course finishes regardless of what the person is doing career wise.

That would likely see a reduction in people taking degrees in areas that traditionally lead to jobs in lower paid sectors though. Nursing, public sector jobs etc. Those areas hard to recruit in anyway.
SickAndTiredAgain · 25/09/2021 11:18

@CloudPop

Your argument makes no sense. Fees get paid either by (a) parents up front covering the full amount or (b) students themselves covering some or all of the amount by paying a monthly sum.
You have interest on the loan though. So can end up paying back more which I guess is OP’s point. Obviously you can end up paying back far less, if you don’t earn enough to pay much back.
sst1234 · 25/09/2021 11:12

[quote Tryingtryingandtrying]@sst1234 A tax that the wealthy don't pay? How's that fair?[/quote]
They do pay. That’s the whole point of the system.

CloudPop · 25/09/2021 11:12

Your argument makes no sense. Fees get paid either by (a) parents up front covering the full amount or (b) students themselves covering some or all of the amount by paying a monthly sum.

sst1234 · 25/09/2021 11:11

@Tryingtryingandtrying

I think it should be a graduate tax that everyone pays regardless of wealth. That would be fairer than the current system.
Why? So we can find useless degrees like underwater crochet…or media studies.
Piggy42 · 25/09/2021 11:09

Surely your point is that the wealthy pay up-front? They are still paying, just not the interest.

FirewomanSam · 25/09/2021 11:09

Paying it all up front would be a very silly thing to do since most people won’t pay off the full amount before it gets written off. Martin Lewis has some good explanations about it on the MSE website.

So yes, wealthy people could pay all the fees up front and thereby avoid having to pay anything else in future but it would make very little financial sense to do that.

IceCreamAndCandyfloss · 25/09/2021 11:08

[quote Tryingtryingandtrying]@sst1234 A tax that the wealthy don't pay? How's that fair?[/quote]
But they do pay, they don’t get tuition free Hmm

Lots of parents save from birth for uni costs etc for their children, it’s not just the wealthy that help out.