Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to think the student loan is a graduate tax that you can avoid if your parents are wealthy enough?

160 replies

Tryingtryingandtrying · 25/09/2021 10:57

Was it designed deliberately this way by people with wealthy parents? Can you pay the fees up front each year if you have enough money?

OP posts:
Bluntness100 · 25/09/2021 12:48

@burnoutbabe

i am doing a masters right now, and i can take out a loan for the fees (or £12k max)

and its only repayable if i earn over £30k in the next 25 years.

now i am nearly 50 and winding down in my professional life, doing this for interest. I can choose to only work 1-2 day a week and earn just up to the £30k limit in consulting roles.
Therefore there is a big incentive for older people to do these courses with no repayment (though there is a cut off of 60? to qualify for the loan)
NB you won't get a loan if you already have a degree for a 2nd degree unless its a specific ones (usually health care related)

I choose to just pay it, as i can afford it. But i could have just taken the loan and odds on never repaid.

At least you’re paying it, I really find it sickening those who take the loans out to do fun degreees and have no intention of ever paying it back. And there is plenty of them about. Taking places off of kids who would have got that place in clearing or wherever if the fun degree person hadn’t taken it.
SaddenedByItAll · 25/09/2021 12:47

Equally it's an opportunity for people from low income backgrounds to have a right old wheeze at uni and if they don't score a job over whatever the cut off is, may end up never paying it back.

purpleneon · 25/09/2021 12:45

@Tryingtryingandtrying

Young people are paying the equivalent if nearly 50% tax because of the student loan. The interest accumulating means few ever pay it all off. (but would have covered the actual money) Ultimately it should either be a graduate tax or interest free loan. If I had been paying £25000 a year in school fees £9000 is a lot cheaper and my child won't be on effectively a higher tax code for 30 years.

Your maths isn't correct though 😩 you need to learn the difference between tax bands and effective tax rates. Can't be bothered to write out the maths but just Google for some worked examples.

Bluntness100 · 25/09/2021 12:45

But wealthy people pay the same tax on their earnings, often more, so either way they pay.

Are you suggesting everyone who goes to uni should pay a tax to reduce the burden on those from poorer families, thus taxing the wealthy twice?

GenderApostatemk2 · 25/09/2021 12:42

I think that student loans should be written off for people like Teachers once they’ve done say 10 years in that profession, either that or not increase in line with salary rises.
I know my DD now pays a fortune in repayments for her Maths degree and she was lucky to get a stem bursary for he PGCE.

Comefromaway · 25/09/2021 12:41

The repayment threshold for a masters loan is £21k per year not 30k

burnoutbabe · 25/09/2021 12:22

i am doing a masters right now, and i can take out a loan for the fees (or £12k max)

and its only repayable if i earn over £30k in the next 25 years.

now i am nearly 50 and winding down in my professional life, doing this for interest. I can choose to only work 1-2 day a week and earn just up to the £30k limit in consulting roles.
Therefore there is a big incentive for older people to do these courses with no repayment (though there is a cut off of 60? to qualify for the loan)
NB you won't get a loan if you already have a degree for a 2nd degree unless its a specific ones (usually health care related)

I choose to just pay it, as i can afford it. But i could have just taken the loan and odds on never repaid.

sst1234 · 25/09/2021 12:13

OP simply doesn’t get it. The system does exactly what they are advocating for, both through the student loans system and general taxation. It’s like they are arguing for something that already exists.

Timeforachangetoday12 · 25/09/2021 12:10

My daughter has just started uni and the money needed has taken us by surprise. Neither of us had been and she’s one of the first from my family. Financially on paper we ok - we had explained to her about the loans etc I think it went in! We did have a conversation around whether apprentice or uni path. She wants to be a social worker so the uni path is the one she’s taken. It scares me how much debt she will be in especially as we can’t afford to help as much as we would like to!!

I don’t know what’s ‘fair’ in life there will always be more wealthy people who earn more or parents help them buy a house etc that’s life. Sadly!

If I could, I’m not sure I would pay the fees for her anyway, as she needs to be responsible for her own future and choices.

Seeline · 25/09/2021 12:05

OP - have you got any figures on the proportion of students (not overseas) that actually pay their fees out right? And the proportion that don't apply for any part of the maintenance loan?

jimmyjammy001 · 25/09/2021 12:01

It's fair that everyone pays they're own way for higher education whether that be through a loan or parents that have saved and pay for their children's future upfront.
Its like saying it's not fair that rich parents buy their children a house whilst poorer parents children will have to take a loan(mortgage) out

Seeline · 25/09/2021 12:01

@Tryingtryingandtrying

Young people are paying the equivalent if nearly 50% tax because of the student loan. The interest accumulating means few ever pay it all off. (but would have covered the actual money) Ultimately it should either be a graduate tax or interest free loan. If I had been paying £25000 a year in school fees £9000 is a lot cheaper and my child won't be on effectively a higher tax code for 30 years.
£9250 each year is for fees only. Students can apply for a maintenance loan of about the same, but that is means tested on parents income. Most students don't qualify for the full loan, all are entitled to the minimum if about £4,500. Parents are expected to make this up to the full amount each year. However, accommodation costs, especially first year halls are more than the minimum loan (often considerably more), leaving all other living costs as extra. If no loan is to be taken out, that's getting on for £19K at least. Of course many students take part time jobs, but this isn't possible with all courses, and some unis don't even allow it.
Mybalconyiscracking · 25/09/2021 12:00

You do realise that if you earn more then you pay more tax, don’t you?

Porfre · 25/09/2021 11:59

The interest rate though is scandalous.

I'm on plan 1, so luckily it's very low at present, but the other student dont really have a chance to pay back their loans unless they are on a sky high salary.

titchy · 25/09/2021 11:58

[quote Tryingtryingandtrying]@comefromaway Over £40ish k it is 40% tax or 49% for those with a loan. And 40kish supporting a family is not megabucks. So that 9% will be felt every month.[/quote]
It's 9% over the threshold though, not 9% on the whole lot. Whilst I'm not supportive, I am old enough to remember basic rate tax being 33% and personal allowance being proportionally far lower than now.

Comefromaway · 25/09/2021 11:57

[quote Tryingtryingandtrying]@comefromaway Over £40ish k it is 40% tax or 49% for those with a loan. And 40kish supporting a family is not megabucks. So that 9% will be felt every month.[/quote]
£40k supporting a family is megabucks to me. Dh and I put two kids through private school on a combined income of £65k

Everyone at the firm I work who is on over £40k puts extra in their pension to keep their income down.

Tryingtryingandtrying · 25/09/2021 11:57

A graduate tax would be staggered, probably easier to administrate. And those who are extremely high earners would pay a percentage for x number of years. So would pay more than those who never cashed in in a high paying graduate loan. Eg nurses v investment banking.

OP posts:
ChequerBoard · 25/09/2021 11:56

[quote Tryingtryingandtrying]@sst1234 A tax that the wealthy don't pay? How's that fair?[/quote]

But they are paying it.

Just as a lump sum upfront for fees and payments straight to their child for maintenance rather than borrowing it from SLC and paying it back over time after graduation.

titchy · 25/09/2021 11:55

@BasicDad

YABU.

It's a pretty fair system.

It's regressive - the very definition of unfair! Reducing interest rates would make it less regressive, but of course means less income to the Govn. Although the RAB charge would be lower so reducing interest is palatable politically.
Bratnews · 25/09/2021 11:55

The way it’s structured is unfair. Yes the monthly are designed to be affordable but that’s just to get everyone to buy into the concept of a graduate tax. Many many of our dc will end up with an effective rate of tax which is >50%. I wouldn’t be v happy with that.

Plus the government can flex the terms of repayment. With the way things are going I’d expect them to play around with the thresholds and the term of repayment.

Essentially it’s a gamble, low earner and your fine, high earner and your fine, middle earner pay for 30 years and repay significantly more than you actually borrowed because of the usurious interest rates.

Comefromaway · 25/09/2021 11:55

The bit I disagree with I think the same amount of maintenance loan should be available to all because I’ve seen loads of young people over the years including my own husband whose parents refused to support them for whatever reason.

Tryingtryingandtrying · 25/09/2021 11:54

@comefromaway Over £40ish k it is 40% tax or 49% for those with a loan. And 40kish supporting a family is not megabucks. So that 9% will be felt every month.

OP posts:
Chessie678 · 25/09/2021 11:54

Student loans do make the top bracket of tax high.

The part of your income from c£27k is taxed at 20% income tax, 12% NICs and 9% student loan (so 41%).

And the part form c.50k is taxed at 40% income tax, 2% NICs and 9% student loan, so 51%.

(And NICs are to rise soon).

Clearly the blended rate is lower.

sirfredfredgeorge · 25/09/2021 11:51

Yes it is designed this way and much better than being an ‘actual loan’

But quite a bit worse than being an actual graduate tax.

Porfre · 25/09/2021 11:48

I graduated in 2008.

Ive still got about a year of payments to go.

But the way I see it.
I earn a decent amount that I would never have had the chance to earn if I hadnt gone to university in the first place.
Hopefully I can help my kids with the Uni costs so they dont have the same problems i did.
It is a large amount going out every month, and next year when it ends it will be a good boost to my income.