Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to think the student loan is a graduate tax that you can avoid if your parents are wealthy enough?

160 replies

Tryingtryingandtrying · 25/09/2021 10:57

Was it designed deliberately this way by people with wealthy parents? Can you pay the fees up front each year if you have enough money?

OP posts:
BasicDad · 25/09/2021 13:59

@titchy I genuinely don't think you have an answer for how you think the student loan system is regressive.

BasicDad · 25/09/2021 13:58

How are wealthy students benefitting from up front payments? If I was gifted 28k from mom and pop for my tuition fees, I'd still take the loan and invest the money they'd given me!

Pottedpalm · 25/09/2021 13:57

@ShinyMe

As *@Seeline* says, if you had to pay back the loan regardless, lots of people from poorer households and people on courses which lead to poorly paid jobs would just not go, and that causes huge problems. I graduated over 20 years ago and am still not paying back my loan (although I think I am just over the threshold on the newer loan payment terms, but I had an OLD OLD loan with better terms) and I don't see that I will ever repay mine. My wage is below the national average, even though I see it as comfortable for me (I earn more than most of my friends) so why should I be repaying the same as say, a law graduate earning four times my salary?
Because you got the degree; what you chose to do with it is irrelevant.
titchy · 25/09/2021 13:57

@BasicDad

Even in the worst case scenario of repayment, I don't know how anyone can feel hard done by earning £50k+ from the age of around 22.Confused
Well they'd likely be one of the high earners that the loan system is beneficial for...Hmm
Pottedpalm · 25/09/2021 13:55

@FirewomanSam

Paying it all up front would be a very silly thing to do since most people won’t pay off the full amount before it gets written off. Martin Lewis has some good explanations about it on the MSE website.

So yes, wealthy people could pay all the fees up front and thereby avoid having to pay anything else in future but it would make very little financial sense to do that.

You pay interest on the loan. Both my DC have paid off their loans, they have paid more than they would have done if it was paid upfront.
DeepaBeesKit · 25/09/2021 13:49

Ish.

Of course anyone can pay it up front. But the way it is done now is fairest, because it keeps the repayment levels manageable and you only pay back so much as your earnings support.

The only way you can eliminate wealthy students benefitting from their parents paying the fees would be to make it "free" and past the cost into general taxation. This would utterly unfair on the millions of hardworking non graduates who shouldnt have to pay for students who choose to spend 3 years studying in a very expensive way.

BasicDad · 25/09/2021 13:48

@titchy explain how it is regressive?

Are you talking about the poor £50k/year 22 year old?

poshme · 25/09/2021 13:47

@IceCreamAndCandyfloss

There’s no obligation to go to uni nor take out a loan.

What I do disagree with is the option to not pay the loan back by either not working or keeping below the salary threashold , repayments should start from six months after the course finishes regardless of what the person is doing career wise.

Well this wouldn't work at all. Every single time anyone went on maternity leave they'd get into debt over their student loan payments.

Or if someone became ill And couldn't work, they'd get into debt over their loan payments.

BasicDad · 25/09/2021 13:46

Even in the worst case scenario of repayment, I don't know how anyone can feel hard done by earning £50k+ from the age of around 22.Confused

cupofdecaf · 25/09/2021 13:45

Yes it is.

titchy · 25/09/2021 13:42

@ChequerBoard

"A graduate tax proper wouldn't be (as) regressive because those high earners would be paying throughout their working lives."

The higher earners are already paying more throughout their lives - you know through tax.

It may not be perfect, but the current system is better than any of these daft double taxation suggestions.

Errr yes - that's what would make an actual graduate tax system less regressive than the current system. That's the point I was making Confused
Bobsyer · 25/09/2021 13:32

[quote Tryingtryingandtrying]@comefromaway Over £40ish k it is 40% tax or 49% for those with a loan. And 40kish supporting a family is not megabucks. So that 9% will be felt every month.[/quote]
You don’t understand how taxes work, clearly.

ChequerBoard · 25/09/2021 13:28

"A graduate tax proper wouldn't be (as) regressive because those high earners would be paying throughout their working lives."

The higher earners are already paying more throughout their lives - you know through tax.

It may not be perfect, but the current system is better than any of these daft double taxation suggestions.

SaddenedByItAll · 25/09/2021 13:27

It's regressive because the amount paid back is lower the more you earn. While it's fine for low payers who won't pay anything back, for middle income earners they pay proportionally more of their salaries in their lifetime on their loan than high earners do.

A graduate tax proper wouldn't be (as) regressive because those high earners would be paying throughout their working lives.

Eh?
Are you suggesting that everyone pays a tax to allow low income families to send a child to uni?
Because as you were pointed out, this is a loan.
It's like buying a fridge, high incomes will just buy the fridge outright and that's the end of it.
A low income family may need to use credit to buy it and end up paying more, as well as that fridge taking up considerably more as a proportion of the family income.
That is just a fact of life

BasicDad · 25/09/2021 13:26

@titchy That's how loans work though right? The quicker you reduce the debt, the lower the capital charge. It's not a tax, it's a loan.

If you never or hardly breach the earning threshold, it's the cheapest loan you'll ever take. How is that regressive?

daisypond · 25/09/2021 13:20

The repayment threshold in England is just under 28k. Many graduates will never earn that. I’m in my 50s with a first class degree from a top university and I only just earn that now.

titchy · 25/09/2021 13:17

@BasicDad

It's not a tax, it's a loan. How is it regressive?
It's regressive because the amount paid back is lower the more you earn. While it's fine for low payers who won't pay anything back, for middle income earners they pay proportionally more of their salaries in their lifetime on their loan than high earners do.

A graduate tax proper wouldn't be (as) regressive because those high earners would be paying throughout their working lives.

GreenWhiteViolet · 25/09/2021 13:15

For various reasons I was very afraid of getting into debt when I was young. I went to university as a mature student in my late twenties, after having saved enough that I could get by without taking out any loans.

I know most people here would say that's a bad way to do it, but it worked for me. Point being that it isn't just rich people paying upfront, and I wouldn't be best pleased about having to pay an extra tax after I lived very frugally for years to avoid the debt to begin with!

BasicDad · 25/09/2021 13:09

It's not a tax, it's a loan. How is it regressive?

lunar1 · 25/09/2021 13:00

We will probably pay our children's university fees, we pay for private school so it's a continuation for us.

I understand the argument for and against, the careers they both have in mind would have them paying it all back anyway. They will both be expected to get a Saturday job to contribute.

I think the way student finance is worked out is awful.

Northernsoullover · 25/09/2021 12:58

I'm happy with my graduate tax. Its catapulted me from a cleaner on NMW to top 10% of earners.

LobsterNapkin · 25/09/2021 12:56

It's not a tax, it's just that some people pay up front, and some don't.

I am all for publicly funded higher education, but it doesn't need to involves some weird after the fact tax.

SkinnyMirror · 25/09/2021 12:54

[quote Tryingtryingandtrying]@comefromaway Over £40ish k it is 40% tax or 49% for those with a loan. And 40kish supporting a family is not megabucks. So that 9% will be felt every month.[/quote]
Your maths is wrong.
It's 9% above the threshold not 9% of your whole salary.

LookAtMoiPloise · 25/09/2021 12:52

repayments should start from six months after the course finishes regardless of what the person is doing career wise

🙄

RufustheBadgeringReindeer · 25/09/2021 12:51

You have interest on the loan though. So can end up paying back more which I guess is OP’s point

Exactly