Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to think the student loan is a graduate tax that you can avoid if your parents are wealthy enough?

160 replies

Tryingtryingandtrying · 25/09/2021 10:57

Was it designed deliberately this way by people with wealthy parents? Can you pay the fees up front each year if you have enough money?

OP posts:
titchy · 25/09/2021 16:44

But in other countries where graduate taxes operate, they are applied to all who actually graduate as far as I am aware. Fees are often not paid by the studnet at all so rich parents cannot pay in their offsprings behalf and thus avoid them paying the graduate rate of tax.

titchy · 25/09/2021 16:41

Well as graduate tax isn't on the cards it's a moot point, and the thread was about the existing scheme.

BasicDad · 25/09/2021 16:27

@titchy if graduate tax is introduced. Is it only for students that received their tuition fees for free? Or tax for all graduates regardless? Is it forever, or time boxed? What about students that drop out? Is it only for those that graduate? At what band does it kick in? Should it also be a higher % for middle and higher earners?

titchy · 25/09/2021 15:21

I also think there's far bigger policies round the corner than pose a greater risk to HE in this country than just the loans system. But another thread I suspect!

titchy · 25/09/2021 15:19

And it's a loan, not a tax, so you can't even call it regressive...it's just finance!

It's called a loan. But that's a misnomer. It looks like a tax, it functions as a tax, to all intents and purposes it IS a tax. A regressive one, unlike a true grad tax which wouldn't be regressive.

I'm not arguing for or against either the current loan which is a tax, or a true graduate tax system by the way, just pointing out how one is fairer than the other.

BasicDad · 25/09/2021 14:50

@thegcatsmother

Due to reasons which are none of your business, it wasn't possible to do that. He hasn't paid for anything; we did.
True. Should have qualified that in many situations it's better...not specifically yours.
thegcatsmother · 25/09/2021 14:45

Furthermore, by paying in full, the university got the money up front; a discount was available if you paid the fees upfront, and the taxpayer wasn't paying for the loans.

SusieBob · 25/09/2021 14:43

[quote BasicDad]@SusieBob but that would almost certainly create a two class system.

Little Tarquin's Mummy and Daddy are going to pay in full to avoid an unlimited tax on future earnings. Therefore the only people paying graduate tax are those that couldn't afford to pay up front.[/quote]
Little Tarquin's mummy and daddy can already do that.

At least with a simple graduate tax nobody is scared off by the prospect of a bogus "debt" hanging over them.

thegcatsmother · 25/09/2021 14:42

Due to reasons which are none of your business, it wasn't possible to do that. He hasn't paid for anything; we did.

BasicDad · 25/09/2021 14:39

@thegcatsmother

If you'd have given him the money to stick in a LISA or SIPP, he'd have been in a better financial position in the long run and reduced risk of paying for something he didn't need to.

purplecarrot23 · 25/09/2021 14:35

@InvincibleInvisibility

Yes. Not really a surprise that children from wealthy families have advantages and opportunities that other children don't.

We are comfortably off and can't complain. DS' best friend's dad earns 10 million a year. Their experiences, especially during school holidays, are vastly different.

@InvincibleInvisibility what job does he do to earn £10million per year? Genuinely interested as that's a helluva salary!
BasicDad · 25/09/2021 14:34

@SusieBob but that would almost certainly create a two class system.

Little Tarquin's Mummy and Daddy are going to pay in full to avoid an unlimited tax on future earnings. Therefore the only people paying graduate tax are those that couldn't afford to pay up front.

thegcatsmother · 25/09/2021 14:29

We paid upfront for ds's BA and MA. He has no student loans at all. It was pointless taking a student loan and incurring interest when we would have paid it anyway. No, he may not have ever paid it back, but we preferred he start adult life with no debt.

daisypond · 25/09/2021 14:29

That's got to be very unusual, surely. I know people who started on £28k without a degree

I don’t think so. Most people in the company I work for have top degrees from top universities, including Oxford and Cambridge, and the starting salary is about 22k in London, and less elsewhere in the country. My DH went to Oxford and is in his 50s and he earns about 25k. Most jobs simply don’t pay particularly well. My DD graduated with a first this year from a RG university and earns much less than that too.

SusieBob · 25/09/2021 14:23

The biggest problem with calling it a loan is that it still actively discourages people from going to university as they worry about getting into debt.

The truth is < 25% of graduates will ever pay the loan off, and a lot of those people pay it off early in the mistaken belief that it saves them money when, in fact, it's often better to not pay the loan off and just let it be written off. The system is expensive to administer and with the different types of loan out there overly complicated to understand.

Just do away with the whole thing, introduce a graduate tax and be done with it.

BasicDad · 25/09/2021 14:17

@titchy but middle income earners that earn £50k/year straight out of uni?

And it's a loan, not a tax, so you can't even call it regressive...it's just finance!

Even if you can make the fictional leap to pretend it was a tax, it'd still be hard to argue it being regressive when it's still advantageous to earners up to around £45k/year (from 22!). Additionally, those that clear the loan quicker by virtue of a higher income will be paying an order of magnitude more tax as a whole through a progressive taxation system!

It's pretty proposterous to consider otherwise.

TheHouseILiveIn · 25/09/2021 14:13

@daisypond

The repayment threshold in England is just under 28k. Many graduates will never earn that. I’m in my 50s with a first class degree from a top university and I only just earn that now.
That's got to be very unusual, surely. I know people who started on £28k without a degree
DGRossetti · 25/09/2021 14:10

The trick is - or used to be - to get your degree and then emigrate (like my DB did).

JoborPlay · 25/09/2021 14:09

I can't get het up about it to be honest. DH and I both have significant student debt, but I can't say it impacts massively on our lives.

daisypond · 25/09/2021 14:07

Not if you end up in a decent career. If you end up a high earner the interest rate on the loan is extortionate.

But that doesn’t much matter - because a high earner can pay it off quickly. A friend’s child paid off their entire loan within three years after graduating.

titchy · 25/09/2021 14:05

@Jaxhog

On the basis suggested here, we should also do away with mortgage interest rates too! After all, it isn't fair that richer people have shorter, smaller or no mortgages, so pay less interest!
There isn't an argument that mortgages should be fair though. They're a private arrangement between two private bodies - the bank and the individual. Education loans I would argue are a public good and come from the public purse so should be as fair as possible.

I'd happily go back to Gov funding HE in full though as a principle. That's the only truly fair system.

Blossomtoes · 25/09/2021 14:03

@Tryingtryingandtrying

I think it should be a graduate tax that everyone pays regardless of wealth. That would be fairer than the current system.
You mean the way it used to be when only 5% of the population were graduates?
titchy · 25/09/2021 14:03

Ok @BasicDad .... maybe some examples will help with what is meant by regressive.

(Remember we're only talking about high vs medium earners here.)

A high earner might pay off all their loan in ten years. They will have accrued ten years of interest, so maybe paid a grand total of £75k in repayments.

Middle income earners can expect to spend the maximum thirty years in repayments, irrespective of whether they pay it off or not. So they will end up paying a heck of a lot more than the high earner. That's what we mean by regressive.

Jaxhog · 25/09/2021 14:02

On the basis suggested here, we should also do away with mortgage interest rates too! After all, it isn't fair that richer people have shorter, smaller or no mortgages, so pay less interest!

TheHouseILiveIn · 25/09/2021 14:01

@WoozySnoozy

Even the wealthy people should consider taking out the loan. Its one of the best rates you'll ever get.
Not if you end up in a decent career. If you end up a high earner the interest rate on the loan is extortionate. It's something like 5.6% off the top of my head and starts accruing straight away. So by the time you graduate your loan is higher than the amount you took out and increases every year. If you think base rate is 0.1% then 5.6% is daylight robbery. This is my beef with the student loan system. It's as bad as the American system if you end up being a high earner.