Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for your help getting my finances under control

39 replies

SpikeyFloof · 25/09/2021 10:27

I have always lived hand to mouth and often fallen into the trap of having a spend up on payday, then counting pennies to buy milk at the end of the month.

I need a spreadsheet for household finances and a spreadsheet/income expenditure sheet for my business. I jot down my business ingoings and outgoings in a notepad at the moment which is not the best system. I'm self-employed and have an online shop where I sell things I make. I usually get a small top up from UC at the end of the month if my income was low.

I'm on a dmp after my other business had to close during first lockdown. Ex DP is about to press the self destruct button and quit his job so the cm he has been paying is likely to reduce or stop altogether in the next month (right before Christmas ffs). I'm really worried about money so any advice greatly appreciated.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
workwoes123 · 27/09/2021 13:18

@BarbaraofSeville

Using YNAB or similar software allows you to run multiple “pots” in a single account - including for future spends. You do have to keep it up to date and properly reconciled, but once it’s up and running you can pretty much ignore your actual balance and look only at your YNAB categories.

This only works if, as I say, you are always keeping track and checking frequently.

BarbaraofSeville · 26/09/2021 19:51

Bills account that never gets touched, salary paid in and all DDs etc go from there

I think this is key, along with accounting for annual and irregular essentials like car maintenance, broken appliances etc.

Using one account for bills, essentials like food, and non essentials must be so hard to manage, yet so many people seem to do this.

Doorhandleghost · 26/09/2021 18:37

I also use multiple accounts to manage things:

Bills account that never gets touched, salary paid in and all DDs etc go from there
A Current account for travel costs
A Current account for food money
A current account for spends
Savings accounts

If your credit is shot I’d try for basic accounts rather than currents if you decide to open multiple accounts.

workwoes123 · 26/09/2021 12:34

Have you got a Gmail account? It's free, and Google Sheets is easy to use. You could sign up to a workshop or watch YouTube videos to get the basics under your belt. I honestly think it would be time very well spent, both for personal budgeting and for your business.

user1471548941 · 26/09/2021 12:00

I have 4 accounts. It took some working out but now I have worked out the best amounts to divide it by:

1 x account for all bills money, including an amount set aside for yearly bills such as car service so it adds up over the year.
1 x account with correct amount for food and fuel for the month (account for whether it’s a 4 or 5 week month!)
1 x amount for savings
1 x amount of “free” spending money e.g. clothes, shoes, day out.

I found that by separating the amounts needed for other things I could still accommodate for my own habit to have a payday spend up!

FindingMeno · 26/09/2021 11:47

If you possibly can afford it, think about one of the more expensive items of shopping ( eg washing powder or coffee) and stock up a bit when it's on offer. Or identify the biggest offer savings on items you use and stock up on them.
Eventually you will end up buying most of your shelf stable products on offer if you continue to apply this rule.
You may need to swap brands a bit, but it saves a fortune.

Elieza · 26/09/2021 11:45

PS Id have all my direct debits for contents insurance, debt repayments, council tax, tv licence, electric etc come out the week I get paid. So for me that’s the first week of the month. Then you know if you look at your bank the second week of the month or thereafter what’s there is your own money not money you need to not touch as it’s for bills.

Elieza · 26/09/2021 11:43

Your ledger will work for your home.

I’d start at the front for work finances and the back page for home finances. If it’s a fair size ledger it will do you some time.

If you decide it’s not working you can just rip out the back pages of home finances and shred, and just keep the ledger for work.

Start at the next pay day.

B/f or c/f (depending what acronym you use means brought forward or carried forward)

That’s the first thing you put, what your starting with. So if you have a tenner left in the bank unspent you put that.

And then you put all your Ins and Outs and tally it up daily to get a running balance.

It won’t stop you overspending though it will record what shop you overspent on (like Asda £74 when you knew you only needed £39 of groceries so you know at the time you shouldn’t have bought that new cost you didn’t need etc). But as you won’t likely itemise everything you will forget. You could try keeping the receipts though.

You could also note how much food you throw out as that shows if you need to plan better meals to use up stuff.

Purplewithred · 25/09/2021 19:50

Learn how to use spreadsheets, really easy, they do all the sums for you, and will make a massive difference to how you run the business as well as your personal spending.

Martin Lewis has a really good budgeting thing you can fill in too, will prompt you for all the expenses you should be thinking of.

Akire · 25/09/2021 17:32

Doesn't have to be fancy just list and amounts where you can keep track. Spreadsheets can add it up for you but just as easy with calculator. Long as have record that’s what counts.

Egghead68 · 25/09/2021 17:07

Seconding Monzo (not used it but others swear by it)

SpikeyFloof · 25/09/2021 17:05

I don't know how to use spreadsheets. I've just ordered an ingoing and outgoing ledger from amazon for my shop. I wonder if that would work for household income?

OP posts:
workwoes123 · 25/09/2021 16:31

The first thing you need to do before taking any of the budgeting tips above is to track every penny you are currently spending. You need to know where every penny is going. Atm you don’t actually know where you can cut down, because you don’t know where it’s going in the first place.

To do this:

Print out 2-3 months of bank statements. If you spend cash, then you need to start collecting every receipt: card payments are much easier to track.

Set up a very basic spreadsheet. You’ve already got the most common categories of expenditure in your previous post. Start with the and add categories so the you are accounting for every single penny. Knowledge is power: there’s nowhere to hide once you start tracking properly.

Do you know how to use a spreadsheet? Google Sheets or Excel?

You should also be doing this for your business. Track every penny.

waybill · 25/09/2021 16:07

If you use part of your home as an office/workshop, you can recover part of your household bills (rates, water, insurance, utilities, broadband etc) as business expenses. Check on the HMRC website under self-employed, there's loads of information on there.

When you fill in your weekly incomings and outgoings on your UC account, how does that work exactly? (sorry, never done it myself). I would have thought that since you are self-employed, then your income is after business expenses have been deducted, not your turnover before expenses.

Otherwise, if you were bringing in say £1,000 a week and business expenses were £900 then your earnings are only £100 so they should be using that figure of £100 for the calculation of your earnings, not £1,000. Because that's all you have earned.

Akire · 25/09/2021 15:37

Is prime just 7.99 are you just using for Tv or are you spending £100 month on essentials little things because it’s free postage and easy? Easy thing to add up and how much of the “I really need” are essentials rather than nice or can wait few more weeks months.

BarbaraofSeville · 25/09/2021 15:17

I'm wasting money on top ups, eating out, days out, toys for the kids, bits for the house, etc

If you buy enough food during your weekly shop, none of those things are essential. You could work out a budget including savings for annual and irregular expenses like Christmas, insurance, MOT and repairs etc and put your spare money after all that in a separate account to be used on a 'when it's gone, it's gone basis' with no more until next month.

For days out can you do free things or get an annual pass if there's something local you like to go to a lot and take a picnic to avoid spending £££s at cafes.

fuzzymoomin · 25/09/2021 15:13

Ok, so, suggestions as follows. My questions are not questions to get an answer, it's just questions for you to think about yourself.

Rent: Is this a safe £400? If your landlord is likely to put it up soon then work it into your planning.
DMP: Is this debt mgmt plan? Stick with it... how long have you got left? Are you accruing interest or charges on the debt? If so it might be better to use your savings amount to clear the debt faster.
Kids classes: Are they really into all of the classes? (If yes, keep them) Are there any they are losing interest in that you could drop? Or, do any of the classes offer a subsidy fee for parents with financial struggles?
Car insurance: Have you done an online comparison recently to check if there is a cheaper deal?
Gas/electric: This will rise for everyone. Same question again, have you done an online comparison recently to check whether there is a cheaper deal? Are there ways you could be more frugal - wear jumpers before you put the heating on, are you using all of the hot water you heat, run your washing machine etc at night if your supplier has an off-peak.
Water: Are you on a water meter? Could you be more frugal with water usage? Shorter showers, half a bowl for washing up.
Prime: Would you really miss it if it was gone? Six months without it gets you an extra £50.
Food: Do a food plan for your three meals per day plus any snacks and drinks. Buy exactly what you need each week.
Petrol: Well, we might not have any soon Confused But are you using the car for any journeys that you could actually walk instead?
Phone/internet: As above, do an online comparison to see whether you can switch to a better deal. I've just switched my phone to virgin for £6/mnth and broadband with Sky for £25/mnth.
Savings: It's brilliant that you can save but as above check whether it would be beneficial to use this to clear the debt faster.
Maybe you also have council tax, tv licence? Go through your bank statements for the past few months and list every outgoing, then pick out which are essential and which are nice but not essential.
The top-up shopping, whatever you are topping up on, add it to your weekly shop so you're not needing to go shopping multiple times.
Eating out: Can you cut this back? If it's to meet friends can you meet for coffee instead of food, or get a take away in, or find special offers, or go for a walk for free? Or just be strict and not eat out for a few months?
Toys for the kids: Could this be cut out until Christmas? Maybe arrange a toy swap with their friends so they pass on anything they are bored with and get something different?
Days out: Look for free things, special offers.
Bits for the house: As with toys, can you set yourself a challenge not to buy anything until Christmas?
Your income: As I suggested before, have a big clear out and try to sell on things, a few £s here and there adds up each week. Then your business, you have an online shop? Is this business something where you can get a boost from Christmas/seasonal? Like, suppose you are making mugs, are you now making Halloween mugs, then bonfire night mugs, then winter and Christmas mugs. Are there local websites, facebook pages where you can promote yourself more? Are there local events where you can have a stall and sell a bit extra in person?

You might well have already thought of all of this. I really sympathise with your situation. I was in debt and living hand to mouth for a decade, it's hard work. But small changes over time does benefit, as with being strict with yourself. Good luck 👍🏻

BarbaraofSeville · 25/09/2021 15:12

Yes, you've missed off quite a few things like council tax and car maintenance for a start.

Do you actually spend £300 on food or is that what you hope to spend?

Some good advice here

www.moneysavingexpert.com/banking/budget-planning/

SpikeyFloof · 25/09/2021 14:08

Quick rundown of monthly expenses are:

Rent 400
Dmp 105
Kids classes 150
Car insurance 40
Gas/electric 70
Water 45
Prime 7.99
Food 300
Petrol 60
Phone/internet 50
Savings 50

Probably some stuff I've missed off there. Income is roughly 1,500 including child benefit. Ex has been paying 200 a month which covered all the kids extra curriculars.

I'm wasting money on top ups, eating out, days out, toys for the kids, bits for the house, etc.

OP posts:
fuzzymoomin · 25/09/2021 13:31

Without knowing your bills and stuff it's difficult to advise. Do you feel able to list a months outgoings here? We could flag up areas to look at.
But I'd suggest four things.
First, look at what you call your essential spends at the beginning of the month. Are they all genuinely essential? Can any of them be second hand or free from websites? For the birthday presents, could any of them be dropped with a mutual "no presents" agreement with the recipient? When you're buying new uniform, shoes, are the old ones good enough to sell on even for a few £s?
Second, the £10-15 you're spending every few days, really look at what you are spending that on. Extra milk, bread? Add it to a weekly shop at the beginning of the week. I was also in a habit of popping to the shop a few times a week, a few things I needed and a few things that caught my eye - when I stopped going so often I stopped getting the little extras.
Third, make a food plan either for the week or month. Batch cook so you eat some and freeze some. When you know you have spare meals in the freezer there's less need to buy anything last-minute.
Fourth, go through your entire home clearing out anything you don't use that can be sold on. Even if only a few £s it all adds up.

PooWillyNameChange · 25/09/2021 12:54

If your business isn't that profitable and money is such an issue is it time to retrain for an alternative professional career or take a job as an employee?

PooWillyNameChange · 25/09/2021 12:53
  1. A budget. Don't just track what you spend, plan it. Use an app like YNAB (it's not free but worth its weight in gold, free trial (no card required), loads of Facebook groups to help you and it's cheaper through the website not app store. Or go old fashioned and put your money into imaginary pots, or real ones and use cash! I think Starling bank allow you to divvy your money up when you get paid so you can see what is in each 'pot' for spending and that's free.
  2. Cut expenses where you can. Do you switch everything every year? Car insurance, electricity/gas (probably best to wait on that one right now!), home insurance etc...set a reminder on your phone or put it in your calendar and use comparison sites to find the best deal. And see the aforementioned budget? When you're in a better place you can save 1/12th of all of these costs per month into their respective 'pots' and you'll be able to buy annually, usually saving around 10%
  3. Food is a massive cost for most people. Meal plan every week. Go through your cupboards, plan to use up what you have, make sure you end up with an empty fridge at the end of each week (soup is great for any leftover veggies) so you're not throwing away your money. Avoid top up shops. Getting your shopping delivered may help you stick to the list/stay on budget. Also see the moneysavingexpert old style forums for cheap recipe inspiration
Lemonlemon88 · 25/09/2021 12:50

Freezing bread and milk will really help. We currently have DM living with us and she eats an astounding amount of bread (I suspect she gives the children a lot of extra toast too), I end up spending heaps on top up shops when I only mean to buy bread and milk so now I'm freezing it to break the habit.

Doorhandleghost · 25/09/2021 12:47

Do you keep your business and personal expenditure separate at the moment ie use different accounts? If not you really should, don’t forget to account for your tax and ni and save for it so you don’t get caught out by that.

I think I was a bit like you until about 2 yrs ago when I decided to really get a handle on my finances - that horrible panic about whether there’s enough.

First thing I did was to spend a month tracking literally everything I spent. This helps inform your budget - for instance I had £200 down on my spreadsheet for food, but when I tracked my spending I found I spent nearer £350! And travel - bus fares, the off taxi to one of DDs clubs on a rainy day, I paid for this from my “spends” budget but after tracking it realised I needed to account for it separately. Let’s not even get started on the amount I was frittering on crap 😉.

Once I knew my actuals I could start making informed decisions as to what my budget should be. So for food I decided £200 wasn’t enough so I went for £250 and kept an eye on it. Travel money I keep in a separate account (I have an expensive commute to London so I need to ringfence that money as it would be a bit of a disaster if I didn’t have it!). Spends I allocated myself a reasonable budget.

My spreadsheet is really simple - it adds up what comes in, what goes out, and I make a new copy for each month so I can play around with the figures (for instance I changed jobs recently so had a tax refund, and I have a couple of one off expenses next month). If your maintenance payments are not reliable I would suggest that you don’t include that as income in your official budget and account for it separately. I did this and it meant I was never caught short unexpectedly.

myadhdusername · 25/09/2021 12:43

Monzo

Swipe left for the next trending thread