Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The purpose of school photos has changed, hasn't it?

143 replies

merzeemee · 25/09/2021 10:02

When I was a child in the 1970/80's the School Photo was an annual opportunity for a professional shot of me and my brother smiling, sitting still, and looking clean and smart in our uniforms. They were proudly bought, distributed to grandparents, compared from year to year, and fondly looked back on - especially the class photos of familiar faces with gradually forgotten names.

Now I'm a secondary school parent, I see them differently. They're an annual opportunity for the school to get cheap (free?) photos of every child and teacher. The childrens' photos are attached to their records in the school's Management Information System, helping staff to put faces to names. They are also used as profile pictures on school Microsoft accounts, so teachers and students remotely interacting via Teams can see a face rather than just a name. The teachers' photos are put on the wall of a corridor, again to help everyone to put faces to names.

The cost to the school is kept low because the photography firm makes its money from selling copies of the photos to parents, which is fine, so long as the quality of the photos remains high, and parents continue to buy photos.

Unfortunately, I haven't bought my children's individual school photos for the past 6 years, because they are always on an ugly mottled blue background, and I can take nicer pictures myself at home. I don't think the photographer makes any effort at all to take photos that are relaxed or flattering, and they are overpriced. I do buy the group photos, but certainly not every year. (This year the group photo was a clever montage of the whole year group's individual photos - a covid memento we weren't expecting because only individual shots were taken!).

Do you buy your child's school photo every year?

OP posts:
ParkheadParadise · 25/09/2021 12:20

I buy them
I still have dd1 from 20+ years ago.

I remember having our school photo done with my siblings. My oldest sister cut our hair before it and I had a MASSIVE pink flower in my hair, one of my sisters had my mums rosary beads on 😂😂😂 My mum was in hospital at the time.
When she came home the photo was propped up on the fireplace. She took one look at it and burst out crying 😂😂😂. My dad was in the doghouse for weeks because he let us all go to school looking like that.

Comedycook · 25/09/2021 12:19

No I don't buy them. The world has changed and we all have cameras on us 24/7. Back when we had to have an actual camera with a roll of film you'd get developed at the chemists, I could see the appeal of the school photo but not nowadays

Groovee · 25/09/2021 12:19

I work in a school and have never had my photo taken, that's not been done by a colleague.

I bought my children's ones until S1.

GoodnightGrandma · 25/09/2021 12:16

We bought DD’s last school photo but the quality was awful, I take a better photo on my phone.
I’m not buying any more.

Peanutsandchilli · 25/09/2021 12:16

I buy them maybe every couple of years in primary school. Once they hit high school they get an individual one taken in year 7 and year 11. That's it. No form ones, although they take a full year group one for the school's use. As they get further up the school (GCSE years) they change forms regularly, as part of the school's attempt to use their form time as extra revision time - they'll be put in a form with a teacher who teaches one of their weaker subjects, so it would be pointless taking form group ones.

This year, due to covid, two of mine (then nursery and year 6) had individual and class photos taken in July. I bought them, then was given one of my eldest as part of the year 6 leaver's gifts. They've both now moved to new schools, so the eldest has just had her year 7 picture taken, and the youngest is having another individual photo taken next week, though her new school are offering after school family photos, which will allow me to take my 2 older kids and my toddler, so at least I can get all 4 of them in one photo. I'll probably buy that and none of the others.

SaberToothKitten · 25/09/2021 12:13

The kids liked the group ones in primary, so I always used to buy those. But stopped buying them 4 years ago (sorry DC3) when the photo company were absolute dicks. They first promised ('of course, no problem!') then suddenly refused to cancel an order I made in error, despite my emailing them within seconds of realising I'd selected the wrong thing and phoning them on the dot the next morning. They pissed me off so much that they can keep their overpriced inflexible systems.

Abraxan · 25/09/2021 12:12

As a school we really don't make lots of money from school photo companies coming in.

And yes, they are often not great. They are taken on a decent camera but only in a standard setting, linked to a computer which then lines up the shot etc. Takes a few seconds to position child and take the picture. There is little time taken by the photographer to actual capture the child properly. As staff we've sometimes asked for an obviously rubbish one to be redone, but we have to be really watching careful to catch them - whilst also organising the line of children waiting and when finished, and trying to untuck collars, smooth hair down, checking child doesn't have food round their face, etc.

The whole process is a military exercise of getting the right children in the right order, in the right place. Literally is sit, smile, click, go.

It's next week at my school.

liveforsummer · 25/09/2021 12:11

Our school takes their own photos on iPads for their records. I don't buy the photographers pictures though as I can definitely take better myself on my phone. No idea how they manage to get pictures that don't even look like my dc

Lottle · 25/09/2021 12:10

They are also used to help detect eating disorders. I guess professional photos are less important now everyone gets snapped with their phone camera whenever the mood strikes.

Comefromaway · 25/09/2021 12:09

I stopped buying them in primary when they started taking those take you shoes off and stand in your socks holding a random piece of school equipment type pictures.

StCharlotte · 25/09/2021 12:08

@ArblemarchTFruitbat

When I was a child in the 1970/80's the School Photo was an annual opportunity for a professional shot of me and my brother smiling, sitting still, and looking clean and smart in our uniforms.

Yes - there was a point to it when not everyone owned a camera and the cameras that were around, unless you spent a fortune, were not of great quality, and you didn't know whether the pictures were any good until you'd had the film developed, and any duds represented a waste of money.

Nowadays most people have a smart phone with a camera and you can snap away until you get pictures you're happy with.

I'm amazed school photos are a thing.

Exactly that.

I was born in the 60s and as the youngest of five there are very few photos of me as a child (single figures). I'm not sure my parents even had a camera. I destroyed the one school photo we had because I really really hated it (world's worst haircut) and I gave my favourite picture to a boyfriend who I haven't seen for decades - I'm still cross with myself about that!

Sunshinealligator · 25/09/2021 12:07

I tend not to buy them. We take many many photos of DD. It just seems like a lost tradition now.

MamaBear7a · 25/09/2021 12:06

I'm amazed at how expensive some of these are! We pay £5 total, that gives us an individual, class, and siblings photo. We get one print out of each and emailed the digital file if we want to print more. They are all really well done!

Abraxan · 25/09/2021 12:06

We take our own photographs for our learning platform, and for reports etc. Every class has 1-2 iPads and they are taken for free on them, plus a member of staff has a SLR camera/photography hobby and takes photographs at special school events etc inc start of the year (all following the school code of conduct and policy for photographs) - all taken and used for free by school and often digital copies available for free for parents too.

The only thing the school photographs are used for is SIMS but that's simply as we get sent a low res version of each photograph digitally which is easy to upload as a whole school, but the photo quality of that low res version is poor and certainly not good enough for use on reports etc.

reluctantbrit · 25/09/2021 12:04

Oh, and the only photo we have on display is the one from her first day in Reception, I don’t like the gallery of photos everywhere and we have two multi photo frames with different sizes so the traditional school ones don’t fit anyway.

Prokupatuscrakedatus · 25/09/2021 12:03

School does an annual fotoshoot for pupil's ID (needed for reduced entrance fees, free public transport etc.) and offers group fotos and individual fotos to buy, but you do not have to.
I usually buy them because they are still better than what I could do, cheaper than done privately and I get fotos for grandparents, grandaunts etc.

saraclara · 25/09/2021 12:03

The purpose was always to provide photos for record keeping, and for fundraising. Even when I started teaching over forty years ago. I have no idea why you ever thought they were done purely for the benefit of parents.

If anything they're needed less now, as schools have digital cameras for records, and fewer parents buy them because we all have thousands of photos of our kids.

reluctantbrit · 25/09/2021 12:02

In Primary school we bought the class photos and the one from her gymnastic squad. The individual Infant school photos were crap, DD looked in most like she was dragged through the hedge backwards, face down. How has the idea of doing the photos after lunch?

Secondary: in Y7 they used the individual ones for the library cards but I found that I have lots of nicer ones from DD so didn’t buy it. They then had the great idea of doing a year photo, 240 girls in identical uniforms surrounded by 10 teacher (8 form teacher, head of year and head teacher). Even with DD pointing herself out I couldn’t identify her. Useless. They did now Y10 photos but I haven’t seen them yet.

derenstar · 25/09/2021 12:01

Going against the grain here but I like them and still buy them most years. I love having a snapshot of a particular point in their school journey to display and of course they make good pressies for the grandparents. My parents still have mine and my siblings and I think it’s so sweet.

Yes, we have a lot of digital photos of these days but we hardly ever print them out unless we need to for some sort of project. Having said that, I agree they are hideously overpriced but if some of that cost is passed back to the school, then I actually don’t mind. One year, DH decided he was going to do them himself, he took the snaps and never got them printed!

FatAnkles · 25/09/2021 11:59

In primary school, I used to buy them, but they are very expensive. I haven't had the opportunity to buy one in secondary., because I don't think they are done. I'd buy a class one for DD in Y11 or 12 for the memories but nothing else. I take photos of her on my phone which usually capture her better anyway.

deadleaves · 25/09/2021 11:59

No I never buy them. I hate school uniform and it does not make me happy to see my kids in it.

SeanChailleach · 25/09/2021 11:59

DD's primary school had a lovely photographer. They did two photos a year. Not even my photographer sister could capture portraits like that.
I love the class group photo - which I obviously couldn't snap myself.

Simonjt · 25/09/2021 11:49

I bought my sons reception photo as that is a big milestone, his year 1 and 2 pictures were so hilarious I had to buy them. Year 1 was the typical grimace of a child who doesn’t know how to smile, this years year 2 photo he couldn’t have looked more miserable if he tried.

DumplingsAndStew · 25/09/2021 11:46

I bought them every year at Primary, except P7 for my youngest, when they also missed their class photo (only done every second year). These didn't happen because of Covid.

Secondary school takes S1, S4 (last mandatory year) and S6 (last optional year).

Eldests S1 photo was one of them looking awful as they'd been ill, so I didn't buy that. S4 photos cancelled because of covid. They left before S6, so no secondary school photos at all.

Youngest were cancelled in S1 due to covid. Not sure if they'll get the chance this year, but they likely won't want it done.

Doubletap · 25/09/2021 11:44

The earlier PP got it right- the purpose of the school photo was so there is a recent clear photo of children in case they should go missing. It is still the main purpose now.

The other uses (ID on school systems, money spinner) are an added bonus.

Swipe left for the next trending thread