Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this landlady is ridiculously tight

62 replies

coffeerevelsrock · 25/09/2021 09:55

I have neighbours at a right angle to me who are tenants. A large tree at the back of their house was overhanging my drive and the pavement and making both unusable until they finally cut it back. Ivy was growing up my wall from their garden and starting to cover one of my bedroom windows. It's finally been cut back and is now still on my wall but dead, so not getting worse. When I spoke to them about these matters they were frustrated with their LL as she never checks on them and they have 3 broken fence panels that border my drive - they couldn't be fixed until the tree was sorted as it blocked access to them.

Now the ll is still refusing to fix their fence as she insists I have shared responsibility. I have looked at the land registry documents and it doesn't mention who is responsible for each boundary. I understand in this case it is normal to share but in previous years that fence has been fixed by the ll of that property, though the house has been sold since so it was a different person. The tree never got out of hand in those days either. She has emailed me one of those sheets you get when you but a house with tick boxes filled in by hand saying it's a shared boundary, but that's not a legally binding thing is it? Surely it's only the deeds that show it definitely?

She has quoted me £90 to fix the fence, so my share would be £45 but I really don't have this at the moment. It's been an expensive summer and I'm saving as much as I can having dipped into savings. I don't want a fence there - it's just my drive and doesn't need privacy from my side, though tenants obviously want it as it's their back garden but it's not completely exposed anyway. There's no legal requirement to have a fence anyway and I don't want to pay for something I don't want.

Also, when they cut the tree back I was having my bathroom done and had a skip on the drive. It was too big for the bathroom stuff and I planned to fill the rest with shit I've needed to get rid of for years but when the tenants asked I allowed them to put the tree waste there as I felt bad for them. I feel like that was my contribution to the whole thing, not that I have to make one. I keep all trees on my property under control and don't really want to pay for others as well.

Shouldn't she just pay the £90 to keep her lovely tenants happy? I feel like I feel more guilty about them than she does. I also feel like she could get the dead ivy off my house too rather than trying to push this. It's wrong priorities imo. This has gone on for months now.

OP posts:
icklekid · 25/09/2021 11:09

My next door neighbours have horrendous ivy all over their garden and it constantly comes through the fence. It wouldn’t be their responsibility to deal with it on my side of the property so I have to. You can’t expect your landlord to sort your property. If she tried to remove it and damaged your property then you would be more cross!

I think the precedent set by previous owner is irrelevant regarding the fence - if your not bothered stay out of it and let landlord and tenants sort it out!

Antinerak · 25/09/2021 11:07

Your money issues and lack of tools to deal with the plant are your own issues. They're not asking for the money to rip you off they're asking for half because it's a shared boundary. You and the LL are both responsible for it, it makes sense to share the cost. For £45 you get your plant issue solved and they get their fence issue solved.

Outbutnotoutout · 25/09/2021 11:04

I wouldn't pay for something I didn't want or didn't need.

If you have never paid half then I wouldn't start now...

Just say no

Limejuiceandrum · 25/09/2021 10:58

Why on earth are you being so difficult Over £45

findmeaholiday · 25/09/2021 10:54

Christ you sound like an absolute nightmare

SD1978 · 25/09/2021 10:43

If it's her fence and she doesn't care, then you can either pay half or put your own up on your property surely?

IncessantNameChanger · 25/09/2021 10:39

I didnt want my neighbours trees growing over my roof so I paid for tree surgeon to remove and kill the stamp ( with the neighbours permision of course) one cost job done.

Shared boundaries I think in law become your responsibility the moment you touch them so I dont touch mine. Unfortunately it's all part of the cost of ownership.

The house I border with is a two acre villa. The fact it's worth millions doesn't negate my legal duties just because the owner has more capital than me. I took this into consideration when I bought it. Our shared boundary is 20 fence panels. It's on the floor and I'm just waiting to see who blinks first. If they do it great. If they ask me to go halves its a legal request.

NoSquirrels · 25/09/2021 10:35

@coffeerevelsrock

Mutual cooperation is much, much better.

Can't see what's mutual about it to be honest. They plant what they like and it can go anywhere but I have the responsibility to maintain it and repair any damage done. I pay for the removal of the tree, including bits blocking the pavement and not my property. I pay for half a fence I don't want at all.

You agreed to pay for the removal of the tree branches in your skip. Your free choice. But you had the skip anyway so it didn’t cost you extra.

Of course anyone can plant anything they like.

Of course you are responsible for upkeep and maintenance of your own property.

Don’t pay for the fence if you don’t want to. Just be aware of the long-term consequences of saving £45 is all I’m saying.

You’re really angry at the LL and I’m not sure quite why it’s so distressing to you when you didn’t care about the tree and you don’t care about the fence!

coffeerevelsrock · 25/09/2021 10:35

Thank you for the diagram. Mine didn't look like that, much less clear and I did get it fro m land registry.

OP posts:
coffeerevelsrock · 25/09/2021 10:34

I've done that and it shows nothing at all in terms of Hs or Ts! Haven't got theirs though.

OP posts:
SweetBabyCheeses99 · 25/09/2021 10:34

Sorry I forgot to post diagram to help.

To think this landlady is ridiculously tight
SweetBabyCheeses99 · 25/09/2021 10:33

It should be in the deeds who is responsible. It might be in the little map you get with it rather than the written deeds. A “T” shaped mark on the boundary indicates who has responsibility for it. “H” shape indicates both of you. Might have to order deeds for neighbours property if it’s not on yours. Think it’s only £3 from land registry.

coffeerevelsrock · 25/09/2021 10:31

Mutual cooperation is much, much better.

Can't see what's mutual about it to be honest. They plant what they like and it can go anywhere but I have the responsibility to maintain it and repair any damage done. I pay for the removal of the tree, including bits blocking the pavement and not my property. I pay for half a fence I don't want at all.

OP posts:
friendlycat · 25/09/2021 10:31

£45 is worth it for good relationships with neighbours. Just pay it especially since it can’t be determined who owns the fence.

You may need the LLs help yourself one day and quibbles over this won’t stand you in good stead for the future.

If it were £450 you might have to really think about it but it’s £45.

Avenueofcherryblossom · 25/09/2021 10:30

Isn’t it the tenant’s responsibility to look after general garden maintenance such as keeping ivy under control? You are blaming the landlady for the ivy on your house when the ‘lovely tenants’ should be cutting it back. The house next to me used to be rented and their ivy grew across to my house I just kept an eye on it and cut it back to the boundary as and when necessary. If you were concerned about the tree branches hanging over the pavement you could have contacted the council about it.

coffeerevelsrock · 25/09/2021 10:29

@SaddenedByItAll

Just check with the skip company as I think you may be charged extra for any parts of tree that are greater than 4" in diameter
Skip went months ago, but thank you.
OP posts:
NoSquirrels · 25/09/2021 10:29

Forget how you feel about the LL personally. It’s doing you no good.

coffeerevelsrock · 25/09/2021 10:29

Kneesaregood The deeds don't state anything. The tick boxes aren't deeds. He was not doing me a favour! I don't want a fence.

OP posts:
SaddenedByItAll · 25/09/2021 10:28

Just check with the skip company as I think you may be charged extra for any parts of tree that are greater than 4" in diameter

NoSquirrels · 25/09/2021 10:28

WRT the Ivy - yes the roots are in their garden but if it ruins your render or bricks it would still be your issue to deal with and pay for. Then you’d need the cooperation of the LL (and the tenants) to go into their garden and use their land, if that’s the only access.

So being difficult about £45 could really cost you in the long run. Mutual cooperation is much, much better.

coffeerevelsrock · 25/09/2021 10:27

Also, people are ignoring that the tree wasn't only blocking my drive (didn't bother me too much as I don't park on it) but the pavement. People were having to cross over. Was that my responsibility too? yes, I'll probably end up paying but I'm fucked off and yes, the ll is tight but no one agrees (or hardly anyone) as I should take responsibility for everything growing from her garden and pay for it's removal and pay for half the fence while she makes a profit with minimum expenditure.

OP posts:
Kneesaregood · 25/09/2021 10:27

The previous owner doing the work was doing you a favour btw, not setting legal precedent!

Kneesaregood · 25/09/2021 10:25

If the deeds say it's a shared boundary then you share the responsibility about maintaining it, which means either going halves on the cost of repair or halves on the cost of removal.

The other stuff is annoying but it's irrelevant to your responsibility for the boundary.

coffeerevelsrock · 25/09/2021 10:24

@SeasonFinale

You have said that the deeds aren't clear and also that the documentation provided to her on sale states it is a shared boundary. She doesn't want to pay for it all and thereby set a precedent that you would want to rely on to shift your responsibility.
But the precedent has been set as up to now the fence has been repaired by the owner of that property, even if that wasn't her. What responsibility would I shift? You don't have to have a fence anyway.
OP posts:
NoSquirrels · 25/09/2021 10:23

Setting aside “common decency”, the skip, the ivy etc. you have 2 choices with the fence.

  1. Say no, I don’t care about fence panels on that boundary, I’m happy for there to be no fence there, so I won’t contribute.
  1. Pay £45 as a gesture of goodwill to keep relations less strained so that the LL hopefully deals better with you in the future.

I’d pay £45. If you’re a homeowner that’s just a small maintenance cost. You say “I really don't have this at the moment. It's been an expensive summer and I'm saving as much as I can having dipped into savings.” That’s not “I don’t have £45” that’s “I don’t want to contribute £45”. Own your choices.