Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who’s to blame for panic buying?

157 replies

HeechulOppa · 25/09/2021 09:54

Just wondering that really. Media or the people (or the twats in power)? Personally I think it’s the media (and the government for engineering the situations sometimes). I honestly can’t find it in myself to blame people - let’s face it, no matter how much you may believe in not panic buying, no matter how much you might believe in not contributing to the problem, it’s very very hard to stand back while everyone else buys things that are running out so quickly. So what do you do? If you don’t buy the item you know in your heart it will run out and, as these items are generally high importance (fuel, loo roll) you will probably be stuffed. If you do buy then you’re contributing to the problem. And whilst it’s also largely made worse by people buying more than they need, that level of thinking is usually entirely justifiable when you consider the hassle you go through and, quite frankly, the fear that supplies will take a while to return to normal so ‘best get some more to tide you over’.

Obviously slightly different with people who buy enough to keep them stocked for months.

It’s a pickle. And I don’t drive so don’t have a vested interest in fuel shortages for myself, but completely understand why people might panic there.

OP posts:
Unfashionable · 25/09/2021 12:18

At an individual level panic buying is a completely rational response for people who are entirely dependent on their cars when the supply of fuel is threatened. This isn’t a case of stockpiling several months’ supply of pasta or loo roll. My car’s tank only holds a week’s worth of fuel.

Unfortunately, the problems start when millions of other people also make the same rational decision at the same time....

RedToothBrush · 25/09/2021 12:18

The media, btw are the link between the public and government. They are supposed to hold power to account. The media can not survive unless it represents the worries and concerns of the public, because it can not make money (either from sales or advertising or support for the service). It might be ownered by the rich, but it isn't profitable unless it reflects the masses and their concerns.

The media reporting shortages are reflecting issues and highlighting lack of government planning and oversight to prevent problems which is supposed to be their role in protecting the national interest..

AmericanTie · 25/09/2021 12:15

Government.

That's why we're short.

RedToothBrush · 25/09/2021 12:15
  1. Its been made clear for a number of years that supply chain shock was likely due to market uncertainity and the inability of business to plan because the government haven't manage to get firm long term trade agreements in place. So government lack of understanding of logistics and business planning has to go top of the list. HGV drivers need to be top of the list of things you think of when you think of logistics - you are short of everything if you don't have enough of them.

  2. Fragility of the employment market for HGV - namely poor pay and working conditions. This has been driven by market forces so thats business and the public. And there's not been any oversight about national security issues stemming from that, which should have been a government concern (see point 1)

  3. Covid added to market fragility. Working from home, drove up demand for deliveries and delivery drivers. Whilst at the same time working from home led to a drop in fuel useage. Fuel firms needs to satisfy less demand so will have laid off drivers or drivers have left for better paid jobs. This lack of driver retention by petrol and diesel suppliers has meant when demand has increased as people have returned to work, they've been unable to meet that demand. Thats then driven the current panic. Petrol and diesel come above a lack of HGV drivers in terms of what you need to get goods from one place to another. Again another national security related issue. (See points 1 and 2)

  4. The complexity and the interlinking of businesses mean that a problem in one area, ripples through and gets increasing worse leading to a crisis point which can be difficult to resolve. Realistically government should have civil contigence planning for things of national importance such as food and fuel security. It appears there is a certain lack of this. Long supply chains without multiple alternatives are more vulnerable to problems than short ones with multiple sources. So outsourcing abroad and moving further from self sufficiency makes us more vulnerable. Thats strategic planning and politics. But its also driven by desire for low costs. (Thats points 1 to 3 summed up in terms of national security issues)

  5. I think there is a good argument here for issues about moving business and manufacturing abroad being a much bigger issue than immigrants 'taking all our jobs'. A cycle of outsourcing as employment moves abroad to exploit lower regulation and lower wages has fueled unemployment and poverty here. Public desire for rock bottom prices is in no small part due to high levels of inequality and poverty. Ultimately government is responsible for not addressing this over a long period. Nor do you resolve that by deregulating here which is being pitched, if your largest export market still requires those standards and protects against exploitation. You perhaps look at the exploitation and you value your domestic workers more because they offer greater national security. Again, a public, business and government issue.

  6. However it is pretty clear that the biggest issue is the conflict of interest between government and business leaders who have for many decades, disregarded and ignored the issue of domestic security issues such as food, fuel and health security. And the public have taken it for granted that the government is there to serve them first and not the interests of big businesses. In reality there should be a sweet spot to balance the needs of all three which are the basis of economic and political stability.

The following has just been point out to me by an old MN friend:

Emergency Food Reserves
German national food reserves are calculated for 84 million people for 6 weeks, totalling 800,000 metric tons.

Stored in ~150 huge warehouses around the country.

Contrast to the UK where successive govts cba about food reserves:
evaq8.co.uk/FoodSecurity.html

Almost unbelievable irresponsibility 🤬

House of Commons Environment, Food and Rural Affairs Committee, Food security; Second Report of Session 2014–15
www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm201415/cmselect/cmenvfru/243/243.pdf

"The United Kingdom holds no strategic food reserves [wtf !]

and overall reserves run to just a few days.

Responsibility falls on farmers and supermarkets: 🤬 [wtf !]

Levels of self-sufficiency in fruit and vegetables have fallen the most,

and farmers should seek to extend the seasonal production of fresh fruit and vegetables "

Conclusion
Let me put it another way. If we were to have a real major disaster - particularly in a major city - on the scale that many countries around the world do experience regularly, we could well be begging for help from the UN for the very basics.

We are just one major crisis away from civil breakdown. If it happened we would see wide spread civil unrest as well as food shortages.

That very much is a government issue. The buck must stop with government. What are the government for, if it is not to protect the national interest in terms of food, fuel and health security? It does not serve the interests of anyone but the most wealthy if it doesn't consider these seriously

With that in mind, those who can might well be advised to consider how they could cope if the shops did close for a fortnight.

The fragility of where we are, isn't being stated anywhere near as strongly as it should be.

It is deeply, deeply troubling.

Thirtyrock39 · 25/09/2021 12:13

Two papers yesterday had front pages with a petrol pump and the headlines 'running on empty' . I drive a lot for work and so was conscious of needing to fill up (warning light was on ) and motorways services was quiet but expensive (at 10am think in hidsighr I was very lucky) when I got back to my base I mentioned to a few colleagues that I'd stopped to get fuel and it seemed ok 'despite what the papers are saying' and they didn't know what I was on about but then all went to get petrol themselves as were all also low 🤦‍♀️with lots of appointments to drive too so it's a vicious circle and we do rely on our cars so much. I don't think people are doing it to be selfish

OrangeTortoise · 25/09/2021 12:12

For the people saying they blame the media - what solution do you suggest? Newspapers can write stories about whatever they like. While I definitely agree that media stories have contributed towards the current situation, I would be strongly against any suggestion of media censorship. So how can you avoid this happening?

The government, on the other hand, knew this was coming and could have tried to take steps to avoid it. So I feel that more of the blame must lie there.

FreeBritnee · 25/09/2021 12:09

It’s the media every ticking time. They walked us into Brexit. They walked us into panic buying food and the huge amount of waste that then ensued. They’ve walked us into a fuel shortage that will undoubtedly lead to deaths and more food shortages. They are utter click bait scumbags.

mrshoho · 25/09/2021 12:08

It may be down to people but I would say the majority are not selfish or stupid but rather just trying to be sensible. Examples I know of; one friend who had a 2 hour trip planned for today that was arranged months ago. With less than 1/4 in her tank she attempted to fill up yesterday unsuccessfully. She's now cancelled as there's no guarantee she could fill up alon the route and could end up stranded. People who travel to work Monday and would normally fill up on a Monday will now be scrabbling to fill up over the weekend or risk not getting to work. Each person normally has their own valid reason for wanting petrol. It's too convenient for leaders and large corporations to blame the people.

maddening · 25/09/2021 12:03

Def media, even the Language trying to say not to panic is poorly chosen, for example in the bbc news a person talking on the subject who was apparently telling people not to panic could not have said the word panic more times if she tried.

Rather than saying "people need to relax and calm down following the scare stories in the press, the supply chain is fine, the stories relate to isolated issues which are being managed appropriately, if everyone buys normally then we anticipate no disruption.

We had " people should not PANIC, because people PANIC there are queues, blah blah blah PANIC, blah blah blah you should not PANIC, blah blah PANIC" etc

Language can really make a difference to what people hear.

DumplingsAndStew · 25/09/2021 11:59

The fuel issues are down to people. There were no fuel shortages. That's a man-made problem.

Elieza · 25/09/2021 11:44

Totally agree it’s the media. Otherwise I’d have had no clue that there were problems.

You should have seen the queue at Sainsbury’s petrol station yesterday, ridiculous. (I was at b and q).

I later went to Asda for my food shopping. Their forecourt was shut as presumably they’d run out or the queue was into the main road and therefore dangerous. I passed shell and it was shut too.

If the media had kept its trap shut this issue would not have arisen.

I have a quarter tank and and am due to top up my usual £20 but I’m not desperate. As pp said if they don’t limit what we are allowed to spen in fuel/number of litres then it will be a few people with all the fuel and rural nurses unable to get to shift work etc, just like when all the food was being massed by fuckwits stocking up a whole lot that subsequently got uneaten and wasted while others went hungry.

We have not learned. Sad that a society who has gone to the moon and so on can’t even learn to share its ‘toys’ like a small child should. Pathetic.

Coronado2 · 25/09/2021 11:43

I think largly the media for makong something out of nothing with this story, but people have now made it a self fulfilling prophecy. Media said there was a fuel shortage when there wasn't, people panicked and made a fuel shortage. The public need to stop looking for someone to blame all the time and take some responsibility.

DrManhattan · 25/09/2021 11:41

@MatildaIThink
When this government say not to do something automatically people do it because they don't trust them.
Why did the chicken cross the road?
Because Boris said it wouldn't

Skysblue · 25/09/2021 11:36

The media. I’ve seen so many fear-mongering irresponsible articles. Even the BBC are at it now.

MatildaIThink · 25/09/2021 11:29

@DrManhattan

Government
As much as I dislike the government and think that this current regime is especially incompetent, I can not see how I is the government's fault that some people are being idiots.
DrManhattan · 25/09/2021 11:26

Government

StrawberrySquash · 25/09/2021 11:26

The people who stirred up people to vote for Brexit. And the hard-line Brexit MPs who pushed May into setting out her red lines including no customs union and no single market. And the current appaling government who went and implemented it, knowing it would cause this sort of thing. And the companies who haven't looked after staff properly and given them decent working conditions and the public who want stuff delivered but don't appreciate that it means there need to be decent facilities for the people driving that stuff.

Porfre · 25/09/2021 11:23

I blame this incompetent government

happinessischocolate · 25/09/2021 11:22

Ideally they'd set a minimum fill up amount of £25

If your can't fit £25s worth in your tank, you don't need to get petrol today

Thing is no petrol station is going to turn away paying customers who will then just go somewhere else.

IncessantNameChanger · 25/09/2021 11:21

@aquashiv

Everyone but me.
Yes! This 1000%

I must admit that I'm normally bumbling along with just fumes in my car. Live in a rural village. Three kids with disabilities. Not a care in world about my fumes running out. Luckily by pure chance I filled up on Monday as I was into my 30th mile on fumes.

If I hadn't I could have posted on FB

" I only fill my car up when I'm when my petrol light had flashed for two days ( true). Now there is a petrol shortage. I am so angry and fuming and crying as I didnt think until I was on fumes to fill up with my disabled kids living five miles from town. It's all YOUR fault you selfish, selfish people!"

Except I would be thinking what a idiot I am especially as I have broken down with no fuel before. I would also be kicking myself as no one, no one alive can prevent my recklessness except me.

Anyway it's never my fault. I'm worthy and superior and I cant see in my situation where I have gone wrong.

I dont hold any power to control my destiny. It's all your fault.

MatildaIThink · 25/09/2021 11:20

The panic buyers pure and simple. It is ridiculous to try and blame other people for one's own behaviour.

CuriousaboutSamphire · 25/09/2021 11:16

@HalfShrunkMoreToGo

The media certainly have culpability. There were choices available, they chose to report headlines like:

"Fuel Crisis U.K."
"What is causing the fuel crisis"
"Fuel shortages add to winter woes"

In actuality there is no fuel shortage, we have plenty of fuel in the U.K. and more coming into the country and into the forecourts of petrol satiations every day.

SOME suppliers have a reduced number of drivers which meant that a TINY number of stations may not have been able to get supplies delivered as regularly, BP reported that 100 of their 8500 petrol stations may run out of fuel, that's 1.2% of their petrol stations.

As a result of the headlines, thousands of people went and drained their petrol stations yesterday, now there are empty tanks all over the place so more deliveries are needed which is logistically difficult due to the reduced number of delivery drivers.

I just posted that locally. Immediately I was told that I didn't understand and that the shortages are real!

A very angry man told me I was an idiot, in a very long, angry, rude post. Apparently I don't understand the issues.

Another man, number 2, told angry man number 1 exactly the same as I had posted and angry man number 1 agreed with him, tagging me to show me what the real issues are.

Man number 2 told angry man number 1 just how fucking stupid he was as he had literally just reposted what I had said.Grin

Meanwhile fuel rationing is being discussed in an attempt to keep everyone moving until the next scheduled deliveries are made!

BrendaBubbles · 25/09/2021 11:15

Government. But media are a convenient scapegoat for people who vote Tory

Blessex · 25/09/2021 11:15

My DH lives in the Netherlands. He reads the British press and chuckles. He can see it all. Everything is blown up - because it creates clicks and sells papers.

mrshoho · 25/09/2021 11:14

@IncessantNameChanger

According to local FB group its every single person filling up. Except the person posting.

Like in March 2020. Local woman at Sainsbury's at 9.40 on a Sunday 20 minutes before they open posting pics of the queues. "Look at this queue. So selfish. I'm crying here as I have to feed my kids, my gran, my disabled neighbour. I'm a doctor and care worker in a home and I only live from pay check to pay check and I dont drive and I have to do my hgv shift tonight or sainsbury's wont be re stocked. I'm am worthy but everyone else is a selfish selfish fucker as no one else alive is a dr, nurse, carer, supply chain, front line staff, teacher, police etc"

In the queue extra early but the irony is lost on them. They are the special one. The only one there with a valid reason.

Or my neighbour posting how he is enraged as his wife is disabled. Leave the poor woman at home then and go shopping without her!

So I conclude its narcissistic people who post on FB while the rest of the frontline staff, carers etc just silently get on the best they can.

Jokeung aside we need to be less knee jerk as a population and more resilient and forward planning

quite agree!