Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who’s to blame for panic buying?

157 replies

HeechulOppa · 25/09/2021 09:54

Just wondering that really. Media or the people (or the twats in power)? Personally I think it’s the media (and the government for engineering the situations sometimes). I honestly can’t find it in myself to blame people - let’s face it, no matter how much you may believe in not panic buying, no matter how much you might believe in not contributing to the problem, it’s very very hard to stand back while everyone else buys things that are running out so quickly. So what do you do? If you don’t buy the item you know in your heart it will run out and, as these items are generally high importance (fuel, loo roll) you will probably be stuffed. If you do buy then you’re contributing to the problem. And whilst it’s also largely made worse by people buying more than they need, that level of thinking is usually entirely justifiable when you consider the hassle you go through and, quite frankly, the fear that supplies will take a while to return to normal so ‘best get some more to tide you over’.

Obviously slightly different with people who buy enough to keep them stocked for months.

It’s a pickle. And I don’t drive so don’t have a vested interest in fuel shortages for myself, but completely understand why people might panic there.

OP posts:
FindingMeno · 25/09/2021 13:00

Surely it's time to get the army to alleviate the problem in the short term.

Pollythecat15 · 25/09/2021 13:00

Everyone! We all play a part in it.
I panicked when I saw other people panic buying and after reading the news, so I'm as bad myself.

FindingMeno · 25/09/2021 12:59

The media.
Most people who are "panic buying" are doing so because " panic buying " is happening and they're genuinely worried they may not be able to attend to their responsibilities.
I've never bought petrol/ diesel in my life and very rarely actually go in a car, but its not difficult to understand how people's circumstances make them so dependent on car use for their own welfare and others.
Obviously some people are also being arses too.

Chloemol · 25/09/2021 12:57

@3luckystars

Brexit.

This is not happening anywhere else. It is caused by brexit.
So, everybody and nobody is to blame.

Thanks for the laugh- Brexit!!

There is no fuel shortage, the country has shedloads, it’s coming in as normal

BP and Esso may have issues getting it to 300 forecourts ( out of 8500) but no other companies have issues

However you go ahead and think it’s down to Brexit if it makes you feel better

Ori3 · 25/09/2021 12:56

Sorry but the general public are daft. If all the panic buyers just engaged brain for a second to think about how their actions might influence a crisis in supply we wouldn’t be in this mess. The supply chain would continue to operate smoothly if everyone took a measured approach to the situation & just continued their normal purchasing habits.

Panic buying becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy. It’s guaranteed to disrupt the supply chain, forcing a deficit of resources. Then there’s not enough to go round & voila, we’ve created the very situation we’re afraid of.

The Govt. are also to blame on a wider scale - it was obvious this was going to happen after Brexit. Now they’re in the rather embarrassing position of having to formalise temporary visas for EU nationals to pick up the work. Oops. But then again the general public did choose Brexit so……..yes the people have chosen this haven’t they. Well done British public. Good move there

Chloemol · 25/09/2021 12:55

The media

There is plenty of fuel available in the country, there is no shortage. It’s just BP not being able to get it all quickly to 100 of their sites also esso said they had supply chain issues to 200. Both have approx 1209 sits to give some perspective and there are 8500 across the uk

But all others said they have no problems at all, however the media have wiped up a frenzy, and the idiots don’t read the article just see the headlines and off we go

3luckystars · 25/09/2021 12:54

Brexit.

This is not happening anywhere else. It is caused by brexit.
So, everybody and nobody is to blame.

RedToothBrush · 25/09/2021 12:52

@FOJN

The idiots who think the UK is Bartertown. If most posters here can spot the sensationalist headlines then so can everyone else. We've been told there is no fuel shortage it's a delivery issue which will be resolved with a little time.

Not being able to get to work will be the least of everyone's worries if supermarkets can't get fuel for delivery lorries, emergency services can't fuel vehicles etc. I'm more worried about the, "every person for themselves" attitude than lack of fuel.

That attitude has come from realising, no other fucker is going to look after you if shit hits the fan. Thats come from the very top in terms of failure to look after the public, not from the public mentality itself.

Thats the scary bit.

TeenMinusTests · 25/09/2021 12:48

The problem is, who would police this? Do we expect petrol station workers on minimum wage to come out and look at each customers fuel gauge and determine whether they are running low?

I was only a child in the 70s, but I have vague recollections of precisely that - people in queues being turned away as they weren't low enough. Could well be making it up though.

RedToothBrush · 25/09/2021 12:48

I'm sure that I'm not alone in having no choice other than to be part of the problem as I use my car for work & can't run the risk of not being able to do my job.

Indeed.

Those saying the word 'selfish', either don't rely on petrol (having a short commute if they do drive), can work from home or had a full tank of petrol already.

I haven't been near a petrol station over the last few days.

I absoluetely do not blame anyone filling up though. What exactly are they supposed to do differently? I did it in previous shortages because it was essential I got to work. If I didn't, I wouldn't have a job to go back to.

This 'selfish' thing is a great big pile of hairy bollocks and I think people saying it, are doing so from a position where its not a concern for them to begin with.

HungryHippo11 · 25/09/2021 12:44

@TeenMinusTests

I think in cases like this they shouldn't let anyone who is more than say 1/4 full fill up. So not limit to £30 per customer, but but only let people who are running low fill up.
The problem is, who would police this? Do we expect petrol station workers on minimum wage to come out and look at each customers fuel gauge and determine whether they are running low? And if they're not, send them home? I give it ten minutes before that person is being abused by an angry customer who needs more than 1/4 tank of fuel.

£30 limit per customer would be easier as they could presumably programme the pumps to stop after a certain limit. But many people would just go round again, or to the next petrol station and get a second helping.

FOJN · 25/09/2021 12:44

The idiots who think the UK is Bartertown. If most posters here can spot the sensationalist headlines then so can everyone else. We've been told there is no fuel shortage it's a delivery issue which will be resolved with a little time.

Not being able to get to work will be the least of everyone's worries if supermarkets can't get fuel for delivery lorries, emergency services can't fuel vehicles etc. I'm more worried about the, "every person for themselves" attitude than lack of fuel.

purdypuma · 25/09/2021 12:42

Everybody is part of the problem, myself included but the problem is not a shortage of fuel but a lack of drivers to get it to the consumer. You can have all the fuel in the world available but its no good if you can't get it to the customer.

I was at Tesco near to us from 05.45 this morning as I literally had 26 miles left, having used 52 miles for work purposes alone yesterday & I can get through a full tank in a week. I put in a full tank to be on the safe side by the time I left the queues were getting bad.

I'm sure that I'm not alone in having no choice other than to be part of the problem as I use my car for work & can't run the risk of not being able to do my job.

Timeforachangetoday12 · 25/09/2021 12:38

I’m blame the media.
I also blame the government - it’s more around peoples mistrust of the government. This is being shown by people panic buying!!!

I wish petrol stations put a limit in place and stopped the cans being filled (that really drives me mad!) I remember seeing photos last year the ships full with fuel with no one buying it …convenient that now the petrol stations can whack the prices up and make a lot of money :( just wish people could see the bigger picture (they putting a lot of money in someone’s pocket and probably they not paying tax on it!!)

Yet again people who can’t afford to fill there car up are affected again!! Same as panic buyers shopping - cause and effect :(

It does make me sad that some British people think like this - make sure they ok and forget about who is the affected by their selfish choices.

Gingernaut · 25/09/2021 12:35

We are.

The media aren't putting a gun to our heads and forcing us to act like twats.

The same morons who stockpiled toilet paper are depleting filling stations now.

DrManhattan · 25/09/2021 12:35

@MatildaIThink
It might be a poor excuse but it's alot of people's reality.

NantesElephant · 25/09/2021 12:33

There are multiple reasons for the situation. Blame the government for mismanaging and creating the supply problems in the first place, blame Brexit voters, the pandemic and the media.

Some individuals put their personal ‘freedom’ ahead of the needs of others, so keep everything topped up ‘just in case’ they decide to go for a last minute trip. Then the car sits on their driveway with a full tank all weekend whilst someone else is panicking about not being able to get to work on Monday, because they habitually fill up on a Sunday night and the fuel tanker couldn’t replenish the petrol station.

And some people it has to be said are disorganized. If you absolutely need your car for a vital purpose, why let the tank fall below half at any time?

TheGoogleMum · 25/09/2021 12:31

I blame the media. There must be an element of panic buying if everyone happened to need petrol now it would always be this busy, but I've only seen 1 post on social media where they claimed they saw someone filling up Jerry cans (this is the sort of thing they shouldn't allow at the moment!). I also like the minimum spend suggestions! I did fill up yesterday but even without low stocks would have definitely filled up yesterday or today, the thing is most people are saying the same thing!

MatildaIThink · 25/09/2021 12:28

[quote DrManhattan]@MatildaIThink
When this government say not to do something automatically people do it because they don't trust them.
Why did the chicken cross the road?
Because Boris said it wouldn't[/quote]
That is a poor excuse. I don't trust the government on a lot of things, but there is enough information to see what the structural issue are here and that the only reason there anything more than isolated issues at the moment is the idiotic panic buyers.

RedToothBrush · 25/09/2021 12:25

During the last 18 months the government has more or less stressed the point that we are all responsible for ourselves in someway during various points in the pandemic.

They've actively abdicated responsibility repeatedly when they should have stepped up and admitted failures and were certainly found wanting on civil contigency planning when it came to PPE. They could only be reactionary rather than proactive - which had a mass casualties as a result.

You are either a fool or you are poor if you don't listen to this messaging loud and clear.

(And I stress that I don't believe that this is a Tory party problem alone).

Zeal · 25/09/2021 12:24

People. We all have choices.

Same with climate change. Corporates will only produce things that people want. Buy plastic wrapped fruit and veg and it will always be there.

Prisoners’ Dilemma.

tenredthings · 25/09/2021 12:24

Unpopular opinion but unless we find a way to use less petrol the problems we are facing now will seem like nothing compared to the tsunami of problems climate change is bringing. Rather than finding more drivers we need to look at reducing the supply chains.

The Tories don't give a fuck about the future and I think creating managed bubbles of panic in the population is a useful tool for keeping the masses inline.

waybill · 25/09/2021 12:20

People were told not to panic buy.

They were told that if they did, then we would run out.

They were told that if they didn't, there would be enough to go round until the backlog of deliveries was sorted out.

But typically, Joe Public couldn't give a shit about anything as long as they are all right, and damn everyone else.

There you go.

RedToothBrush · 25/09/2021 12:20

(Crucial point: The media are not creating the underlying structural issue. They aren't responsible for strategic planning and ensuring there is a contigency plan if there is an emerging crisis)

trappedsincesundaymorn · 25/09/2021 12:19

The only people responsible for panic buying are those that panic buy.