Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who’s to blame for panic buying?

157 replies

HeechulOppa · 25/09/2021 09:54

Just wondering that really. Media or the people (or the twats in power)? Personally I think it’s the media (and the government for engineering the situations sometimes). I honestly can’t find it in myself to blame people - let’s face it, no matter how much you may believe in not panic buying, no matter how much you might believe in not contributing to the problem, it’s very very hard to stand back while everyone else buys things that are running out so quickly. So what do you do? If you don’t buy the item you know in your heart it will run out and, as these items are generally high importance (fuel, loo roll) you will probably be stuffed. If you do buy then you’re contributing to the problem. And whilst it’s also largely made worse by people buying more than they need, that level of thinking is usually entirely justifiable when you consider the hassle you go through and, quite frankly, the fear that supplies will take a while to return to normal so ‘best get some more to tide you over’.

Obviously slightly different with people who buy enough to keep them stocked for months.

It’s a pickle. And I don’t drive so don’t have a vested interest in fuel shortages for myself, but completely understand why people might panic there.

OP posts:
CandyLeBonBon · 25/09/2021 16:25

@mrshoho

If people were buying according to genuine, regular need, we'd be seeing these scenes every week, wouldn't we? But we don't, which strongly suggests this madness is due to additional, unneeded trips outside of normal filling up routines. It's not rocket science is it?

It's not as simple as that though is it! In normal times you could start a trip knowing that you could stop anytime to fill up. You could think I've got enough to get half way and then stop somewhere but with things currently unless you have enough petrol to get there and back you can't take a chance. Likewise if you've got to be at work at 8am you could normally stop on the way in to fill up but the way things are you have to try and fill up the day/night before. It really doesn't take much in the way of people changing habits to cause this knock on effect.

1% of national petrol stations had to temporarily close due to a haulage issue.

Mainly BP I think.

So no, if you'd carried on as normal, you'd have been fine. Because 99% of petrol stations were unaffected and it would have been similar to situations where one station is refuelling do you drive on to another.

If people had kept their heads, then only 1% of stations would have been temporarily shut. As it stand now, 50% of the stations in my town are closed due to panic buying. That would not have otherwise been the case.

SoloISland · 25/09/2021 16:21

We lived through the Suez crisis with rationing. Essential workers got more.

Living deep rural for decades at this season I have basic supplies in for three months as a matter of course.

Years since toilet paper though....

TractorAndHeadphones · 25/09/2021 16:20

100% thé média.
It’s a chicken or egg question.
For something to make the national news/have a statement out it must be of importance.
If people see headlines about panic buying - the inference is that people elsewhere have been panic buying.

Therefor if they wait they could run into an empty tank. So the rational thing to do is to buy more yourself.

SaddenedByItAll · 25/09/2021 16:18

ozanj
And your source for this is...?

We only take people on a PAYE basis these days as the responsibility for tax/NI now sits with the employer should there be a dispute under IR35
More people than not that come to us to work want to be SE as they get more each week in their pay packet

mrshoho · 25/09/2021 16:16

If people were buying according to genuine, regular need, we'd be seeing these scenes every week, wouldn't we? But we don't, which strongly suggests this madness is due to additional, unneeded trips outside of normal filling up routines. It's not rocket science is it?

It's not as simple as that though is it! In normal times you could start a trip knowing that you could stop anytime to fill up. You could think I've got enough to get half way and then stop somewhere but with things currently unless you have enough petrol to get there and back you can't take a chance. Likewise if you've got to be at work at 8am you could normally stop on the way in to fill up but the way things are you have to try and fill up the day/night before. It really doesn't take much in the way of people changing habits to cause this knock on effect.

CandyLeBonBon · 25/09/2021 15:59

@HeechulOppa

Some very good responses here, thank you.

For those who feel it’s genuinely the fault of the panic buyers (and I am not saying there should be no personal responsibility and I absolutely believe there will be some who are taking more than they need) can you not believe that the majority of people are buying out of genuine need or need in the near future. I don’t drive, as I said, and I take two buses to work. It takes me 2 hours each way (a whole other story!) In my area we currently have a severe bus driver shortage - a lot of drivers recently quit. Buses are running on a quarter of their time table. I am also rural. So people can’t rely on buses to provide alternative transport. So you hear of these panic buys etc and you can decide to either stay out of it and know there’s a good chance you’re going to end up in trouble, or you buy and become part of the problem. And in saying that I am absolutely not blaming people for this - if I drove I would absolutely buy fuel if I needed it, or make sure I had enough to last me. And the fact is I know I would be part of the problem. But what else can you do? Put yourself in possible trouble by relying on others calming down and becoming level headed, and things returning to normal? But let’s face it, no one will believe the public will collectively decide to calm down (I appreciate that this also includes myself/ you etc and therefore we become part of it - but most other people will also be facing the same quandary so the faceless panic-buying public suddenly become more understandable.)

We need the government to step in. Put up limits. Something

If people were buying according to genuine, regular need, we'd be seeing these scenes every week, wouldn't we? But we don't, which strongly suggests this madness is due to additional, unneeded trips outside of normal filling up routines. It's not rocket science is it?
Thomasina79 · 25/09/2021 15:52

People filling up because they are getting low, or because they need to get to work is one thing, filling up Jerry cans as well is downright greedy!

Under these circumstances I agree with rationing, or perhaps a spending limit of £30.

Ozanj · 25/09/2021 15:50

@SaddenedByItAll

ozanj Most drivers want to be self employed as it is a more tax efficient method for them Are you suggesting that all UK drivers want to be on PAYE? But yeah, cos of Brexit innit You keep being you
No most drivers prefer being paid a salary actually. The self employed rules came specifically from companies that tried to cheat the rules re employee rights & hours.
vivainsomnia · 25/09/2021 15:42

Sadly, I do very well three people who absolutely did not need to fill up. WFH, living in urban area, no kids or school walking distance. No need to care for anyone. As a matter of fact, probably it fill up 4 or 5 times a year at most.

Why do they do it? Because of an inherent fear of missing out and a sense of entitlement that they are more important than others. Selfish people indeed.

HeechulOppa · 25/09/2021 15:26

Some very good responses here, thank you.

For those who feel it’s genuinely the fault of the panic buyers (and I am not saying there should be no personal responsibility and I absolutely believe there will be some who are taking more than they need) can you not believe that the majority of people are buying out of genuine need or need in the near future. I don’t drive, as I said, and I take two buses to work. It takes me 2 hours each way (a whole other story!) In my area we currently have a severe bus driver shortage - a lot of drivers recently quit. Buses are running on a quarter of their time table. I am also rural. So people can’t rely on buses to provide alternative transport. So you hear of these panic buys etc and you can decide to either stay out of it and know there’s a good chance you’re going to end up in trouble, or you buy and become part of the problem. And in saying that I am absolutely not blaming people for this - if I drove I would absolutely buy fuel if I needed it, or make sure I had enough to last me. And the fact is I know I would be part of the problem. But what else can you do? Put yourself in possible trouble by relying on others calming down and becoming level headed, and things returning to normal? But let’s face it, no one will believe the public will collectively decide to calm down (I appreciate that this also includes myself/ you etc and therefore we become part of it - but most other people will also be facing the same quandary so the faceless panic-buying public suddenly become more understandable.)

We need the government to step in. Put up limits. Something

OP posts:
Bushey222 · 25/09/2021 15:08

Hi I am in Kings Langley, Herts. Texaco has just had a diesel delivery, so hopefully other garages will slowly be replenished with petrol + diesel.
It is cars in queues for the garage, which are blocking main roads - ridiculous.

CandyLeBonBon · 25/09/2021 15:01

Anyway, you can be as angry as you like that I think it's stupid and selfish to panic buy. You will justify your choices. There is not a snowflake's chance in hell that every person queuing and subsequently shutting down petrol stations is doing it for the reasons you've cited.

So I still think the vast majority are selfish and stupid, because those who didn't actually need to 'stock up' and recognise that there is enough for everyone, are the ones causing the problem.

CandyLeBonBon · 25/09/2021 14:56

@Offmyfence I was swearing at the general stupid selfishness I have seen first hand in my home town. That was not directed personally at you. HTH

Offmyfence · 25/09/2021 14:54

@CandyLeBonBon

I have also rearranged medical appointments next week just in case. But before you start sweating at me, tell me that every single person panic buying absolutely needed to do it for work, hospital appointments or to care for elderly parent. Because I'd bet my house that's not the case, so save your anger for the selfish fuckers filling up extra Jerry cans and topping up on nearly full tanks when they don't need to, 'just in case. I am not the problem here.
You started the swearing, if you don't like it, don't fucking start it!

Sone appointments can't be rearranged! Some people can't get to work without a car.

Feel lucky that you're not one of those people.

By

gardeninggirl68 · 25/09/2021 14:40

I've enough to get to work and back for next 3 days, that's including today

BUT

My food order is due on Sunday, if that's cancelled I will need to use the remaining fuel to do a food shop so won't have fuel for Monday

I'm not sure how supermarket deliveries will cope

FreeBritnee · 25/09/2021 14:36

DP also can’t get to work.

CandyLeBonBon · 25/09/2021 14:28

I have also rearranged medical appointments next week just in case. But before you start sweating at me, tell me that every single person panic buying absolutely needed to do it for work, hospital appointments or to care for elderly parent. Because I'd bet my house that's not the case, so save your anger for the selfish fuckers filling up extra Jerry cans and topping up on nearly full tanks when they don't need to, 'just in case. I am not the problem here.

CandyLeBonBon · 25/09/2021 14:25

I can't get to work.

Offmyfence · 25/09/2021 14:19

@CandyLeBonBon

it’s very very hard to stand back while everyone else buys things that are running out so quickly. So what do you do? If you don’t buy the item you know in your heart it will run out and, as these items are generally high importance (fuel, loo roll) you will probably be stuffed. If you do buy then you’re contributing to the problem.

Well it's not difficult. I didn't do that the first time round, and I'm not doing it now. I am watching my town go fucking berserk. I am running on close to empty but I refuse to participate in this fucking stupidity. So yes. I blame stupid people who can't employ a bit of common fucking sense and work out that if everyone decides to go out, fill up cars and Jerry cans 'just in case' then THEY are the problem.

Talk about self fulfilling prophecy.

You might feel a bit fucking different if you couldn't get to work, or to your elderly parents, or to your hospital treatment?

All this, I'll do without petrol , do you have any understanding that it's almost impossible for others to do without?

Offmyfence · 25/09/2021 14:15

The people that voted brexit, blame them!

LadyWithLapdog · 25/09/2021 14:08

Brexit and the government.

Johnson couldn’t run a bath, how in hell people were fooled by this clown is beyond my understanding.

CandyLeBonBon · 25/09/2021 14:06

@SaddenedByItAll

ozanj Most drivers want to be self employed as it is a more tax efficient method for them Are you suggesting that all UK drivers want to be on PAYE? But yeah, cos of Brexit innit You keep being you
The new IR35 rules are causing huge problems for these drivers. As is brexit. Those are the two biggest issues after drivers retiring, that is causing the shortfall.
Airyfairymarybeary · 25/09/2021 14:03

Uneducated people!

SaddenedByItAll · 25/09/2021 13:53

ozanj
Most drivers want to be self employed as it is a more tax efficient method for them
Are you suggesting that all UK drivers want to be on PAYE?
But yeah, cos of Brexit innit
You keep being you

Roundtoedshoes · 25/09/2021 13:49

I don’t suppose it matters whose fault it is, it’s how people react. I live somewhere with good transport links and amenities in walking distance. I also own a car, which I do use, and I’m lucky enough to be able to keep it topped up so I have plenty of fuel.

I realise a lot of people are not in that position. However, looking out my window onto a fairly busy road (not far from a petrol station), it’s almost gridlocked. And lots of angry beeping. Do all these people need fuel? Are they using more fuel trying to fill up in case they need it?

It’s quite sad how these things show us as being selfish on the whole (see toilet roll debacle, 2020).

I won’t be contributing to the madness (again, I realise I am fortunate and not condemning those in genuine need). I’ve had friends with planned longish social journeys this weekend and they would not consider changing their plans or using public transport. People just don’t think.