Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The Lancet calls us “Bodies With Vaginas”

218 replies

42SrauvP · 25/09/2021 00:02

On behalf of all women and girls, I am f*cking livid.

twitter.com/thelancet/status/1441372277786951681?s=21

Be in no doubt, when society removes the words we use to define ourselves they remove the means for us to gather, to push back, to protect ourselves, to fight for our rights, to roar. It’s slow and almost imperceptible and then, BOOM…you have the likes of Ed Davey proclaiming on prime time radio that we can’t exclude men.

I am NOT a Body with a Vagina, I am WOMAN hear me roar.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
EdgeOfACoin · 25/09/2021 10:16

Being too angry can also cause it to be dismissed

Best not be too angry, you bodies with vaginas.

ChinstrapBobblehat · 25/09/2021 10:02

Regardless of how objections are phrased, it is the volume of objections that will highlight to the Lancet their need to consider and respond to this issue.

OrShouldIJustLeave · 25/09/2021 09:59

@timeisnotaline

There must be some perfect clip from a movie with men sitting around talking about women as holes that should be shared on that Twitter thread.
I started going off sex when I started viewing women as holes. Not because (I think) they are but because it dawned on me - through the media especially - that this is how society in general and a lot of penis and scrotum-havers view women.

Sex, to me, feels like being a hole for a penis-haver, thanks to sex-craved, male-gaze entertainment industry. Just a hole with a body, and that body must make sure to make irritating noises and squirm like so, just to give that penis-haver some satisfaction and boost his ego, making him feel like he's doing the best job in the world.

Nope! You can keep your sacs, thanks!

Theeyeballsinthesky · 25/09/2021 09:54

@Pineapplepyjamas

My organisation receives complaints of this sort.

Please consider that:

  1. The people reading the emails won’t have a clue about the trans v women’s rights issue.
  2. Any mention of trans in a negative context will cause the email to be pigeonholed as anti trans.
  3. Being too angry can also cause it to be dismissed

I’d recommend you keep it simple and focus solely on the problems this particular action causes to women.

Sadly some of the complaints my organisation receive are ignored for the above reasons, and it’s hard to defend them as it would expose my views.

We received one that, I, knowing the contexts knew made sense and linked our actions back to the key wider issues… but everyone else was totally confused. It was far too complex and detailed and angry.

Perhaps we could coordinate and each send emails that tackle one issue each? It’s easy for an organisation to ignore half the issues if you raise all of them at once.

Suggested wording:

I am writing regarding The Lancet Volume 198. The cover features a quote which says, “Historically, the anatomy and physiology of bodies with vaginas have been neglected”.

What is the reason for this wording?

Does it mean human women, or does it include animals?

The people who work at the lancet know all about this issue because the woman who wrote the article is full on TWAW and tweets about it extensively.

Richard horton is a doctor and knows exactly what a woman is

They have zero excuses

ChinstrapBobblehat · 25/09/2021 09:54

@Pineapplepyjamas

I would have thought that an international media publication might have a more robust approach to interacting with its readership and the public at large than just leaving correspondence to be farmed by people who are ignorant of and/or oblivious to the point of the correspondence.

But I don’t know where you work or how comparable that organisation may be, so accept I may be wrong about that.

Dozer · 25/09/2021 09:47

Rubbish, Pineapple, abusive messages aside the action to be taken - to use the term ‘women’ - should be straightforward. It’s the organisation that is being ‘kafkaesque’, not complainants.

CindersPumpkin · 25/09/2021 09:43

Looking back into history and what the next steps after dehumanisation are and what a weird woke world awe are in at the moment, it's not looking good for us.

DrSbaitso · 25/09/2021 09:42

I just said that I didn't appreciate being called a body with a vagina, especially as men got to be called men, and could they explain themselves?

Pineapplepyjamas · 25/09/2021 09:41

@Dozer

Pineapple, the problem there is your organisation’s failings, not complainants’ presentation!
Well obviously the organisation’s actions are a problem. But the complaint’s writing is a problem too.

The presentation of the complaints sometimes means that people reading them can’t take any action. As much as they’d like to.

I can’t do anything with an email about the Kafkaesque capture of the whole world to trans issues. I can do something with an email that states your organisation did X which negatively affects women in X way.

LorenzoVonMatterhorn · 25/09/2021 09:38

@Penistoe

I clicked on the link and there are actually toilets in pubs in the uk with options of ‘men’ And ‘gender neutral’ and that’s it! Wtaf
Is that even legal?
Dozer · 25/09/2021 09:32

Pineapple, the problem there is your organisation’s failings, not complainants’ presentation!

Pineapplepyjamas · 25/09/2021 09:29

My organisation receives complaints of this sort.

Please consider that:

  1. The people reading the emails won’t have a clue about the trans v women’s rights issue.
  2. Any mention of trans in a negative context will cause the email to be pigeonholed as anti trans.
  3. Being too angry can also cause it to be dismissed

I’d recommend you keep it simple and focus solely on the problems this particular action causes to women.

Sadly some of the complaints my organisation receive are ignored for the above reasons, and it’s hard to defend them as it would expose my views.

We received one that, I, knowing the contexts knew made sense and linked our actions back to the key wider issues… but everyone else was totally confused. It was far too complex and detailed and angry.

Perhaps we could coordinate and each send emails that tackle one issue each? It’s easy for an organisation to ignore half the issues if you raise all of them at once.

Suggested wording:

I am writing regarding The Lancet Volume 198. The cover features a quote which says, “Historically, the anatomy and physiology of bodies with vaginas have been neglected”.

What is the reason for this wording?

Does it mean human women, or does it include animals?

ChattyLion · 25/09/2021 09:29

How dare they. Absolute misogynistic bastards. They are not safe to be around women or advising on their medical care, with those attitudes.

MintyCedric · 25/09/2021 09:28

Well they seem to have got the hang of using the word 'woman' this morning.

Perhaps because they're more afraid of being called racists that they are of being called misogynists?

The Lancet calls us “Bodies With Vaginas”
ineedsun · 25/09/2021 09:27

This feels like an incels wet dream. Horrific

TheShadoutCrepes · 25/09/2021 09:26

Well MedTwitter is starting to react to this, and none of it good.

I am absolutely astonished and outraged by this. I’m seriously struggling to understand that choice of the word ‘bodies’ to describe a group of human beings, and then of course they add on ‘with vaginas’ to really double down on the insulting language.
What the FUCK were they thinking?

Penistoe · 25/09/2021 09:25

I clicked on the link and there are actually toilets in pubs in the uk with options of ‘men’ And ‘gender neutral’ and that’s it!
Wtaf

tinselvestsparklepants · 25/09/2021 09:22

To clarify - I'm not saying that their opinion is more important but I'm saying I'd like to think we can fight this together.

Dillyjones72 · 25/09/2021 09:22

So ‘men’s health’ is men’s health? Not bodies with
A
Penis, but women are this??? What the actually fuck. It is possible to be inclusive without this kind of fuck wittery.

Chrysanthemum5 · 25/09/2021 09:21

@LorenzoVonMatterhorn that made me laugh and thank you I needed a laugh after reading that a medical journal has dehumanised half the population

tinselvestsparklepants · 25/09/2021 09:21

Disgusted to read about this and esp on the night if Sabina Nessa's vigil.

I would like to hear what trans men think about this. I cannot believe that any trans man, who has thought long and hard about their body and identity, would be at all offended by the use of the word woman. In fact, I'm of the opinion that it's insulting to trans men to think that they don't have the intelligence to see that they may still (for example) need a cervical smear if the literature about the same refers to women, and that they are effectively calling for the word woman to be erased. I can't believe that any of this is coming from them. We need trans men's voices here.

MerylSqueak · 25/09/2021 09:20

I've emailed.

LorenzoVonMatterhorn · 25/09/2021 09:15

I was so tempted to address my email ‘Dear Dick’ as it works on different levels.

IsabelBeck · 25/09/2021 09:14

I frequently ask this question but how many people who identify as trans are there in the UK? I know there are around 30 million women and girls and I would guess trans people are only in the thousands (at most).

So why do trans rights trump those of our daughters, mothers, sisters? Why are so many men invested in trans rights?

TheAntiGardener · 25/09/2021 09:13

The irony in using such a revolting term to discuss shame that affects women and is derived from misogyny is quite incredible. I really struggled with internalised misogyny when I was younger and just seeing this, knowing I am such a ‘body’ brought back a little bit of that old self-revulsion. Goodness only knows who this would make a dysphoric ‘body with vagina’ feel. Not that trans men approving of this term would make it more acceptable to me, but I am highly sceptical that anyone would choose to apply this term to themselves. Which begs a few questions...

Swipe left for the next trending thread