Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

... to say that the Tories are in power indefinitely?

216 replies

MrsPeacockInTheLibrary · 24/09/2021 22:59

I said similar in a political discussion earlier with a friend and they got quite angry and said that was ridiculous.

I had shared some of the reasons I have this opinion: Labour factionalism and infighting (I am a party member and see it entrenched everywhere), Scotland, the split vote on the left, the Tory majority, conservative voting trends in recent years... I just can't see how the Tories will be ousted within at least the next 10-20 years.

I know the old adage about a week in politics... I wish we had more hope of reform in the system, and safe seats did not exist in their current form, but it is what it is.

OP posts:
LetHimHaveIt · 25/09/2021 15:23

'The Labour Party needs to gets its act together' is the MN political equivalent of 'Wow. Just wow'. People just pop these platitudes down there as if they're so profound that they need no explanation, when the truth is they don't know what they're fucking talking about. No-one has ever been able to adequately explain what the actually mean by 'Labour needs to get its act together'.

Anyone with any money at all doesn't want to pay more taxes. Those with fuck all think it's aspirational to vote Tory, and lay the entirety of the blame for their lot in life at the door of brown people and the EU.

Biker47 · 25/09/2021 14:47

I wouldn't trust current Labour to run a bath let alone this country, so the conservatives are like choosing the slightly smaller half of a dogshit sandwich, both "halves" would be unpalatable to eat but if you've got to, at least pick the one that is slightly smaller.

It's telling when everyone comes in and says "New Labour" were just Tories in disguise. So what you're saying is the only time Labour can be popular enough to get voted into power in recent years, is if they behave more like Tories, by being more towards the centre rather than being totally raging lefty? Everyone was beating the drum about how Corbyn was the second coming of Christ, and how now the true left would triumph with impunity because it's what the "people" wanted, look how that turned out, eh?

I live in a safe Labour seat in the North East, lived in council housing most of my life, my parents were low earners, I'm in a working class profession, by rights I should be blindly voting Labour like all the other people round here do in perpetuity, but I don't, they don't deserve it, us up here in their famous "red wall" we're just sheep guaranteed their vote so they don't have to do anything meaningful, I live in a neighbouring seat now, but I see my former Labour MP bleating on occasionally on the news, offering nothing of constructive value in what they say, only snide derision and criticisms (sometimes criticisms are valid, but you need to be offering solutions on what your party would do differently, or change to get your message out there to tempt other people to vote for your party nationwide).

Having a deputy leader as odious as Angela Raynor is just the cherry on top of the shit sundae that is; Labour.

When a party supposedly fighting for the working class of Britain spend a disproportionate amount of time focusing on a state in the Middle East at their party conference every single time, I just switch off, I couldn't care any less if Israel bulldozed the entirety of Palestine and turned it into a giant theme park, I care about things that directly effect my day-to-day working and social life, here, in this country.

PastMyBestBeforeDate · 25/09/2021 09:21

You said 90s were the glory years. The Conservatives were in power for 7 of those so you must be saying the Tories were responsible for them. Labour were in for the 2000s. Apparently you don't class those as glory years. Enough said.
porridge you must have confused me with another poster as I said no such thing.

SueSaid · 25/09/2021 09:13

They are in power indefinitely until Labour have a credible leader with a credible deputy for starters. Starmer whines and wibbles and everytime Rayner opens her gob their credibility plummets further.

I'm not a die hard tory but Labour are just an unconvincing, hapless bunch of embarrassments.

VladmirsPoutine · 25/09/2021 09:11

@ILookAtTheFloor

Labour need to stop all the woke stuff. They're too Islington, too much identity politics which the traditional working class have ZERO interest in.

I know Starmer is kind of trying to move away from it, but the party is so woke to the bones, he can't unite it.

You see this is the problem. Woke doesn't mean what it's been made to mean. People essentially want Labour to be like a diet Tory.
Iggly · 25/09/2021 09:11

@Shade17

I certainly hope so! Labour can fuck off to the far side of fuck and then fuck off some more!
Why?

Do you feel proud having a Prime Minister who lies, cheats and is a bully?

I find it appalling that our politicians are not setting a decent example. They don’t deserve to be in charge quite frankly.

GlobalForce · 25/09/2021 08:59

"...I listened to the News Quiz and someone on there had it right - that half of Labour hates the other half..."

I think one half hates everyone, having had personal experience of them they make Angela Rayner look agreeable and not neurotic in the slightest.

Shade17 · 25/09/2021 08:43

I certainly hope so! Labour can fuck off to the far side of fuck and then fuck off some more!

MrsPeacockInTheLibrary · 25/09/2021 08:42

The idea of safe seats is still there for the Conservatives when looking at the map of the election results over the last twenty-thirty years. My constituency is one of the safest Tory seats in the country.

I agree about Scotland - Labour can't hope to gain a majority without Scotland. And the left in general can't really hope to gain a majority without a ground-breaking, cohesive coalition where they all work together. But of course they won't - on the left the vote remains split across several parties, whereas the Tories have their dominance.

I listened to the News Quiz and someone on there had it right - that half of Labour hates the other half. I have supported various leaders and strategies over the years, and would love to see efforts concentrate on unifying the party. But ultimately Labour can't be all things to all the different factions it needs to attract - converted Tory voters, its own left or centrist or whatever supporters, former (?) Scottish voters from its heartlands. And that is without me mentioning Brexit, the media or the red wall/ working class debates etc.

I genuinely think it is nearly impossible.

OP posts:
ILookAtTheFloor · 25/09/2021 08:27

Labour need to stop all the woke stuff. They're too Islington, too much identity politics which the traditional working class have ZERO interest in.

I know Starmer is kind of trying to move away from it, but the party is so woke to the bones, he can't unite it.

ChateauxNeufDePoop · 25/09/2021 08:18

When you look a politics since 1900 they've been in power for most times since then barring a bit of Labour popularity in the 60/70's and 90's and it could be argued Blair's Labour wasn't massively "left". So yes, I think you're right sadly. Policies aside, if people can stomach this current and previous cabinet as well as PM who only recently admitted how many kids he has then I can't see how Labour could ever get in. Not that I'm saying they'd be much better, maybe that should be the point of more discussions as well.

FWIW, I think a lot of people with no political or economic background go into politics for the wrong reasons.

TeacupDrama · 25/09/2021 08:15

Elections are won and lost by how those who are centerists vote, sometimes they go slightly left sometimes slightly right your policies. If you want to be elected you have to appeal to the centre you can't win by being either more left or more right than you currently are. The left or Labour at the moment is considered too left by centerists there in lies their problem. All elections ultimately hang on the economy with a smaller amount on nhs and schools everything else is fringe for 90%-95% of the population

CMZ2018 · 25/09/2021 08:15

Labour are of no significance these days and unlikely to be for years to come

worriedatthemoment · 25/09/2021 08:15

@GlobalForce not many parties actually stick to their manifestos and sometimes they don't add up
Until they are legally binding they are just false promises in many cases

SweetBabyCheeses99 · 25/09/2021 08:06

Yes for the simple reason that they aren’t an opposition party anymore! But do they really mind when it seems that Kim Jong Johnson is our leader.

That and the fact they’ve gone way too woke, which no one really cares about but you have to pretend so you don’t get cancelled.

GlobalForce · 25/09/2021 07:50

Not many read Manifestos.

I know a woman who worked for the state, now in her 70s who votes every time, mostly she voted Tory.

She said she voted "remain" because she doesn't like BoJo and she thought her money would be safer if we stayed in the EU and said Greece was a one off.

She voted for one PM because they had the same birthday as her.

She voted for many years for whoever she was told to by someone she knew we'll who was into politics because she was too lazy to pay attention and make her own decision.

She would prefer to sit and watch Jeremy Kyle, gossip about people, apply makeup and go to her exercise classes or meet a friend for lunch than read a political Manifesto.

Generallystruggling · 25/09/2021 07:49

I don’t think right wingers know where else to go though, that’s the issue. In the Blair days they could safely vote Labour because Blair was obviously a Tory in disguise. Now they have nowhere else to turn, particularly since the fall of UKIP in the wake of Brexit. Sadly we are quite a right leaning country so the tories will inevitably remain in power, despite fucking us all over time and time again.

Islamorada · 25/09/2021 07:48

EatYourVegetables - exactly! A few years ago Miliband was unelectable because he pulled a weird face eating a sandwich, now we’re quite happy to vote for a man who cheats on his wives, gives tax payer’s money to his mistress, embarrasses us across the globe & hides in a fridge. How the fuck has he got away with it?

I think you find it was mansion taxes with Milliband.

Iggly · 25/09/2021 07:40

I think maybe we need a new party too. I work with the next generation of voters and their answer to Lab or Con is neither. Obviously Lib Dem are a joke. Maybe another "New Labour" re-brand?

Funnily enough I’ve read a lot of manifestos and even tried to see why people would vote conservative and read background into the history of the party etc. Still don’t get it.

Anyway the party that most resonates with me is the Greens, when reading their manifesto, but sadly their name puts people off and makes people think of lentils etc.

PaperDolphin · 25/09/2021 07:23

@Beapot

This should be labours time to shine and walk the next election, they won't thought because they've forgotten about the values they were founded on, and are so keen to chase the woke votes they don't give a crap about actually trying to make life better for the average person. Ideally we need a new party to emerge that isn't shit.
I think maybe we need a new party too. I work with the next generation of voters and their answer to Lab or Con is neither. Obviously Lib Dem are a joke. Maybe another "New Labour" re-brand?
Iggly · 25/09/2021 07:21

@Beapot

This should be labours time to shine and walk the next election, they won't thought because they've forgotten about the values they were founded on, and are so keen to chase the woke votes they don't give a crap about actually trying to make life better for the average person. Ideally we need a new party to emerge that isn't shit.
This a million times.

Labour are too busy trying to suck up to Tory voters who will never vote for them. Never.

arield · 25/09/2021 07:21

@LibrariesGiveUsPower45321

Sadly I think you’re right. What do Labour even stand for these days?
Trans rights.
PaperDolphin · 25/09/2021 07:20

@PastMyBestBeforeDate

Porridge, firstly Brown didn't run us into debt, it was a global crash. He actually did a decent job in the face of a crisis. Secondly I'm talking about 97 rather than later years.
Agree. At the time I was meh about Gordon Brown. I look back now and think he was one of the best. What I wouldn't give to have had him in the driving seat during the pandemic.
Iggly · 25/09/2021 07:20

No, he didn't. He inherited a country whose finances were on the rise and he spent money that we didn't have and put us in debt so when the crisis hit, we had no cushion

Governments issue bonds which help investors such as pension funds and provide the government with cash to invest.

It’s pretty standard economics.

Why did the government bail out banks for gambling? For being reckless?

And why, pray tell, did New Labour have to spend so much money? Because the Tories has run the public sector into the ground.

And they’re doing it again.

PaperDolphin · 25/09/2021 07:19

@LizzieW1969

No. It felt that way during the Thatcher years, but then under Major it went wrong for them because of sleaze. They then lost spectacularly in 1997, I remember staying up to watch Blair’s election win as a student.

The Tories will implode eventually, it’s just a question of how long it will take. This current crisis could mean it will be sooner than we might have thought earlier this year.

But how much worse can it get? Seriously? John Major was nowhere near as sleazy as Boris Johnson and Matt Handcock - add to that the death toll from Covid, the aftermath of Brexit, they seem to be untouchable. How much worse does it need to get? I want to believe you but we passed 1997 levels of Tory fuck up yeeeeaaaars ago and still here they are.
Swipe left for the next trending thread