Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

We fecking told you so. Brexit making us suffer.

413 replies

flashbac · 24/09/2021 22:08

Project Fear you said. Sunlit Uplands you said. Sovereignty you said. Can I buy food and heat my house with Sovereignty? Can I put sovereignty in my car's fuel tank? Can I?

It was common sense that this would happen. Common SENSE.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
EnidFrighten · 25/09/2021 07:18

@MumsTheWordFact

Many people are looking at this from their own Brexit/Anti-Brexit viewpoint, let's have a little balance. Until earlier this year I used to work for a company that dealt with haulage, and there has been a shortage of drivers for some time now. There were campaigns and plans to try to recruit ex-service personel and various other plans but the big reason for a lack of drivers were poor wages over a span of time. The fact is only 20% of the current shortage of drivers is down to Brexit. We'd still have a massive problem anyway. Its also very likely that the stagnant wages of the last 20 years was enabled by Eastern European workers. We might not be having that much of a problem if after the massive EU expansion of 20 years ago there wasn't immediately freedom of movement for those people. Look, the EU does some good things but to conclude that everything on the lorry driver front would be OK if we were still in the EU is ignorant. Ignorant of the current situation, and ignorant of the historical situation.
@mumsthewordfact we could have put a delay on freedom of movement for newly joining countries, as other countries did. We chose not to. We've blamed the EU for the failings of our own politicians.
TheReluctantPhoenix · 25/09/2021 07:15

@Iggly,

I don’t think anyone (with half a brain) believed that, in the short term, which could be a decade, frictional costs of Brexit would not outweigh benefits.

However, being in the EU allowed us to mismanage everything important to an ongoing stable society (fair pay, education etc). We could cover over the cracks with our infinite supply of cheap Eastern European labour, regardless of the cracks to the fabric of society.

If the EU just consisted of the original Northern European members, I could buy into it, as there was, broadly, equality of income, law etc.

When you see pay and conditions being forced up for crop pickers, lorry drivers etc, I see this as a Brexit benefit. And not having infinite choice in Waitrose every time I shop there is a very small price to pay.

FightingtheFoo · 25/09/2021 07:04

@EatSleepRantRepeat

If people had spent the last 5 years doing proper planning instead of batching and trying to overturn the result, recruiting and training British people in shortage jobs, and paying people decent wages in the first place we wouldn't be in such a mess. I'm not willing to live in a country which runs on exploiting poor Eastern Europeans and migrants because we won't pay the going rate for goods and services.
As a child of Eastern Europeans thank you for saying this.

The EU only let in a handful for Eastern European countries to effectively use as slave Labour and every time I hear people hear moaning about how Brexit means it's no longer to exploit Eastern Europeans and how unfair it is because it means they can't have their daily quinoa I want to scream.

daisypond · 25/09/2021 07:01

My young adult DD emigrated to an East European country where she now has residency. She earns local wages, but those wages mean she can live well in her own rented flat in the centre of a capital city- none of which would be possible in the UK.

Iggly · 25/09/2021 07:01

It is time that the passionate ‘remainers’ honestly acknowledged that Brexit has upsides and downsides

The people who put in place the current form of Brexit have made it so that the upsides are few and far between.

As anyone with any bit of sense knows, there was more than one way to do Brexit and our government went for the shit version. So, unless that version changes, Brexit is crap.

TheReluctantPhoenix · 25/09/2021 06:53

@MsJinks,

We need immigration, as every thriving country does. We do not need unbridled immigration.

And, no, you cannot create a competitive market where people are paid their worth in this country, when others, coming from countries with a GDP/capita less than 1/3 of ours are prepared to camp five to a room and work for less than the minimum wage, as they can still save a lot in terms of their own country.

The EU (and globalisation in general) has the upside of keeping inflation low (as the pool of cheap labour is virtually infinite) and services running efficiently. However, it also has two major downsides: dependency on people whose primary loyalty is not to you (look at PPE and vaccines) and increasing the gap between rich and poor.

It is time that the passionate ‘remainers’ honestly acknowledged that Brexit has upsides and downsides.

Dave20 · 25/09/2021 06:52

**I suspect the lorry drivers applying for jobs paying £50k plus, with decent working conditions, are not complaining.

These Daily mail articles are quite misleading. I have a truck licence and not many jobs will pay that kind of money. Not unless they work 70 hours a week, and stay away all week. They’d have to earn bonuses and work every hour.
If all lorry drivers earned 50k per year, there wouldn’t be any job shortages would there?
Don’t believe all you read in the media.

Pongo101 · 25/09/2021 06:48

Covid would have happened without brexit
Energy prices would have risen without brexit
Lorry driving would have been an unattractive profession with or without brexit
Glass vial supplies would have been low without brexit
Inflation would have risen without brexit

But the thing is, in times of disaster, it helps to have solidarity with your neighbors. The EU was expensive and annoying but it was like an insurance policy you hope you will never need. The UK canceled its policy just before disaster struck. It promised its people would save money based on everything being fine and dandy. But when all the bad stuff came it had no insurance. It's fighting all the fires alone. Meanwhile the EU looks at its resources to ensure they are evenly spread. That's why the vaccine roll out was so slow - but everyone (who wants it) is getting their vaccine in the end.

Yes there are a few shitty things going on in Europe now too but no way near the scale of what's going on in the UK.

And honestly the worse things get in the UK, the more people will return to their home countries, the less likely they will return, and the fewer workers there will be.

All those immigrant workers were also there by choice and still have the freedom to leave the shit show thanks to their red passports. Their insurance policy never actually got canceled because they can go home, just like the people of the UK asked them to do.

People arguing it's Covids fault. Well yeah you're right but how equipped we are to deal with Covid is on us.

Dave20 · 25/09/2021 06:48

I’m going to be balanced again. EU workers that lived here before we left had the right to remain here. No one was forced to leave.
But this is an expensive country to live in.Our house prices are too high as of course are out renting prices.
Why would EU workers chose to live here and be ripped off when they can return home or live in other EU countries?

MsJinks · 25/09/2021 06:45

It’s really nice folk didn’t want us to exploit Eastern European’s, perhaps we could have pressured the governments over the years to provide better conditions for them. Fact is our country cannot operate without immigration and it was the EU migrants who actually provided more wealth into the U.K. than the non EU migrants. Obviously such exploitation of folk wanting to be here is abhorrent- so I hope everyone is keeping a close eye then on potential freedom of movement with India and the post study route where students can remain in the U.K. after graduation without securing a job first, we certainly don’t want the chance of exploitation happening again.
I am a remainer, but leaving that aside, who actually thought that the richest elite in the U.K. would forge ahead with a good brexit for the majority, and the most incompetent guy ever in post would resolve it competently?
5 years no plan, little work, glaring misunderstandings and even more glaring errors - I’d get sacked for a lot less.

Islamorada · 25/09/2021 06:42

🥱🥱🥱🥱🥱🥱🥱🥱

Dave20 · 25/09/2021 06:42

Tonne fair, let’s be balanced here. Before we blame leaving the EU for all our problems.
Norway and Switzerland are not part of the EI, but are obviously in Europe.
These countries are wealthy and seem to do quite well being out of the EU club.
Likewise what about independent countries, like Canada and Australia? They seem to manage quite well being independent trading countries.
Maybe it’s down to poor negotiating from our politicians that’s caused our problems.

TheReluctantPhoenix · 25/09/2021 06:42

@BoredZelda,

‘The myth about Eastern European lorry drivers depressing wages is provably untrue…’

What is the proof, then?

TheReluctantPhoenix · 25/09/2021 06:24

I suspect the lorry drivers applying for jobs paying £50k plus, with decent working conditions, are not complaining.

The EU allowed us to keep inflation down by underpaying huge swathes of semi skilled and unpaid workers, as we could import them from countries with GDP per capita a fraction of ours.

If you are a massive fan of the majority of the last 20+ years economic growth going to the top 10% (and none to the bottom quintile), you will detest Brexit.

MultiStorey · 25/09/2021 05:54

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

onlychildhamster · 25/09/2021 03:41

@LobsterNapkin there would always be poorer countries. We should absolutely crack down on exploitative practices on immigrant workers but
it was their decision to come to the UK. It does benefit them and most of them had probably calculated that it was better than staying in their own countries.

We need workers due to the ageing population in the UK and rather than increase the UK birth rate, it's better to import immigrants who would have been born anyway.

I am an immigrant btw.

LobsterNapkin · 25/09/2021 03:33

@onlychildhamster

Btw I am not saying that we should remove the welfare safeguards that make it possible for Brits to have more options! I think its a great thing that we have a welfare system and its a sign we are an advanced economy.

We just need to be realistic about the number of immigrants that we need to do the jobs that British people are not willing to do.

It's not really a solution though, is it? It depends on people coming from societies that are poor, it makes us dependent on those poor societies so we can harvest their workers in order to have people to do the shitty jobs.

It's just a class system that we don't have to take responsibility for. We need those poor places so we can have those workers, just like we need them to supply us cheap tvs and clothes.

Which is one of the reasons it really sticks in the craw of people when they are told they just hate immigrants if they supported Brexit, while out of the other side of their mouths the same people are complaining that we need access to a cheap, plentiful underclass of workers.

A society that can't fulfill it's own need for workers has a problem, it's an unsustainable situation.

TooBigForMyBoots · 25/09/2021 03:32

Brexit is an expensive, beauricratic nightmare. But worse than that, it has deprived us of useful people, divided us and weakened us as a country.Sad

Furries · 25/09/2021 03:30

There are generally huge pinch points/sticking points or whatever you want to call them during every leadership term.

Some of them we will look back on as history (as we didn’t experience them). Some we will look back on as “history’” as we were alive, but not old enough to experience how they felt. Some we will look back on with understanding as they did (or didn’t) impact us.

Every version of government, in “our times” has impacted us.

MSM doesn’t help matters - as highlighted by queue for petrol. And SM doesn’t help either. It’s a blessing and a curse. Easy to find info , advice, tips. But can fuel anxiety etc. It’s like a snowball of fear.

Brexit hasn’t helped, necessarily, but it’s not the sole reason for where we are now.

onlychildhamster · 25/09/2021 03:26

Btw I am not saying that we should remove the welfare safeguards that make it possible for Brits to have more options! I think its a great thing that we have a welfare system and its a sign we are an advanced economy.

We just need to be realistic about the number of immigrants that we need to do the jobs that British people are not willing to do.

Marchitectmummy · 25/09/2021 03:25

You do realise you are all part of society and are equally responsible for making it successful or fail don't you? Moaning away and blaming politics is comfortable I'm sure, but it's hardly going to set the world on fire is it.

onlychildhamster · 25/09/2021 03:22

the people who say that we should train British people to take on jobs as HGV drivers and in the food industry are not being realistic.

Even if you look at Germany (where the pay and working conditions for HGV drivers are vastly superior to that in the UK), they are also facing a shortage- trans.info/en/germany-is-desperately-looking-for-drivers-due-to-staff-shortages-20-percent-of-trucks-are-at-a-standstill-97306 That is not to say we wouldn't face a problem even if we are in the EU, but not having that crucial population of Eastern European drivers means the supply chain problems are much much worse than in the UK.

Its also naive to think that Brits would automatically start training en masse to be HGV drivers/work in the hospitality industry/food industry if the pay is better. In most developed countries that i can think of, these jobs are staffed primarily by immigrants. Maybe this isn't a good thing, but in a developed economy like the UK, every child gets free education, loans to go to university etc. There is a big problem with educational inequality but it means sufficient numbers of children have aspirations to take on more 'middle class jobs' . My Dh grew up needing free school meals and raised by a mum who was the sole breadwinner but he got a Masters degree and was unemployed for some time after graduation. He didn't immediately sign up to work as a barista or for minimum wage to bridge the gap; he stayed with his mum, kept applying and eventually got that graduate job that paid £46k. Its similar for his sisters; when they found it difficult to get jobs after university, they went for overseas internship programmes/volunteer abroad programmes and the grant money (due to their low household income) covered their costs. As a result, none of them have ever worked in minimum wage jobs despite their mum's income being in the bottom 5% of the country according to IFS. I appreciate that a lot of posters would probably tell me that this is not their experience and of course it would not apply to everyone, but a local Brit has a lot more options with regards to jobs compared to an immigrant without family here and who would be homeless without a job. I know Italians with Masters Degrees who work at Caffe Nero because its much better than being in a country with a 50% unemployment rate. DH also has a younger sister who doesn't have any GCSEs, she doesn't need to get a job as she is able to support herself on UC as she can stay with parents.

So if Brits have more choice re jobs than an immigrant, you can bet most of them are going to settle for the easier jobs as opposed to HGV driver jobs (where you don't see your family for days) or minimum wage jobs in the hospitality industry. The feedback from employers was that the majority of applications for jobs in places like Pret were from Europeans, not local Brits. This is why most HGV drivers are in their 40s and 50s and few young people want to take it up even if the advertised pay is high. My friend who is a solicitor posted an article about it ( I know his pay is lower than what they are advertising for HGV drivers) with the comment ' who would want to be a lawyer!'. But his conclusion was still that- he preferred being a lawyer to being a HGV driver cos money wasn't everything!

LobsterNapkin · 25/09/2021 02:55

Not really sure why people blame the EU for richer countries exploiting cheap labour. Domestic governments have every power to increase minimum wages and legislate against exploitation of labour.

Because that's what movement of labour is for. The fact that middle class people can travel and send their kids to universities abroad or work in a management position elsewhere is just the carrot to keep them contented.

Free movement of labour, the labour force that can be increased or discarded at will and moved where you want it when you need it, along with movement of capital - these things are the wet dreams of the capitalist class.

The EU is a trade organisation, it exists for the benefit, first and foremost, of those who own and run trade.

What is quite funny, and yet disheartening, is that they have now managed to convince so many that wanting to control that is somehow right wing, when the right wing have always been the people that promoted it, and the left have tended to resist it.

It's been quite the coup.

Billandbob · 25/09/2021 02:21

Disaster Capitalism is well underway…

ilovesooty · 25/09/2021 02:03

@Chloemol

Yawn, yawn, yawn, yawn, yawn

Yawn, yawn, yawn, yawn

Life’s hard and then you die

No one is forcing you to comment.